StarZero All shows Try the podcast clipper →

Feb 21, 2023 · 20m · startup-acquisition-stories

Startup Acquisition Stories with David Mellstrom, Co-founder of Buddy

David Maelstrom · 11m spoken Andrew Gazdecki · 6m spoken
0:00 / 0:00

gold bands on the timeline = statements, start to end. Hover to read, click to jump. CC turns on captions

In this episode of Startup Acquisition Stories, host Andrew Gostecki interviews David Mellstrom about building SMS commerce platform Buddy, running a competitive acquisition process on Acquire.com, and leveraging his venture capital background to navigate diligence and plan his next software venture.

How this conversation actually went

Every chapter scored 0–10 on four independent dynamics. Hover any point for the reasoning behind the score. Andrew holds 33.7% of the talking time here. How this is scored →

Andrew as informed peer 5.4 Guest teaching 2.0 Guest disagreement 0.0 Andrew pushing back 0.0
05100:0010:0020:002:44–5:47 · Andrew as informed peer 4/10 The Inspiration for SMS Commerce and Early Customer Acquisition David explains the psychological edge of SMS marketing over email and their Instagram DM acquisition strategy. Andrew enthusiastically affirms the business model and reflects on the power of using scarcity in sales.5:47–8:48 · Andrew as informed peer 6/10 Listing on Acquire.com and Building Competitive Buyer Momentum David details listing on Acquire and receiving instant LOIs, describing how he batched buyer meetings to generate deal momentum. Andrew unpacks this strategy, demonstrating his acquisition expertise on how deadline-driven urgency prevents buyer dragging.8:49–11:00 · Andrew as informed peer 5/10 Evaluating Offers and Selecting the Winning Strategic Buyer David explains choosing a strategic buyer capable of moving Buddy upmarket to enterprise clients. Andrew validates the decision, noting how partnering accelerates otherwise tedious and long enterprise sales cycles.11:00–15:16 · Andrew as informed peer 5/10 Navigating Due Diligence and Legal Negotiations David describes navigating legal diligence and indemnification caps using his venture capital background. Andrew shares his personal founder experience with diligence fatigue and highlights the value of operational transparency during asset handoffs.15:17–19:12 · Andrew as informed peer 7/10 Future Venture: Modernizing Blue-Collar Legacy Software David outlines his thesis on modernizing legacy software in blue-collar industries amidst generational business handoffs. Andrew demonstrates deep domain expertise from his eight years selling to SMBs, articulating his 'time, aptitude, money' framework and average budget benchmarks.2:44–5:47 · Guest teaching 3/10 The Inspiration for SMS Commerce and Early Customer Acquisition David explains the psychological edge of SMS marketing over email and their Instagram DM acquisition strategy. Andrew enthusiastically affirms the business model and reflects on the power of using scarcity in sales.5:47–8:48 · Guest teaching 1/10 Listing on Acquire.com and Building Competitive Buyer Momentum David details listing on Acquire and receiving instant LOIs, describing how he batched buyer meetings to generate deal momentum. Andrew unpacks this strategy, demonstrating his acquisition expertise on how deadline-driven urgency prevents buyer dragging.8:49–11:00 · Guest teaching 1/10 Evaluating Offers and Selecting the Winning Strategic Buyer David explains choosing a strategic buyer capable of moving Buddy upmarket to enterprise clients. Andrew validates the decision, noting how partnering accelerates otherwise tedious and long enterprise sales cycles.11:00–15:16 · Guest teaching 2/10 Navigating Due Diligence and Legal Negotiations David describes navigating legal diligence and indemnification caps using his venture capital background. Andrew shares his personal founder experience with diligence fatigue and highlights the value of operational transparency during asset handoffs.15:17–19:12 · Guest teaching 3/10 Future Venture: Modernizing Blue-Collar Legacy Software David outlines his thesis on modernizing legacy software in blue-collar industries amidst generational business handoffs. Andrew demonstrates deep domain expertise from his eight years selling to SMBs, articulating his 'time, aptitude, money' framework and average budget benchmarks.2:44–5:47 · Guest disagreement 0/10 The Inspiration for SMS Commerce and Early Customer Acquisition David explains the psychological edge of SMS marketing over email and their Instagram DM acquisition strategy. Andrew enthusiastically affirms the business model and reflects on the power of using scarcity in sales.5:47–8:48 · Guest disagreement 0/10 Listing on Acquire.com and Building Competitive Buyer Momentum David details listing on Acquire and receiving instant LOIs, describing how he batched buyer meetings to generate deal momentum. Andrew unpacks this strategy, demonstrating his acquisition expertise on how deadline-driven urgency prevents buyer dragging.8:49–11:00 · Guest disagreement 0/10 Evaluating Offers and Selecting the Winning Strategic Buyer David explains choosing a strategic buyer capable of moving Buddy upmarket to enterprise clients. Andrew validates the decision, noting how partnering accelerates otherwise tedious and long enterprise sales cycles.11:00–15:16 · Guest disagreement 0/10 Navigating Due Diligence and Legal Negotiations David describes navigating legal diligence and indemnification caps using his venture capital background. Andrew shares his personal founder experience with diligence fatigue and highlights the value of operational transparency during asset handoffs.15:17–19:12 · Guest disagreement 0/10 Future Venture: Modernizing Blue-Collar Legacy Software David outlines his thesis on modernizing legacy software in blue-collar industries amidst generational business handoffs. Andrew demonstrates deep domain expertise from his eight years selling to SMBs, articulating his 'time, aptitude, money' framework and average budget benchmarks.2:44–5:47 · Andrew pushing back 0/10 The Inspiration for SMS Commerce and Early Customer Acquisition David explains the psychological edge of SMS marketing over email and their Instagram DM acquisition strategy. Andrew enthusiastically affirms the business model and reflects on the power of using scarcity in sales.5:47–8:48 · Andrew pushing back 0/10 Listing on Acquire.com and Building Competitive Buyer Momentum David details listing on Acquire and receiving instant LOIs, describing how he batched buyer meetings to generate deal momentum. Andrew unpacks this strategy, demonstrating his acquisition expertise on how deadline-driven urgency prevents buyer dragging.8:49–11:00 · Andrew pushing back 0/10 Evaluating Offers and Selecting the Winning Strategic Buyer David explains choosing a strategic buyer capable of moving Buddy upmarket to enterprise clients. Andrew validates the decision, noting how partnering accelerates otherwise tedious and long enterprise sales cycles.11:00–15:16 · Andrew pushing back 0/10 Navigating Due Diligence and Legal Negotiations David describes navigating legal diligence and indemnification caps using his venture capital background. Andrew shares his personal founder experience with diligence fatigue and highlights the value of operational transparency during asset handoffs.15:17–19:12 · Andrew pushing back 0/10 Future Venture: Modernizing Blue-Collar Legacy Software David outlines his thesis on modernizing legacy software in blue-collar industries amidst generational business handoffs. Andrew demonstrates deep domain expertise from his eight years selling to SMBs, articulating his 'time, aptitude, money' framework and average budget benchmarks.

speaking balance: gold is Andrew, purple is the guest (3 minute bins)

0:00 · Andrew 18.5% · guest 81.5%0:00 · Andrew 18.5% · guest 81.5%3:00 · Andrew 38.1% · guest 61.9%3:00 · Andrew 38.1% · guest 61.9%6:00 · Andrew 40.4% · guest 59.6%6:00 · Andrew 40.4% · guest 59.6%9:00 · Andrew 35.9% · guest 64.1%9:00 · Andrew 35.9% · guest 64.1%12:00 · Andrew 42.7% · guest 57.3%12:00 · Andrew 42.7% · guest 57.3%15:00 · Andrew 17.1% · guest 82.9%15:00 · Andrew 17.1% · guest 82.9%18:00 · Andrew 44.9% · guest 55.1%18:00 · Andrew 44.9% · guest 55.1%
Sharpest disagreement ▶ 17:25 Dismissing Silicon Valley Assumptions

David points out the massive blind spot of tech graduates ignoring blue-collar legacy industries using 40-year-old software.

 Hardest push from Andrew ▶ 7:57 Host Steers Discussion on Deal Timelines

Andrew steps in to explicitly unpack and emphasize the tactical necessity of forcing firm buyer deadlines in M&A.

 Biggest teaching moment ▶ 3:06 Educating on Consumer SMS vs Email Behavior

David educates on the high conversion disparity between saturated email inboxes and personal SMS inboxes.

 Andrew holds their own ▶ 18:19 Andrew Details SMB SaaS Dynamics

Andrew leverages his eight years of running an SMB startup to detail exact customer budget constraints and the pickaxe investment thesis.
the scores for every segment, with the reasoning behind each
ChapterTopicAndrew as informed peerGuest teachingGuest disagreementAndrew pushing backWhy
The Inspiration for SMS Commerce and Early Customer Acquisition 4300 David explains the psychological edge of SMS marketing over email and their Instagram DM acquisition strategy. Andrew enthusiastically affirms the business model and reflects on the power of using scarcity in sales.
Listing on Acquire.com and Building Competitive Buyer Momentum 6100 David details listing on Acquire and receiving instant LOIs, describing how he batched buyer meetings to generate deal momentum. Andrew unpacks this strategy, demonstrating his acquisition expertise on how deadline-driven urgency prevents buyer dragging.
Evaluating Offers and Selecting the Winning Strategic Buyer 5100 David explains choosing a strategic buyer capable of moving Buddy upmarket to enterprise clients. Andrew validates the decision, noting how partnering accelerates otherwise tedious and long enterprise sales cycles.
Navigating Due Diligence and Legal Negotiations 5200 David describes navigating legal diligence and indemnification caps using his venture capital background. Andrew shares his personal founder experience with diligence fatigue and highlights the value of operational transparency during asset handoffs.
Future Venture: Modernizing Blue-Collar Legacy Software 7300 David outlines his thesis on modernizing legacy software in blue-collar industries amidst generational business handoffs. Andrew demonstrates deep domain expertise from his eight years selling to SMBs, articulating his 'time, aptitude, money' framework and average budget benchmarks.

Statements from this episode (9)

Opinion
Mellstrom: Marketing tools like Klaviyo left a huge purchasing gap
“But we felt like, you know, those companies weren't taking marketing far enough, and there was still a huge gap between, you know, re receiving a message from a brand and actually making a purchase.”
David Maelstrom Feb 21, 2023 ▶ 2:26
Insight
Mellstrom: Text message marketing is far more effective than email or social
“And the inbox, the text message inbox is usually reserved for friends and family. So if you let a brand into your text message inbox, you know, you're probably going to read it. So it's just incredibly more effective than other mediums out there, whether it's …”
David Maelstrom Feb 21, 2023 ▶ 3:58
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Mellstrom: Buddy acquired its first 30 customers via Instagram DMs
“So we were like DM warriors on Instagram for like two or three months. And that worked. We got to, you know, I'd say probably 25 or 30 customers just using the like pure DM, you know, scrappy outreach.”
David Maelstrom Feb 21, 2023 ▶ 5:09
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Buddy received two all-cash LOIs within 24 hours on Acquire.com
“It wasn't more than 24 hours after I listed on acquire that I got probably five to 10 inquiries and received two unsolicited LOIs for at or above asking price and all cash.”
David Maelstrom Feb 21, 2023 ▶ 6:54
Insight
Gostecki: Strict LOI Timelines Create Urgency and Speed Up Acquisition Decisions
“When you know, kind of don't have a timeline, buyers can really extrapolate that in a week and turn into a month. But when you have multiple parties interested and you put it into one day, say, Hey, we want LOIs on this day. That could be a very, very powerful…”
Andrew Gazdecki Feb 21, 2023 ▶ 8:18
Disclosure
Mellstrom: Managed Buddy acquisition diligence solo using venture background
“And for the most part, I managed everything on our end. So again, my background, you know, having been an early stage investor previously, like been through this process many, many times, seen the movie play out. Many different ways and felt, you know, confide…”
David Maelstrom Feb 21, 2023 ▶ 11:33
Disclosure
Mellstrom: Buddy acquisition was not life-changing but provided bridge capital
“So, so we sold Buddy wasn't a life-changing outcome but it did provide some you know, some bridge, I guess, bridge money to go on to the next thing.”
David Maelstrom Feb 21, 2023 ▶ 15:33
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Mellstrom: Generational turnover in blue-collar SMBs will drive modern software adoption
“Look at like your local HVAC company. It's probably a 50 or 60 year old guy that owns the company. And he's thinking about, you know, either selling it or passing it down to his son. Either way, the new owner is going to be slightly more sophisticated than the…”
David Maelstrom Feb 21, 2023 ▶ 17:33
Assertion Partly supported
Gostecki: Average SMB marketing budget is $500 per month
“I think the average SMB budget is 500 a month on marketing spend”
Andrew Gazdecki Feb 21, 2023 ▶ 18:20
Made with StarZero

Turn any episode into a week of clips.

This entire site, over 100 episodes transcribed, diarized, checked and made playable, runs on the StarZero media pipeline. Drop in your own episode and the podcast clipper finds the moments worth sharing, cuts them, captions them, and reframes them for every feed.

Try the podcast clipper Learn more