why aren't all 14 resolved? a statement only gets an assessment when the public
record can support or contradict it. opinions and what-ifs never can, and 0 checkable
ones are still open, waiting for their date. predictions held up or didn't;
assertions are supported or contradicted. on every card:
▮▮▮▮▮ certainty ·
▮▮▮▮▮ debate potential. speakers are clickable
Insight
Patel: Nvidia must vastly outperform rivals to overcome vertical integration
“Google, Amazon, they get to vertically integrate, integrate, and vertical integration always saves tons of money. So he has to be better than everyone. By, not just like a little bit, by a ton. To justify his margins. Otherwise, the vertical integration of his…”
Prediction Held up
Patel: Google and Amazon will borrow debt to fund AI infrastructure
“Google and Amazon haven't taken on debt yet for AI infrastructure, but they will, right?”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Backlund: AI agent bribed humans with Amazon purchases for training data
“We give it the task to train a face recognition model on us. So it became super excited about this and has like check-ins every half an hour where it tries to like identify as many people as it can. And it started offering us like, Hey, Axel I'll buy something…”
Assertion Supported
Patel: Google and Amazon stocks dropped 10% on combined $380B CapEx
“Google announced a hundred and eighty billion of capex. The stock went down and then Amazon announced two hundred billion of capex and their stock went down. Like, I want to say like 10%.”
Opinion
Patel: AWS holds major infrastructure efficiency advantage over Azure and GCP
“Behind the scenes, they've done a lot on the infrastructure that is super custom, That Microsoft, Azure, and Google Cloud just don't even match in terms of efficiency. Like, if you think about the cost to rent out SSD space, so the cost to rent, you know, offe…”
Opinion
Swyx: Amazon Polly is embarrassing compared to modern text-to-speech alternatives
“As someone who is ex-Amazon, I'm very embarrassed by Polly, it sucks.”
Disclosure
Perszyk: Adept negotiated an insulated startup model within Amazon AGI Lab
“Yeah, so I came with the original adept folks, and when we came, we convinced leadership that in order to do frontier level research, we really needed to keep an operating model that was more like a startup. We needed to insulate our research and be able to fo…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Fredrikson: Amazon excels at deploying formal software verification, Microsoft in research
“Microsoft historically has been pretty good about it too. More on the research side, Amazon is, is stellar and actually deploying a lot of this.”
Assertion Supported
Google, Microsoft, Amazon, OpenAI, and Anthropic joined AAIF as platinum members
“You have Google, Microsoft, Amazon Block, Bloomberg, Cloudflare, OpenAI, Anthropic. Just a platinum member, create a foundation.”
Insight
Conrad: NVIDIA avoids customer concentration to prevent hyperscaler price setting
“It's really bad for NVIDIA if you have customer concentration, and Microsoft and Google and Amazon, like, Oracle to, like, buy up your entire supply and then you have four or five customers or so who pretty much get to set prices.”
Disclosure
Hsu: Retool has 11 separate business units using its platform at Amazon
“Today at Amazon, actually, we have, I think, 11 separate business units that use Retool at this point”
Opinion
Yegge: Grab succeeded by copying Amazon's playbook and executing with laser focus
“I mean, they had their success because they are laser focused. They copied Amazon. I mean, they're just they're executing really, really, really well.”
Disclosure
Falk: Zeus originally targeted Global 2000 companies for $5M-$10M contracts
“And so ended up leaving Amazon, starting this company, Zeus, And, you know, the idea, pretty simple. Number one, we would only go after the global 2000. That was very, very deliberate. Two is we are, we were building very custom software. So the idea was we wa…”
Assertion Contradicted
AWS has about 20,000 private equity-backed customers
“And what's interesting is Amazon has about AWS has about 20,000 customers that are backed by PE firms.”