StarZero All shows Try the podcast clipper →

Mar 3, 2025 · 34m · the-pitch

#67 Call-in Pitch Competition

Josh Muccio · 9m spoken Heather Rogers · 4m spoken Kareem Maddox · 4m spoken Leigh Isaacson · 3m spoken Edward Skisov · 2m spoken Hector Morales · 1m spoken Sean McCarty · 6s spoken Rhiannon Payne · 5s spoken Rich Kellerman · 4s spoken
0:00 / 0:00
▶ Watch on YouTube →

gold bands on the timeline = statements, start to end. Hover to read, click to jump. CC turns on captions

In this special call-in episode of The Pitch, host Josh Muccio and producers Heather Rogers and Kareem Maddox evaluate three standout listener startups from over 200 submissions to award a coveted spot on their investor pitch stage. After conducting rigorous due diligence on each business model, the team selects dog dating app Dig as the winner while launching a public wildcard vote for the runner-up slot.

How this conversation actually went

Every chapter scored 0–10 on four independent dynamics. Hover any point for the reasoning behind the score. Josh holds 40.3% of the talking time here. How this is scored →

Josh as informed peer 4.7 Guest teaching 3.3 Guest disagreement 1.5 Josh pushing back 3.0
05100:0010:0020:0030:001:31–4:56 · Josh as informed peer 5/10 Setting the Stage for the Call-in Competition Josh probes Hector on his financing structure, questioning whether the $1.3 million came from investors or debt, and challenges the viability of direct-to-consumer luxury manufacturing.4:57–7:38 · Josh as informed peer 4/10 Pitch 2: Lee Isaacson and Dig Dating App Lee delivers a polished one-minute pitch for Dig dating app, and Josh enthusiastically validates her concept while inquiring about customer acquisition strategies.7:39–10:26 · Josh as informed peer 4/10 Pitch 3: Edward Skisov and KickSense Edward explains the refereeing challenges in karate and how KickSense automates scoring, while Josh clarifies the product mechanism and hardware use cases.10:33–16:40 · Josh as informed peer 6/10 Call-in Pitch Wrap-Up and Mid-Show Tease The production team critically analyzes each pitch; Heather and Josh challenge Kareem on vague karate market sizing and scrutinize whether Dig is merely a feature rather than a business.17:04–30:59 · Josh as informed peer 7/10 Deep-Dive Diligence Findings and Winner Selection The team reviews founder diligence findings; Hector explains the 10x middleman supply chain markup, Lee explains Match Group's portfolio strategy, and Heather firmly rejects Hector's business model.31:14–33:30 · Josh as informed peer 2/10 Notifying the Winner: Lee Isaacson Josh calls Lee to deliver the good news that she was selected, followed by a collaborative and joyful reaction before Josh closes with the listener voting announcement.1:31–4:56 · Guest teaching 4/10 Setting the Stage for the Call-in Competition Josh probes Hector on his financing structure, questioning whether the $1.3 million came from investors or debt, and challenges the viability of direct-to-consumer luxury manufacturing.4:57–7:38 · Guest teaching 3/10 Pitch 2: Lee Isaacson and Dig Dating App Lee delivers a polished one-minute pitch for Dig dating app, and Josh enthusiastically validates her concept while inquiring about customer acquisition strategies.7:39–10:26 · Guest teaching 4/10 Pitch 3: Edward Skisov and KickSense Edward explains the refereeing challenges in karate and how KickSense automates scoring, while Josh clarifies the product mechanism and hardware use cases.10:33–16:40 · Guest teaching 2/10 Call-in Pitch Wrap-Up and Mid-Show Tease The production team critically analyzes each pitch; Heather and Josh challenge Kareem on vague karate market sizing and scrutinize whether Dig is merely a feature rather than a business.17:04–30:59 · Guest teaching 6/10 Deep-Dive Diligence Findings and Winner Selection The team reviews founder diligence findings; Hector explains the 10x middleman supply chain markup, Lee explains Match Group's portfolio strategy, and Heather firmly rejects Hector's business model.31:14–33:30 · Guest teaching 1/10 Notifying the Winner: Lee Isaacson Josh calls Lee to deliver the good news that she was selected, followed by a collaborative and joyful reaction before Josh closes with the listener voting announcement.1:31–4:56 · Guest disagreement 1/10 Setting the Stage for the Call-in Competition Josh probes Hector on his financing structure, questioning whether the $1.3 million came from investors or debt, and challenges the viability of direct-to-consumer luxury manufacturing.4:57–7:38 · Guest disagreement 0/10 Pitch 2: Lee Isaacson and Dig Dating App Lee delivers a polished one-minute pitch for Dig dating app, and Josh enthusiastically validates her concept while inquiring about customer acquisition strategies.7:39–10:26 · Guest disagreement 1/10 Pitch 3: Edward Skisov and KickSense Edward explains the refereeing challenges in karate and how KickSense automates scoring, while Josh clarifies the product mechanism and hardware use cases.10:33–16:40 · Guest disagreement 3/10 Call-in Pitch Wrap-Up and Mid-Show Tease The production team critically analyzes each pitch; Heather and Josh challenge Kareem on vague karate market sizing and scrutinize whether Dig is merely a feature rather than a business.17:04–30:59 · Guest disagreement 4/10 Deep-Dive Diligence Findings and Winner Selection The team reviews founder diligence findings; Hector explains the 10x middleman supply chain markup, Lee explains Match Group's portfolio strategy, and Heather firmly rejects Hector's business model.31:14–33:30 · Guest disagreement 0/10 Notifying the Winner: Lee Isaacson Josh calls Lee to deliver the good news that she was selected, followed by a collaborative and joyful reaction before Josh closes with the listener voting announcement.1:31–4:56 · Josh pushing back 4/10 Setting the Stage for the Call-in Competition Josh probes Hector on his financing structure, questioning whether the $1.3 million came from investors or debt, and challenges the viability of direct-to-consumer luxury manufacturing.4:57–7:38 · Josh pushing back 1/10 Pitch 2: Lee Isaacson and Dig Dating App Lee delivers a polished one-minute pitch for Dig dating app, and Josh enthusiastically validates her concept while inquiring about customer acquisition strategies.7:39–10:26 · Josh pushing back 2/10 Pitch 3: Edward Skisov and KickSense Edward explains the refereeing challenges in karate and how KickSense automates scoring, while Josh clarifies the product mechanism and hardware use cases.10:33–16:40 · Josh pushing back 5/10 Call-in Pitch Wrap-Up and Mid-Show Tease The production team critically analyzes each pitch; Heather and Josh challenge Kareem on vague karate market sizing and scrutinize whether Dig is merely a feature rather than a business.17:04–30:59 · Josh pushing back 6/10 Deep-Dive Diligence Findings and Winner Selection The team reviews founder diligence findings; Hector explains the 10x middleman supply chain markup, Lee explains Match Group's portfolio strategy, and Heather firmly rejects Hector's business model.31:14–33:30 · Josh pushing back 0/10 Notifying the Winner: Lee Isaacson Josh calls Lee to deliver the good news that she was selected, followed by a collaborative and joyful reaction before Josh closes with the listener voting announcement.

speaking balance: gold is Josh, purple is the guest (3 minute bins)

0:00 · Josh 65.4% · guest 34.6%0:00 · Josh 65.4% · guest 34.6%3:00 · Josh 28.3% · guest 71.7%3:00 · Josh 28.3% · guest 71.7%6:00 · Josh 28.7% · guest 71.3%6:00 · Josh 28.7% · guest 71.3%9:00 · Josh 68.9% · guest 31.1%9:00 · Josh 68.9% · guest 31.1%12:00 · Josh 18.9% · guest 81.1%12:00 · Josh 18.9% · guest 81.1%15:00 · Josh 57.6% · guest 42.4%15:00 · Josh 57.6% · guest 42.4%18:00 · Josh 18.1% · guest 81.9%18:00 · Josh 18.1% · guest 81.9%21:00 · Josh 14.7% · guest 85.3%21:00 · Josh 14.7% · guest 85.3%24:00 · Josh 54.7% · guest 45.3%24:00 · Josh 54.7% · guest 45.3%27:00 · Josh 18.9% · guest 81.1%27:00 · Josh 18.9% · guest 81.1%30:00 · Josh 46.4% · guest 53.6%30:00 · Josh 46.4% · guest 53.6%33:00 · Josh 100% · guest 0%33:00 · Josh 100% · guest 0%
Sharpest disagreement ▶ 27:10 Heather firmly rejects Hector's business viability

Heather bluntly dismisses Josh's enthusiastic defense of Luxology, stating she is even less convinced of Hector's business model working in venture capital.

 Hardest push from Josh ▶ 28:10 Josh rejects Kareem's comparison between business models

Josh pushes back against Kareem's critique regarding recurring revenue, arguing that comparing a consumer furniture startup to enterprise SaaS is comparing apples to oranges.

 Biggest teaching moment ▶ 23:45 Hector breaks down the ten-fold middleman markup

Hector educates Josh on the six-step supply chain economics where a $200 manufactured couch doubles at each step to reach a $2,000 retail price.

 Josh holds their own ▶ 15:15 Josh identifies core venture risks for niche dating apps

Josh sharpens the analytical focus by framing the fundamental investor dilemma: whether Dig is an acquirable business or just a feature easily copied by Match or Tinder.
the scores for every segment, with the reasoning behind each
ChapterTopicJosh as informed peerGuest teachingGuest disagreementJosh pushing backWhy
Setting the Stage for the Call-in Competition 5414 Josh probes Hector on his financing structure, questioning whether the $1.3 million came from investors or debt, and challenges the viability of direct-to-consumer luxury manufacturing.
Pitch 2: Lee Isaacson and Dig Dating App 4301 Lee delivers a polished one-minute pitch for Dig dating app, and Josh enthusiastically validates her concept while inquiring about customer acquisition strategies.
Pitch 3: Edward Skisov and KickSense 4412 Edward explains the refereeing challenges in karate and how KickSense automates scoring, while Josh clarifies the product mechanism and hardware use cases.
Call-in Pitch Wrap-Up and Mid-Show Tease 6235 The production team critically analyzes each pitch; Heather and Josh challenge Kareem on vague karate market sizing and scrutinize whether Dig is merely a feature rather than a business.
Deep-Dive Diligence Findings and Winner Selection 7646 The team reviews founder diligence findings; Hector explains the 10x middleman supply chain markup, Lee explains Match Group's portfolio strategy, and Heather firmly rejects Hector's business model.
Notifying the Winner: Lee Isaacson 2100 Josh calls Lee to deliver the good news that she was selected, followed by a collaborative and joyful reaction before Josh closes with the listener voting announcement.

Statements from this episode (10)

Disclosure
Morales: Luxology funded by $1M bank loan and $300k personal investment
“Yes, I got a million dollar loan from my bank and I invested 300 of my own money.”
Hector Morales Mar 3, 2025 ▶ 3:54
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Dig CEO: 60,000 people have used dog dating app Dig
“So far, 60,000 people have turned to Dig to find love.”
Leigh Isaacson Mar 3, 2025 ▶ 5:34
Assertion Supported
Isaacson: 55% of single US adults are pet owners
“55% of single adults in the U.S. Are pet owners with dogs leading the way.”
Leigh Isaacson Mar 3, 2025 ▶ 6:05
Disclosure
Dig CEO: Startup raised $410k and is seeking $350k
“We've raised 410,000 dollars, and now we're seeking 350,000 dollars.”
Leigh Isaacson Mar 3, 2025 ▶ 6:16
Assertion Open · timeframe Mar 2028
Skisov: KickSense reduces karate tournament judges from five to one
“And for karate tournament organizers who want their tournaments to run smoothly and without tears, KickSense has automated competition scoring system that needs just one judge per ring instead of five that are needed today.”
Edward Skisov Mar 3, 2025 ▶ 8:32
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Skisov: Karate in the Olympics will fail miserably
“And with karate going into Olympics in I, you know, they're gonna fail miserably. They don't know it yet.”
Edward Skisov Mar 3, 2025 ▶ 10:00
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Maddox: Refereeing across sports will become increasingly automated
“I think across sports, like, more and more of, like, refereeing will become automated and I just look as far as, like, tech goes in sports, like, if you look at baseball, they're, you know, instituting more tech as far as, like, the umpires.”
Kareem Maddox Mar 3, 2025 ▶ 13:06
Assertion Partly supported
Lee Isaacson: Match Group owns 49 dating apps and actively acquires others
“So if you look at Match Corporation, for example, they own 49 different dating apps, and so in terms of exit possibilities, places like Match Group, the Meet Group is another one. There are these large corporations looking to not just incubate their own dating…”
Leigh Isaacson Mar 3, 2025 ▶ 17:42
Assertion Partly supported
Isaacson: Average dating app user uses three to four apps simultaneously
“You've got your average dating app user using three or four dating apps at a time. People are used to kind of having their main dating apps that they could swipe all day if they want to, and then dating apps that really cut to the chase in addition, kind of in…”
Leigh Isaacson Mar 3, 2025 ▶ 19:26
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Skisov: 17,000 US karate dojos are interconnected through sensei lineage
“To a degree, the sport of karate is very hierarchical, meaning that every sensei traces its lineage to some other sensei who traces its lineage to some other sensei and so forth. So even though there is 17,000 dojos out there, they are all connected to each ot…”
Edward Skisov Mar 3, 2025 ▶ 21:58
Made with StarZero

Turn any episode into a week of clips.

This entire site, over 100 episodes transcribed, diarized, checked and made playable, runs on the StarZero media pipeline. Drop in your own episode and the podcast clipper finds the moments worth sharing, cuts them, captions them, and reframes them for every feed.

Try the podcast clipper Learn more