The Argument Index

Debate potential by speaker, the highest-scored statement each year, and the companies with the most bearish calls on record. All of it clickable, all of it playable.

45debate potential 4–5 → 2debate potential 5 → 173rated speakers →
People

Average debate potential by speaker

All 173 guests with 5 or more scored statements, ranked. 49 more have fewer than 5, too few for a fair average, and the host is scored on his own page. Sort or filter below.

#PersonAvg debate potential Statements scored
1 Antonio Forenza Founder & CEO, AWEAR 2.75 8
2 Hayden Sonnad Co-Founder & CCO, Carmiq 2.7 10
3 David Goldberg Board Partner & Co-Founder, Alpaca VC 2.6 5
4 Michael Hyatt Executive Chairman, DataStealth 2.44 63
5 Jake Chapman Managing Partner, Marque Ventures 2.41 34
6 Howie Diamond Managing Partner, Pure Ventures 2.4 43
7 Ben Trenda Founder, Backchannel 2.38 8
8 Laura Bilizarian Founder, SevenCommas 2.33 9
9 Daniel Gulati 2.29 42
10 Martin Tobias Investor, Incisive Ventures bio Martin Tobias is an investor at Incisive Ventures. He appears on The Pitch to assess and back startup founders. 2.25 12
11 Alex Besenval 2.25 8
12 Jennifer Brandel Co-Founder and CEO, Hearken 2.25 8
13 Demetrius Gray Founder & CEO, Captain 2.2 5
14 Kalle Freese Co-Founder, COO & Head of Product, Taika 2.2 5
15 Jonathan Kumar Founder & Head of Outcomes, Samaritan 2.18 11
16 Sheel Mohnot Co-Founder & General Partner, Better Tomorrow Ventures 2.17 23
17 Sarah Downey Operating Partner, Accomplice VC 2.14 22
18 Christopher Hussain Founder & CEO, RealKey 2.14 7
19 Sterling Smith Founder & CEO, RightMatch AI 2.13 15
20 Dawn Dixon Founder & CEO, PopCom 2.12 25
21 Chelsea Lee Co-founder and CEO, Shipsi 2.12 8
22 Jared Kugel Founder & CEO, Tire Agent 2.12 8
23 Al Bsharah Managing Partner, Interlock Capital 2.11 9
24 Tina Hedges Founder and CEO, LOLI Beauty 2.1 10
25 Topias Soininen Co-founder & General Partner, Failup Ventures 2.1 10
26 Juan Pablo Segura Assistant Secretary of State, U.S. Department of State 2.09 11
27 Elias Stahl Co-founder & CEO, HILOS 2.07 15
28 Gabe Elias Co-Founder and CEO, Material 2.05 19
29 Mac Conwell Founder & Managing Partner, RareBreed Ventures 2.05 40
30 Jillian Manus Managing Partner, Structure Capital 2.05 138
31 Phil Nadel Managing Director, Forefront Venture Partners 2.01 94
32 Rowe Metzer Founder and CEO, Avelo Running 2 9
33 Hunter Walk Partner & Co-Founder, Homebrew 2 7
34 James Altucher Host, The James Altucher Show 2 5
35 Tiffany Walling McGarrity Co-Founder and CEO, Metapyxl 2 5
36 Andrea Madho Founder, Lab141 2 14
37 Blake Sorensen Founder & CEO, Blake's Seed Based 2 7
38 Vanessa Clark Co-Founder, Atomos 2 13
39 Peter Bokoff Founder & CTO, Nobal Technologies 2 9
40 Elizabeth Yin Co-Founder and General Partner, Hustle Fund 1.98 122
41 Cyan Banister General Partner, Long Journey Ventures 1.97 29
42 Charles Hudson Founder and Managing Partner, Precursor Ventures 1.96 206
43 Kevin Allen Co-Founder & COO, Access Mode 1.95 19
44 Dan Hershberg Founder and General Manager, Amateur Golf Society 1.94 18
45 Marquette Burton 1.92 13
46 Dr. Therese Canaris Founder & CEO, CurieDx 1.91 11
47 Chelsea Brownridge Associate Director, Program Management, frog 1.91 11
48 Davina Desai Founder & CEO, Kinometrix 1.9 10
49 Miki Agrawal Founder, TUSHY 1.9 10
50 Jenny Fielding Co-Founder and Managing Partner, Everywhere Ventures 1.88 8
51 David Sarabia Founder & CEO, inRecovery 1.88 8
52 Kenny Rose Founder & CEO, FranShares 1.84 25
53 Gwyneth Borden Founder, Remynt 1.83 12
54 Ramya Passett Co-Founder, BlueFoot 1.83 6
55 Tommy Duquette Co-Founder & Head of Content, FightCamp 1.83 6
56 Jorge Rios Co-founder & CEO, Bridgefy 1.82 11
57 Jessa Lux Co-Founder, Ride iQ 1.82 11
58 Margot Schmorak Founder, Hostfully bio Margot Schmorak is the founder of Hostfully, a platform that helps vacation rental properties manage their online operations. She pitched her business to venture capitalists on The Pitch. 1.82 22
59 David Dicko Airbus A220 Captain, Air France 1.81 16
60 Ben Zeises Founder & General Partner, SuperAngel.Fund 1.8 5
61 Jesse Middleton General Partner, Flybridge Capital Partners 1.8 30
62 Adam Weinstein Founder & CEO, ThriveFantasy 1.8 5
63 Jenna Kerner Co-Founder and Co-CEO, Harper Wilde 1.8 5
64 Anastasia Trofimova Founder, Sundae 1.79 14
65 Kinzie Lux Co-Founder & CEO, Ride iQ 1.78 9
66 Sofia Dominguez Founder, SVRF 1.78 9
67 Hunter Rosenblum Co-Founder and CEO, Ordo 1.78 9
68 Paige Finn Doherty Founding Partner, Behind Genius Ventures 1.77 13
69 Ariel Puga Founder, Finnecto 1.77 13
70 Michele Callegari Co-founder & CEO, Barberino's 1.75 16
71 Alon Schwartz Co-Founder and COO, Trellis 1.75 20
72 Xiao Wang Co-Founder and CEO, Boundless Immigration 1.74 19
73 Chad Wilson Founder & CEO, immersionED 1.73 11
74 Mike Burton Founder, Lockstop 1.72 25
75 Luke Barkley Young Co-founder & CEO, Outlines 1.72 29
76 Alexandra Stanton CEO, Empire Global Ventures LLC 1.71 7
77 Jason Fox Vice President, Growe 3PL Real Estate 1.71 7
78 Paul Kesserwani Former Founder & CEO, Cushion 1.71 17
79 Meghan Carreau Group Director, UX & AI, Dentsu 1.71 7
80 Cody Candee Co-founder & CEO, Bounce 1.7 27
81 Ryan Lee 1.69 13
82 Whitman Kwok Founder & CEO, KAV 1.67 12
83 Jim Brown Co-Founder and CEO, Uncovered 1.67 27
84 Ismail Salhi Co-Founder and CEO, Wildgrain 1.67 15
85 Josh Israel Co-founder & CEO, Hale Therapeutics 1.67 9
86 Andrew Hoagland Founder, Vetd 1.67 6
87 Al Lagunas Founder & CEO, Levee 1.64 14
88 Aparna Srinivasan Founder, SpotOn, null, 1.64 14
89 Ben Walters Head of Journeys, Fullscript 1.64 11
90 Kate McAndrew Co-Founder & General Partner, Baukunst 1.62 13
91 Nehomitza Calvin Co-Founder and CEO, Vital Audio 1.62 8
92 Nilo Rahmani Co-Founder & CEO, Thoras AI 1.62 8
93 Neal Sales-Griffin Managing Director, Techstars 1.6 5
94 Capri Wheaton Investor, Palm Drive Capital 1.6 10
95 Tiffany Dufu President, Tory Burch Foundation 1.6 10
96 Spencer Shulam Founder and CEO, BuildBetter 1.6 10
97 Amanda Weeks VP of Ambrosia, Recycle Track Systems 1.59 29
98 Kavita Guy Co-founder and CEO, Nectir 1.58 19
99 Ariana Vargas Head of Brand Media & Events, Populous 1.57 7
100 Claire Smith Founder & CEO, Teffola 1.57 7
101 David Matthews Founder, Dotcal Corporation, Inc. / Dotcal (or just Founder, Dotcal) 1.57 7
102 Rama Poola Founder & CEO, SkyHi 1.57 7
103 Luis Sánchez Co-Founder & CEO, KredFeed 1.56 18
104 Vita Mallela Co-founder & CEO, Flock AI 1.56 9
105 Orion Brown Founder & CEO, The Black Travel Box 1.56 9
106 Chinar Movsisian AI & Product Leader, ActiveCampaign 1.55 11
107 Chase Robbins Co-Founder and CEO, Handle Delivery 1.55 56
108 Duval Sanchez 1.55 11
109 Louis Medina Co-founder & CEO, Tether 1.55 11
110 Ryan James Co-Founder and CEO, Dopl Technologies 1.54 13
111 Edward Brawer Founder, Podcast AI 1.54 13
112 Ben Taft Founder & General Partner, Genius Ventures 1.5 6
113 Dean Eberhardt Founder & CTO, ReCraft 1.5 6
114 Emmanuel Brown Co-Founder and Co-CEO, ChurchSpace 1.5 18
115 Debbie Wei Mullin Founder and CEO, Copper Cow Coffee 1.5 28
116 Ray Lee Founder, Sene 1.5 6
117 Tom Impalameni Co-founder & CEO, Tribe XR 1.5 8
118 Susan Sirota Founder, Waggit 1.5 8
119 Harold Hughes Founder & CEO, NFNTE Capital 1.5 10
120 Julie Roth Novak CEO and Co-Founder, PartySlate 1.5 12
121 John Rinaldi Founder, JiobitJohn Rinaldi is the founder of Jiobit, a company that makes geotracking devices for children. He pitched the startup to investors on The Pitch. 1.5 8
122 Evan Thomas Co-Founder, Guru Games 1.5 6
123 Thor Wood Founder & CEO, SnapShyft 1.45 11
124 Amado Guloy Former Founder & CEO, Rex Animal Health 1.45 20
125 Julian Alvarez Co-founder & CEO, Jungle 1.44 18
126 Emily Kennison Founder & CEO, RobeCurls 1.44 16
127 Ofo Ezeugwu Founder and CEO, WhoseYourLandlord 1.44 9
128 Anthony Gonzalez Co-CEO, Cobalt Service Partners 1.44 9
129 Mark Phillips Founder & Managing Partner, 11 Tribes Ventures 1.43 7
130 Kayla Epps Founder and CEO, Oma Health 1.43 7
131 Pierre Laguerre Founder, Fleeting 1.43 14
132 Matthew Peltier Co-Founder, Community 1.43 7
133 Luisa Castellanos Co-Founder and COO, Science On Call 1.42 19
134 Kathy Wong Co-founder & CEO, FolioWorks 1.42 24
135 Virginia Frischkorn Founder & CEO, Partytrick 1.42 12
136 James Kubik Founder, Somewear 1.42 12
137 Alexa Von Tobel Founder & Managing Partner, Inspired Capital 1.4 10
138 Beck Bamberger Founder & Managing Partner, Bad Ideas Group 1.4 10
139 Allie Kamenetsky Founder & CEO, Modern Picnic 1.4 10
140 Kate Flynn Co-Founder and CEO, Sun & Swell 1.4 10
141 Jane Fisher Co-Founder and Co-CEO, Harper Wilde 1.4 5
142 Jen Saxton Founder, Tot Squad 1.38 13
143 Julia Dixon Founder, ESAI 1.36 14
144 Jason Vigo Co-Founder & CEO, Bevz 1.35 17
145 Madeline Fraser Founder & CEO, Gemist 1.33 27
146 Claire Coder Founder and CEO, Aunt Flow 1.33 12
147 Bobbi Racette Founder & President, Virtual Gurus 1.33 9
148 Jacqueline Fu Co-Founder and CEO, Pepper 1.33 9
149 Maryam Braima Founder & CEO, Kimoyo Insights 1.32 37
150 Capella Kerst Founder, geCKo Materials 1.31 13
151 Bill Smith Founder, Shipt 1.31 13
152 Zahra Kassam Founder, Monti Kids 1.31 13
153 Monica Williams Co-Founder and CEO, Scarlet by RedDrop 1.3 10
154 Nicole Sewell Founder & CEO, ECGO 1.27 11
155 Stefan Lobel Founder & CEO, Bluffworks 1.27 11
156 Phil Bearer Founder, FutureMoney 1.25 12
157 Maria Schneider 1.25 8
158 Christine Locker Founder & CEO, Locker 1.24 21
159 Ryan Husk Lead of Partnerships, Pulley 1.22 9
160 Kelsey Willock Co-Founder and CEO, Aura Finance 1.2 20
161 Leigh Isaacson Founder, Dig 1.2 15
162 Khalil Zahar Founder & CEO, FightCamp 1.2 25
163 Romy Rad Founder & Brand Strategist, Sunny Side Up 1.2 10
164 Joshua Zloof Founder, The Cozy Dragon 1.19 16
165 Jenna Sereni Founder, SALT + GROVE 1.17 6
166 Dennis Meng 1.17 12
167 Andrew McHugh Founder & CEO, Wist Labs 1.14 7
168 Nicole Toole Founder & CEO, ECGO 1.12 8
169 Max Tuchman Co-Founder and Former CEO, Caribu 1.12 8
170 Georgia Grace Edwards Co-Founder & CEO, Gnara 1.08 13
171 Kelvin Johnson Co-Founder and CEO, Brevity 1 6
172 Mike Slagh Founder and CEO, Shift 1 15
173 Max Pouvreau Founder, Petit Pot 1 5
Companies

The most bearish calls

Debate potential is an AI score of how much a statement invites disagreement. Bearish counts tally what was said about a company on the show; they describe the conversation, not the company. Every count opens to the exact tape. full disclaimer →

All 242 companies, funds and products with at least one bearish claim on the record.

Company Bearish statements Of which 4–5
Sudden Coffee company 12 ↓
Uncovered company 9 ↓
UnGlue company 8 ↓
Thrive Fantasy company 7 ↓
Who's Your Landlord company 6 ↓
RealKey company 6 ↓ 1
Qleek company 6 ↓
Precursor Ventures fund 6 ↓
Playven company 6 ↓
Outlines company 6 ↓
Industrial Organic company 6 ↓ 1
Hykso company 6 ↓
Hostfully company 6 ↓
CurieDX company 6 ↓
Boundless company 6 ↓
ROWViGOR company 5 ↓
Metapixel product 5 ↓
Levee company 5 ↓
IMirror product 5 ↓
FranShares company 5 ↓
Meta company 5 ↓
DraftKings company 5 ↓
Amazon company 5 ↓
Amateur Golf Society company 5 ↓ 1
Tushy company 4 ↓
Terrascope company 4 ↓
ShearShare company 4 ↓
Samaritan company 4 ↓
PartySlate company 4 ↓
Kimoyo Insights company 4 ↓
Hustle Fund fund 4 ↓
Gemist company 4 ↓
FitGuard product 4 ↓
ECGO company 4 ↓
Cushion company 4 ↓
Copper Cow Coffee company 4 ↓
Bluefoot company 4 ↓
Blue Nile company 4 ↓
Aura Finance company 4 ↓
Aunt Flow company 4 ↓
Apple company 4 ↓
WeDo company 3 ↓
User Interviews company 3 ↓ 1
TuckerBox company 3 ↓
Tire Agent company 3 ↓
Tesla company 3 ↓
Spot On company 3 ↓
Somewear company 3 ↓
Snapshift company 3 ↓
SkyHi company 3 ↓
Shipsy company 3 ↓
Shipsi company 3 ↓
Sene company 3 ↓
Science On Call company 3 ↓
Sandbox Commerce company 3 ↓ 1
Ride IQ company 3 ↓
Remynt company 3 ↓
PopCom company 3 ↓
Nate company 3 ↓
Modern Picnic company 3 ↓
Metabrew company 3 ↓
Lab 141 company 3 ↓
Jungle company 3 ↓
Jiobit company 3 ↓
Harper Wilde company 3 ↓
HandsDown company 3 ↓
Handle company 3 ↓
FanDuel company 3 ↓
BridgeFi company 3 ↓
Bandwagon company 3 ↓
Waggit company 2 ↓
Virtual Gurus company 2 ↓
Uber company 2 ↓
Twitter company 2 ↓
TribeXR company 2 ↓
Tesloop company 2 ↓
Target company 2 ↓
Swig & Swallow company 2 ↓
Sun & Swell Foods company 2 ↓
Sun And Swell Foods company 2 ↓
Starbucks company 2 ↓
Slack company 2 ↓
Skylights company 2 ↓
Shimmur company 2 ↓ 1
Robe Curls company 2 ↓
RareBreed Ventures fund 2 ↓
Pinterest company 2 ↓
Petit Pot company 2 ↓
Orbirental company 2 ↓
Lunar Wireless company 2 ↓
Keihan company 2 ↓
Immersion Ed company 2 ↓
HBO company 2 ↓
G2 company 2 ↓ 1
Fletch company 2 ↓
ESAI company 2 ↓
Dynofit company 2 ↓
Dressed company 2 ↓
Dig company 2 ↓
CultureForce company 2 ↓ 1
The Cru company 2 ↓
Bounce company 2 ↓
Blake's Seed Based company 2 ↓
The Black Travel Box company 2 ↓
Baukunst fund 2 ↓
Barberino's company 2 ↓
Awear company 2 ↓
Avello company 2 ↓
Atomos Space company 2 ↓
App Store product 2 ↓
Alpha Bridge Ventures fund 2 ↓
Albert company 2 ↓
1 Second Everyday product 2 ↓
Zoom company 1 ↓
Zirtual company 1 ↓
Y Closet company 1 ↓
Wist company 1 ↓
Wet Wipes product 1 ↓
WeatherCheck company 1 ↓
Wardrobe company 1 ↓
Warby Parker company 1 ↓
Walmart company 1 ↓
Vimcal company 1 ↓
Victoria's Secret company 1 ↓
Venues & More company 1 ↓
Venues And More company 1 ↓
The Venetian company 1 ↓
Usertesting.com company 1 ↓
United Airlines company 1 ↓
Uni company 1 ↓
Tot Squad company 1 ↓
Ticketmaster company 1 ↓
Thoras AI company 1 ↓
Tether product 1 ↓
Teffola company 1 ↓
Techstars fund 1 ↓
Teamable company 1 ↓
Tampax product 1 ↓
SWIRL product 1 ↓
SVRF company 1 ↓
Supercharger product 1 ↓
Structure Capital fund 1 ↓
Stayfree product 1 ↓
SpaceX company 1 ↓ 1
Snapchat product 1 ↓
ShopMy company 1 ↓
Shipt company 1 ↓
Sequoia Capital fund 1 ↓
Samsung company 1 ↓
RTR company 1 ↓
Rooted company 1 ↓
Rocket company 1 ↓
Rex Animal Health company 1 ↓
Rent The Runway company 1 ↓
Reddit company 1 ↓
Red Drop company 1 ↓
ReCraft company 1 ↓
Quora company 1 ↓
The Pitch Fund One fund 1 ↓
The Pitch Fund fund 1 ↓
Pickle company 1 ↓
Pew Research Center company 1 ↓
Peloton company 1 ↓
Patch company 1 ↓
Osmosis company 1 ↓
Open Bottle company 1 ↓
Oma Health company 1 ↓
NRF company 1 ↓
Netflix company 1 ↓
MoviePass company 1 ↓
Monti Kids company 1 ↓
Mint company 1 ↓
Lyft company 1 ↓
LTK company 1 ↓
Long Journey Ventures fund 1 ↓
Lolli Beauty company 1 ↓
LOLI Beauty company 1 ↓
Lockstop product 1 ↓
Lock Stop Device product 1 ↓
LinkedIn company 1 ↓
Le Tote company 1 ↓
Kraft Foods company 1 ↓
Kotex product 1 ↓
Kitty Hawk company 1 ↓
Kinemetrix company 1 ↓
Kickstarter company 1 ↓
Kaiser company 1 ↓
Juul company 1 ↓
Juicero company 1 ↓
ITunes product 1 ↓
IPad product 1 ↓
Interlock Capital fund 1 ↓
Instagram product 1 ↓
InRecovery company 1 ↓
Indochino company 1 ↓
Hydro Row company 1 ↓
Hyde Closet company 1 ↓
Hurdle company 1 ↓
Hearken company 1 ↓
Harry's company 1 ↓
Google company 1 ↓
Ginger company 1 ↓
Founder Dating company 1 ↓
Flock AI company 1 ↓
Fleeting company 1 ↓
FireChat product 1 ↓
Finecto company 1 ↓
FightCamp company 1 ↓
Everywhere Ventures fund 1 ↓
Ethereum product 1 ↓
Enjoy Life company 1 ↓
Eavesdrop product 1 ↓
Doppel Technologies company 1 ↓
DoorDash company 1 ↓
DogSpot company 1 ↓
DirecTV company 1 ↓
Descript company 1 ↓
Datadog company 1 ↓
CredFeed company 1 ↓
Comcast company 1 ↓
Cold Case Rewards company 1 ↓
Codecademy company 1 ↓
ChatGPT product 1 ↓
Chase company 1 ↓
CAV Sports company 1 ↓
Castle company 1 ↓
Caribu company 1 ↓
Candy Crush product 1 ↓
Brevity company 1 ↓
BoxGroup fund 1 ↓
Bloomberg Terminal product 1 ↓
Bike Keep company 1 ↓
Big Ideas Group fund 1 ↓
Bejeweled product 1 ↓
Babyscripts company 1 ↓
AWSM Sauce company 1 ↓
Avelo company 1 ↓
Aura company 1 ↓
Angry Birds product 1 ↓
Amazon Prime product 1 ↓
88 Acres company 1 ↓
11 Tribes Ventures fund 1 ↓

Highest debate potential, by year

2025

Assertion Not checkable as stated
Allen: A VC told me I was "too young and too Black"
“I remember my first company, I actually had a venture MD pull me aside and tell me I was too young and too black to get funded. Like they weren't gonna listen.”
Kevin Allen Mar 4, 2025 ▶ 27:30 #94 The Breaking Point
Insight
Nadel: Founders investing VC money must pay the minimum possible wage
“When you're investing your own money, do the right thing. When you're investing my money, pay the minimum you can pay.”
Phil Nadel Mar 3, 2025 ▶ 23:10 #3 Industrial Organic

2024

Prediction Not checkable as stated
Conwell: Podcast AI will be replicable as a weekend project by 2025
“Yeah, I hate to be the killjoy of the year, but literally a year from now, somebody wanted to recreate podcast AI, they'll probably be able to do it as a weekend project.”
Mac Conwell May 15, 2024 ▶ 25:53 $1.5M on the Line! Raising Venture Capital for the Future of Podcast Automation Software!
Insight
Conwell: VCs Automatically Assume Black-Focused Startup Markets Are Small
“When VCs hear black, they automatically think small. Every time.”
Mac Conwell Nov 20, 2024 ▶ 21:44 Oma Health Shocks Investors—$175K Raised in One Pitch!

2023

Prediction Not checkable as stated
Brown: Uncovered Will Track Killers' IP Addresses When They Join
“We do believe that the killers will come and become members of Uncovered, and we'll track their IPs, and we'll give that information to law enforcement to help solve these cases.”
Jim Brown Sep 13, 2023 ▶ 5:27 “VCs React to a Bold True Crime Startup—Is Crowdsourced Crime Solving the Future?”
Made with StarZero

Turn any episode into a week of clips.

This entire site, over 100 episodes transcribed, diarized, checked and made playable, runs on the StarZero media pipeline. Drop in your own episode and the podcast clipper finds the moments worth sharing, cuts them, captions them, and reframes them for every feed.