Jan 21, 2019 · 1h 9m · how-i-built-this
Bonobos: Andy Dunn
0:00 / 0:00
gold bands on the timeline = statements, start to end. Hover to read, click to jump. CC turns on captions
In this episode of NPR's How I Built This, host Guy Raz interviews Bonobos co-founder Andy Dunn about pioneering the direct-to-consumer menswear market, overcoming severe co-founder conflict and liquidity crises, and successfully executing a $310 million acquisition by Walmart.
How this conversation actually went
Every chapter scored 0–10 on four independent dynamics. Hover any point for the reasoning behind the score. Guy holds 28.2% of the talking time here. How this is scored →
Guy as informed peer 2.1 Guest teaching 1.3 Guest disagreement 0.6 Guy pushing back 0.9
speaking balance: gold is Guy, purple is the guest (3 minute bins)
Sharpest disagreement ▶ 45:55 Rejecting the optimism framing
Andy forcefully dismisses Guy's premise that he stayed optimistic during financial peril, retorting that he was defiant in the face of a terrifying reality.
Hardest push from Guy ▶ 43:38 Challenging the Palo Alto tech closureGuy refuses to accept the logic of suddenly shutting down the West Coast tech branch, pointing out that Bonobos was fundamentally dependent on software engineers.
Biggest teaching moment ▶ 17:54 Educating on structural venture capital biasAndy expands Guy's brief comparison with Katrina Lake by citing specific industry data regarding the 9% female VC representation vs 80% consumer spend control.
Guy holds their own ▶ 59:06 Pressing on consumer brand backlashGuy directly confronts Andy with the perceived contradiction between a premium menswear brand and Walmart's discount retail image.
the scores for every segment, with the reasoning behind each
| Chapter | Topic | Guy as informed peer | Guest teaching | Guest disagreement | Guy pushing back | Why |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Andy Dunn's Upbringing and Cultural Identity | 1 | 0 | 0 | 0 | Guy Raz asks open biographical questions about Andy Dunn's upbringing and transition into business school. Andy shares his personal journey with self-awareness and cultural identity in a collaborative, reflective tone. | |
| Stanford Ideation and the Biltong Experiment | 2 | 1 | 0 | 1 | Guy asks about Stanford MBA ideation and pushes slightly on whether incumbent brands like Banana Republic and J.Crew already solved men's fit. Andy explains Brian Spaley's specific insight regarding the curved waistband. | |
| First Production Batch and Campus Sales | 1 | 0 | 0 | 0 | Guy guides the narrative of Brian making the initial batches in San Francisco and selling them in campus dorms. Andy narrates the organic early customer traction and high demand among classmates. | |
| Co-Founding Bonobos and Declining VC | 3 | 2 | 0 | 1 | Guy probes Andy's value proposition against established competitors and questions why early seed investors bought in so rapidly. Andy explains the Ralph Lauren plus Zappos framework that convinced Joel Peterson and Andy Rachleff. | |
| Venture Dynamics and Relationship-Driven Investing | 4 | 4 | 1 | 2 | Guy contrasts Andy's quick fundraising with Katrina Lake's experience encountering venture capital bias at Stitch Fix. Andy provides a nuanced breakdown of systemic gender disparities in venture capital alongside the personal relationships that enabled his initial check. | |
| Moving to New York and Apartment Trunk Shows | 1 | 0 | 0 | 0 | Guy asks about moving operations to New York and targeting early adopters. Andy details early trunk shows with professional peers in Manhattan. | |
| Early E-Commerce Growth and Residential Eviction | 2 | 1 | 1 | 0 | Andy humorously corrects Guy's taxonomy regarding the Urban Daddy article ('bonobos are apes, not monkeys'). Guy follows the story of exponential e-commerce order growth leading to an eviction from Andy's residential apartment. | |
| Brian Spaley's Return and Co-Founder Friction | 2 | 1 | 0 | 1 | Guy probes the friction that emerged after Brian returned to the company full-time. Andy candidly details how their 50/50 equal partnership deteriorated under conflicting product priorities and the loss of friendship dynamics. | |
| Mental Health Struggles and Therapy | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | Guy gently inquires about the personal and emotional toll on Andy during the company's internal conflict. Andy shares his battle with clinical depression and the therapy breakthrough regarding repressed anger. | |
| The Co-Founder Split and Resolution | 2 | 1 | 0 | 1 | Guy asks about how the difficult separation was executed and whether it could have been salvaged. Andy praises Brian's dignity and generosity in stepping aside, recognizing that both founders were too young and insecure to reconcile at that time. | |
| Mid-Roll Sponsor Break and Teaser | 2 | 0 | 0 | 0 | Guy introduces the mid-roll break recapping the 2009 cash crisis, then transitions into Andy describing an insolvency scare and piecing together angel funding. | |
| The Bi-Coastal Tech Rift and Office Closure | 3 | 2 | 2 | 3 | Guy challenges the rationale behind shuttering the Silicon Valley engineering office, questioning how an e-commerce firm could operate without tech staff. Andy explains the destructive cultural rift and emphasizes the founder courage required to reverse a sunk cost. | |
| The Guideshop Model and Retail Expansion | 3 | 3 | 3 | 1 | Andy playfully pushes back against Guy's assumption that he was 'optimistic', stating he was 'defiant in the face of a terrifying reality'. Andy explains the counterintuitive Guideshop fit-to-ship model and the wholesale deal with Nordstrom. | |
| Founder Equity and Perspectives on Wealth | 3 | 2 | 1 | 1 | Guy asks whether heavy dilution bothered Andy as valuation climbed. Andy reflects on renegotiating his equity stake with the board while maintaining a grounded philosophy on wealth beyond basic family security. | |
| The Walmart Acquisition Opportunity | 2 | 2 | 0 | 1 | Guy questions how Walmart and Bonobos could possibly align strategically. Andy explains his mind meld with Jet.com founder Marc Lore around the Netflix-style vertical integration thesis for proprietary digital brands. | |
| Navigating Deal Leaks and the $310M Sale | 3 | 2 | 1 | 2 | Guy presses Andy on brand dissonance and customer backlash regarding the Walmart acquisition. Andy describes managing internal leaks, holding an emergency all-hands, and securing long-term brand survival. | |
| Reflections on Luck, Kismet, and Gratitude | 2 | 2 | 1 | 2 | Guy asks his signature question on the balance between skill and luck, prompting Andy to define 'kismet'. When Guy summarises that Andy doesn't believe in luck, Andy immediately clarifies that foundational privileges like family and genetics are entirely luck. | |
| Show Outro and Stanford Case Study | 1 | 0 | 0 | 0 | Guy provides the episode outro and conducts the 'How You Built That' segment featuring Amy and Brady King of Pallet Shelter. The dialogue is completely supportive and descriptive. |
Statements from this episode (23)
Dunn: Stanford Graduate School of Business does not disclose grades to employers
“There's no Grade disclosure to employers. So they remove the competitive dynamic of how you do in your classes.”
Dunn: Curved waistbands were a novel breakthrough in early menswear design
“And that was this genius insight that actually the way to do this is to make pants with a curved waistband, which would bring in the pant around to your waist in a way where the overall shape looks Looks great. And that hadn't really been done in a meaningful …”
Dunn: Bonobos sold $16,000 worth of pants in one day at Stanford
“One day, we had a pants party at our house, and I think we sold 16,000 dollars worth of pants that day.”
Dunn: Retail is a bundle of physical products and customer service
“Retail isn't just physical products. It's a bundle of physical products and customer service, and those two things together create the experience that drives customer enthusiasm.”
Dunn: Benchmark co-founder Andy Rachleff backed Bonobos at a $3M valuation
“I went to see the other professor from school who is an amazing business person named Andy Ratcliffe, one of the co-founders of Benchmark. And he also offered to invest, and he was willing to do it at the three million dollar price”
Dunn: Venture capital is a fundamentally misogynistically wired system
“So we have a mismatch where men who don't understand women or how women shop are trying to decide how to make investments, and only nine percent of VCs are women. So it's a fundamentally misogynistically wired system.”
Dunn: Nearly every attendee purchased multiple items at the first Bonobos trunk show
“Seven guys bought three pairs of pants, six guys bought two pairs of pants, only one guy didn't buy anything, and it was at that moment that I decided, we need to build this company in New York.”
Dunn: Bonobos reached $90,000 in monthly revenue within six months of launch
“So we properly launched BonobosPants.com in October of oh seven, and we did 10 grand that month, then in November we did 20, December we did 30, came back from the holiday break in January, and we did no sales for the first five days, and I thought, oh my god,…”
Dunn: Founding a business with friends destroys the friendship's emotional support
“Once you get into a business partnership with a friend, the friendship gets totally sublimated to the business partnership. So a lot of the stuff that you used to talk about or do, you don't have time to do because you've got to work on this little growing bab…”
Dunn hid clinical depression while leading Bonobos through severe co-founder conflict
“It turns out I have a propensity clinically for depression, and so I got to the place where I kind of had to fake it at work that I was doing ok, but drag myself out of bed and come to the office and kind of put on a show.”
Dunn: Bonobos was eight days away from missing payroll in 2009
“We had, I guess, promised a supplier through a letter of credit, and we were about Eight days away from not making payroll”
Dunn: Bonobos raised its first $8M from over 120 individual investors
“We ended up raising our first eight million from, you know, over, over a 120 investors.”
Dunn: Bonobos generated $2M in year one and $4M in 2009
“We did two million in that first year, and of, kind of, full operations in a way, and then four in a nine, and then we were heading towards seven or so”
Dunn: Opening a Bonobos engineering office in Palo Alto was catastrophic
“You know, we opened an office in Palo Alto, and it turned out to be a catastrophic error.”
Dunn: Bonobos' physical retail and wholesale channels ultimately funded e-commerce losses
“Our most profitable business became Nordstrom. And our second most profitable were our retail stores, and those two businesses' profits were funding losses from the e-commerce business, which is a wonderful paradox to the way that we conceived of the company.”
Dunn: Zero-inventory clothing stores generate higher retail sales per square foot
“You create a clothing store that has no clothing. And that was the insight, which is the customer doesn't need it right away, and that flew in the face of everything everyone in retail told me from the traditional industry. Instant gratification. And it turns …”
Dunn: The Bonobos board initially rejected his request for additional founder equity
“They said no at first. And, you know, said, hey, like, you need to work for the shares that you've got. And then, you know, ultimately I just wore them down, and I got some alternative perspectives from people in the venture capital backed company space, and s…”
Dunn: Launched Bonobos with $3,000 in the bank and $160,000 in debt
“When I graduated business school, I had 3000 dollars in the bank and 160,000 dollars of debt, and I started a company with that balance sheet.”
Dunn: Knowing what he knows now, building Bonobos required only $30M
“I can't go back in time and do this company on 20 to thirty million. Which is what I think it would take, knowing what I now know”
Dunn: Founders have a moral obligation to deliver liquidity after ten years
“Once you've got venture investors who've been in For seven years and angel investors who've been in for 10, it just would be wrong to not make other people money.”
Dunn: Marc Lore is probably the East Coast's best e-commerce entrepreneur
“So probably the best third-party e-commerce entrepreneur on the East Coast.”
Dunn: E-commerce platforms will vertically integrate proprietary brands just like Netflix
“The future of e-commerce was going to look a little bit like the history of Netflix. That a platform that was streaming other people's content and distributing other people's content would vertically integrate and start to develop their own proprietary content…”