why aren't all 92 resolved? a statement only gets an assessment when the public
record can support or contradict it. opinions and what-ifs never can, and 6 checkable
ones are still open, waiting for their date. predictions held up or didn't;
assertions are supported or contradicted. on every card:
▮▮▮▮▮ certainty ·
▮▮▮▮▮ debate potential. speakers are clickable
Disclosure
Lutnick: Google, Microsoft, and Amazon are building U.S. government software for free
“I go to the heads of Google and Microsoft and Amazon. They're all For America. Building for us. Right. For free. Right. To make America better.”
Opinion
Benioff calls Microsoft Copilot a universal failure and a complete disaster
“I think in the last few years, what we've kind of heard, and you know, some of it has come from OpenAI, but especially from Microsoft, that we're in this co-pilot world, and these co-pilots have universally failed. The level of accuracy, the spillage of inform…”
Prediction Open · timeframe May 2029
Chamath: Nvidia will likely compete directly with GCP, AWS, and Azure
“So I think it's likely that Nvidia goes on a full frontal assault against GCP and Amazon and Microsoft.”
Prediction Partly held up
Calacanis: Microsoft will release an OpenAI search engine impacting Google
“Microsoft, I think is going to release a and there's a prediction as well, a search engine with Open AI, that has a significant impact on Google's franchise.”
Prediction Open · timeframe Jun 2030
Friedberg: Microsoft faces core application revenue decline within next five years
“I do think that there's a real probability of revenue decline in the next five years. So if you look at the enterprise install base, I think that cloud gets competed away. So I do think like on the application software layer, they're going to have a really har…”
Prediction Open · timeframe Dec 2028
Kirtley: Helion will bring 50MW fusion plant online for Microsoft in 2028
“We have a per, a power purchase agreement to build a power plant with them to come online in 20, 28. This is 50 megawatts.”
Opinion
Musk argues Microsoft exercises more control over OpenAI than OpenAI does
“Really what you have is, I think, at the end of the day, Microsoft having more control than OpenAI. They have access to all the source code. They have access to all the weights of the you know, GPT-IV and future versions.”
Opinion
Chamath: FTC wastes taxpayer money funding frivolous lawsuits tech giants win
“And I think it just wastes taxpayer money by funding these frivolous lawsuits that then sophisticated organizations like Microsoft and meta just win.”
Opinion
Chamath: Chip and cloud investments in AI startups round-trip cash
“So whenever I see a chip maker and a cloud provider come together to put in a lot of money, it's essentially round tripping cash. They're giving them money, which then they use to buy their services. And then you know, you just you're just pumping revenue.”
Opinion
Chamath: Big Tech companies have passed peak growth and become cash cows
“I think we're now well past peak big tech. Their valuations may still go up because they generate such an enormous amount of cash flow. But these are exactly those kinds of businesses now. They are X growth, large cash flow businesses.”
Insight
Chamath: OpenAI selling 49% to Microsoft proves foundation models have capped upside
“If it was a highly proprietary asset, you would have never sold 49% of it to Microsoft for ten billion dollars, because you would assume that it was worth a trillion dollars. So it's a huge tell on the part of OpenAI, their deep understanding, and they underst…”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Palihapitiya predicts Google losing search market share kills FTC antitrust cases
“Microsoft taking five or 600 basis points of share is the best way to ensure that the FTC has zero credibility in going after Google or anybody else in tech. Those, all of those things I think are DOA.”
Opinion
Sacks: Microsoft clones products from Slack, Okta, and Zoom to weaken them
“If Microsoft can basically clone the sort of the breakthrough innovative product, you know, just to say they do one every year and then they put a crappy version of that in their bundle. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. 10% or 50% worse, but they give it away effectively for…”
Opinion
Sacks: Microsoft bundling cloned software into enterprise packages is anti-competitive dumping
“I think it's very anti-competitive, actually. I think it's akin to dumping.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Laffont: Top AI platform revenue could surpass Microsoft by 2028
“We estimate that only, not only is it bigger than Azure, but by the end of the year it could be bigger than AWS and potentially bigger than all of Microsoft. By twenty-twenty-eight.”
Opinion
Ackman: Amazon, Meta, and Microsoft are undervalued amid AI hype
“I think a similar thing is happening today, in a sense, to Amazon and Meta, Microsoft.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Calacanis: All consumer AI queries will eventually be free
“My base case here is that all consumer queries are going to be free. Apple's going to make them free. They're already free for Google. I think Meta is going to make them free and actually have a decent product soon, and Microsoft, same thing.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Nadella: Software builders will use multiple AI models, not just one
“In that app server, one of the things that structurally now is pretty clear is anyone building any application or any company is going to use Not one model, but all the models, right?”
Insight
Nadella: Orchestrating role-prompted models beats any single frontier model
“What it proves is that by assigning roles, right? So investigator, data analyst, domain expert, just giving even prompted roles to models, And then orchestrating them gets better results than any one single frontier model.”
Prediction Open · timeframe Dec 2026
Calacanis: Big Tech will make a $50B+ AI acquisition in 2026
“For twenty-twenty-six, I think we're going to see some massive M&A. It doesn't matter to me how it occurs, but I do think we're going to see a fifty billion plus deal, and I think it could be, ah, one of the Mac seven, an Apple, a Meta, a Microsoft, or an Amaz…”
Prediction Open · timeframe Jun 2030
Chamath Palihapitiya predicts Microsoft's employee base will grow over five years
“So I suspect that Microsoft business on the margin grows back to Dave's point. Some of the four 93 shrink and go away. It'll be cheaper for Microsoft to bundle together a bunch of other products that are point features today. And so they'll have more people. T…”
Assertion Supported
Chamath: Microsoft turned to Anduril after failing a $24B Army contract
“They had a twenty four billion dollar contract with the United States Army to deliver some whiz bang thing. And they realized that they couldn't deliver it. And so what did they do? They went to Anduril.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Chamath: Big tech and Elon Musk will win the AI hardware war
“In a capital war, I think the big companies like Google, Amazon, Microsoft, Meta, And brands like Elon will always be able to attract effectively infinite capital, and their cost of capital goes to zero, which means they'll be able to win this hardware war.”
Assertion Supported
Baker: Microsoft's largest GPU cluster remains smaller than xAI's Memphis cluster
“The best information I have is the largest cluster Microsoft has after panicking. It's still smaller than XAI's cluster in Memphis.”
Disclosure
Hoffman details Inflection AI deal returning 1x to investors
“With a, you know, kind of outside party, you can get paid enough in a non-exclusive IP license and an ability to selectively hire folks, and then you can dividend some of that out to investors. So investors, you know, get back a, you know, kind of a one X and …”
Opinion
Chamath: Google ruling is tech's most important antitrust case since Microsoft in 2000
“I think that this Google thing is the most important thing that's happened in tech since the Microsoft DOJ decision in 2000.”
Prediction Held up
Palihapitiya: Google breakup unlikely, Microsoft-style consent decree very likely
“Again, the big O outcome of breaking up the company, like what happened in Mabel, I don't think that's going to happen here. A little O outcome that is a consent decree similar to the one that Microsoft had to sign is very likely.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Sacks: Microsoft will systematically dominate enterprise software through bundling unless stopped
“If we don't do that, I do think that Microsoft will use the power of the bundle to systematically dominate enterprise software, and they won't take on everybody at once. But like I said, they'll, every year they'll add a new product to the bundle.”
What-if
Chamath: Inflection AI deal would not happen without Hoffman and Gates
“They were able to get a deal for investors that would have never happened otherwise.”
Opinion
Sacks: Microsoft's Inflection AI acqui-hire was a bailout for investors
“This was a bailout of the investors.”
Assertion Supported
Gurley: Four of Elizabeth Warren's top ten donors are big tech companies
“Four of the top 10 contributors to Elizabeth Warren are Alphabet, Apple, Microsoft, Amazon.”
Opinion
Friedberg: Google has a massive structural AI advantage over Microsoft
“I think Google has such an incredible AI advantage over Microsoft. And, you know, Microsoft is almost solely dependent on open AI, this small startup company, and all of Bing chats is powered by it. And Microsoft hasn't built out the infrastructure, the team, …”
Opinion
Sacks: Regulators should mandate itemized individual pricing for software bundles
“What you need to do is require that when they create a bundle, every product in that bundle needs to basically have an individual price. And the price of every product in that bundle should add up to the cost of the bundle.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Chamath: Microsoft forced Slack into acquisition by Salesforce
“And in many ways, David, it forced the hand of Slack to be acquired by Salesforce.”
Insight
Palihapitiya: Startups should target monolithic vendors, not bundled platforms
“It's much, much, much easier to build value when you're competing against a monolithic product company versus an entangled platform company.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Chamath: Microsoft's open app store strategy will pressure Apple and Google
“And I think this is a first step towards a really interesting play that Microsoft could pull, which is essentially to scorch the earth of app stores, which is Google's and Apple's really big money printer to make a completely open permissible platform with ver…”
Opinion
Chamath: Microsoft is the most immune Big Tech company to long-term issues
“There is one business above all others that I think is immune amongst big tech from any sort of real long-term issues. And that's Microsoft.”
Insight
Chamath: Microsoft faces less regulatory scrutiny than consumer Big Tech
“Microsoft is beyond the level of regulatory scrutiny that the rest of big tech actually has because they are consumer businesses.”
Prediction Held up
Chamath predicts Microsoft's $68B acquisition of Activision Blizzard will close
“I still think this Microsoft Activision deal on balance gets done, because if you take the absolute values away from it, The reality is that it's an adjacent part of Microsoft's core business, and there's nothing fundamentally monopolistic about what would hap…”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Palihapitiya: Microsoft entering Notion's market will succeed with 80% feature parity
“This past week, Microsoft decided to go after Notion, and it's going to be, I think, a very similar story where, you know, once they decide to sort of go after this product experience, they only need to be 80% as good. And then the distribution and bundling an…”
Opinion
Sacks: Microsoft's presenter introductions reflect woke capitalism out of control
“So, look, this is just woke capitalism. This is wokeism out of control.”
Assertion Partly supported
Gerstner: Nadella reports over 30% ROIC for Microsoft token infrastructure
“Satya is out this week saying, you know, citing Morgan Stanley's report and saying they're seeing over a 30% return on invested capital in tokens as a service, right?”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Friedberg: Early Google benchmarked against millions of Yahoo and Microsoft search results
“At Google in the early days, we would submit millions of search queries to Yahoo and Microsoft search engines to see what the results sets were. And we would compare our results against their results as a way of improving our search engine rankings and our alg…”
Assertion Supported
Chamath: Microsoft and Amazon allocating billions toward forward-deployed engineers
“Microsoft just announced a two and a half billion dollar investment to stand up in FDE, or Amazon is spending a billion dollars to create an FDE.”
Assertion Supported
Roberts: IREN's $9.7B Microsoft deal uses 5% of its capacity
“We signed a 9.7 billion dollar contract with them late last year, but as I was explaining to you before the show, that's five percent of our capacity, so.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Calacanis: Major AI labs will never permit root-level system access
“Nobody like Claude or XAI or Microsoft would ever allow you to do this because it's so dangerous, obviously.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Nadella: Enterprise AI ROI initially comes from customer service, supply chain, HR
“Top-down is if I look at the ROI of applying AI in customer service or in supply chain, or in HR self-service, those are the easy projects where IT and CXOs can make calls, and that's where you're seeing the first drop of real AI adoption.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Chamath: AI decoding chip market will quickly become highly fragmented
“What we are quickly seeing is that there's going to be a highly fragmented layer of decoding chips that exist in the marketplace. Grok is one. TPU is one. Microsoft has a spin. Amazon has Inferentia. Facebook, I think, is Apparently spinning up their own silic…”