why aren't all 58 resolved? a statement only gets an assessment when the public
record can support or contradict it. opinions and what-ifs never can, and 2 checkable
ones are still open, waiting for their date. predictions held up or didn't;
assertions are supported or contradicted. on every card:
▮▮▮▮▮ certainty ·
▮▮▮▮▮ debate potential. speakers are clickable
Assertion Contradicted
Gracias: DOGE found thousands of non-citizens on voter rolls in four states
“We looked at the voter rolls. We found these people, thousands of them on the voter rolls, and we found many of those people had voted, right? In one state in particular, well over a thousand voted.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Gracias: 1.3M non-citizens with flagged Social Security numbers receive Medicaid
“We found in the benefit programs that every benefit program that was being accessed by these people, you know, 1.3 million of them are on Medicaid right now, today.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Gracias: Flagged Social Security numbers yielded terrorist watchlist hits
“We sent this data list to the National Targeting Center. They, and I don't want to get too far into the data, but I can tell you they found hard hits in the Targeting Center of very bad people. Criminals and people on terrorist watch list that are in this grou…”
Assertion Supported
DOGE sampling found non-citizens registered to vote and actually voting
“We have sampled a handful of states and in those handful of states we found people registered to vote, and we have found people who actually voted”
Assertion Supported
Gracias: DOGE voter investigations yielded arrests in Florida and New York
“We had already three arrests here in Florida, actually, and one indictment in New York.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Gracias: One DOGE engineer finds 10 to 20 non-citizen voters daily
“It takes an engineer about a day to find 10 to 20 cases per state in sampling.”
Assertion Contradicted
Gracias: Biden administration raised citizenship database API fees, deterring states
“In the Biden administration, they raised the price, when I think about a dollar, an API call, to three dollars and change the API call, and all the states stop using it.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Gracias: Social Security will go bankrupt between 2032 and 2037
“Man, this system's going bankrupt. It's going to be bankrupt in 23 to seven. The country overall, as you guys know, talked about many times, is on its way toward bankruptcy.”
Assertion Not publicly verifiable
Gracias: DOGE found 2.4M questionable non-citizen Social Security entries
“This is about 5.4 million people total. There were about 1.2 million people that the status is marked as unknown, and about 1.2 million people that were marked as general parole.”
Assertion Supported
Gracias: US policy funneled $13B to $15B annually to human traffickers
“You've got to realize we gave 13 to fifteen billion dollars a year to human traffickers.”
Assertion Contradicted
Gracias: Social Security Administration issued numbers based on minimal ID
“You get a Social Security number before we got here by walking in office. Answering, you know, with a medical record and a school ID that had your name and your date, the date of birth on it.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Gracias warns US federal bureaucracy risks becoming a Latin American kleptocracy
“What I'm afraid of now is we have a bureaucracy that is about to turn into a kleptocracy. I mean, a Latin American style kleptocracy.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Gracias: xAI will win AI race due to cluster efficiency and data
“It's a 100,000 GPU cluster. It's the most dense coherent cluster in the world, and it will just train faster and better. Than other clusters. And it's also built for the most cheaply, and the fastest. So, XAI will have the highest training capital, and I also …”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Gracias: Electric VTOL startups will earn basic industrial margins due to competition
“SpaceX is an end of one. If you compare that to someone making an electric vehicle that, say, an electric airplane or electric VTOL, that will not be an end of one. It'll be an end of many. And in an end of many business, you're ultimately going to have margin…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Gracias: US can cut spending 15% without touching core entitlements
“I think if we had the political will, you'd easily get that 15%, no problem. Not without any problem at all, and without cutting the core entitlement programs.”
Assertion Partly supported
Gracias: 88% of departing federal workers took voluntary severance packages
“I think it's 88% of the people that have left the government have taken packages. The packages are very lucrative. There's, you know, nine months or so of severance and they're voluntary.”
Assertion Supported
Gracias: Secretary Noem signed memo making SAVE citizenship database access free
“Secretary of Homeland Security, I want to thank her, Secretary Noem, has just signed a memo, a policy memo, to make it free.”
Disclosure
Gracias: DOGE will overhaul both legal and illegal immigration systems
“These programs, I've mapped the entire system now they go from DHS to State Department to labor. They're very disconnected, and they're hard to manage, so we are going to work on this. One of the things we are going to work on and hopefully leave behind is bot…”
Assertion Open · timeframe Apr 2026
Gracias: January 1st was the most common birthdate in border data
“When we looked at the birth certificate data that was presented at the border, the number one birth date was one. And it was four times more likely to be born on one-on-one than any other day of the year.”
Assertion Contradicted
Gracias: 23% of analyzed border records lacked fingerprint biometrics
“We found that 23% of the records we looked at did not have fingerprints.”
Assertion Partly supported
Gracias: Over 70 border agents committed suicide during recent border surge
“Both Border Patrol and Border Protection told me they had the highest suicide rates of all time during the surge. Okay, over 70, over 70 of these agents committed suicide in this period.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Gracias: 1980s amnesty turned California into a solidly blue state
“Ronald Reagan signed amnesty, and you know, some, four years later, it is now a solidly blue state, and I think some of us on this program, I know you, Jason, are a refugee from California because of that, because of some of those policies, and I want to be, I…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Gracias: US government lacks controller function and accounting reconciliation to pass audits
“There is no control. There is no controller. There's no reconciliation. The reason they can't pass audits.”
Prediction Open · timeframe Apr 2028
Gracias: Orbital rockets will enable sub-hour point-to-point global Earth transport
“Yeah, I mean, look, Gavin could jump in here too, but the reality is once you could take that much mass to orbit, you can move anything around the planet very quickly. You can kind of go up or spin below you and come down. So transportation generally changes. …”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Gracias: Starlink will deliver very high margins and strong ROIC
“So it's like in building Starlink, same thing, capital going in, but we know that the margins and the profitability of that business on the back end will be very, very high, and so the ROIC will be very good.”
Assertion Supported
Gracias: US economy is currently in a recession
“Look, we think, I think we're in a recession. I mean, I'll, I don't know if someone's already said this, but we're in a recession. We're in a recession.”
Disclosure
Gracias: Valor held fracking assets in the same fund as Tesla
“And in the same fund we did Tesla, we actually had fracking assets.”
Assertion Partly supported
Gracias: US workers are eight times more productive than Chinese workers
“The productivity difference between the kind of U.S. And China right now is about eight to one. So a U.S. Worker is eight times more productive than a Chinese worker.”
Opinion
Gracias: Government complexity makes Twitter overhaul look like JV league
“So if Twitter was like the JV league, this is like the NBA. It's the most complex thing I've ever seen. I have in, ah, our office in DC, I have a, I've mapped now, as an example, the entire system of, like, basically from the border to the benefits programs. I…”
Opinion
Gracias proposes a short-term civic public service model for US government
“I think there should be a third type, which is what you're talking about. People that are doing public service for a short duration, shorter duration, whether it's me, one-thirty as a SGE, or, you know, it's a couple of years as an engineer or something. I thi…”
Disclosure
Gracias: Elon Musk directed him to audit Social Security before the VA
“Yeah, no, what happened was I had actually volunteered to go to the VA because that's kind of, as you guys know, close to my heart. And Elon said to me, look, great, you can do that next, but will you go to SSA first and see what's going on there? Cause it's t…”
Assertion Partly supported
Gracias: Average court date wait time for immigration Notices to Appear is six years
“And while you're waiting for your court date, which could be six, six years out is the average, by the way.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Gracias: Initial critic deleted counter-chart and admitted DOGE data was right
“The person, the first person that posted the chart actually deleted it and sent me a post saying, Hey, I, you know, I'm deleting it because I get it. You're right.”
Opinion
Gracias calls Twitter restructuring the biggest corporate turnaround in history
“It's literally the biggest turnaround, I think, ever in history.”
Disclosure
Antonio Gracias: Valor avoids investments where government pay exceeds one-third of revenue
“We literally have a rule here government pay or in those areas, if it's more than like a third of the business, we don't do it.”
Assertion Partly supported
Gracias: DOGE is a renamed government agency originally created under Obama
“Doge is not a new agency. It's the renaming of existing agency. I can't remember the name of it. We'll have to find it. Elon tweeted about this some weeks ago. That was set up under Obama actually to do this, to create an audit function to the government.”
Prediction Held up
Gracias: SpaceX will need at least two to three months to rebuild launchpad
“It'll take at least two or three months to really get the pad rebuilt and get another vehicle back on for testing maybe longer.”
Disclosure
Gracias: Not putting more capital into Flexport was a major mistake
“We invested in Andrewl with Palmer. We have a small investment in Flexport, which should have been one of the biggest mistakes the last 10 years of my career is not putting more money in Flexport.”
Opinion
Gracias: Offshoring US chip manufacturing to TSMC was a terrible idea
“TSMC basically took the many, this idea of outsourcing manufacturing assets that Intel did with TSMC in the beginning, Created that business and moved most of our high technology and chips off and offshore into Taiwan. This is like a terrible idea.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Gracias: US industrial policy is needed to reshore Intel and AMD manufacturing
“I think actually it's going to require industrial policy to force people like Intel, AMD to want to bring stuff back into the U.S., and to really get great talent to want to do it.”
Disclosure
Gracias: Valor Equity Partners employs a Caltech neuroscientist to evaluate people
“We have a woman who's got a PhD in the neuroscience of emotion, Caltech now, on staff, that helps us learn, as you said, always learning, about how to assess people and how to assess their emotional states.”
Insight
Gracias: Major technological shifts always cause political disruption and often war
“When you have moments of large technological change, you always have political disruption because the means of communication have changed. This, the Gutenberg press, the tall ship, and you just go back and look, it always leads to a lot of disruption and often…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Gracias: Current U.S. productivity statistics are inaccurate due to remote work
“I think the productivity numbers in American, that we're seeing today are wrong, because they're not capturing what's happening underneath the technology, because these remote environments.”
Opinion
Gracias: Allocating $10B in venture capital over Zoom is a bad idea
“Like being able to allocate ten billion dollars in a venture fund in two years over zoom and think that's on just the metrics and not see people. I think that's a bad idea.”
Assertion Supported
Gracias: Social Security Administration hasn't closed a single field office under DOGE
“We haven't closed one field office, not one since we've been there.”
Disclosure
DOGE publicly released Social Security website metrics after improving performance
“You know, we were, as an example, at Social Security, we were criticized for the web setup time. Well, turns out web setup time has been better since we got there than after, imagine we have engineers. And we've now published the metrics on the website publicl…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Gracias: Harvard student dropped out with two classes left for DOGE
“He is in, he's in my son's class at Harvard. He dropped out of Harvard with two classes left.”
Assertion Supported
Gracias: Twitter cut 80% of full-time staff following acquisition
“80% of the people gone. That doesn't include all the contractors that were there.”