Retrieval Augmented Generation

topic on 14 shows · 97 statements across 73 episodes · said 1 times in 1 episodes since 2025

My First Million 1 In Depth Mixergy More or Less Latent Space Lenny's Podcast No Priors the Official SaaStr Podcast A Product Market Fit Show Sourcery the MAD Podcast the a16z Podcast TBPN 20VC

Mentions by year, every show

tap a year for its mentions
0011112025episodesmentions
0112025episodes it came up in
000.50.5112025episodesmentions per episode

My First Million 1

2025 1 mention in 1 episode

every mention on every show, scene by scene, with the transcript →

The latest 60 statements about Retrieval Augmented Generation, every show

20VC Assertion Contradicted
Jain: Glean was the first enterprise AI company to deploy RAG
“We actually get a lot of credit for being the first enterprise AI company in the world. The first ones to actually bring RAG into the enterprise. The first ones to build conceptual semantic search.”
Arvind Jain Jul 11, 2026 ▶ 10:45 ⁠Why OpenAI and Anthropic Won't Win the App Layer | Glean Founder · 20VC with Harry Stebbings
MAD Prediction Not checkable as stated
RAG will shift from universal use to handling long-tail distribution cases
“Maybe it changes in a way that, you know, like it doesn't need to trigger RAG for like everything, but I'm pretty sure that they're going to be some tail of the distribution that we're going to do RAG still for it.”
Mostafa Dehghani Apr 2, 2026 ▶ 58:09 AI is Already Building AI — Google DeepMind’s Mostafa Dehghani
Singleton: Dreamer replaced Vector DB RAG for agent memory due to complexity
“Very early on, we were putting lots of facts into a vector database and doing embeddings and pulling them back out using, you know, reverse look of embeddings. Rag that actually worked, but turned out to be much more complexity than was actually required. So, …”
David Singleton Mar 20, 2026 ▶ 52:07 Dreamer: the Agent OS for Everyone — David Singleton
a16z Assertion Not checkable as stated
Misra claims he built the first known implementation of RAG using GPT-3
“And I got GPD three to do in context learning, few short learning, and you know, it was kind of the First, at least to me, it was the first known implementation of RAG, Retrieval Augmented Generation, which I used to solve this problem of querying, getting GPT…”
Vishal Misra Mar 17, 2026 ▶ 1:20 Why Scale Will Not Solve AGI | Vishal Misra - The a16z Show
Standard RAG fails in enterprises due to conflicting internal knowledge
“Just a standard LLM doing rag onto these knowledge sources and trying to answer questions is often you have conflicting answers from two different sources because that's the reality of enterprise building up knowledge bases across You know, a huge company.”
Roy Moussa Mar 12, 2026 ▶ 28:59 This 3x founder hit $1M ARR in 5 months. Here's his playbook. | Roy Moussa, Founder of GetVocal · PMF Show
Madheswaran: AI Startups Must Shift Architectures as LLMs Become Agentic
“Like, you know, before, if you imagine like a year or two ago, you had to put a lot of effort into very bespoke ragstacks and routing, but now LLMs are getting more capable of doing more agentic behavior. As a result, you have to change your architecture. Othe…”
Jay Madheswaran Feb 10, 2026 ▶ 48:11 How I grew to $3M ARR in 6 months—& to a $1B valuation in 2 years. | Jay, Founder of Eve Legal · PMF Show
Nina Lopatina: Agentic RAG and query reformulation outperform traditional RAG baselines
“Agentic RAG is just generally better than RAG. Even that initial incremental step of making that doing query reformulation, so when you receive that initial query, being able to break it down into sub-queries so that you can better match those queries to docum…”
Nina Lopatina Dec 31, 2025 ▶ 5:07 [State of Context Engineering] Agentic RAG, Context Rot, MCP, Subagents — Nina Lopatina, Contextual
Catanzaro: Application Startups Benefited Most from RAG Breakthroughs
“I think there were a lot of advances in RAG, and the biggest beneficiaries of these advances were the application companies for whom, you know, retrieval was a critical unlock.”
Sarah Catanzaro Dec 30, 2025 ▶ 26:16 [State of AI Startups] Memory/Learning, RL Envs & DBT-Fivetran — Sarah Catanzaro, Amplify
LATENT SPACE Prediction Not checkable as stated
Webster: Meaningful AI red teaming will require internal tracing and observability
“I think especially where, where things are headed, like with more complex rags and agents and so forth, you're going to have to have some type of observability or like internal tracing in order to have, to do meaningful automated red teaming.”
Ian Webster Oct 24, 2025 ▶ 14:21 Breaking AI to Fix It: Ian Webster's Journey from Discord's Clyde to Promptfoo's $18M Series A
Huyen: Data preparation drives bigger RAG gains than database choice
“Data preparations for Rack is extremely important. And I would say that's like in the, a lot of the companies that I have seen, that's like the biggest performance in their Rack solutions coming from like better data, data preparations, not agonizing over like…”
Chip Huyen Oct 23, 2025 ▶ 34:33 Al Engineering 101 with Chip Huyen (Nvidia, Stanford, Netflix)
Alarie: Reliable legal research synthesis was impossible before LLMs
“The big move was retrieval augmented generation, where you kind of run a search. So you have a master corpus of all of the relevant tax research materials. You run an intelligent search, and you've got, like, really good vector embeddings, and you're chunking …”
Ben Alarie Oct 20, 2025 ▶ 19:45 He "kind of" had PMF for 8 years—until, after a rebuild, he raised $100M | Ben Alarie, Founder of... · PMF Show
Alarie: RAG shifts legal AI effort from retraining models to data curation
“The brilliant thing about leveraging retrieval augmented generation is we can just curate the data. And if we're confident about the currency of the tax database and the content in the database, and we're confident about our retrieval algorithms, our Prompt en…”
Ben Alarie Oct 20, 2025 ▶ 20:47 He "kind of" had PMF for 8 years—until, after a rebuild, he raised $100M | Ben Alarie, Founder of... · PMF Show
Off-the-shelf RAG limitations force enterprises to do internal data labeling
“We're starting to see the labeling move into enterprises and into governments because you can only get so far with off the shelf plus rag, plus some fine tuning based on recorded data.”
Jason Droege Oct 9, 2025 ▶ 25:55 Scale AI CEO on Meta’s $14B deal, scaling Uber Eats to $80B, & what frontier labs are building next
Smith: Influencing LLM core pre-trained models takes a year
“Most of what I'm describing is about the RAG piece, not the core model piece to influence the core model is probably extremely hard. And maybe you will see the impact a year later.”
Ethan Smith Sep 14, 2025 ▶ 20:52 The ultimate guide to AEO: How to get ChatGPT to recommend your product | Ethan Smith (Graphite)
Smith: LLMs will not recommend products absent from RAG search results
“And I think also the LLM is, is probably not going to say your product if it didn't show up anywhere on the RAG. So I think that's where most of the interesting stuff is for, from an optimization perspective.”
Ethan Smith Sep 14, 2025 ▶ 21:18 The ultimate guide to AEO: How to get ChatGPT to recommend your product | Ethan Smith (Graphite)
Smith: Feeding AI derivatives into RAG collapses output diversity into single opinions
“If you feed in derivatives of derivatives into the model, you will basically take the wisdom of the crowd and that will shrink and you'll have a single opinion on everything, which is really bad.”
Ethan Smith Sep 14, 2025 ▶ 58:07 The ultimate guide to AEO: How to get ChatGPT to recommend your product | Ethan Smith (Graphite)
Martin: Reading agent memory at scale is just a multi-step RAG pipeline
“Memory retrieval at large scale is just retrieval, right? I kind of view them as... In the case of sophisticated memory retrieval, it is just like a, you know, complex rag system in the same way we talked about with like Varun and building windsurf. It's kind …”
Lance Martin Sep 11, 2025 ▶ 42:58 Context Engineering for Agents - Lance Martin, LangChain
MIXERGY Insight
Howard: The primary value of RAG chatbots is internal team drafting
“Where we find that chatbots and RAG, which is essentially Taking documents and putting them into a vector database so AI can read them, right? AI that can read your documents in a custom way is RAG. When you think about a chatbot in RAG, the value there is giv…”
Rob Howard Sep 10, 2025 ▶ 38:40 #2279 How are there so many AI agencies?
MAD Assertion Supported
Cherny: Claude Code does not use RAG for codebase memory
“And so quad code actually doesn't use this technique called rag. Instead, what it does is it just searches files the same way that a human would.”
Boris Cherny Aug 7, 2025 ▶ 30:34 Anthropic's Surprise Hit: How Claude Code Became an AI Coding Powerhouse
LATENT SPACE Disclosure
Ambience AI Stack Uses Prompting, RAG, SFT, and RFT
“Ambience internally, we use prompting, we use chaining, we'll use RAG, we use fine tuning. It will use SFT and RFT.”
Brendan Fortuna Jul 29, 2025 ▶ 5:07 ⚡️Using RFT to Build Clinical Superintelligence
MAD Opinion
Laskin: Traditional RAG agents fail for any meaningful software engineering query
“It'll grab it, and then that's all you have, and most likely, for any meaningful query it will not have given you the information that you need to actually go do the task. So rag agents are actually, are pretty weak.”
Misha Laskin Jul 17, 2025 ▶ 12:57 Ex‑DeepMind Researcher Misha Laskin on Enterprise Super‑Intelligence | Reflection AI
a16z Insight
Bhardwaj: RAG alone is insufficient for high-accuracy enterprise data processing
“While drag is good for casual search, you need a complex workflow under the herd that is explainable, that is auditable, that is guaranteed to be accurate and correct, is important for solving many of these enterprise problems.”
Anant Bhardwaj Jun 10, 2025 ▶ 12:00 Giving New Life to Unstructured Data with LLMs and Agents
MAD Assertion Contradicted
Hebbia was the first company to productionize RAG in 2020
“Hebbia were actually the first to turn that into a product. So it's like a very close thing to my heart. So back in 2020, we were the first people to actually productionize it, roll it out.”
George Sivulka May 29, 2025 ▶ 29:06 AI That Ends Busy Work — Hebbia CEO on “Agent Employees”
a16z Insight
Clark: Expanding RAG datasets with historical data degrades search quality
“And so RAG has obviously become very prevalent in a wide variety of industries and people use it for a lot of different things. We've spoken with different firms that they were like, okay, well, I'm just going to continue to add more and more data to the corpu…”
Scott Clark May 23, 2025 ▶ 28:46 Building AI Systems You Can Trust
Alberti: Wiki pages are a better abstraction than pure RAG for codebase search
“If you just do like pure, like rack on like such a big base code files, it'll just be like pretty bad at a certain point, you know, on a single code base. Sure. I can see it, but Tens of thousands of code bases. It's tougher. But I think actually the wiki page…”
Silas Alberti May 21, 2025 ▶ 26:29 DeepWiki: The GitHub Encyclopedia
IN DEPTH Assertion Not checkable as stated
Abraham: Customers almost never ask Reducto about RAG chunking anymore
“Part of the initial interest for Reducto is RAG as a paradigm introduced this need for thinking about chunking, for example. So it wasn't just, can you parse the documents? It was after you parse it, what do I feed into my VectorDB? That was a, Initial selling…”
Adit Abraham Apr 29, 2025 ▶ 33:40 How a weekend hack became a multimillion-dollar AI startup | Adit Abraham (CEO at Reducto)
MAD Insight
Arvind Jain: AI agents are shifting from RAG to process automation
“Agents are now getting a lot more powerful. They are, You know, they're getting they're sort of shifting from sort of basic two step rack kind of application flow where you take a task, you find some information, and then you make AI work on it to generate the…”
Arvind Jain Apr 24, 2025 ▶ 30:19 Glean’s Breakthrough: CEO Arvind Jain on Scaling AI Agents & Search
Bergum: Search, not vector storage, is the natural abstraction for RAG
“I think that's a more natural abstraction for connecting AI with knowledge and all the arguments for doing rag. I think the natural concept there is search.”
Jo Kristian Bergum Apr 19, 2025 ▶ 5:25 The Rise and Fall of the Vector DB category: Jo Kristian Bergum (ex-Chief Scientist, Vespa)
Bergum: Build RAG with BM25 first, hybrid search second, re-ranking third
“I think actually that a very strong baseline is the classical BM-Five like algorithm that's been around for 30 years, right? It's keyword matching, but it offers a very useful baseline for a lot of different search use cases because it gives you that baseline,…”
Jo Kristian Bergum Apr 19, 2025 ▶ 14:55 The Rise and Fall of the Vector DB category: Jo Kristian Bergum (ex-Chief Scientist, Vespa)
TBPN Assertion Not checkable as stated
Huber: Over 90% of enterprise AI use cases are retrieval-augmented generation
“I think like today, 90 plus percent of it in enterprises is retrieval event generation, or it's, you know, using retrieval, it's sort of a chat on top of unstructured data.”
Jeff Huber Apr 10, 2025 ▶ 11:26 The Most UNDERRATED Use Case in AI | Jeff Huber on TBPN April 8th
Shah: Graph representations may outperform standard vector chunking in RAG
“The reality is something gets lost in the chunking process in the, okay, well, those tend to, you know, like you don't really get the whole picture, so to speak, and maybe not even the right set of dimensions on the kind of broader picture. And it makes intuit…”
Dharmesh Shah Mar 28, 2025 ▶ 14:40 The Agent Network — Dharmesh Shah, Agent.ai + CTO of HubSpot
MAD Assertion Contradicted
Kiela: FAIR was the first team to build a generative RAG model
“Why RAG became the way you name these things is because it's generative, right? So we were the first ones to have a generative model there.”
Douwe Kiela Mar 6, 2025 ▶ 18:38 Top AI Researcher on GPT 4.5, DeepSeek and Agentic RAG | Douwe Kiela, CEO, Contextual AI
a16z Insight
Ian Webster: AI jailbreaks let attackers pivot within RAG architectures
“Those are often the gateway to messing around with other stuff, right? Like once, once you punch a hole in the defenses with something like a jailbreak, if it's part of a larger system or architecture, like a rag or agent that would give an attacker a lot of r…”
Ian Webster Feb 28, 2025 ▶ 2:28 How to use DeepSeek safely
20VC Opinion
Morin: RAG is a dirty workaround limited by context size
“It's a bit dirty because, of course, you know, you are limited by the amount of data you can input, right?”
Steeve Morin Feb 24, 2025 ▶ 1:04:51 Steeve Morin: Why Google Will Win the AI Arms Race & OpenAI Will Not | E1262 · 20VC with Harry Stebbings
20VC Insight
Morin: AI developers will always choose smaller models if performance matches
“What really pushes model sizes are the efficiency rather than specializing. So meaning that if you can do the same performance with a smaller model that is fine tuned with rag or whatever, then you'll do it with a smaller because again, less is better.”
Steeve Morin Feb 24, 2025 ▶ 1:06:21 Steeve Morin: Why Google Will Win the AI Arms Race & OpenAI Will Not | E1262 · 20VC with Harry Stebbings
LATENT SPACE Disclosure
Sridhar: Gemini Deep Research falls back to RAG beyond context limits
“We also have we have retrieval mechanisms, if required. So we natively try to use the context as much as it's available beyond which you know, we have, like, a rag setup to figure out”
Mukund Sridhar Feb 18, 2025 ▶ 19:03 Why is everyone cloning Deep Research?
Sridhar: Vector dot-product RAG breaks down on multi-attribute queries
“The tricky thing for RAG, it really works well because a lot of these things are doing like cosine distance, like a dot product kind of a thing, and that kind of gets challenging when your query side has multiple different attributes. The dot product doesn't r…”
Mukund Sridhar Feb 18, 2025 ▶ 20:19 Why is everyone cloning Deep Research?
Sehgal: Keep recent research tasks in context, relegating older ones to RAG
“Just to add to that, I think like, just like a simple rule of thumb that we use is like, if it's the most recent set of research tasks where the user is likely to ask lots of follow-up questions, that should be in context. But like, as stuff gets 10 tasks ago,…”
Arush Sehgal Feb 18, 2025 ▶ 21:11 Why is everyone cloning Deep Research?
LATENT SPACE Prediction Not checkable as stated
Sutin: Existing general RAG frameworks will likely become obsolete
“I think existing kind of rag pipelines also will probably be obsoleted. The frameworks, I have not found one, like, there's no general Way to do RAG that works like it's really highly dependent on the data.”
Ethan Sutin Feb 17, 2025 ▶ 58:04 Bee AI: The Wearable Ambient Agent
Sutin: Bee replaced traditional RAG embeddings with massively parallel small models
“What we've learned is, like, doing the traditional, like, embedding and RAG is suboptimal. We kind of built our own using small models to do really massively parallel retrieval, which I think is going to be maybe more common in the future.”
Ethan Sutin Feb 17, 2025 ▶ 58:41 Bee AI: The Wearable Ambient Agent
20VC Assertion Contradicted
Sivulka: Hebbia was first to productionize RAG in 2020
“We end up building a product studio, which is the first to productionize RAG, Retrieval Augmented Generation, also in 2020.”
George Sivulka Jan 22, 2025 ▶ 20:24 George Sivulka, Co-Founder & CEO @Hebbia: The Future of Foundation Models | E1250 · 20VC with Harry Stebbings
20VC Opinion
Sivulka: Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) does not work at all
“That's a bit of a plot twist over here. We, I actually don't think RAG works at all.”
George Sivulka Jan 22, 2025 ▶ 21:26 George Sivulka, Co-Founder & CEO @Hebbia: The Future of Foundation Models | E1250 · 20VC with Harry Stebbings
Neubig: RAG From Natural Language To Code Does Not Work Well
“At least in my experience, rag from language to code doesn't work super well.”
Graham Neubig Dec 25, 2024 ▶ 46:09 Best of 2024 in Agents (from #1 on SWE-Bench Full, Prof. Graham Neubig of OpenHands/AllHands)
LATENT SPACE Assertion Not checkable as stated
Fu: Embedding model quality barely matters for final RAG performance
“We had this experience over and over again where you could have any, an embedding model of any quality, so you could have a really, really bad embedding model, or you could have a really, really good one by, and by any measure of good, and for the final RAG ap…”
Dan Fu Dec 24, 2024 ▶ 33:00 2024 in Post-Transformer Architectures: State Space Models, RWKV [Latent Space LIVE! @ NeurIPS 2024]
MAD Insight
Douetteau: RAG tools and AI agent builders are becoming commoditized
“Ultimately lots of those technology can become, in isolation, pretty much commoditized. Meaning it's not hard to build RAG or agent builder.”
Florian Douetteau Dec 12, 2024 ▶ 27:14 Dataiku's Secret to Scaling AI in Global Enterprises | Florian Douetteau, CEO, Dataiku
SAASTR Insight
Boehmig: Sticking to Main-Branch Foundation Models Beats Custom Model Training
“Staying on the main branch, staying on the core capabilities and supplementing it with fine tuning and additional techniques like RAG seems to be the approach that's winning right now.”
Jason Boehmig Dec 11, 2024 ▶ 9:10 5 Things That Are Working and 5 Things That Aren’t in B2B SaaS AI with Ironclad's CEO and a16z
Shreya Shankar: DocETL builds semantic unstructured layers, not point-lookup RAG systems
“This is very different from traditional rag or Q&A or document processing for a chatbot. Like, the kinds of queries that people are, people want to use .etl for can be expressed as etl style sweep and harvest, kind of, I want to look at my entire dataset. I wo…”
Shreya Shankar Nov 29, 2024 ▶ 47:13 [Paper Club] DocETL: Agentic Query Rewriting + Eval for Complex Document Processing w Shreya Shankar
SOURCERY Assertion Contradicted
Socher: You.com invented RAG at web scale before the term existed
“We realized just like with rag where we had invented rag already, we're doing it at a web scale, but it wasn't yet a term.”
Richard Socher Oct 25, 2024 ▶ 10:23 Former Chief Scientist at Salesforce, Richard Socher | You.com, LLMs, AI Agents, Complex Work · Sourcery with Molly O'Shea
Wang: Planning and reasoning are the next AI frontiers after RAG
“The next frontier after RAG is planning and reasoning.”
Shawn Wang Oct 19, 2024 ▶ 37:39 Singapore: the AI Engineer Nation — with Minister Josephine Teo
LATENT SPACE Assertion Supported
Hu: SWE-bench scores jumped from 3% on GPT-4 RAG to 43%
“If we just use GPT-IV plus RAG, what do we get? It's, like, a measly three percent. And then up to the most recent submissions where they get up to 43%.”
Jesse Hu Oct 19, 2024 ▶ 7:40 [Paper Club] SWE-Bench [OpenAI Verified/Multimodal] + MLE-Bench with Jesse Hu
Hu: Long-context accuracy degrades; RAG remains necessary for entire large codebases
“My guess would be that, like, long context works, but it's sort of a lie as far as your accuracy, and that rag matters no matter what, because even in the longest context windows, you can't fit the whole code base.”
Jesse Hu Oct 19, 2024 ▶ 27:29 [Paper Club] SWE-Bench [OpenAI Verified/Multimodal] + MLE-Bench with Jesse Hu
NO PRIORS Assertion Not checkable as stated
Goyal: 50% of enterprise AI production use cases involve RAG
“Unambiguously, people are doing rag. So that one is, you know, it's like simple and obvious. Probably around 50% of the use cases that we see in production involve rag of some sort.”
Ankur Goyal Oct 8, 2024 ▶ 6:17 No Priors Ep. 85 | CEO of Braintrust Ankur Goyal
Pokras: OpenAI Assistants API requires too many initial API requests
“Some of the things that are good in the assistance API is hosted tools. People really like posted tools and especially RAG. And then some things that are, you know, less intuitive is just how many API requests you need to get going with the Assistant's API.”
Michelle Pokrass Oct 4, 2024 ▶ 1:05:05 Building AGI in Real Time (OpenAI Dev Day 2024)
NO PRIORS Insight
Taylor: RAG is woefully insufficient for meaningful enterprise customer service
“What we found in practice is that broad category of technology investment is woefully insufficient for almost any meaningful customer experience. If you think about, you know, all of the interactions you've had with brands that you care about, what percentage …”
Bret Taylor Sep 19, 2024 ▶ 10:50 No Priors Ep. 82 | With CEO of Sierra Bret Taylor
20VC Prediction Not checkable as stated
Kolter: RAG systems will remain essential despite fine-tuning advances
“RAG based systems are so Are so common here, and so, and probably will remain, even with the advent of fine-tuning availability, they're going to remain a useful paradigm.”
Zico Kolter Sep 4, 2024 ▶ 24:33 Zico Kolter: OpenAI's Newest Board Member on The Biggest Questions and Concerns in AI Safety | E1197 · 20VC with Harry Stebbings
LATENT SPACE Prediction Not checkable as stated
Howard: AI developers will spend 12 months mapping RAG, fine-tuning, and KV caching
“Something over the next 12 months people will be spending time thinking about is how to, like, where to use RAG, where to use fine-tuning, where to use KV cache storage, you know, and how to use state.”
Jeremy Howard Aug 17, 2024 ▶ 1:08:05 Answer.ai & AI Magic with Jeremy Howard
MAD Insight
RAG and prompt engineering are just search techniques, not real AI
“Today when people are running RAG or prompt engineering those are search. That's not AI. It's like keeping the AI frozen and fixed.”
Sharon Zhou Jul 25, 2024 ▶ 41:05 Making AI Work: Fine-Tuning, Inference, Memory | Sharon Zhou, CEO, Lamini
LATENT SPACE Disclosure
Brightwave uses composable, context-aware prompting conditioned on retrieved context semantics
“You can have prompts that are composable and that have different sort of command units that like may or may not be present based on the semantics of the content that is being populated into the rag context window. And so that, that's something we make great us…”
Mike Conover Jun 11, 2024 ▶ 35:50 How AI is Eating Finance - with Mike Conover of Brightwave
NO PRIORS Insight
Ma: RAG Response Quality Is Bottlenecked by Retrieval Quality
“Right now for implementing Rack the bottleneck seems to be that, you know, it's not very hard to implement it, right? You can just connect the components and have your Rack system ready very quickly. But the bottleneck seems to be the quality. Of the response …”
Tengyu Ma Jun 6, 2024 ▶ 7:03 No Priors Ep. 67 | With Voyage AI Co-Founder and CEO
NO PRIORS Prediction Not checkable as stated
Ma: RAG Software Heuristics Will Vanish as Embedding Models Improve
“And my long term vision here is that some of the software engineering layers on top of the networks will be less and less needed when the networks are more and more clever.”
Tengyu Ma Jun 6, 2024 ▶ 22:20 No Priors Ep. 67 | With Voyage AI Co-Founder and CEO

← every entity, every show

Made with StarZero

Turn any episode into a week of clips.

This entire site, thousands of episodes across every show transcribed, diarized, checked and made playable, runs on the StarZero media pipeline. Drop in your own episode and the podcast clipper finds the moments worth sharing, cuts them, captions them, and reframes them for every feed.