Dec 23, 2023 · 1h 47m · allin
E158: Global trade disrupted, Adobe/Figma canceled, realtors sued, Trump blocked
David Sacks · 26m spoken Jason Calacanis · 24m spoken Chamath Palihapitiya · 22m spoken David Friedberg · 14m spoken Ryan Petersen · 7m spoken
0:00 / 0:00
▶ Watch on YouTube →
gold bands on the timeline = statements, start to end. Hover to read, click to jump. CC turns on captions
In Episode 158 of the All-In Podcast, the hosts analyze critical economic and geopolitical developments, including the Red Sea shipping crisis, regulatory blocks on tech M&A, changing venture capital dynamics, the real estate commission lawsuit, and Donald Trump's disqualification in Colorado.
How this conversation actually went
Every chapter scored 0–10 on four independent dynamics. Hover any point for the reasoning behind the score. The hosts hold 91.8% of the talking time here. How this is scored →
The hosts as informed peer 5.8 Guest teaching 0.8 Guest disagreement 0.1 The hosts pushing back 2.8
speaking balance: gold is the hosts, purple is the guest (3 minute bins)
Sharpest disagreement ▶ 22:00 Ryan Peterson Refutes Regional Alignment Optimism
When Chamath argues Middle Eastern nations will unite to resolve conflicts, Ryan directly challenges the optimistic premise, noting that historical actions rarely follow such idealized logic.
Hardest push from the hosts ▶ 43:20 Friedberg Rejects Antitrust Framing for Deal CancellationsFriedberg firmly pushes back against Sacks and Chamath, asserting that rising interest rates and return on capital discipline were the true drivers behind Adobe abandoning the Figma transaction.
Biggest teaching moment ▶ 31:38 Ryan Peterson Illustrates Air vs Sea Capacity RealitiesRyan educates the hosts on global freight mechanics by contrasting a single container vessel holding 10,000 containers against a 747 cargo plane holding only seven.
The host holds their own ▶ 1:21:00 Friedberg Cites Global Real Estate Commission DataFriedberg demonstrates deep domain knowledge by contrasting America's 5.5% real estate fees with the UK's 1.3%, showing how MLS access controls market pricing.
the scores for every segment, with the reasoning behind each
| Chapter | Topic | The hosts as informed peer | Guest teaching | Guest disagreement | The hosts pushing back | Why |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pre-Show Banter: Dictator Upgraded to Chairman | 1 | 0 | 0 | 1 | The hosts engage in light pre-show banter regarding Chamath's title upgrade from dictator to chairman and Jason's mild illness. No guest is present and no complex domain expertise is discussed. | |
| Podcast Intro Sequence and Defining BIPOC Chairman | 1 | 0 | 0 | 1 | The hosts continue casual banter defining the BIPOC chairman joke and sharing photos from a holiday party. The atmosphere is purely lighthearted social conversation. | |
| Red Sea Crisis Overview and Phoning a Lifeline | 2 | 1 | 0 | 1 | Jason introduces the Red Sea shipping crisis caused by Houthi drone strikes. Sacks admits he lacks sufficient detailed knowledge on global maritime shipping and requests to call an expert guest. | |
| Flexport CEO Ryan Peterson on Global Shipping Disruption | 6 | 7 | 2 | 4 | Guest Ryan Petersen details how Red Sea disruptions remove 20-25% of shipping capacity and explains logistics realities across ocean, canal, and air transport. Chamath offers macro theories on Middle East alignment which Ryan gently refutes based on historical conflict patterns. | |
| Asymmetric Warfare Economics and Regional Escalation Risks | 5 | 0 | 0 | 2 | The hosts summarize the interview, focusing on the economic asymmetry where cheap drones force expensive missile defense responses and cause massive supply chain blockades. | |
| Adobe-Figma Merger Termination and Regulatory Chilling Effect | 7 | 0 | 0 | 3 | Chamath and Sacks analyze the Adobe-Figma breakup and FTC/UK regulatory pushback, explaining how blocked M&A forces startups into prolonged private gestation without capital market support. | |
| Adobe-Figma Deal Collapse & The New Era of M&A | 7 | 2 | 0 | 5 | Friedberg pushes back against the regulatory overreach narrative, arguing that high interest rates and return on capital metrics made paying the breakup fee financially rational for Adobe. | |
| IPO Dynamics, VC Return Realities, and AI Financial Research | 8 | 0 | 0 | 2 | Chamath draws on historical market knowledge to explain how Reg FD and reduced sell-side research constrained public market liquidity, proposing AI financial agents as a potential solution. | |
| Operating as a CEO Post-ZIRP: Profitability over Valuation | 8 | 0 | 0 | 3 | Friedberg and Chamath outline operating strategies post-ZIRP, emphasizing capital efficiency, customer payback periods, and unit economics over chasing inflated VC valuations. | |
| How AI Disrupts VC and the Return to Small Fund Economics | 8 | 0 | 0 | 4 | Chamath details how AI tools lower team operating costs from millions to tens of thousands, while Sacks counters that go-to-market scaling still demands significant capital expenditure. | |
| Venture Incubations & Chamath's Operational CEO Reality | 7 | 0 | 0 | 2 | Sacks explains Craft's incubation structure for projects like SaaSGrid, while Chamath shares his hands-on experience re-entering operational CEO duties and writing code. | |
| Real Estate Class Action Lawsuits & NAR Commission Monopoly | 8 | 0 | 0 | 4 | Jason and Friedberg break down the $1.8B NAR antitrust verdict, with Friedberg presenting data on international commission rates and explaining how the MLS monopoly inflates fees. | |
| Colorado Supreme Court Disqualifies Donald Trump Under 14th Amendment | 7 | 0 | 0 | 4 | The hosts discuss the Colorado Supreme Court ruling disqualifying Trump under the 14th Amendment, with Sacks analyzing legal precedents and due process concerns while Friedberg questions conviction thresholds. |
Statements from this episode (33)
Calacanis: Top five shipping conglomerates paused Red Sea transit
“All five of the world's largest shipping conglomerates have paused transfers through the Red Sea.”
Peterson: 30% of ocean container traffic passes through Red Sea
“About 30% of all ocean container traffic flows through the Suez and through the Red Sea.”
Peterson: Asia-to-Europe ocean freight prices jumped 3x for January
“Prices are coming out now for January freight for ocean freight, Asia to Europe. You're seeing about a three X increase in the price of ocean freight versus where we were a month or two ago”
Peterson: Houthi rebels will not disrupt Suez Canal long term
“The Suez canal is too valuable in my opinion, Too valuable to civilization, to the modern world, to believe that, you know, a group of rebels, no matter how well funded they may be, is going to be able to disrupt that for any long period of time.”
Peterson: Rerouting around Africa adds 8% transit time to US vs 20% to Europe
“To go around the southern tip of Africa around the Cape of good hope to get to the east coast, it's like an eight percent increase in transit time versus 20 to Europe.”
Chamath: Gaza and Red Sea wars will get resolved quickly
“I suspect that both of these two hot wars get resolved quickly because the larger multi-decade implications for the Middle East are too big to let it be subsumed by the Houthi rebels or Hamas.”
Sacks: 90% of Israeli public supports continuing war until Hamas is eliminated
“If you look at Israeli domestic politics, it's true that Netanyahu is unpopular, but something like 90% of the Israeli public favors the continuation of this war until Hamas is eliminated.”
Peterson: Houthi drones cost $20k while US interceptor missiles cost $2M
“They shoot a 20,000 dollar drone and we need a two million dollar missile to shoot it down.”
Peterson: Air freight prices will surge if Red Sea crisis lasts weeks
“I suspect if this lasts another week or two, you're going to see big run-ups in air freight prices.”
Friedberg: Insurers' zero loss tolerance lets cheap drone attacks freeze trade
“If you send a drone and it blows up on a ship and it costs you a couple thousand bucks to do that, the lack of risk tolerance, the fact that the insurance companies won't insure the ship anymore means that now that ship can't travel and that's tens of millions…”
Friedberg: Houthi and Hamas actions will embolden proxy attacks worldwide
“There are many other groups like this that may get emboldened and you start to see more activity in other regions as well, that you can have these kind of outsized impacts and folks suddenly, you know, start to take action.”
Chamath: VC-backed startups will stay private for 15 to 20 years
“We'll have companies gestating for 15 and 20 years. And I think that just has a chilling effect because it's like, what investor wants to put money away locked up in highly illiquid stuff for 20 years?”
Sacks: Regulatory delay on Adobe-Figma will chill Silicon Valley M&A
“The fact that regulators took 15 months to analyze the deal, only to come to the conclusion that they basically weren't going to allow it, and then Adobe finally killed it, is going to have a chilling effect on M&A in Silicon Valley. I mean, if acquirers and t…”
Sacks: Startups should avoid putting European headquarters in the UK
“If you're a startup and you're trying to consider where to put your Europe office, I would not choose the UK anymore. I used to think that the UK was number one because it was so easy, but you don't want to create that nexus if you can help it. It might subjec…”
Chamath: You cannot underwrite a $20 billion deal in any industry
“I don't think you can underwrite to get a twenty billion dollar deal done in any industry.”
Chamath: Meta acquiring WhatsApp for $17B could never happen today
“Today, that could never happen.”
Sacks: Canceled Adobe-Figma merger would have been worth $30B
“And that, that Figma Adobe deal, it was a twenty billion dollar deal, but with the rise in Adobe stock, it's really a thirty billion dollar deal if it would have been consummated, because half the consideration was in Adobe stock, and that has basically double…”
Chamath: VC funds often return less than the S&P 500
“Why take on 15 year illiquidity for oftentimes funds that return less than the S and P, which is the dirty little secret of Silicon Valley.”
Chamath: The number of public US companies halved in 20 years
“The number of public companies I think has halved in the last 20 years.”
Friedberg: Founders are better off avoiding venture capital to prevent distortions
“If you can avoid raising capital, you're better off because then you don't have any shareholder pressure to get liquid and that can create contortions in what you do and how you operate the business.”
Chamath: Calling a startup a 'tech company' to gain valuation premium is meaningless
“To say you're a tech company is a meaningless statement that means nothing.”
Calacanis: Firm invested in 100 startups in 2023 matching early career
“We invested in a hundred companies this year. It's more than I've ever done. That's the same amount I did in the first seven years of my career.”
Chamath: AI will be 10x to 100x more deflationary for startups than AWS
“The economic impact of AI is so massively deflationary. It may be An order or two orders of magnitude more deflationary Then AWS was, and that was massively accretive to the startup economy.”
Chamath: VC fund sizes will shrink by 75-80% due to AI efficiency
“I think what it means is that the two hundred million dollar fund today becomes 50, the five hundred million dollar fund needs to be a hundred and the billion dollar fund needs to be 200.”
Chamath: LP investments in large VC funds yield no success
“If I look at my returns as an LP, I've never had success when I've invested in big funds. I've only had success in small funds.”
Calacanis: Federal jury orders NAR to pay $1.8B over inflated commissions
“In October, a federal jury in Missouri found the NAR, that's the National Association of Realtors and several of the brokerages that have those brokers working for them, guilty of conspiring to artificially inflate commissions for home sales. They now have to …”
Friedberg: US residential real estate commissions reach $100B annually
“The total volume in the U S is an incredible number. It's a hundred billion dollars a year in residential real estate commissions. And there's 1.6 million folks who are real estate agents that are licensed, making their living doing this.”
Sacks: Real estate monopoly ends when buy-side commissions disappear
“Here's how you'll know that the monopoly has ended is when the buy side commission goes away.”
Friedberg: NAR lawsuit settlement will benefit consumers but hurt real estate jobs
“And I think that this lawsuit and the settlement ultimately leads to a change, a shift in the industry that would certainly benefit consumers, but could have a negative economic impact. Because of the number of people that depend on brokerage fees as their job…”
Calacanis: NAR settlement will let sellers pick broker commission percentages
“The settlement is likely to be that when you hire a broker, they will give you a form and you'll pick what percentage you want to pay.”
Calacanis: Real estate commissions should combine flat fees with performance upside
“So it really should be based upon a flat rate up to a number, and then a percentage above that number to align interests.”