why aren't all 57 resolved? a statement only gets an assessment when the public
record can support or contradict it. opinions and what-ifs never can, and 1 checkable
ones are still open, waiting for their date. predictions held up or didn't;
assertions are supported or contradicted. on every card:
▮▮▮▮▮ certainty ·
▮▮▮▮▮ debate potential. speakers are clickable
Insight
Gil: The largest startup successes had solo or unequal founders
“If you look at the biggest successes in the startup world over time, they were either solo founders or very unequal founders. So that, and there's counter examples to that, of course, but that was Amazon, right? Jeff Bezos was the only founder. Microsoft, it w…”
Opinion
Mackey: Professional managers view roles at Whole Foods as stepping stones
“In my experience, they're very, they're not usually mission driven. They've gotten their MBA from Harvard or Wharton or Stanford. They're very intelligent. They work hard, but working at Whole Foods or Amazon, it's just a, it's just part of their career path. …”
Assertion Contradicted
Pincus: Every Amazon C-staff member was once Jeff Bezos's technical assistant
“In fact, I believe every C staff member at Amazon was at one point Jeff Bezos' tech assistant, And Andy Jassy was, and the CEO.”
Opinion
Diller: Tech giants like Netflix and Apple have ended Hollywood's hegemony
“Those tech companies essentially have now taken over the old hegemony of quote, Hollywood, and now Netflix and Apple and Amazon.”
Insight
Evans: Meta and Amazon want LLMs to become commoditized infrastructure
“What Meta and Amazon want to do is to make LLM's commodity info that sold at cost. This is why Meta made it open source, because they want to make it commodity info that sold at cost, and they differentiate on top with Meta stuff, with Facebook, social, Instag…”
Insight
Gil: Startups captured 80% of Internet value, while incumbents won mobile
“So the internet was 80% startup value. It was Google, it was Amazon, you know, it was all these companies we now know and love. Meta, you know and then mobile, the mobile revolution was probably 80% incumbent value, or 90%, right? And so that was, mobile searc…”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Taylor: AI model market will consolidate into a few massive capex players
“I think we have probably have too many people building models right now. There's already been some consolidation actually of companies being folded into Amazon and Microsoft and others. But I do think it will play out a bit like the cloud infrastructure busine…”
Opinion
Big platforms unknowingly subsidize 3M's online air filter pricing
“In my opinion that a lot of these big companies actually subsidize companies like three M maybe unknowingly to compete on price on, on online on some of these products because The economics of shipping them and putting them through their distribution networks …”
Opinion
Brands refusing to sell on Amazon are incredibly naive
“I think anybody that kiss themselves and says, oh, you know, I'm too good to sell on Amazon or I want to ignore it is just incredibly naive.”
Disclosure
Repeated disagreements with Amazon ultimately led to Mackey's retirement
“I had my share of disagreements with Amazon. I fought with them many times, and ultimately that led to me to retire.”
Opinion
Only Amazon, Walmart, and Toyota Control Cost, Quality, Time, and Variance
“At this point, I said that's only Amazon, Walmart, and Toyota are probably the only three companies I can imagine that are even closer to being able to do that.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Shah: Amazon's India GMV matches a small European nation
“The total GMV that Amazon would make in India would easily be done by a small European nation after being here for like maybe seven, eight years that they have spent over here because the people who can spend just do not exist.”
Insight
Collins: Investing in proven, scaling flywheels beats trying to predict nascent ones
“But I don't think you want to find a flywheel at only 10 turns. If it's a great flywheel, So maybe we'll talk in a minute about the Amazon flywheel, because that's what stimulated me further thinking about Amazon. Would it be so bad to pick up a flywheel when …”
Insight
Shopify provides for $29 what Jeff Bezos built from scratch
“What Shopify allows People to do is like have, you know, for 29 dollars a month get something that gets them pretty close to having all the things that Jeff had to build for himself when he started Amazon, right?”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Tech giants will be disrupted by paradigm shifts, not direct competitors
“Their sort of upheaval and downfall will come not from someone being in a garage alone. It will come from someone being in a garage who latches onto the next paradigm shift that makes it impossible for, you know, the powers that be to compete.”
Opinion
Bakshi: Amazon's True Economic Earnings Vastly Exceed Its Reported Accounting Earnings
“You can't just go by reported earnings. The true economic earnings of Amazon are significantly higher than reported earnings.”
Insight
Nejatian: Internet marketplaces are won by platforms that underwrite transaction risk
“And the third thing Player almost always tends to be someone who says, great, I will help you both find something, trust the counterparty, and underwrite the risk on both transactions. Amazon. And usually, in the marketplace of, like, on the internet, the thir…”
Insight
Nejatian: Eliminating approval chains beats managing them through 'default yes' mandates
“But I think a better way to deal with this problem is to not have the chain of command
Like, to minimize the number of people who can say no, and only have people that you want and trust to do things.”
Assertion Partly supported
Gurley: AI startups burn an order of magnitude more cash than Uber
“Why Amazon was, you know, they had a big burn rate, but then Uber took it to a new level but now it's had an, they've added a zero.”
Insight
Clear: 3-star Amazon reviews offer the best actionable feedback on competitor books
“I went to the three star reviews on Amazon, one star review. Everybody hates it often for some stupid reason, like the book showed up and it was dirty on the dust jacket or whatever. Five-star review. Everybody loves it. But the three-star reviews or the four-…”
Opinion
Amazon and Danaher are the only U.S. companies advancing Toyota's production system
“I mean, the Toyota production system, I think there's like two companies that have taken it really, really seriously and advanced it in the United States. One is Amazon, and one is Donaherr.”
Opinion
Amazon aggressively pushes its warehouse bottlenecks to merchant unloading docks
“One of the things that they do that pisses off their merchants is they have this endless line of trucks at the warehouse they can't unload. They've pushed the bottleneck off into the unload piece. The loading docks and truckers and can't get appointments and s…”
Opinion
Nooyi: Amazon and Philips corporate cultures have no braggers
“Even Amazon has no braggers. Philips, the other company I said on the board of, the MedTech company from the Netherlands, not at all. Nobody brags. Everybody's talking about what can we do together to move the company forward.”
Insight
Converting Amazon shoppers to direct DTC is a fool's errand
“Early on, I would spend some time thinking about that, and honestly, I realized, at least in our case, and maybe everybody's different, it's a fool's errand. I mean, it's like there's a reason why customers choose to buy on Amazon.”
Assertion Supported
Amazon leadership originally conceived AWS as a low-margin infrastructure business
“They didn't think this was a, this is a high margin business. They thought of it as like, ok, this will be a low margin business too, and we like low margin businesses.”
Opinion
Stalk: Walmart Cannot Easily Replicate Amazon's Dense Distribution Network
“If you're Walmart trying to catch up with the distribution system of Amazon, I can't really use much of my current distribution system because it's made up for dealing with large volumes, selling large volume stores. And I have to come up with a distribution s…”
Insight
Dignan: Large corporations do not exist; they are interconnected 150-person Dunbar groups
“I mean, there's no such thing as a big company, really. I think it's the main thing I deal with when Folks ask me about doing this at scale is like, there's no such thing as Apple or Amazon, right? Like that's not actually a real thing. There are groups of. 15…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Andreessen: Bezos said building another startup would be like kindergarten
“We talked to Jeff Bezos about this at one point, and he asked us why we were starting a venture capital firm and not another company. And another startup and we asked him, well, if Amazon, you know, for some reason, Amazon got sold or whatever and you were a f…”
Opinion
Greenblatt: Tech mega-caps driving the market are not irrationally valued
“Most of the big indexes are driven by the Amazon, Google, Microsoft, Apple, and those businesses don't seem very irrational to me. Those are some of the greatest businesses that man has ever created partially due to the internet interconnectedness of the world…”
Assertion Supported
Howey: Amazon halves self-publishing royalties outside the $2.99 to $9.99 range
“They think eBooks should be between two 99 and nine 99. And if you price it there, they'll give you a 70%. If you price it below two 99, Hey, you're welcome to do that. But they're going to pay you 35%, which is half. If you price it over nine 99, again, your …”
Insight
Diller: Amazon's video content is merely a storefront hook for Prime subscriptions
“If your Amazon and your main business Is subscriptions in prime and you offer content as kind of the thing in the front of the store to get people to come in. You're so far away. It's a different business model.”
Opinion
Nooyi: Amazon's customer obsession surpasses PepsiCo's consumer focus
“So, I've never been part of such a customer-obsessed company, ok? PepsiCo was consumer-focused, but these are customer-obsessed companies, first.”
Assertion Not publicly verifiable
Filterbuy captures 25% to 33% of Amazon furnace filter sales
“Between one and four and one and three filters purchased in the furnace filter category on Amazon is one of ours.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Startups building incremental AI refinements will become roadkill for Big Tech
“Other things that, you know, I'd say we try to avoid is things that are roadkill along the way of a company like OpenAI or Google or Amazon or Meta. So, small refinements into what the model doesn't do well today. That's just gonna be real cool along the way.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Lin: Only Amazon and Zappos Solved Unbatched E-Commerce Operations
“The solution to pick back and ship in four hours was to solve a operations flow issue and not batch the operations, which I don't think anybody else figured out in e-commerce back then besides Amazon.”
Assertion Contradicted
Hoehn: At least 80% of book purchases happen on Amazon
“I believe it's at minimum of 80% of books, book purchases are through Amazon online.”
Assertion Partly supported
Mackey: Whole Foods signed Amazon merger agreement six weeks after first meeting
“They came down just three days later, and six weeks after that first meeting, we had signed an agreement to get married, to merge”
Insight
Housel: Forcing oneself to finish every book makes reading miserable
“A lot of the reason that people don't like reading, why people don't read as much as they should, or if they say, ah, I'm not a big reader. A lot of the reason is because they feel like morally that they need to finish every book that they start. And we realiz…”
Assertion Supported
Valiante: Jeff Bezos created $800B in wealth for other people
“Jeff Bezos has created eight hundred billion dollars of wealth for other people.”
Assertion Not publicly verifiable
Gupta: Whole Foods represented 43% of Instacart's volume when Amazon acquired it
“When Amazon bought whole foods, that was a terrible moment for us at the time. We our blood competitor, who's known for annihilating everyone in their way buys our biggest partner who owns, who has responsible for 43% of our volume.”
Insight
Hoffman: Companies should adapt between memos, slides, and bullet points
“And I actually think the answer is these are all tools and you should use all of them, right? Sometimes you should write like a six pager on something. Sometimes you should write a PowerPoint. Sometimes you should just have a list of bullets, right? And it dep…”
Insight
Immelt: Amazon is complex but not complicated; Walmart is simple not simplistic
“There's a difference between being complex and being complicated. And there's a difference between being simple and simplistic. You know, I would say Amazon is complex, but it's not complicated. It's a software company, right? They have certain things they sta…”
Insight
Page: No single person can understand complex companies like Amazon
“There's so many dimensions to a company like Amazon or Disney, right, that there's no way any one person can understand it, and so what you want is you want cognitive diversity, and what that cognitive diversity means is people who have different, you know, li…”
Insight
E-commerce search makes active brand recollection far more important than passive recognition
“Whereas on the, if you go to Amazon for deodorant, You search for Dioran. You search for Old Spice, or you search for Reichardt, which means the recollection of a specific brand name is much more important than the sort of recognition of a brand, if that makes…”
Opinion
Mauboussin: Tech giants leverage capital into insurmountable data capture flywheels
“The amount of data that they can capture, and because all those companies have substantial resources, they can put a lot of resources against not only capturing, but analyzing data. It's an interesting flywheel, right?”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Cool: Pampered Chef scaled digital sales from 10% to 75%
“We took the business from 10% sort of digital to 75%. Now we still did that through the channel, so through the sales consultants. We didn't go on Amazon or you sell direct, but we actually really focused on how do we utilize our competitive advantage, which w…”
Disclosure
Flexport requires 26 teams to submit monthly six-page strategy reviews
“There's about 26 teams that do an MBR, a monthly business review, and a six pager, and then that's just like, it doesn't, I think we cap it at six, but it's, the six isn't that important... So we have, I think, 25 or 26 teams that write those monthly, and then…”
Disclosure
Filterbuy fulfills 100% of its Amazon orders directly
“We fulfill a hundred percent of our orders on Amazon.”