Dec 12, 2024 · 1h 53m · the-pitch
Season 12 Finale: What Happened After The Pitch?
Josh Muccio · 32m spoken Davina Desai · 8m spoken Capella Kerst · 4m spoken Virginia Frischkorn · 4m spoken Julia Dixon · 3m spoken Kayla Epps · 3m spoken Ryan James · 3m spoken Philip Behn · 3m spoken Chinar Movsisian · 3m spoken Elizabeth Yin · 2m spoken Charles Hudson · 2m spoken Gwyneth Borden · 2m spoken Cyan Banister · 1m spoken Jorge Rios · 1m spoken Lisa Muccio · 1m spoken Chad Wilson · 1m spoken Niamh Itza Calvin · 1m spoken Dean Eberhardt · 1m spoken Mac Conwell · 1m spoken Jesse Middleton · 1m spoken Ben Taft · 59s spoken
0:00 / 0:00
▶ Watch on YouTube →
gold bands on the timeline = statements, start to end. Hover to read, click to jump. CC turns on captions
The Season 12 finale of The Pitch reviews how fourteen startup founders navigated summer venture capital diligence, business model pivots, and fundraising hurdles following their pitch appearances. Through candid founder debriefs, the episode details how over $3.8 million in institutional and listener-syndicate capital was deployed across deep tech, fintech, healthcare, and consumer sectors.
How this conversation actually went
Every chapter scored 0–10 on four independent dynamics. Hover any point for the reasoning behind the score. Josh holds 35.7% of the talking time here. How this is scored →
Josh as informed peer 4.1 Guest teaching 3.9 Guest disagreement 2.1 Josh pushing back 1.8
speaking balance: gold is Josh, purple is the guest (3 minute bins)
Sharpest disagreement ▶ 1:30:20 Davina rejects Silicon Valley founder posturing
Davina bluntly dismisses the expectation to inflate projections like a stereotypical tech founder, calling out exaggerated claims as fantasy and reaffirming her commitment to realistic execution.
Hardest push from Josh ▶ 18:48 Josh challenges how Future Money ships products so fastJosh directly presses Philip on whether his rapid development pace is realistic given his burn rate, jokingly asking if code was reused from a previous company.
Biggest teaching moment ▶ 1:12:34 Jorge corrects out-of-date diligence data on competitorsJorge educates the host and investors by pointing out that the supposed major market competitor actually ceased operations years ago in 2018.
Josh holds their own ▶ 49:10 Josh defends the human operational component as a software moatJosh uses industry domain knowledge to counter standard software dogma, citing Salesforce to explain how human services can actually serve as a strong competitive moat.
the scores for every segment, with the reasoning behind each
| Chapter | Topic | Josh as informed peer | Guest teaching | Guest disagreement | Josh pushing back | Why |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Season 12 Finale Overview and VC Summer Slowdown | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | This introductory segment is a solo host monologue and audio montage recapping the season and introducing the summer venture slowdown. As a monologue/recap segment, host-side and interactive metrics remain at zero. | |
| Gecko Materials Closes Seed Round with Kitty Hawk | 4 | 3 | 2 | 2 | Josh interviews Capella Kerst regarding Gecko Materials closing an $8M seed round led by Kitty Hawk at a $26M pre-money valuation. Capella teases the price and shares her diligence experience, maintaining an upbeat and collaborative dynamic throughout. | |
| Future Money Secures Rapid Investment and Milestone Growth | 5 | 4 | 1 | 3 | Philip Behn details the rapid growth of Future Money and bringing in over $1M from pitch listeners. Josh lightly presses Philip on how a startup can move so quickly on relatively modest capital, which Philip explains through his ten years of fintech experience. | |
| Christie's Chips Expands to Whole Foods and Restructures Corporate Entity | 4 | 5 | 2 | 2 | Christie recounts restructuring her company into a C-Corp following Elizabeth Yin's diligence advice and securing shelf placement in 65 Whole Foods locations. Christie counters Josh's perception that she is completely unfazed by fundraising by admitting to internal anxiety balanced by preparation. | |
| EdTech Founders Tackle Educational Systems with AI and Video Games | 5 | 4 | 3 | 2 | EdTech founders Julia Dixon and Chad Wilson discuss whether to reform education from within or disrupt it externally. Chad offers a reasoned pushback against the reckless idea of completely dismantling public systems without considering collateral harm. | |
| Party Trick Founder Navigates VC Expectations and Services Moat | 6 | 4 | 4 | 2 | Virginia Frischkorn shares her candid reaction to VC investor ghosting and pushback regarding tech-enabled services vs pure software. Josh actively supports her thesis, noting that operational human service elements can function as an effective defensible moat. | |
| Vital Audio Closes Key Checks and Launches Clinical Pilot | 4 | 3 | 1 | 1 | Niamh Itza Calvin reflects on competitive pitching and closing checks from Jesse Middleton and Cyan Banister for Vital Audio. The exchange is deeply collaborative as Calvin shares Swahili philosophy about coachability and adaptability in founder journeys. | |
| Remint Buys First Debt Portfolio to Prove Rehabilitation Model | 4 | 5 | 2 | 2 | Gwyneth Borden outlines how Remint purchased its first $1.2M debt portfolio for $22,000 to validate their consumer credit rehabilitation model. She educates the host on the nuances of buying distressed personal loan portfolios and the systemic barriers around debt-servicing payment processors. | |
| Feedback Intelligence Accepts Hustle Fund Terms to Extend Runway | 4 | 4 | 2 | 2 | Chinar Movsisian explains accepting lower valuation terms from Hustle Fund to secure five months of developer runway for her engineering team in Armenia. The discussion remains friendly and transparent regarding the practical tradeoffs of taking early investor cash over prolonged fundraising. | |
| ReCraft Pivots to Licensing While BridgeFi Pursues Organic Growth | 5 | 5 | 3 | 2 | Dean Eberhardt details ReCraft pivoting to equipment licensing and Jorge Rios explains how BridgeFi's mesh networking technology was misunderstood during diligence. Jorge directly corrects an investor's outdated assumption regarding a defunct competitor. | |
| Kinematrix Founder Confronts VC Stereotypes and Finalizes Seed Round | 4 | 6 | 5 | 2 | Davina Desai provides a sharp, humorous critique of tech investor stereotypes, founder mythology, and unsolicited coaching to smile less. She vigorously rejects theatrical VC expectations in favor of grounded, realistic healthcare operations. | |
| Doppel Navigates Deep Diligence to Secure Milestone Funding | 4 | 4 | 1 | 2 | Ryan James walks through the rigorous diligence process with Charles Hudson and closing a $400K lead check from Tacoma Ventures for Doppel. The atmosphere is warm and professional with playful banter about Ryan tracking investor backgrounds. | |
| OMA Health Sweeps Investor Interest to Build Maternal Care Platform | 4 | 4 | 2 | 1 | Kayla Epps shares her experience building OMA Health, dealing with unresponsive investors, and navigating Alabama's capital matching program. The segment ends with the Pitch Fund offering a $50K check, followed by the season finale wrap-up. |
Statements from this episode (34)
Kerst: Gecko Materials deploys on the ISS and lands major enterprise clients
“We're currently on the International Space Station. Honda, Ford, Toyota, GE, Intel, Hyundai are just to name a few of our seven of our customers here on Earth.”
Kerst: Gecko Materials raised an $8M seed round at a $26M valuation
“A pre-money evaluation of twenty six million for an eight million dollar round is what we landed at.”
Muccio: The Pitch and listeners invested $900k in Gecko Materials
“After the show aired, we ended up hosting a syndicate for our LPs, aka listening partners, wink, wink, and you all invested an additional 600,000 in the company, and we invested another 300,000 out of the pitch fund.”
Middleton: Future Money has the best onboarding flow among fintech products
“So your onboarding flow is better than any other fintech product I've ever signed up for.”
Future Money raises an additional $1.02M from Pitch listeners
“We raised an additional one million and 20,000.”
Behn: Future Money users are on track to invest over $350M
“In the last few months, since we've filled in the pitch podcast, our users are already on track to invest over three hundred fifty million dollars for their kids.”
Elizabeth Yin: Institutional investors refuse to invest in LLCs
“From an investor perspective, especially institutional investors, like they will not invest in LLCs. They'll only invest in C corps because of the complexity.”
Muccio: Christie's Chips raised $200K total, including $120K from show LPs
“Not to be a bummer, but, ah, Ben still hasn't invested in Christie's chips. Yet. But you all did. After the show, LPs invested another 120,000, bringing her total raise so far to 200 K.”
Julia Dixon: ESAI Closes Round at Over $1M
“So we have closed the round. We've raised just over a million and we've had to start turning people away at the end.”
Julia Dixon: ESAI Exceeds 200K Users and Beats Revenue Goals
“I can say that we've now reached over 200,000 students that have accounts on our platform. We just started a real big monetization push with the launch of the Common App, which was the very beginning of August, and we're beating our revenue goals.”
Chad Wilson: Over 4,000 Schools Signed Up for ImmersionED
“A little over 4000, and schools are still continuing to sign up every day, and so we'll see where we end up.”
Banister: Investing $50K angel check to track Party Trick for fund
“But I would like if you would have me to put in 50 K personally. I would like to track the company for a future round with my fund.”
Frischkorn: Personally invested $1.5M to bootstrap Party Trick
“So bootstrapped primarily. I've personally done about a million and a half into it.”
Josh Muccio: Humans in the loop can become a defensible software moat
“I get it's really easy if it's just pure software because it just scales easier, but also having humans in the process can also become a moat.”
Flybridge closes and wires $50,000 investment in Vital Audio
“After our due diligence call, in about a week or so, we were able to actually close.”
Charles Hudson passes on Vital Audio after pitch due to conflict concerns
“He wasn't able to get himself to a yes at the moment.”
Vital Audio launches pilot with Minneapolis Heart Institute
“Vital Audio also just launched a pilot with the Minneapolis Heart Institute, so the first, ah, phone calls are happening as we speak.”
Borden: Payment processors treat debt collection like cannabis and gambling
“Debt collection is treated like cannabis and gambling and those kinds of controversial industries. And so there are a lot of payment processors that won't work with us.”
Gwyneth Borden: Remynt acquires debt portfolios for two cents on the dollar
“Yes, we actually are about to buy our first 1.2 million dollars of debt at the big whopping price of two cents on the dollar.”
Movsisian: Feedback Intelligence charges $90k on average per annual contract
“On average, we charge them 90 K annual contract.”
Movsisian: An Armenian engineering team extends $150K runway to five months
“And good thing is that my team, the tech team that I have is in Armenia, and there is a huge difference between paying there and here that I was like, okay, this is a, another five months runway.”
Rios: Bridgefy leads offline communications by millions of users with no active rivals
“And I cleared up that that competitor hasn't operated. They stopped existing in 2018, and this space is not crowded at all. We are the market leader by millions of users.”
Davina Desai: Kinematrix aims for strategic acquisition by Oracle, not an IPO
“We are not intending to exit for at least the next five to six years. We are also aware that we will probably not be an IPO company, but better suited for someone like, I'm thinking Oracle helped.”
Desai: Optimism is believing your startup works, not claiming to beat Epic
“Optimism is not fantasy. Optimism is, yes, it's going to work out. It's not, I'm going to be larger than epic. That's just fantasy.”
Charles Hudson: The three core questions Precursor asks before leading a round
“When we lead, the three things I usually try to think about are like, what's a price that I think would pull in the other people who we need as investors? What amount should we commit to sort of like help catalyze the round? And then like, what else can we do …”
Charles Hudson: Outside investors rarely fund bridge rounds between key milestones
“When you're in between milestones, pretty much the only people that will fund you are existing investors. Otherwise, most people will just say, like, it's just too risky. I'm just going to wait until you clear that threshold.”
Tacoma Ventures leads Dopl's round with $400k, bringing total raise to $740k
“Tacoma Ventures ended up leading the round with a 400,000 dollar investment, bringing his total raise to 740 K.”
Epps: Charles Hudson and Cyan Banister signed SAFEs for OMA Health
“Charles' process was so seamless and we signed with Charles. Cyan was able to sign our safe agreement, so that's really exciting as well.”
Kayla Epps: Under 1% of venture capital goes to Black founders
“I mean, you hear horror stories, and I'll be candid, I mean, less than, what, one percent of VC dollars go to Black founders, and I think it's even smaller for Black women founders, so I was under no assumptions that it was going to be an easy ride.”
Josh Muccio: The Pitch Fund will invest $50,000 in OMA Health
“Well, we'd love to take max 50,000. I mean, the Pitch Fund would love to invest in your company.”
Muccio: $3.88M was invested across Season 12 of The Pitch
“In fact, 3,881,000 was invested on the pitch this season.”
Josh Muccio: Listeners invested $2.87M into startups during Season 12
“And 2,871,000 of that was from you, the listeners, which is crazy.”