why aren't all 20 resolved? a statement only gets an assessment when the public
record can support or contradict it. opinions and what-ifs never can, and 0 checkable
ones are still open, waiting for their date. predictions held up or didn't;
assertions are supported or contradicted. on every card:
▮▮▮▮▮ certainty ·
▮▮▮▮▮ debate potential. speakers are clickable
Insight
Preysman learned real-time internal transparency on every decision only induces employee anxiety
“It takes time to make decisions, and if you're informed about every decision every time, all you're going to do is induce anxiety.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Preysman undercut James Perse's 6x apparel markup with Everlane's 2x margin
“The James Pursty cost six, seven dollars to make, too. And they were selling that for a four to six X markup. And the basic principle of Everlane in the early days was two to two and a half X markup. That's it.”
Assertion Supported
Preysman admits Everlane's marketing outpaced its product quality for five years
“Everlane was lucky in the early days because we were at a, we had such a unique marketing position in a world that wasn't as crowded as it is today, and eventually we, our product caught up with our marketing, but that didn't happen for five or six years, and …”
Insight
Preysman: Consumer focus is shifting from designer clothes to designer bodies
“I really believe we're moving from a world of designer clothes to designer bodies.”
Insight
Preysman: Sourcing, Production, and Creative Are Crucial Early Apparel Hires
“So the two most important hires for me in the early days in an apparel brand are sourcing and production and creative.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Everlane lost money in 2019 after increasing paid digital advertising spend
“Break even, and then losing a bit of money in 2019.”
Insight
Everlane shifted from calling traditional retail dishonest to radical pricing transparency
“Because it, to us, felt dishonest, and then I think there was a point where we realized, actually, they're not dishonest, they're just doing what they're doing, but the vehicle that we can have that's different is transparency.”
What-if
Preysman believes Everlane should have prioritized profit after hitting $100M revenue
“The decision I would have made now, and I think everybody's making even today, is that when we hit a hundred and we were profitable, that it was the time to transition from growing what we call the top line, which is the revenue, to growing the bottom line. So…”
Disclosure
Preysman realized he was not the right person to lead sustainable Everlane
“There was a moment in time where I imagined my life being a lifer, and the more I thought about it, I was like, wait, I don't, I'm not the best person to run a fashion brand that's sustainable.”
Disclosure
Preysman: Everlane Started by Selling Phone Cases
“We started Everlane, we started selling phone cases, and then it ended up looking like radical transparency.”
Insight
Preysman: Fixing Apparel Product Mistakes Takes 6 to 12 Months
“The challenge with apparel is everything's this iterative cycle where you buy, it takes a while to get in. You sell. So unless you can get the supply chain really tight and short, it takes six, 12 months to fix something properly by the time you sell through t…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Everlane's initial launch inventory of 1,500 t-shirts sold out in two days
“The first run sold out, I mean, it was 1500 t-shirts times 15 dollars. It sold out in a day or two.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Everlane's pre-launch viral referral landing page generated 80,000 email sign-ups
“And next thing you know, I kid you not, this thing blows up, and we have 80,000 people. Sign up. 80,000 people.”
Assertion Supported
Everlane doubled revenue from $53 million to $100 million in 2017
“And so we raised twenty-five million in total, and we were profitable, and that was the year of 2017, which was a hugely pivotal year for Everlane, when we went from fifty-three million dollars to a hundred million in one year.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Everlane hit $200K in monthly revenue and sold out in early 2012
“It was March, 2012, I believe, when we raised our next amount of money. We had been doing about a hundred to 200,000 dollars a month, but selling out every month.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Co-founder Jesse Farmer left when Everlane pivoted from tech to apparel
“At the end of the day for Jesse, what he wanted was to build a technology business, and what we moved away from was being a technology business, and we moved into building a brand. And that Wasn't the journey he wanted to be on”
Disclosure
Everlane live-blogged factory conditions from its Chinese manufacturing partners in 2013
“In 2013, there were a couple of key events that happened for us. One is we had started to manufacture in China, and we really wanted to understand are the factories we working, we're working with in China, high quality. And myself and a few of us went to China…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Everlane's first product was 1,200 ties sourced from a Bronx factory
“Made in a factory in the Bronx that manufactured everything for Brooks Brothers. And we sold them for 35 dollars, and we bought 1200 ties and bow ties.”
Disclosure
Preysman and his co-founder bought the domain Everlane.com for just $17
“Jesse and I were sitting in a room one day on instantdomainsearch.com, and we were just, for three hours, typing in names, names, names, and I had a whole bunch of scratch, and I always, you know, we liked the names that were simple and clear, and all of a sud…”
Disclosure
Everlane labeled garments with specific manufacturing cities instead of just importing countries
“On every label, we would name the city where things were made, not just the country. We wouldn't say imported.”