Dec 10, 2022 · 1h 13m · allin
E107: The Twitter Files Parts 1-2: shadow banning, story suppression, interference & more
David Sacks · 21m spoken Jason Calacanis · 21m spoken Chamath Palihapitiya · 13m spoken David Friedberg · 7m spoken Kevin O'Leary · 38s spoken Joe Kernen · 31s spoken
0:00 / 0:00
▶ Watch on YouTube →
gold bands on the timeline = statements, start to end. Hover to read, click to jump. CC turns on captions
In Episode 107 of The All-In Podcast, the hosts analyze the Twitter Files revelations regarding shadow banning, blacklists, and pre-election story suppression, while examining broader institutional censorship, geopolitical shifts in China, the FTX collapse, and US political primary dynamics.
How this conversation actually went
Every chapter scored 0–10 on four independent dynamics. Hover any point for the reasoning behind the score. The hosts hold 97.7% of the talking time here. How this is scored →
The hosts as informed peer 5.7 Guest teaching 2.1 Guest disagreement 3.8 The hosts pushing back 3.4
speaking balance: gold is the hosts, purple is the guest (3 minute bins)
Sharpest disagreement ▶ 42:06 Sacks rejects Calacanis's framing on Trump and 2016
Sacks forcefully dismisses Calacanis's query regarding Trump's 2016 rally statements, calling the line of questioning delusional and pure Trump Derangement Syndrome rather than answering directly.
Hardest push from the hosts ▶ 42:06 Calacanis presses Sacks on foreign power hackingCalacanis repeatedly interrupts Sacks and demands a direct yes-or-no answer on whether presidential candidates should encourage foreign powers to hack political opponents.
Biggest teaching moment ▶ 1:02:05 Chamath details fraudulent conveyance doctrineChamath educates the room on the legal principles of fraudulent conveyance, using the Bernie Madoff bankruptcy precedents to demonstrate why FTX promotional payouts and political donations must be clawed back.
The host holds their own ▶ 53:42 Chamath delivers macroeconomic demographic analysisChamath demonstrates deep expertise in global population demographics, dismantling popular assumptions about population surplus and outlining multi-decade economic impacts on global workforce productivity.
the scores for every segment, with the reasoning behind each
| Chapter | Topic | The hosts as informed peer | Guest teaching | Guest disagreement | The hosts pushing back | Why |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pre-Show Banter and Supergut Product Plug | 1 | 0 | 1 | 1 | The co-hosts engage in playful banter regarding weight loss, coffee, and a Supergut product plug before joking about event revenue split conditions. | |
| The All-In Podcast Opening Title Sequence | 2 | 1 | 1 | 1 | The panel opens the episode and contrasts media coverage of Elon Musk's Twitter management with the New York Times staff strike. | |
| Detailed Breakdown of Twitter Internal Blacklists | 5 | 1 | 4 | 3 | Calacanis lists the account blacklists revealed in Twitter Files Part 2, prompting Sacks to compare Twitter's secret suppression of conservative accounts to FTX fraud. | |
| Debating Moderation, Libs of TikTok, and Harassment | 6 | 2 | 6 | 7 | Calacanis presses Sacks on whether aggregating and mocking LGBTQ individuals via Libs of TikTok constitutes targeted harassment that justifies content moderation. | |
| Product Choice Curation versus Scientific Discussion Censorship | 6 | 3 | 3 | 3 | Friedberg frames Twitter as a curated product rather than a free speech public utility, while Chamath highlights Jay Bhattacharya's tweet on how suppressing scientific debate caused real societal harm. | |
| Media Censorship Gaslighting and Elon Musk's Impact | 6 | 2 | 4 | 4 | Sacks accuses the legacy media of gaslighting the public by dismissing shadowbanning as a conspiracy theory, while Chamath advocates for Section 230 reform to enforce transparency. | |
| Calacanis's Moderation Framework and Bipartisan Thought Experiment | 6 | 1 | 2 | 3 | Calacanis proposes a thought experiment asking left-leaning observers how they would feel if right-wing moderators covertly shadowbanned prominent progressive voices like Rachel Maddow. | |
| Societal Harms of Censorship and Legacy Media Complicity | 6 | 2 | 4 | 2 | Chamath and Calacanis cite historical investigative journalism examples to illustrate the danger of suppressing heterodox views, while Sacks criticizes media complicity. | |
| Media Incentives and Investigative Journalism Cover-Ups | 7 | 3 | 5 | 3 | Sacks breaks down Matt Taibbi's Twitter Files drop on the Hunter Biden laptop suppression and details former FBI lawyer Jim Baker's role in vetting internal document releases. | |
| Deep State Influence and the Praetorian Guard Analogy | 6 | 2 | 5 | 2 | Sacks compares intelligence community influence in social media moderation to a Praetorian Guard operating inside tech bureaucracies. | |
| Debating Election Interference: 2016 Context vs. 2020 Laptop Suppression | 5 | 2 | 8 | 8 | Calacanis and Sacks clash intensely when Calacanis brings up 2016 foreign election interference context; Sacks accuses Calacanis of intellectual dishonesty and Trump Derangement Syndrome while Calacanis demands a direct answer. | |
| Resolving the Debate on Pre-Election Story Suppression | 5 | 2 | 7 | 7 | The panel resolves the heated exchange on pre-election censorship, with Calacanis clarifying he agrees news stories should not be suppressed while Sacks maintains Twitter executives used hacked policy as a pretext. | |
| China Ends Zero-COVID Policy Amid Public Unrest | 7 | 3 | 2 | 2 | Chamath rejects the claim that Foxconn's CEO single-handedly forced China's zero-COVID rollback, attributing the policy pivot to Xi Jinping's planned economic strategy and public unrest. | |
| Analyzing Global Demographic Pyramids in Iran, China, and Japan | 8 | 4 | 1 | 1 | Calacanis and Chamath review demographic pyramid data across Iran, China, and Japan, with Chamath explaining global population contraction threats to long-term GDP growth. | |
| Satirical Discussion on CCP Censorship and Western Elite Echoes | 5 | 1 | 4 | 1 | Sacks delivers satirical commentary equating Western elite social credit preferences with CCP censorship of lockdown dissenters. | |
| FTX Collapse and Kevin O'Leary's Controversial CNBC Defense | 6 | 3 | 7 | 8 | The host plays a CNBC segment where Joe Kernen vigorously challenges Kevin O'Leary over defending SBF after taking a $15M spokesperson deal from FTX. | |
| Fraudulent Conveyance and the Economics of Crypto Belief Systems | 8 | 3 | 3 | 3 | Chamath and Sacks explain the legal mechanism of fraudulent conveyance clawbacks, while Friedberg analyzes how crypto business models rely on manufactured belief systems. | |
| Kyrsten Sinema's Independent Switch and Primary System Dynamics | 8 | 2 | 2 | 2 | Sacks analyzes Kyrsten Sinema's strategic switch to Independent as a tactical move to bypass a Democratic primary, while Chamath explains primary system incentives. |
Statements from this episode (34)
Sacks: NYT reporters on strike are running a 'clickbait farm'
“The same reporters who couldn't stop writing About the oppressive working conditions that Elon Musk was supposedly creating because he simply wanted the employees to go back to the office and work hard. And if they didn't, he'd give them a generous three month…”
Calacanis: Twitter Files confirm secret blacklists tagged conservative voices
“We now have confirmation that what the right thought was happening all along, which is a secret silencing system built into the software. Of blacklists was tagging right-wing conservative voices in the system.”
Calacanis: Twitter placed Dan Bongino on a search blacklist
“He was tagged with being on a search blacklist.”
Calacanis: Twitter tagged Charlie Kirk with 'Do Not Amplify'
“Charlie Kirk, who is a conservative commentator, he was tagged with do not amplify.”
Calacanis: Twitter placed Jay Bhattacharya on a trends blacklist
“And then there were people who were banned from the trends blacklist, including a Stanford professor, Jay Bhattacharya.”
Sacks: Twitter's undisclosed moderation is an FTX-level free speech fraud
“This is an FTX level fraud, except that what was stolen here was not customer funds, it was their free speech rights.”
Sacks: Twitter Files prove executives lied about shadowbanning political viewpoints
“You had statement after statement by Twitter executives like Jack Dorsey, like Vijaya, Gadi, like, you know, Yoel and others saying we do not shadow ban. And then they also said, we certainly, this is their emphasis, do not shadow ban on the basis of political…”
Sacks: Twitter suppressed Libs of TikTok despite admitting no policy violation
“There are conversations in the Slack that Barry Weiss exposed where, for example, Libs of TikTok, they admit in the Slack that we can't suppress Libs of TikTok based on our hate policy. Libs of TikTok hasn't violated it. We're going to suppress that account an…”
Friedberg: Google Search ranking relies on significant manual intervention
“And it was always the secret at Google. How did the search results get ranked? And I can tell you, it's not just a pure algorithm that there was a lot of manual intervention, a lot of manual work.”
Chamath: Government regulation is necessary for major social media platforms
“I do think governments have to step in and create better guardrails. So this kind of stuff doesn't happen. I don't buy the whole it's safe, you know, private company. They can do what they want. I think that that is too naive of an expectation for how importan…”
Sacks: Elon Musk is the only billionaire willing to fight for free speech
“I think, look, I think we got, I think we basically got extremely lucky that Elon Musk happened to care about free speech and decided to do something about it and actually had the means to do something about it. He's just about the only billionaire who has tha…”
Chamath: US government will attempt to rewrite Section 230
“The United States government is going to make an attempt to rewrite section two 30.”
Calacanis: Twitter's workforce is 96% to 97% left-leaning
“It's pretty clear what happened here, because these all occurred with a group of people working at Twitter, which is 96 or 97% left-leaning. The statistics are clear.”
Chamath: COVID school closures caused severe learning loss for children
“We've relegated our children to a bunch of years of really complicated relearning and learning that they never had to go through because of all the learning loss they gave them.”
Sacks: Legacy media was complicit in suppressing COVID-19 dissent
“They were complicit in suppressing the views of people like Jay Bhattacharya. They were complicit in choosing the views of Fauci and the elite on COVID.”
Calacanis: Today's conspiracy theories become tomorrow's Pulitzer Prizes
“What journalists need to realize is that today's conspiracy theories are tomorrow's Pulitzer Prizes.”
Sacks: Twitter suppressed Hunter Biden laptop story before 2020 election
“What he did was confirm that a completely true story by the New York Post about Hunter Biden that came out a month before the election was suppressed by Twitter executives, including at the behest of, you know, of FBI agents and former security state officials…”
Sacks: Big tech companies are deeply intertwined with the security state
“I think what it shows is how deeply intertwined our big tech companies have become with the security state.”
Sacks: FBI warned social networks to suppress authentic Hunter Biden laptop story
“A very important piece of this was the pre-bunking that the FBI went to Facebook and Twitter and social networks and said, be on the lookout for a story about Hunter Biden. It is Russian disinformation. And they primed these social networks to suppress that st…”
Sacks: FBI knew Hunter Biden's laptop was authentic in 2019
“The FBI was given the laptop in 2019 by the lap store, store owner. Those guys have forensics. They have cyber experts. They knew the laptop was real. We know it's real now. Nobody questions that. In fact, the FBI has admitted that the laptop was real and that…”
Sacks: Intelligence officials falsely claimed Hunter Biden laptop was Russian disinformation
“There was a letter with this Hunter Biden thing. This is a 2020 election, Jason. We're not going back two elections ago. I wanted to talk about the most recent one. You had Clapper. You had Comey. You had 50 of these security state officials. They write a lett…”
Calacanis: Twitter and Facebook did not know if laptop story was hacked
“Twitter and Facebook did not know.”
Sacks: Twitter execs maintained hack framing despite internal pushback
“Jim Baker and Vijaya Gotti said, okay, that there were a lot of internal questions about whether that, that Hunter Biden story could be justified under the hacked policy. And there were many legitimate questions raised internally about whether they could maint…”
Chamath: China did not end zero-COVID because of Foxconn CEO letter
“I just think it's kind of ridiculous to assume that the second largest economy in the world pivots based on one letter from one CEO.”
Chamath: Xi Jinping's zero-COVID rollback was a planned 3-phase strategy
“I think this has been part and parcel of a very focused and dedicated plan by Xi. Phase one was to consolidate power. Phase two was to get through November and to basically get reappointed for life and dispel any other You know, rivals that he actually had. An…”
Friedberg: CCP changed COVID stance due to public dissent and unrest
“There was enough dissent and enough unrest that in order to stay in power, the CCP had to take action and they have to shift their position and shift their tone.”
Chamath: China's population will halve to 600 million by 2100
“Their population get current course and speed. I think the last number is it's going to have by 2100. There'll be about six hundred million people in China”
Calacanis: Japan's aging demographics will force an economic contraction
“These demographics can't be fought. You're gonna have a contraction, constricting economy in Japan and their place in the world is gonna be very, very different.”
Calacanis: Kevin O'Leary received $15 million to represent FTX
“Kevin O'Leary who calls himself Mr. Wonderful was on CNBC trying to defend the fact that he was given This is stunning, by the way, 15 fucking million dollars to be a spokesperson for FTX.”
Chamath: O'Leary must repay $15M if funded by FTX user deposits
“So in this example, what it would mean is if that they can show that that fifteen million dollars that this guy got. Came from SBF basically rating the piggy bank of user accounts. He's going to have to pay the money back.”
Friedberg: Crypto businesses lack fundamental drivers and depend solely on belief
“The crypto ecosystem and the model that so many kind of crypto businesses have engaged in over the years, which is if you can fester the belief, then there is a business. If you cannot fester the belief, there is no business that there isn't a fundamental prod…”
Sacks: Sam Bankman-Fried's mother was a major Democratic bundler
“Yes, his mother was a huge Democratic bundler.”