Performance Reviews
topic on 5 shows · 9 statements across 9 episodes
We Live to Build
the Knowledge Project
Lenny's Podcast
Capital Allocators
20VC
9 statements about Performance Reviews, every show
Duhigg: Managers should separate delivering critical feedback from discussing it
“Oftentimes when we're doing a performance review, we think that we want to have a conversation, but we actually don't. We want to say, look, here are some problems with your performance. Here's some stuff that you need to work on, but we're not looking for the…”
Adams: Asking references to predict the first review prevents dodging constructive feedback.
“So this question is what feedback will I be giving this person in their first performance review? And it's an amazing question because the person can't dodge it. You know, there's an answer and it's incredibly enlightening.”
Schmidt: Replacing managers with AI in reviews will create more problems
“But I think, you know, offloading that from the person who's most familiar with it is you know, probably going to create more problems in its work.”
Managers Should Lead Performance Reviews Directly With Critical Feedback
“Just go in and just jump to Harry. We got to talk about this Because you're not going to be successful here unless you can nail these three things. I start with the hard stuff because everybody dreads it on both sides. That's my recommendation to you. Like, do…”
Libin: Formal performance reviews often do more harm than good
“I just haven't had good success with like reviews that felt more useful than harmful.”
Dodson: Soft-pedaling feedback to diverse employees stalls their career growth
“One of the common mistakes that people make in mentoring women and people of color oftentimes is that in their organization will during a performance review go easier or not. They're like, well, this person's really experienced a lot of pain in their life. The…”
Culture onboarding requires continuous diagnostic feedback, not annual reviews
“So you have to be explicit in watching the outcomes of attaching a bad outcome to culture, and that's where the real learning happens. It's not just giving them the statement, and it's definitely not waiting for a year-end performance review. And saying, oh, b…”
Dethmer: Feedback-rich cultures can eliminate formal annual performance reviews
“If you create feedback rich environments, like we're talking about here, you can let go of most formal feedback tools. You don't need to do a semi-annual or annual feedback things, which, you know, still gets rated as one of the things most people hate the mos…”