Feb 3, 2021 · 1h 20m · allin
E20: Robinhood wrap up, Insiders vs. Outsiders, California's failing report card & how to fix it
Chamath Palihapitiya · 21m spoken David Sacks · 18m spoken David Friedberg · 17m spoken Jason Calacanis · 14m spoken
0:00 / 0:00
▶ Watch on YouTube →
gold bands on the timeline = statements, start to end. Hover to read, click to jump. CC turns on captions
In Emergency Episode #20 of the All-In Podcast, the hosts analyze the financial market mechanics and insider-versus-outsider dynamics of the Robinhood trading controversy before delivering a comprehensive breakdown of California's governance failures and proposed policy solutions.
How this conversation actually went
Every chapter scored 0–10 on four independent dynamics. Hover any point for the reasoning behind the score. The hosts hold 99.3% of the talking time here. How this is scored →
The hosts as informed peer 6.7 Guest teaching 4.1 Guest disagreement 3.4 The hosts pushing back 3.6
speaking balance: gold is the hosts, purple is the guest (3 minute bins)
Sharpest disagreement ▶ 14:30 Sacks calls out Robinhood talking points and Citadel conflicts
Sacks forcefully rejects Jason's framing of concerns as 'conspiracy theories', insisting Citadel's involvement on both sides represents an undeniable conflict of interest.
Hardest push from the hosts ▶ 29:18 Friedberg defends public institutions against populist rhetoricFriedberg directly challenges the populist narrative, defending the crucial role of career public servants and institutional structures in preserving democratic continuity.
Biggest teaching moment ▶ 22:20 Friedberg explains stock borrow fee income mechanicsFriedberg educates the rest of the podcast on how long holders earn substantial interest yields by lending shares out to short sellers.
The host holds their own ▶ 31:46 Chamath delivers California report card statistical breakdownChamath demonstrates complete empirical mastery by citing precise economic, tax, poverty, and migration statistics defining California's policy failures.
the scores for every segment, with the reasoning behind each
| Chapter | Topic | The hosts as informed peer | Guest teaching | Guest disagreement | The hosts pushing back | Why |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Emergency Episode Welcome and Media Blitz Banter | 2 | 1 | 1 | 1 | Introductory podcast banter reviewing episode statistics, media appearances, and playful teasing about Fox News and CNN invitations. | |
| Chamath's Apology and Friendship Reconciliation | 5 | 2 | 2 | 3 | Chamath apologizes to Jason for getting overly emotional in the previous episode. Sacks analyzes Vlad Tenev's ambiguous answers during Elon Musk's Clubhouse interview. | |
| Clearing House Mechanics and Customer vs. Shareholder Priorities | 7 | 5 | 4 | 5 | Friedberg details the clearing house capital requirements versus commercial decisions. Sacks pushes back, arguing that companies should absorb financial losses rather than harming their customers, citing Airbnb's COVID response. | |
| Payment for Order Flow and Systemic Risk Management | 8 | 4 | 2 | 3 | Chamath breaks down payment for order flow mechanics using SoFi internal figures and draws an analogy between financial market plumbing and airplane safety regulation. | |
| Insiders vs. Outsiders, Citadel Conflicts, and Emergency Rescue Capital | 7 | 3 | 7 | 7 | Sacks forcefully rejects Jason's dismissive 'conspiracy theory' framing, highlighting Citadel's clear conflict of interest on both sides of the trade. The group debates insider power dynamics versus retail investors. | |
| The Mechanics, Borrow Fees, and Regulation of Short Selling | 8 | 6 | 2 | 2 | Chamath and Friedberg explain short selling mechanics, stock borrowing interest fees, T+0 settlement proposals, and personal stock lending experiences. | |
| "The Insiders' Game" and the Shift Beyond Left vs. Right | 7 | 5 | 5 | 4 | Sacks cites Elizabeth Warren's memoir quote from Larry Summers to explain the unspoken rules of the 'insiders game' in Washington and Wall Street. | |
| Institutional Value vs. Careerism and Term Limits | 6 | 4 | 5 | 6 | Friedberg pushes back against blanket anti-institutional populism, defending the critical continuity provided by career public servants. Chamath proposes two-term limits. | |
| California's Failing Report Card and Special Interest Control | 9 | 6 | 4 | 4 | Chamath delivers a comprehensive statistical breakdown of California's economic, social, and governance metrics, citing poverty, tax, homelessness, and business flight numbers. | |
| Structural Constraints, Pension Liabilities, and EDD Fraud in California | 9 | 7 | 3 | 3 | Friedberg educates the group on California's structural budget constraints, including voter-passed propositions, $250 billion underfunded pension liabilities, and $30 billion in EDD fraud. | |
| Newsom Recall, Pension Spiking, and Housing Unaffordability | 7 | 4 | 4 | 4 | Sacks and Jason discuss pension spiking, overtime manipulation by public employees, and housing unaffordability driving young workers to states like Texas. | |
| Fentanyl Crisis, Mental Health Infrastructure, and Role of Government | 7 | 4 | 3 | 3 | The hosts analyze the fentanyl epidemic, DA non-prosecution policies, and the urgent need for state-level psychiatric treatment facilities. | |
| Tax Concentration, Economic Monoculture, and Business Exodus | 8 | 5 | 5 | 5 | Friedberg and Sacks calculate California's extreme tax concentration, showing that losing just 40,000 top-earning households creates a $50 billion budget deficit. | |
| David Sachs Proposes Chamath Run for California Governor | 3 | 1 | 2 | 2 | Sacks proposes Chamath run for California governor, prompting Chamath to deflect with an anecdote about being mistaken for Aziz Ansari at the White House Correspondents Dinner. | |
| Chamath Addresses Political Ambitions and Governance Strategy | 6 | 3 | 2 | 3 | Chamath seriously outlines what running for office would require, emphasizing that any campaign must focus on a legislative platform rather than a single personality. | |
| The Besties Outline Policy Proposals to Fix California | 8 | 5 | 3 | 3 | The hosts outline policy solutions for California, including school vouchers, zero personal tax schemes, corporate equity warrants, and a call to support the Newsom recall. |
Statements from this episode (31)
Calacanis: DTCC demanded $3B in collateral from Robinhood
“The Depository and Trust and Clearing Corporation, which is Wall Street's main clearinghouse for stock trades demanded three billion dollars in additional collateral from Robin Hood, which they said was an order of magnitude more than usually required.”
Sacks: Founders violating their mission must publish government orders or explanation
“If you're going to basically violate your stated mission, you either need to post the government order that required you to do that. Or you need to post a very well reasoned blog explaining why you're doing that.”
Sacks: Airbnb absorbed customer deposit losses from COVID cancellations
“When they had a whole ton of cancellations because of COVID, they ate all those deposits. They made good on that.”
Sacks: Robinhood made a big mistake restricting customer trading
“And I actually think if that's all that was involved, that was a big mistake. I think Robinhood should have eaten it.”
Chamath: SoFi made $1.5M from payment for order flow
“I asked the team at SoFi, like, you know, what's the, how much is how much is made on payment for order flow? And the answer was 1.5 million dollars. And the forecast for next year was like 400 K.”
Chamath: Robinhood employees will be creamed by $3.4B rescue dilution
“I'll tell you the only group of people that are for sure going to get completely creamed in this, which are employees.”
Friedberg: Silver Lake made $3B to $4B on Airbnb emergency deal
“They put in debt, and then they got warrants, and the warrants ended up making them, like, I mean, Silver Lake. Forex, it's insane. They made, like, three, four billion dollars.”
Calacanis seeing rising secondary market bids for Robinhood shares
“All I know is I've been getting increasing offers for my Robin Hood shares in the secondary market”
Chamath: GameStop short interest was around 50% as of Friday
“The best source of data that I have access to is a company called market m a r k i t. They're quite large. But as of this Friday, the short interest was still, I think about 50% in GameStop.”
Friedberg: Borrowing GameStop shares reached a 30% to 60% interest rate
“In the case of GameStop, I think the cost of borrow got so high that you're basically paying 30, 40, 50, 60%, you know, interest rate to borrow GameStop shares to sell them short because there was so much interest in, in selling short.”
Sacks: Insider vs. outsider will be a major post-Trump political theme
“It's not just about left and right anymore. It's about insider versus outsider. And I think this is going to be a major, major theme that we see.”
Friedberg: Career public servants heroically preserved democracy during Trump's presidency
“But if not for that deep state, we may have found ourselves in a lot of very ugly situations over the last four years that there really were layers and layers of career public servants that did incredible and incredibly heroic things to preserve democracy, to …”
Chamath: Restricting politicians to two terms would have a cleansing effect
“So for example, like if the rule was, you know, you can only be a two term politician. Wow, that would be what a cleansing effect that would have on anybody that chose to serve in politics, up and down the board, you know, at the federal level, at the state le…”
Chamath: California had $11B in confirmed unemployment fraud in 2020
“Thirty billion dollars of potential fraudulent unemployment benefits From 2020, eleven billion already determined fraudulent.”
Chamath: 53% of Californians want to leave the state
“53% of Californians want to leave the state and 63% of Californians believe the American dream is dead.”
Sacks: California has 340,000 public workers earning over $100K
“In California, we have over 340,000 public employees who make over a 100,000 dollars a year that cost taxpayers over forty five billion, okay?”
Sacks: Gavin Newsom will not solve California's governance problems
“He's worked his way up the ladder of California politics by, you know, by basically benefiting from these special interests throughout his rise. You know, you step by step. He's never challenged the insiders or any special interests. He just kind of caters to …”
Friedberg: Top 1% of households pay half of California personal income tax
“The state of California generates about a hundred and forty billion dollars in revenue. 70% of that comes from personal income tax, and as Sachs pointed out, half of that comes from the top one percent or 40,000 households.”
Friedberg: California public pension funds are $250 billion underfunded
“One out of nine Californians are a member of a public pension fund in the state of California, one out of nine. And the public pension funds in California, as of the last reporting, are roughly two hundred and fifty billion dollars underfunded relative to the …”
Friedberg: California EDD paid $30 billion in fraudulent unemployment claims
“There's a hundred and fourteen billion dollars in unemployment claims paid since COVID. This is an insane statistic, but it looks like roughly 27% or thirty billion dollars of fraudulent claims were paid by the EDD.”
Calacanis: Austin offers $300k homes within 40 minutes of downtown
“You go to Austin, and I've been looking at Austin real estate just coincidentally, and there are many homes that are 300,000 dollars that are 400 dollars a square foot everywhere within 30, 40 minutes of downtown Austin, and that's where young people are going…”
Calacanis: San Francisco overdose deaths were 4-5x COVID-19 deaths
“And if you look just in San Francisco, we're talking four or five times the number of overdose Overdose deaths to COVID deaths.”
Chamath: Reagan defunded California mental health institutions as governor
“Reagan was the one that defunded all of the mental health institutions, you know, when he was governor of California and sent all these folks spilling into the streets.”
Chamath: Government should generally run at a loss if GDP growth is positive
“Government should not be for profit. You know, government should, I don't even think government should be breaking even. I think that government should be generally running at a loss. And then the net GDP, as long as that's positive and accretive, we're doing …”
Sacks: Government workers will soon be California's only remaining middle class
“The only middle class that's going to be left in California pretty soon are government workers.”
Palihapitiya proposes California offer tax credits for startup equity
“What if whenever you started a company in California, you got, you know, three or four years worth of tax credits for engineers in return for one percent of the equity that California was not allowed to sell.”
Chamath will not run for office if forced to abandon battery project
“I'm working on something in batteries that I think is, it's important for a lot of places much, you know, more than just California. And so like, if I have to abandon this battery project, I wouldn't do it, you know, just that simple.”
Chamath says he would serve only 18 months if elected in California
“The reality is that if I were to do it, if like all the checks came back and it seemed like it was a plausible thing, I would only do it for the 18 months”
Sacks: California public schools spend $18,000 per student with above-average class sizes
“The average student in California costs 18,000 dollars a year, roughly, ok? And we have a classroom size on average of about 25 students. It's actually higher than the national average.”