Feb 27, 2024 · 1h 1m · startup-acquisition-stories
Startup Acquisition Stories Podcast with Wil Schroter, Founder of Startups.com
0:00 / 0:00
gold bands on the timeline = statements, start to end. Hover to read, click to jump. CC turns on captions
Acquire.com host Andrew Gazdecki and Startups.com founder Will Schroter discuss practical strategies for acquiring, restructuring, and salvaging distressed venture-backed software startups. The episode covers founder psychology, cap table renegotiation, operational rightsizing toward profitability, and creative deal structures that deliver soft landings.
How this conversation actually went
Every chapter scored 0–10 on four independent dynamics. Hover any point for the reasoning behind the score. Andrew holds 43.6% of the talking time here. How this is scored →
Andrew as informed peer 5.5 Guest teaching 4.2 Guest disagreement 1.5 Andrew pushing back 0.8
speaking balance: gold is Andrew, purple is the guest (3 minute bins)
Sharpest disagreement ▶ 47:40 Will rejects founder delusions about strategic acquisition value
Will forcefully dismisses the common belief that strategic buyers care about historical R&D spend or raw user counts, calling it an unrealistic Wiley Coyote fantasy.
Hardest push from Andrew ▶ 36:25 Andrew insists founders prioritize employees over investorsAndrew introduces a controversial stance against standard investor-first dogma, asserting that founders have a stronger moral duty to secure severance and transparency for their staff.
Biggest teaching moment ▶ 8:05 Will educates on the immediate drop of startup valuation to zeroWill directly reframes the psychological trap founders fall into, explaining that without active operators at the wheel, a multi-million valuation instantly collapses to zero.
Andrew holds their own ▶ 31:20 Andrew details QSBS tax mechanics and deal protectionsAndrew demonstrates deep M&A knowledge by explaining Qualified Small Business Stock (QSBS) tax advantages alongside legal liability insulation in asset sales.
the scores for every segment, with the reasoning behind each
| Chapter | Topic | Andrew as informed peer | Guest teaching | Guest disagreement | Andrew pushing back | Why |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Welcome and Will Schroter's Entrepreneurial Background | 3 | 2 | 1 | 0 | The conversation opens warmly with Andrew sharing how Will reached out during the early launch days of Acquire.com. Will explains his 30-year entrepreneurial background and setting up the focus on acquiring distressed startups. | |
| The Origin of Buying Distressed Venture Assets | 3 | 5 | 1 | 0 | Will recounts the story of Affordit.com and how running out of cash showed him that distressed venture assets get abandoned. Andrew listens attentively as Will explains the inception of Startups.com's acquisition strategy. | |
| Founder Psychology and the Reality of Zero Valuation | 5 | 5 | 2 | 1 | Andrew highlights current market data on startup runway while Will bluntly explains that once a founder walks away, the business's paper valuation plummets to zero. Both agree on the disconnect between founder expectations and reality. | |
| Statistical Realities of Startups and Facing the End of Runway | 6 | 4 | 2 | 1 | Will breaks down buyer categories (PE, strategic, individual) and warns founders that probability of exit is low. Andrew chimes in with venture success statistics and the psychological imperative not to waste years of one's life. | |
| Investor Motivation and Key Components of Deal Evaluation | 5 | 5 | 2 | 1 | Will explains the contrast between angel and institutional VC motivations regarding write-offs and returns. Andrew raises the issue of startup operational preparation before going to market. | |
| Liquidation Preferences and Setting Realistic Founder Expectations | 5 | 5 | 1 | 0 | Will and Andrew discuss liquidation preferences and how founders often get zero under standard liquidation stacks unless terms are restructured. Andrew reflects on recent founder burnout and changing investor market conditions. | |
| Door 1: Renegotiating Cap Tables and Milestones with Investors | 6 | 4 | 2 | 1 | Will provides a concrete step-by-step playbook on lobbying board members one-by-one to renegotiate cap tables from zero. Andrew validates this strategy by noting that aligned incentives motivate founders to preserve company value. | |
| Door 2: Case Study of Clarity.fm and Asset vs. Stock Purchases | 7 | 4 | 1 | 1 | Will shares the case study of Dan Martell and Clarity.fm, detailing why Startups.com executes asset purchases rather than stock purchases. Andrew demonstrates domain expertise by highlighting QSBS tax advantages for founders and liability firewalls for buyers. | |
| Founder Well-being, Quitting, and Duty to Employees | 6 | 3 | 1 | 1 | The conversation covers founder mental health and the taboo around quitting. Will shares a severe football injury analogy, while Andrew emphasizes prioritizing duty and transparency to employees ahead of investors. | |
| Assessing Runway and Rightsizing Bloated Cost Structures | 6 | 4 | 2 | 2 | Will points out the high legal and operational costs of winding down a startup and shares the Zirtual acquisition story. They discuss how a 50k MRR business burdened with heavy venture overhead can become highly profitable under a lean operator. | |
| Preparing for Sale through Profitability and Strategic Outreach | 7 | 3 | 1 | 1 | Andrew outlines his strategic advice: cutting burn to achieve profitability before listing, which removes time pressure and boosts buyer appeal. Will reinforces this by encouraging founders to design a 'clean reset' version of the company. | |
| The Three Buyer Buckets and Probability Analysis | 5 | 6 | 3 | 1 | Will delivers a reality check on strategic acquisitions, puncturing common founder illusions about product investment and customer lists. He outlines the true probability split across PE, strategics, and individual owner-operators. | |
| Deal Structuring: Cash, Seller Financing, and Equity Kickers | 7 | 4 | 1 | 1 | Will and Andrew detail acquisition deal structures, emphasizing combinations of cash upfront, seller financing, and future equity kickers. Will concludes with the reminder that failed startups often hold valuable underlying assets. |
Statements from this episode (25)
Gazdecki: Distressed VC-Backed Startups Face Active Secondary M&A Demand
“There's a lot of venture backed startups out there with founders that, you know, may have lost motivation, their optionality in terms of upside liquidity is not looking great. And people are looking to buy these companies and there's founders looking to exit t…”
Schroter: Cash-poor startups get abandoned despite having valuable assets
“When a startup runs out of cash, everybody kind of runs for the hills. The founders are like in a broken cap table where they have no upside, so like, hey, I'm out of here. The investor is like, well, hey, there's no one to run it, and there's no money, so we'…”
Schroter: Startups.com evaluated over 100 venture-backed startups and acquired six
“We end up talking to, and doing diligence on over a hundred different venture-funded startups, And we ended up pulling the trigger on six of which all six completed.”
Schroter: Startups Drop to Zero Valuation the Minute Cashless Founders Quit
“Usually the founders are like, well, I just raised that a twenty million dollar valuation. And I'm like, yeah, and if you stop working there, the value is now zero. Like, it works there, there's no value. And most founders don't get that.”
Schroter: Distressed startups have only three potential buyer categories
“I said, here's three buckets that you're going to wind up in either private equity, which is only an option if you have revenue, right? The second is a strategic buyer, which is always your best case, but there aren't that many in the likelihood that they're w…”
Schroter: Large VCs prefer equity roll-overs to trivial cash returns
“Bessemer or folks like them would prefer to be able to have their stock just moved over to another entity that would likely do something with it and hopefully have an outcome down the road so they don't have to write it all down”
Schroter: Acquirers care about revenue, not the startup's venture narrative
“You can't just sell the venture story to the world. Like nobody gives a shit. Do you have some revenue? People understand that.”
Schroter: Distressed Startups Rarely Sell Above Their Liquidation Preference Hurdle
“In a lot of cases, by the time you get to this point, even if you've only raised a few million dollars, the likelihood that you're going to sell something and get over your preference hurdle is usually pretty low”
Schroter: Distressed Founders Can Renegotiate Their Payout Terms Pre-Exit
“One of the things that I coach founders on when they go through this is I say, hey, you know that you can go back and create a new deal for yourself within the company, right?”
Schroter: VCs Usually Write Off Failing Startups Long Before Founders Realize
“By the time you get there, investors knew this a long time ago. I mentioned that company that I did back in the mid-two thousands called Affordit. By the time I was like, guys, you're not going to believe this. We're going to have to shut this down. They were …”
Schroter: Distressed startup renegotiation requires a definitive stance, not open-ended talks
“By the time you're going to have that conversation, it needs to be definitive. Dude, I'm out. I'm out of money. I'm out of, like, hell, like my spouse is trying to, you know, is, is tired of dealing with my shit. I need to get out. Okay, now hear me out. Now, …”
Schroter: Distressed cap table restructuring must treat past capital as completely lost
“You have to start with right now, your option is zero. You can't be like, oh, I know we raised that fifty million, but like, you know, this one will only get you five. You'd be like, dude, you invested however much you invested. Sadly, it's gone. We're startin…”
Schroter: Startups.com only does asset purchases, never acquiring operating entities
“We always do asset purchases. We never buy the actual operating company. There's never any upside in it.”
Gazdecki: Stock Sales Offer Founders QSBS Tax Relief Over Asset Sales
“Really the main benefit to doing a stock sale versus An asset sale for the founder is tax purposes. You'll generally benefit from QSPS.”
Schroter: Struggling founders often ruin their lives before realizing they can quit
“And frankly, having met with thousands upon thousands of founders, I have hardly ever met a founder at the end of this that's just like, ah, I just, my feelings were hurt, so I had to leave. By the time I'm talking to folks, or even, you know, before then, the…”
Gazdecki: Failing Startup Founders Must Prioritize Their Employees Over Their Investors
“I always say you know, also think about your employees before your investors. This might be a little bit more controversial, but these are people that chose to work with you And spend more time with you than their families believed in your mission. And I think…”
Schroter: Winding down a company costs tens of thousands at minimum
“It costs tens of thousands of dollars at the very least in legal fees and in, in consulting financial fees in order to officially wind down a company.”
Schroter: Bloated Assets Can Be Highly Profitable for Leaner M&A Buyers
“They think that their cost structure, their OPEX, everything else is baked into what it's always been. They forget that that asset in the hands of people that don't have that expense base could be a money machine.”
Gazdecki: Gauge strategic acquisition interest by emailing corp dev leaders directly
“Before making any changes, just shoot out a few emails, head of a corp dev, head of product CEO, depending on company size, and see if they'll at least take a meeting, and you'll get to, you'll figure out if there's strategic interest pretty quickly.”
Schroter: Acquiring One Million Startup Customers Failed to Deliver Cross-Selling Value
“I've acquired over a million startup in all the acquisitions that we did. Right. So a million customers on paper that should have yielded me Orders of magnitude of value, cross-selling products, et cetera, never happened, right? I mean, parts of it happened a …”
Schroter: Low-MRR startups can sell to individual operators when PE passes
“When you go to PE, it has to be a lot because it has to be worth their while. When you go to strategics, it has to be a lot. But if you've got 50 K and MRR, there are a lot of people that could just take over that business.”
Schroter: Most startup acquisitions are not bought with upfront cash
“Most of these companies don't get bought with just a big check cash on the barrel head.”
Schroter: Startup acquisitions require equity upside to close discounted cash deals
“If you don't keep that variable component, what I call kind of the lottery ticket in the deal, it is very hard to negotiate a cash purchase.”