hydrogen
60 statements across 25 episodes · 16 bullish · 14 bearish · 20 people on the record · first statement Dec 2, 2021 by Dan Rutherford · across every show →
Everything said about hydrogen, oldest first
Dec 2, 2021 bullish
Dec 9, 2021 neutral
Lubershain: Gas pipelines max out at ~7% hydrogen by energy without retrofits
“Most pipelines We're learning today can probably take up to 20% hydrogen by volume, which is somewhere around seven percent hydrogen by energy content before you need to start at the very least making some changes in all of the ancillary equipment, the pumps a…”
May 12, 2022 bullish
Kann: Synthetic e-fuels may win long-term if input and process costs drop
“It's more of a cost problem, because as it stands today, basically, like, both input costs, hydrogen and CO₂, are too high, and then the process costs, turning those things into e-fuels, are too high. So you've got to solve for all three of those things and sc…”
Jun 2, 2022 bullish
Kann: Active land grab underway for salt domes and CCS sites
“If you're looking for salt domes to store hydrogen, there's absolutely a bunch of, I don't know what to call it, but there's a bunch of exploration and there's a land grab around. There are only so many of those really big salt domes. Same thing you're startin…”
Jun 23, 2022 positive
Jun 23, 2022 bullish
Kann: Clean hydrogen will significantly decarbonize ammonia, chemicals, and heavy industry
“In the sectors where, first of all, we already use hydrogen, things like ammonia and chemicals production and then potentially in a few other really difficult to abate industrial sectors including to some extent in the power sector, I think hydrogen is going t…”
Jun 23, 2022 bearish
Aug 18, 2022 neutral
Mukhopadhyay: Net-zero aviation by 2050 requires electric, hydrogen, and SAF
“And then on the lower end, electrify everything. As much can be electrified, should be electrified. Wherever hydrogen can be used, should be used, and everything else will require SAF to decarbonize, and that's really the only way we get to net zero emissions …”
Aug 18, 2022 positive
Sep 9, 2022 bullish
Beard: Using hydrogen for home heating is a facepalm compared to geothermal
“Every time I read a, an article, for instance, that's talking about you know, how we're sure we're going to heat homes with hydrogen. I literally, I mean, it's a facepalm moment, right? Because geothermal is just so much easier to do than that, right? And so, …”
Oct 20, 2022 bearish
Fleece: Cheaper renewables abroad will drive industrial production out of Europe
“So I think we will, in the end, see some industrial shift out of Europe, just because it'll be, some countries have natural competitive advantage in, in, in access to cheaper renewable resources, and thereby,
Making their hydrogen production costs lower.
and …”
Oct 20, 2022 bearish
Oct 20, 2022 bullish
Oct 20, 2022 neutral
Fleece: Hourly versus yearly temporal correlation shifts hydrogen costs by 10 percent
“The difference between Even yearly and hourly temporal correlation, the difference in, in the levelized cost of hydrogen and how that impacts the price of hydrogen is not that much. There has been recently, very recently in September, an excellent paper from t…”
Oct 20, 2022 neutral
Dec 1, 2022 bullish
Jenny Chase: Solar will be built for green hydrogen production by 2030
“And that's even before you start thinking about, are we going to build solar to make hydrogen? And I suspect that by 2030 we are, just because we've got no idea how else to manage the problems of intermittency and how to decarbonize steel and fertilizer.”
Dec 8, 2022 neutral
O'Donnell: Hydrogen heat requires 2 units of electricity per unit of heat
“Making it from clean electricity. It's about two units of electricity for one unit of heat. The production equipment, the electrolyzers are expensive today, and they're coming down in cost. That two to one ratio, though, is not something that's going to change…”
Jan 5, 2023 neutral
Jan 5, 2023
Friedmann: Shipping liquefied hydrogen adds $3 per gallon equivalent compared to ammonia
“If you tried to liquefy hydrogen and ship that instead of ammonia, and then regasify it at the other end, that basically adds about three dollars a gallon gasoline equivalent compared to just moving ammonia around.”
Feb 9, 2023 bearish
Feb 9, 2023 bullish
Kann: Clean hydrogen is 75% to over 90% better for climate than natural gas
“It is, however much, much, much, much better From a climate perspective than just burning natural gas, for example. I think one study said something like 75% better in a In a negative case, and if it's truly low emissions, embodied hydrogen plus low leakage ra…”
Feb 9, 2023 neutral
Koch-Blank: Recent research doubles hydrogen's 100-year global warming potential to 10
“The global warming potential, which has been traditionally considered, has been, I think, five. Kilograms of CO₂ equivalent per kilogram of hydrogen leaked, and the recent research indicates that it's, should rather be 10.”
Feb 9, 2023 positive
Koch-Blank: Safety risks will force hydrogen infrastructure to leak less than methane
“The safety aspects of leaking hydrogen, because the properties of leaking hydrogen is much more dangerous than leaking, Methane. Partly because it's harder to detect. So, So that's one reason why systems are likely to be tighter.”
Feb 9, 2023 neutral
Feb 9, 2023 positive
Koch-Blank: Hydrogen for steelmaking yields double the emissions reduction of transport
“Using the hydrogen molecule for reducing iron ore Has twice as much you know, impact on the alternative, compared to the alternative If you benchmark with using it for transportation applications, and I bucket here shipping, aviation, and trucking.”
Feb 9, 2023 neutral
Koch-Blank: Hydrogen leaks indirectly cause warming by extending methane lifetime and creating water vapor
“Basically what happens is that the hydrogen that leaks has itself a global warming potential, which has been considered, but then also it has an effect of extending the lifetime of methane in the atmosphere basically causing the methane to stick around longer,…”
Feb 9, 2023 neutral
Koch-Blank: Methane leakage has 5x the 20-year warming impact of hydrogen per megajoule
“For natural gas, it goes from 25 to 80, roughly, from a, when you compare a hundred to 25. And for hydrogen, it goes from 10 to 40, so it increases substantially, but it's still half of the global warming impact, global warming potential of Natural gas per kil…”
May 25, 2023 negative
Jul 13, 2023 neutral
Jul 13, 2023 neutral
Jul 13, 2023
Corbeau: Hydrogen requires over 3,000x the volume of oil for equivalent energy
“If I were to compare that with oil, so the ratio between oil and natural gas is about 1000. So between hydrogen and oil, we are talking about a factor which is largely over 3000. So if you want to transport the same energy as in one cubic meter of oil, well, y…”
Jul 13, 2023 neutral
Jul 13, 2023 negative
Jul 13, 2023 neutral
Jul 13, 2023 negative
Corbeau: $3 to $4 per kg transport costs make hydrogen economically unviable
“I mean, just to say, I mean, you know, if the transport cost is indeed remaining at three, four dollars per kilogram, I mean, you know, this is kind of game over because that would come on top of the production cost of hydrogen. So that would make hydrogen out…”
Jul 13, 2023 neutral
Corbeau: Hydrogen Is a Conversion Business, Not a Rent Business Like Oil
“From an economic point of view, many developing countries want to benefit the maximum from hydrogen, and hydrogen is not a rent business. It's not like oil or gas. It's a conversion industry, so you are never going to get as much revenues and benefits as you w…”
Oct 5, 2023 neutral
Thiel: Synthetic fuels require $1/kg hydrogen and $100-$200/ton CO₂ to compete
“For a fuel, if you want to get anywhere close to economically competitive, you know, subsidies decide, you have to have hydrogen that's going to be on the order of a dollar per kilogram, and you have to have CO₂ that's in that 100 to 200 dollar per ton range, …”
Oct 5, 2023 neutral
Thiel: Single-pass CO2 conversion does not significantly move green methanol economics
“If you get A better conversion of CO two and hydrogen to methanol on a single pass. It just really doesn't move the overall economics in a huge way because, again, back to a previous point, CO two and hydrogen are the big cost drivers in that system.”
Oct 26, 2023 bearish
Hade: Clean long-duration storage is not remotely economically viable today
“So we're looking into things like, you know, iron air batteries, and nickel hydrogen batteries, and you know, hydrogen as a consumable fuel, right? But nothing even, like, comes remotely close to being economically viable right now for us, right? And so maybe …”
Jun 6, 2024 positive
Baglino: Tesla Master Plan Soaks Up Curtailed Power With Hydrogen and EV Charging
“We're doing hydrogen and storing hydrogen in the summer and then using that hydrogen to produce clean fuels on a, on an annualized basis and also using that hydrogen for Ammonia production and steel and other things. And so we are trying to do some things to l…”
Aug 2, 2024 bullish
Aug 2, 2024 neutral
Aug 23, 2024 neutral
Johnson: Geologic hydrogen reservoirs take thousands of years to recharge
“The, this is still, you know, our view is it's still, you're talking about thousands of years. Oil and gas, you're talking about millions of years, and this you might be talking about thousands or tens of thousands or hundreds of thousands of years. There are …”
Aug 23, 2024 bullish
Johnson: Replacing methane power plants with hydrogen cuts emissions by 97%
“If we just said, okay, let's just assume you lose two percent methane, you lose two percent hydrogen. That means if I took that methane and I burned that in a power plant, or I took that hydrogen and I burned that in a power plant, and I'm losing the same amou…”
Aug 23, 2024 negative
Johnson: Microbes present a major preservation risk by consuming underground hydrogen
“If you get microbes into a hydrogen filled reservoir, that hydrogen will be gone. And so you have a preservation risk for hydrogen that you definitely wouldn't have for helium, which is, you know, no, nobody can metabolize that at all, but same with oil and ga…”
Aug 23, 2024 positive
Aug 23, 2024
Aug 23, 2024 neutral
Johnson: A 1987 Mali well has produced high-purity hydrogen for decades
“There was a well drilled in 1987 in Mali, Africa, that was a water well that struck hydrogen and has been producing high purity hydrogen ever since. For, you know, for decades, and other wells have been drilled around that, and there, there's enough hydrogen p…”
Aug 23, 2024 neutral
Oct 31, 2024 neutral
Thiel: Synthetic fuels require $1/kg hydrogen and $100–$200/ton CO2
“And you know that, you know, for a fuel, if you want to get anywhere close to economically competitive, you know, subsidies decide you have to have hydrogen that's going to be on the order of a dollar per kilogram, and you have to have CO two that's in that 10…”
Oct 31, 2024 negative
Thiel: Single-pass conversion gains do not significantly improve green methanol economics
“If you get A better conversion of CO two and hydrogen to methanol on a single pass. It just really doesn't move the overall economics in a huge way because again, back to a previous point, CO two and hydrogen are the big cost drivers in that system.”
Nov 21, 2024 bearish
Kann: Synthetic methane cannot be produced below $20–$30/MMBtu near term
“With today's costs of hydrogen, and today's costs of CO₂, or even the next few years costs of both, You know, it's hard to picture producing synthetic methane. Again, we haven't even talked about the capex here, but it's hard to imagine producing synthetic met…”
Nov 21, 2024 bearish
Thiel: Even at $1/kg hydrogen, synthetic methane feedstock costs $10/MMBtu
“In the best case, you need something like half a kilo of hydrogen per kilo of methane. And so if we looked into a, to a wonderful version of the future where we, Get to the kind of magic one dollar per kilogram hydrogen mark that, you know, is, is on the DOE's…”
Nov 21, 2024 neutral
Thiel: Hydrogen Cost Is Overwhelmingly Dominant Cost Driver for Synthetic Fuels
“If you want to make a synthetic Fuel. If it's going to be a hydrocarbon, you do need a source of carbon, and the source of that CO₂, carbon CO₂, matters from a carbon economic perspective. But from a cost perspective, The thing that matters is number one, the …”
Nov 21, 2024
Ball: Green ammonia electricity costs $210 per ton at 2 cents/kWh
“So, in the in the example I just gave, so if you were saying two cents for energy cost, and we were saying it's 50 kilowatt hours per kilogram of hydrogen input, that's about 20 cents a kilo of ammonia, or 210 dollars per ton. So, almost half your budget, if w…”
Feb 13, 2025 neutral
Kimber: Intersect pivoted clean power assets from hydrogen to AI
“We thought maybe hydrogen would be first because of the supply side supports under the IRA. The demand just didn't materialize, and now all of a sudden, AI has just swept up all of the assets that we developed for, you know, behind the meter And co-located loa…”
Jun 5, 2025 bearish
Brough: Hydrogen-fueled gas turbines will struggle due to fuel supply constraints
“So while they're all spending a lot of money, and their engineers are working very diligently and doing some fantastic development, I have some doubts as to where, whether the market will actually see a significant Increase in purchases of gas turbines that ac…”
Jul 17, 2025 neutral
Kann: OBBB hydrogen extension produces narrow market favoring large developers
“I think you won't see, you know, a booming hydrogen economy as a result of this bill and the extension from end of 25, or I guess the early expiration being not as early as it could have been. It does mean I think some projects are going to move forward. Like,…”
Jul 17, 2025 bearish
Lubershain: Clean hydrogen producers' price sensitivity prevents US market turnaround
“Hydrogen, anyone making hydrogen is not going to be a price insensitive buyer. They're very price sensitive. They want the cheapest clean power. I don't know. I, I'm not personally super bullish on this making, helping make hydrogen make a turnaround”