why aren't all 16 resolved? a statement only gets an assessment when the public
record can support or contradict it. opinions and what-ifs never can, and 0 checkable
ones are still open, waiting for their date. predictions held up or didn't;
assertions are supported or contradicted. on every card:
▮▮▮▮▮ certainty ·
▮▮▮▮▮ debate potential. speakers are clickable
Assertion Contradicted
Chamath: Agent-written code caused three or four SEV-1 outages at AWS
“Why does Amazon issue an edict that says you cannot use this stuff inside of AWS unless a human now reviews and approves it? Because what happened? They had three or four SEV-ONE faults from a bunch of code that was written by agents that brought down AWS.”
Opinion
Friedberg: Enterprise cloud market has no lock-in for AWS, Azure, or GCP
“The cloud is a wide open competitive market right now. Like there is no AWS lock-in in this market. There's no Azure lock-in. There's no GCP lock-in”
Opinion
Chamath: AWS makes building production AI apps unfeasibly expensive
“For example, like AWS, if you look inside of how expensive it is to build an app there, I've tried, even when they give you credits, the credits they give you aren't sufficient enough to even pay for half the power. And then the way that they schedule and the …”
Opinion
Sacks: Infrastructure providers and banks must not engage in viewpoint discrimination
“At the level of pipes, like an AWS, like a cloud flare, like a PayPal, like the ISPs, like the banks, they are not doing any. Content moderation, or they have no legitimate reason to be doing content moderation. None of those companies should be allowed to eng…”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Laffont: Top AI platform revenue could surpass Microsoft by 2028
“We estimate that only, not only is it bigger than Azure, but by the end of the year it could be bigger than AWS and potentially bigger than all of Microsoft. By twenty-twenty-eight.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Palihapitiya predicts AWS, Azure, and Google Cloud will split market evenly
“So there's all these reasons why eventually all these three big companies will converge effectively, roughly a third. We're going to debate the path to get there, but that's where they'll end up.”
Opinion
Lafont: Synthetic index of AWS, Azure, and GCP is all investors need
“Well, I think all four of us would agree that if we could synthetically own AWS, Azure, and GCP, if I could somehow automagically create an index of all three of those businesses, right, over the next five years, you wouldn't need to own anything else.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Chamath: AI will be 10x to 100x more deflationary for startups than AWS
“The economic impact of AI is so massively deflationary. It may be An order or two orders of magnitude more deflationary Then AWS was, and that was massively accretive to the startup economy.”
Prediction Didn’t hold up
Chamath: Amazon's advertising business will surpass AWS within three years
“It'll be bigger than AWS in three years at this rate.”
Prediction Held up
Huang: AWS will purchase 1 million Nvidia chips in coming years
“In the case of AWS, I think they just announced, I think it was yesterday, that they're gonna buy a million chips in the next couple years.”
Disclosure
Chamath: Software company's AI costs tripled since November 2025
“Our costs have more than tripled since November of 25. Between the inference cost that we pay AWS, which is ginormous, between our cost with cursor, between anthropic, we are just spending millions.”
Opinion
Calacanis: Dropbox made a critical error building its own data centers
“Dropbox made this critical error. I don't know if you remember that Saks where they stood up their own data centers instead of, you know, they were just scared to have their data at, I guess, AWS or whatever it was.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Tareq Amin: Humain pays power tariffs equivalent to Google and AWS
“My rates, my tariff is equivalent to what Google would get to what AWS get.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Friedberg predicts recent AWS outage will accelerate enterprise multi-cloud adoption
“But the outage that happened this week, I think, starts to highlight for folks that they can't and shouldn't have a dependency on a single cloud service provider, and will only accelerate the diversification of companies into the other clouds.”
Assertion Partly supported
Friedberg compares revenue run rates and growth for AWS, Azure, and GCP
“AWS has a hundred twenty-four billion dollar revenue run rate. Microsoft, one hundred twenty billion, and Google Cloud, fifty four billion. But AWS, which is slightly larger than Microsoft, is only growing 17% year over year. Microsoft's 26% year over year, an…”
Assertion Supported
Calacanis notes recent AWS outage crippled 2,000 companies for 15 hours
“Monday, massive AWS outage, 2000 companies, four million users unable to function on the internet for half a day, 15 hours, 20 hours.”