why aren't all 160 resolved? a statement only gets an assessment when the public
record can support or contradict it. opinions and what-ifs never can, and 5 checkable
ones are still open, waiting for their date. predictions held up or didn't;
assertions are supported or contradicted. on every card:
▮▮▮▮▮ certainty ·
▮▮▮▮▮ debate potential. speakers are clickable
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Panay: Amazon cancels plenty of late-stage devices before shipping
“There are plenty of devices that get towards the end that don't make it to the shipping floor.”
Insight
Panay: Product teams that please every user have not pushed innovation far enough
“If every single person was happy with what you built, I promise you didn't push it far enough. I promise you just did not. But if everybody's pissed at you definitely pushed it too far, you know, and so you're, and so you have to find a little bit of that bala…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Panay: Alexa Plus will work on 97% of existing home devices
“And while it will work on 97% of devices out there right now in people's homes, we still want to do it in a way where when we're, when we switch people over because they choose to, that they feel great about it.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Panay: Alexa Plus usage spikes after users try agentic features once or twice
“Once you engage it once or twice, the usage spikes.”
Assertion Not publicly verifiable
Amazon machine learning models achieved 98% accuracy identifying cancer from scans
“At Amazon, we did a lot of like cancer identification from MRIs and CAT scans. And, you know, the ML was about 98% accurate, which is tremendously good.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Jeff Bezos believed two redundant systems were better than zero at Amazon
“Jeff Bezos at Amazon used to have this saying that two is better than zero. So he, we would have redundant systems at Amazon, but then work to consolidate them over time.”
Assertion Supported
Siegler: Anthropic capped Big Tech investor ownership in fundraising documents
“Famously Anthropic, you know, apparently built into their fundraising documents that Those companies can only own up to a certain threshold, because they didn't want to be beholden”
Assertion Contradicted
Siegler: Google and Amazon combined own just north of 36% of Anthropic
“Google and Amazon combined, I believe if my math is correct from all these court documents that I sort of went through, but I believe it's roughly correct that I think them combined, those two combined own something just north of 36%.”
Insight
Siegler: Retrofitting Old Voice Assistants With GenAI Is Harder Than Expected
“It's just a lot harder to sort of go back and try to shove this new technology into that old technology, even though on a surface level, they seem like they're similar. It seems like, you know, behind the scenes, they're not similar at all. And in fact, there'…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Kantrowitz: Amazon AI implementation leads to smaller developer teams
“Amazon, for instance, is a company that has smaller teams responsible for the same amount of code. Just with like less people to do it.”
Assertion Supported
Kantrowitz: 60% of Amazon sales come from third-party merchants
“60% of the company's e-commerce sales came from third-party merchants? Okay. Come from third-party merchants that get many of their products from China and then sell on Amazon's website.”
Assertion Supported
Amazon Has Finally Grown Into Its Pandemic-Era Warehouse Capacity
“The reality is while we've right-sized some parts of that supply chain footprint on the margin, we've largely grown our business into that capacity, right?”
Assertion Supported
Amazon Delivered 9 Billion Items Same-Day or Next-Day Last Year
“Last year we delivered nine billion items same day or next day. Nine billion, right? It is, you know, in delivery fees alone, US, prime members last year saved 500 dollars, right?”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Roy: OpenAI o3 Repeated Walmart 23 Times in Top Retailers Query
“However, this morning I asked, and I asked from the deep, deep research side, what are the top 150 retailers in the U.S. By revenue in 2024? Seemingly straightforward query. It returned Walmart 23 times and Amazon 36 times In this list.”
Assertion Supported
Panay: Amazon's Alexa launch event featured a live working product
“What makes you nervous in an event like that, you're not worried about the product working. I mean, six months ago, I would have worried about the product working, and I would have shown you more vision demos, like videos, but the product's working.”
What-if
Panay: Amazon Could Have Launched AI Faster Without Legacy Alexa Base
“If we started from zero customers, I think this is a different story. You can move a lot faster, we can solve problems, and then just add features as we go, if that makes sense. So maybe we just had a conversationalist, a pretty cool one, then we can add perso…”
Disclosure
Panos Panay: Alexa Plus will launch with a dedicated web interface
“And we haven't released the new Alexa app yet. It's coming with, if you get Alexa Plus, you get the Alexa app, the Alexa Plus app, as well as Alexa.com.”
Assertion Supported
Amazon pioneered using automated systems to negotiate with its fulfillment vendors
“When I was reporting on Amazon, I found that they were using automation systems to negotiate with the vendors who are supplying their fulfillment centers.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Garman: Andy Jassy's bureaucracy critique applied inside AWS too
“Yeah, I think it's across across Amazon. So it wasn't specific to the rest of Amazon. It was definitely inside of AWS too.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Garman: Cloud Optimization Is Largely Finished, Funding AI and AWS Growth
“Customers, I think number one, a lot of them have been optimized, right? And there's only so much you can kind of squeeze into an Optimize place and customers are still looking for optimizations, but a lot of that work has been done and they're using some of t…”
Prediction Didn’t hold up
Link: Amazon will generate $48B in free cash flow in 2024
“They are gonna generate free cash flow this year of forty eight billion dollars, so let's just put that to bed right there.”
Assertion Supported
Brown: Amazon pushed out its touchless tech lead and is closing stores
“The guy that developed the touchless technology for Amazon's retail was just pushed out of the company, and they are closing A lot of those Amazon go stores because there just didn't seem to be anything magical that made people want to go to them.”
Assertion Supported
Kantrowitz: Amazon has added hundreds of thousands of jobs since automating in 2015
“They've been implementing automation since 2015. By the way, they've grown their workforce by hundreds of thousands since.”
Disclosure
AWS's Matt Wood confirms Amazon completed its $4 billion Anthropic investment
“Yep, we've completed that investment, yep.”
Assertion Supported
Wood: AWS AI and Machine Learning Business Exceeds Multibillion-Dollar ARR
“Bedrock, which is the service that we make available to customers to build generative AI applications. That's one of our fastest growing services ever. And all up, AI machine learning at AWS is already a multi-billion dollar business. In terms of ARR.”
Assertion Partly supported
Petersen: Amazon only offers freight forwarding for goods sold on Amazon
“Amazon does not see global freight forwarding for brands unless they're shipping the product and selling it on Amazon. And so we just took a different, we don't compete with them in that regard. There's some overlap certainly in the fulfillment piece, but in t…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Petersen: Almost 10% of Flexport Deliveries Go to Amazon
“Well, I think we partner with Amazon a lot, too. I mean, we probably, like, almost 10% of our deliveries go to Amazon.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Srinivas: Amazon faces Google-like ad conflicts with conversational shopping
“For Amazon to do this hard, obviously, because they do rely on advertising revenue on amazon.com to keep amazon.com profitable, so they have, like, similar problems to Google there”
Assertion Supported
Coulter: Amazon flags and manually reviews accounts for excessive returns
“There's definitely like, you get flagged and there's like, I think there's special people who review things and I don't know what the limit is, but yeah, absolutely.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Coulter: Anticipated consumer backlash over Amazon Go surveillance never materialized
“And so when we built Amazon Go, my mind was full of every vicious fear people could have. You know, like, what if they poison our food? Amazon doesn't want us to cook at home anymore. And we prepared for all these eventualities. I mean, I wrote FAQs for the wo…”
Assertion Supported
Coulter: Average employee tenure at Amazon is now under two years
“The tenure, the average tenure is less than two years now.”
Insight
Coulter: Companies want Amazon's DNA but not its aggressive culture
“I think that people, when they bring in Amazonians, they often do it because they do want some of that Amazon DNA in their company, but it doesn't mean they want to be, like, waterboarded with it, you know.
You just arrive and change everything.
It's more like…”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Wood predicts generative AI will create multiple Amazon-sized companies
“And I think that there is going to be a wave of similarly Amazon Size companies that evolve out of the generative AI opportunity, generally. And so I think we're going to see multiple Amazon size organizations develop and grow over the next, who knows, 20 year…”
Insight
Wood: Generative AI makes ML far more accessible by eliminating model training
“One of the super interesting things about generative AI is inherently because you're not training the models yourself, you're taking models from Amazon and Meta and a whole host of other stability, AI, and just building on top of them, ah, it makes machine lea…”
Assertion Supported
Wood: Amazon Titan trained on public web data and licensed datasets
“Titan was trained on publicly available data. And. That's a very squishy phrase. It's very precise. Okay. And data which proprietary data that we had licensed specifically for the purpose of training.”
Opinion
Amazon uses AI to automate execution and make room for idea work
“And this is where I think Amazon has, and many of the tech giants have this key innovation, which is that they're starting to use artificial intelligence to minimize the amount of execution work, to make room for idea work, right?”
Insight
Narrative writing exposes logical gaps that PowerPoint slides allow hiding
“The thing about writing something down as opposed to putting it on a slide is you need to think things through, and I'll say this. I write for a living. It's the most painful thing. You know, it's a terrible decision as a career because it hurts. And the reaso…”
Insight
Amazon's workforce is polarized between one-year washouts and 15-year lifers
“And that's why you see a lot of employees who are there for, you know, a year and leave and a lot of employees who are there for 1015 years and not a lot of employees in the middle, because either you wash out or you become, you fall in love with it and you sa…”
Insight
Bezos designed an idea-circulation culture rather than inventing everything himself
“There's this misconception that Bezos is this visionary that's come up with every idea that Amazon has and that his, you know, underlings have just gone ahead and executed for it. Actually, what he's done is built a culture that is meant to circulate the ideas…”
Insight
Day One mindset requires building without constraint from legacy revenue sources
“The most important thing about being a company on your first day is that you can come in and build what the market needs without any regard for your legacy business.”
What-if
Amazon Would Not Be a $2 Trillion Company by Merely Automating Cashiers
“If he had been uncreative, he would have walked into a bookstore and said, you know, that cashier, we could automate the cashier. We could put a robot where the cashier is and check people out with a robot cashier. And you know, maybe that would have led to a …”
Insight
Sorkin: Retail investors cannot drive meme surges in mega-cap stocks
“I mean, it would be very hard For a retail base of investors to move the stock of an Apple or a Walmart or an Amazon in this kind of way.”
Assertion Supported
Amazon hosts Anthropic's AI models across classified government cloud environments
“Amazon hosts Anthropics models in the, in what they call bedrock. This includes in all of the classified spaces. So if the NSA is using Anthropics models. It is running in AWS secret cloud or top secret cloud.”
Assertion Supported
AWS revenue grew 28 percent after years of slower growth
“AWS, by the way, stuck in the 17, 18% growth rate range for the past few years grew 28%.”
Assertion Supported
Kantrowitz: Anthropic's defense models are hosted on Amazon's government cloud
“Anthropics models were hosted
On Amazon's cloud.
Their government cloud.
And so they upload the weights, weights to the model, and then you use it through Amazon.”
Assertion Supported
Anthropic previews Mythos model to around 50 critical infrastructure organizations
“The company is making a preview model of its new AI model called Mythos, available to about 50 companies and organizations that maintain critical infrastructure, including Amazon, Microsoft, Apple, Alphabet, and the Linux Foundation.”
Assertion Supported
Amazon Announces Alexa Integration With Oura Ring
“Yesterday, we announced an integration with Aura for wellness”
Assertion Contradicted
Kantrowitz: Amazon's Panos Panay says Alexa Plus rolls out broadly by October end
“But I did speak with Panos Panay, the head of devices and services of at Amazon. And he said by the end of October, everybody should have it. So no more early access.”