why aren't all 13 resolved? a statement only gets an assessment when the public
record can support or contradict it. opinions and what-ifs never can, and 1 checkable
ones are still open, waiting for their date. predictions held up or didn't;
assertions are supported or contradicted. on every card:
▮▮▮▮▮ certainty ·
▮▮▮▮▮ debate potential. speakers are clickable
Opinion
Lessin: ByteDance investors ignore national security risks for massive financial incentives
“Oh, they're pretty smart guys. They know exactly what's up. They, they're trading between what is obviously true to any American versus their enormous financial incentive, and empathy is a great word for that.”
Prediction Open · timeframe Mar 2028
Lessin: Any TikTok US deal will merely create a services company
“My prediction is that whatever ends up transacting here is going to look like a services company. It's going to have the data. Maybe it'll have a little bit of revenue ops or eng, but I think this is the needle that now everyone's trying to thread.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Jessica Lessin notes ByteDance and TikTok investors are staying silent on lobbying
“One of the things that's interesting now is actually a lot of the investors in ByteDance and TikTok are actually staying pretty silent on the lobbying front, which is a huge shift from a year or two years ago.”
Opinion
Jessica Lessin says Beijing views ByteDance as a distraction from strategic priorities
“I think largely the Chinese government, what is missed is, like, ByteDance isn't some shining national champion they're trying to win, they hope, win at all costs. They actually see it as sucking time and talent away from more urgent national priorities, and t…”
Assertion Partly supported
Jessica Lessin says China will block a TikTok sale under algorithm export rules
“They won't let them. It will be in violation of their rules against exporting algorithms.”
Assertion Supported
Jessica Lessin: China holds a board seat in a secretive ByteDance subsidiary
“I thought of this because the reason the world knows that actually the Chinese government owns ByteDance is because Of some of the great reporting of my colleagues in Asia that actually broke the news of not just this idea that Chinese companies are controlled…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Morin: ByteDance, Baidu, and Alibaba Have Forks of OpenClaw
“And I mean, in China, you've got Huge deployments on ByteDance and let's see ByteDance, Baidu, Alibaba, they all have forks. They've all, they're all deploying at large scale.”
Prediction Held up
Jessica Lessin: TikTok Will Sue the U.S. Over First Amendment
“So what's gonna happen after Biden signs this is ByteDance or TikTok is gonna sue to block it on the grounds that it's infringing on the First Amendment.”
Opinion
Dave Morin: ByteDance investors don't understand influence because they never built platforms
“That's also because these guys are capital allocators. And not builders of social networks. They've never built social networks, and then they don't know what is possible in terms of influence.”
Opinion
Sam Lessin: TikTok operating in the US is an insane national security threat
“Day 623 of the U.S. Letting a huge national security threat sit inside our borders, which is insane, right? Like, it's like ridiculous that TikTok is allowed to be in the U.S. Given its current control structure. And kind of the geopolitical situation.”
Assertion Contradicted
Morin: US-China Digital Trade Has Been Completely One-Sided for 30 Years
“We cannot export Digital into China at all, right? Like our bits do not flow through their firewall. Like, you know, most of our companies cannot operate there and the inverse is not true, right? Like you bite dance, you name it. Like all of the Chinese compan…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Lessin: ByteDance Q3 2023 Revenue Rose 43% to $31 Billion
“So, in the third quarter of last year, revenue grew 43% to thirty-one billion dollars.”
Assertion Contradicted
Dave Morin: ByteDance moved the TikTok feed into CapCut
“And I noticed a few weeks ago that they've also now moved the TikTok feed into CapCut.”