Jan 2, 2019 · 27m · a16z
a16z Podcast | Welcome to the New Era of Commerce
0:00 / 0:00
▶ Watch on YouTube →
gold bands on the timeline = statements, start to end. Hover to read, click to jump. CC turns on captions
This episode of the a16z podcast explores the shift toward pre-commerce and pre-tail, detailing how direct-to-consumer pre-orders enable both small creators and enterprise companies to validate market demand, eliminate inventory risk, and turn consumers into active community co-creators.
How this conversation actually went
Every chapter scored 0–10 on four independent dynamics. Hover any point for the reasoning behind the score. The host holds 31.3% of the talking time here. How this is scored →
The host as informed peer 6.7 Guest teaching 2.5 Guest disagreement 1.2 The host pushing back 2.7
speaking balance: gold is the host, purple is the guest (3 minute bins)
Sharpest disagreement ▶ 5:32 James reframes host risk premise
When Sonal points out that failing to deliver on pre-orders is a major downside, James politely reframes the premise, arguing that guessing delivery dates is better than blindly guessing market demand upfront.
Hardest push from the host ▶ 5:23 Sonal pushes on pre-order delivery failureSonal directly intervenes to disrupt the optimistic narrative around pre-commerce, forcing the guests to address consumer backlash when pre-ordered items fail to deliver.
Biggest teaching moment ▶ 18:13 James shares data on campaign tipping pointsJames educates the host on Tilt's proprietary data showing that reaching 34 percent funding and five backers creates a self-sustaining momentum threshold for campaigns.
The host holds their own ▶ 21:26 Sonal frames pre-commerce via 'software eating the world'Sonal demonstrates deep strategic expertise by tying the discussion of pre-tail virality directly to Marc Andreessen's thesis of software eating the physical world.
the scores for every segment, with the reasoning behind each
| Chapter | Topic | The host as informed peer | Guest teaching | Guest disagreement | The host pushing back | Why |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Enterprise Adoption of Pre-Orders: Tesla and Xiaomi Case Studies | 6 | 3 | 2 | 5 | Sonal actively pushes back on the initial optimism by questioning why Tesla chose pre-orders and highlighting key operational risks like delivery failures. James acknowledges the trade-offs while using Xiaomi as a counterexample to illustrate execution capabilities. Sonal demonstrates domain knowledge regarding Tesla's long-term master plan evolution. | |
| Community Co-Creation, Scarcity, and Public Development | 7 | 2 | 1 | 2 | Sonal elevates the discussion by drawing explicit parallels between pre-commerce co-creation and iterative public creation in media, citing Kanye West's album release and Chinese web novelists. The guests build upon her thesis regarding consumer disintermediation and brand-direct relationships. The dynamic is highly collaborative with strong host expertise display. | |
| Brand Benefits and Expanding Pre-Commerce Beyond Physical Goods | 6 | 3 | 1 | 2 | Sonal reframes the guest's points on consumer behavior into a broader shift toward fan engagement and experiential co-creation. James responds with concrete data on how music artists crowdfunded concert tours on Tilt. The interaction remains constructive and analytical. | |
| Accessibility for Small Creators and Redefining Social Commerce | 6 | 3 | 1 | 3 | Sonal challenges the guests to clarify how group funding differs from standard group gifts and defines genuine social commerce as native collective action. The guests agree and expand with examples like PayPal's early struggles with social commerce. The dynamic is supportive and exploratory. | |
| Campaign Virality, Tipping Points, and Psychological Drivers | 8 | 2 | 1 | 2 | After James shares empirical data showing a 34 percent campaign tipping point, Sonal introduces Dunbar's number as a psychological framework to explain social commerce dynamics. She further synthesizes the discussion by identifying pre-commerce as the wedge where software eats physical retail. | |
| Enterprise Transformation and Future Industry Outlook | 7 | 2 | 1 | 2 | Sonal contrasts traditional car dealership friction with frictionless mobile pre-orders, predicting that social pre-commerce will spawn an entire ecosystem of ancillary digital tools. The guests validate her assessment using enterprise demand discovery models. |
Statements from this episode (14)
Jordan: Direct-to-consumer models yield higher margins by bypassing traditional aggregators
“This pre-tail or pre-commerce enables you to leverage the internet and your social following to go direct to the consumers. You get to basically disintermediate the historic aggregators. So, you know, if you were selling a phone 20 years ago, you can even say …”
Beshara: Tesla generated $14 billion in Model 3 pre-orders in days
“In about three or four days, they sold 200,000 cars. I mean, this is a car manufacturer. I think they've sold essentially about fourteen billion dollars worth of their new model. And they're expecting, you know, 30% to drop off, but still 70% of that would be …”
Beshara: Tesla used customer pre-orders to secure $2 billion in debt
“Yes. You could sell today directly to your customers, get the demand before you put an ounce of production to work and use that to Tesla since use that, I believe for debt financing of two billion dollars. So be able to use that to verify the demand and securi…”
Beshara: Xiaomi announces phones up to 12 months early for pre-orders
“And in each model, they will basically the equivalent of tweeting it out This is what we're getting. This is the new model. This is everything that's going to be in there nine to 12 months and order it now to get in line, and then you're batched based on when …”
Chokshi: Chinese TV producers option web novels based on iterative reader data
“China authors will actually write chapters as they go, partly because they'll iteratively see what the demand is. And what's really interesting is that some of the TV producers and movie makers will actually look at the data to decide what books to option.”
Beshara: Pre-commerce eliminates working capital risk by securing exact customer demand
“So instead of a working capital risk of, all right, let's build one factory and hope that we choose the right number. You actually get to know the right number before you start production. It's hard to overstate how valuable that is in manufacturing.”
Beshara: Unreleased game Star Citizen presold to 300,000 customers via crowdfunding
“There's a self-hosted crowdfunding, a game out there called Star Citizen that has had 300,000 people buy into this game. It hasn't been released yet, as far as I know. But there is a subreddit with about 30,000 people just talking about the game every day.”
Beshara: A top DJ duo crowdfunded and sold out a tour
“The number one DJ duo in the world used Tilt to bring to life an entire tour. The first time anyone had quote unquote crowdfunded a tour. And I use that term crowdfunding kind of lightly because it's, it crowdfunding can mean a hundred things, a hundred differ…”
Beshara: A six-person drone startup reached $35 million in pre-orders
“There's a drone company. They were a six person company. They launch, and within about 30 days, they reached ten million in orders, and then they went on to reach about thirty five million dollars of orders, so you don't have to be a large brand.”
Beshara: True social commerce requires participatory collective purchasing, not just social graphs
“I think it will be much more nuanced, but much more powerful than just, oh, add your social graph to your credit card transaction. It's much more participatory of collectively, socially.”
Jordan: Early PayPal and Facebook social commerce partnerships failed to gain traction
“PayPal did a few deals in back at the beginning of the decade with the Facebook and, you know, felt like, okay, there you have money there. You have social graph. We have social commerce, right? Well, it just, it hasn't worked that way.”
Beshara: Crowdfunding campaigns reach an unstoppable tipping point at 34% funded
“If you can get to about 34,000, it kind of takes on a life of its own. When you get to about five people and about 33, 34%, that community is committed. They obviously pulled out their wallets. They want this thing to exist. And now they become advocacy to get…”
Beshara: Deferring shipping details in pre-orders significantly increases mobile checkout conversion
“What is really interesting, what we've seen is actually heightens conversion from the conventional points of just, you're only taking in the credit card. You ask for shipping later. It's super just you, it's basically six fields instead of 18 to convert on a m…”
Beshara: Pre-commerce will become the dominant retail model within seven years
“This pre-commerce, this notion of buying something before it exists is, I mean, it's radically different right now, but you fast forward five years, six years, seven years, and it will just be the best way to sell something.”