why aren't all 3,713 resolved? a statement only gets an assessment when the public
record can support or contradict it. opinions and what-ifs never can, and 120 checkable
ones are still open, waiting for their date. predictions held up or didn't;
assertions are supported or contradicted. on every card:
▮▮▮▮▮ certainty ·
▮▮▮▮▮ debate potential. speakers are clickable
What-if
Beck: Rocket Lab would already be launching Neutron if it were expendable
“If our job was just to make a, you know, an expendable launch vehicle, we'd be there now. We'd, we'd be launching Neutrons flat out.”
Disclosure
Beck: Archimedes is designed for benign durability over maximum performance
“This is, I would say is the first engine that is just not designed to be like that. It's designed to be like the most benign engine that you could possibly imagine so that you can just run and run and run and run and never even think about it.”
Opinion
Beck: The biggest commercial application of space hasn't been conceived yet
“I think, you know, my hot take would be, I think, the biggest thing to be done in space hasn't even been thought about, let alone talked about. So I think we're at the very, very beginning of the whole process. If you want to, you know, make an analogy here, i…”
Assertion Partly supported
Beck: Branson poured $1.2B into Virgin Orbit before it went bankrupt
“And, you know, at that, at the time, our nearest competitor was Virgin Orbit, and that was funded by, you know, Sir Richard Branson. And in the end, I think Richard put 1.2 billion dollars into that company before it ultimately went bankrupt with a, you know, …”
Insight
Beck: Startups that fail most spectacularly are usually the best funded
“If you look at if I look back and think of, you know, lots of startups that I've seen or been involved with, the ones that have failed most spectacularly have been the ones that have been funded the most well.”
Opinion
Beck: Spacecraft components are massive moats due to fractured supply chains
“Launch is a huge moat, but all of these spacecraft components are huge moats as well, because, you know, it doesn't matter how much capital you've got. If you turn up tomorrow and say, I want to build a thousand satellites, good luck. Like it's just not happen…”
Insight
Beck: Large space companies must build and launch their own satellites
“You know, I've always viewed the large space companies are going to have the ability to build on their own satellites and launch them. And if you're beholden to someone else providing you all the critical components and you, your ability to scale is governed b…”
Insight
Beck: In rocket design, engineers across all disciplines must be equally miserable
“Everything is a giant engineering compromise in the rocket world, and if you fill a room up with engineers from every discipline, if one of those engineers from one of those disciplines is happy, you have failed. Like, everybody needs to be equally as miserabl…”
Assertion Contradicted
Lamm: Woolly mice are second most genetically modified organisms behind dire wolves
“These are the second most genetically modified
Multicellular organisms on the planet after our direwolves.”
Assertion Partly supported
Lamm: ViaGen cloning efficiency reached 80% versus 2% industry norm
“Well, Viagen had like cloning efficiencies at 80%, or most people are at two percent, right?”
Prediction Didn’t hold up
Lamm: Earth is forecasted to lose 50% of biodiversity within 25 years
“It's currently forecasted that we're going to lose up to 50% of all biodiversity in the next 25 years.”
Disclosure
Lamm: Colossal is educating USDA and defense agencies on genetic tech
“Like right now we are educating USDA, the intelligence community, the Department of War and others on these technologies and how they can combat these issues domestically and abroad.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Lamm: Colossal could eradicate the screwworm problem in six to seven months
“Our solution, which is already made could eradicate the entire problem in every model that we've done in six to seven months.”
Opinion
Lamm: Direct air carbon capture is a dumb climate solution
“So when we were solving these problems, if we are solving it in dumb ways, like, I think, you know, a lot of the air capture systems in other ways, the direct air caption carbon systems and others in a lot of other ways that we're trying to solve climate are d…”
Opinion
Lamm: Academic research labs are underfunded, politicized, and dilapidated
“Go work back in academia where you're underfunded. It's all like massively politicized and it's massively competitive and your labs are like held up by pizza boxes, right?”
Insight
Tech Sector Is Over-Indexing on Foundation Models Instead of Context
“We're over-indexing on the model. I think models are great. But being able to take that model, package that, all that context, all that knowledge, all that training, and be able to deliver a solution to you is what the next big sort of revolution needs to be.”
Insight
Acquirers' Biggest Mistake Is Imperialistic Disrespect of Founder Intelligence
“The biggest mistake that people make during acquisitions is underestimate the intelligence of the people who built the business that you acquired. Because sometimes you take on the imperialistic attitude. I bought you, hence you must work for me.”
Insight
AI Handles Mainstream Tasks But Fails on Cybersecurity Edge Cases
“AI can be great at 80% use cases. We live in the .1% use case. We're looking for the needle in the haystack. AI is not good at looking at the, for every needle in the haystack.”
Insight
Overwhelming Teams With AI-Native Hires Forces Legacy Employees to Adapt
“We infuse those AI native people into teams and say, keep hiring until you get to make sure that these people are more people in that team than people who've been there before. So once you start overwhelming these teams with more AI native people, you start wa…”
Opinion
Market Is Currently Pricing In Perfect Execution for AI Companies
“At the present, the market is pricing in perfect execution for every company. Every idea that you see, the market wants to reward it because it thinks that Their returns are outsized, and the gains are going to be so huge that it doesn't matter.”
Insight
Foroughi: AI cannot yet autonomously generate high-performing long video ads
“It's not at a place where you're just going to get a massive amount of inflow of advertisements that are diverse and creatively inspired and going to create lifts and campaigns, but their tools are available now so that humans can create ads much faster and mu…”
Insight
Gio: Wasteful ideas and bad taste offset AI's productivity gains
“I think a big, big mistake that people are making is that because of the AI, building things become easier. People are making a lot of bad decisions, bad tastes, wasteful ideas that actually offset the empowerment of AI.”
Disclosure
AppLovin halted investor relations for over a year during its market bottom
“We actually didn't do any investor relations for well over a year at the bottom, because what were we going to convey to investors is we're rebuilding our technology stock is dirt cheap, but nobody buys something that's dirt cheap.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Foroughi: AI chatbots will not eliminate ad-driven e-commerce
“We get questions like, well, isn't the chatbot going to tell everyone what to buy and just complete the transaction and no one will ever do e-commerce off of an ad again. And what that leaves a sight of is that people actually like to shop and people want to l…”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Foroughi: Public will not support AI without use cases beyond search
“Until people start understanding what the average person can have as positive use cases that are incremental to search, they're not going to be proponents of AI, and there's no reason to expect them to be.”
Insight
Monroe-Anderson: Battlefield 3D printing fails to solve drone supply chain bottlenecks
“Generally factories are really efficient when they are large and centralized and three D printers can be very useful for adapting drones to Various mission sets, but you'd only be, like, the airframe or a payload adapter. What we're trying to solve for is the …”
Opinion
Monroe-Anderson: Modern conflict demands US factories producing millions of drones annually
“America should have the capability to have factories that can make millions of drones per year, because that's what modern conflict demands.”
Assertion Supported
Monroe-Anderson says 90% of Russian Shahed drones are intercepted midair
“Now that's really coming true, where, like, 90% of the DeepStrike Shawhead drones that Russia is using are getting taken out of the sky before they can even hit a target.”
Assertion Supported
Monroe-Anderson: China is supplying drone components to both Ukraine and Russia
“China is supplying drones and components to both sides. So to Ukraine and to Russia, and they have by far the strongest drone and just electronics industrial base.”
Disclosure
Monroe-Anderson: Neros boards, chips, motors, and magnets never touch China
“We've tried to go quite far, and we think further than anyone else, where, like, you can look at our boards, you can look at all of the chips that go onto our boards, those will not
Have ever touched China. Our motors are made outside of China. The material th…”
Assertion Supported
China completely dominates PCB precursor chemicals used in US defense systems
“Printed circuit boards, they use precursor materials. The manufacturing uses precursor materials that is completely dominated by China. So, even if you go to one of these board shops in America that, that specializes in, you know, ITAR, Exquisite, like, they c…”
Opinion
Monroe-Anderson: DJI Has by Far the Best Technology
“With DJI, like they just have by far the best technology.”
Insight
US drone manufacturing is industrialization, not reindustrialization, because it never existed
“We're not trying to re-industrialize, we're trying to industrialize something that never existed in America, pretty much. Like, electronics and drones specifically just never existed in America”
Disclosure
Monroe-Anderson: Neros aims to be the 'Toyota of defense manufacturing'
“I say we want to be the Toyota of defense manufacturing where instead of being like a current prime where we're very exquisite and siloed, we're very you know, we're making these very accessible systems and we're ubiquitous across allies.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Monroe-Anderson: Autonomous drones in Ukraine broke when facing battlefield edge conditions
“I think that's one of the things that we've seen, especially with systems that went over and failed. I think it was a lot of the systems that are in theory supposed to be easier to use or more autonomous, but then they, like, met these edge conditions that exi…”
Opinion
Lopez: Competing home batteries target wealthy buyers and neglect the grid
“So if you look at other competitive battery products that are like sold mostly to wealthy people at very high costs, they're like small, typically wall mounted, take a long time to install and aren't really focused on supporting the grid.”
Opinion
Fox: Coding Agents Have Expanded AssemblyAI's TAM by 100x
“So I think about this as like our TAM has just increased by a hundred X because we're not just selling to engineering teams within product companies. It's now like any, anyone.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Fox: Most AI note-takers use AssemblyAI as voice infrastructure
“And so the reason, you know, most AI note takers are using assembly as the voice infrastructure is because our models are the most scalable, right?”
Insight
Fox: Training data drives roughly 75 percent of AI model performance
“It's really, probably, like, 75% of it is, like, the data that you're training on. Like, I would say for any AI model, it's like, there's always, like, you know, like, these, like, step functions and, like, algorithms and architectures and stuff, but the data …”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Fox: Callers hang up immediately if voice agents disclose they are AI
“If our customers, if they're building a voice agent and you disclose up front that you're an AI, people just hang up versus if you don't, people continue.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Wu: Nearly all software engineers will use coding agents within three years
“The rough answer for, you know, two, three years from now is roughly every software engineer in the world, and probably a lot more than all the Just the software engineers because I think a lot more people will be able to produce code and produce products and …”
Insight
Wu: Reinforcement learning can solve basically any clearly defined benchmark
“We're kind of getting to the point where you can solve basically any benchmark, right? Because what does it mean to have a benchmark? It means you've already defined the task. You've clarified what success or failure looks like. You've given a bunch of example…”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Wu: AI will solve all intelligence problems, but not in six months
“I really don't think that there are, like, intelligence problems that AI will not solve in the long term. I just don't think of that as, like, it's gonna be all over in six months.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Scott Wu: Single-use and self-driving software will exist
“Like single use software is going to exist. Like self-driving software is going to exist, right?”
Insight
Tech revenues are shifting from high-margin cloud to lower-margin AI compute
“Like, these, you must build these new data centers, because at some point, all of your revenue will become here, and this revenue over here in the old data center, that was asset light, high margin, is now moving to asset heavy, lower margin, big dollars, but …”
Prediction Open · timeframe Dec 2030
Tony Kim: Utility-scale, million-qubit quantum computers will arrive around 2030
“It's very interesting when you look at these long-dated technologies. All roads converge to 2030. It's like quantum computing, utility scale, logically error-corrected, million-qubit quantum computer, twenty-thirty.”
Assertion Supported
Tony Kim: Chip companies have higher profit margins than software or pharmaceuticals
“They have the highest profitability of any company in the world of the sector is chip companies. They're higher margins than software, pharmaceuticals, industrials, telecom, anything.”
Prediction Held up
Tony Kim: China has 30 to 40 potential robotics IPOs this year
“I'm looking at the current pipeline. I see 30, 40 potential IPOs this year in China.”