Simon Cowell bases A&R decisions entirely on personal taste, not technical knowledge.
Simon Cowell · Simon Cowell: Music Mogul · Aug 4, 2025 · at 19:39
Music executive Simon Cowell explains his approach to A&R and talent evaluation despite having no formal musical training.
0:00 / 0:23exact quote · 23.4s
720p mp4 · rendered on demand · StarZero watermark
“What I never did, though, I never tried to pretend that I could produce a record or be a musician, because I couldn't, I can't produce records. I can't play instruments. I don't know what note anyone's any, Singing it, whether it's C, B, D, or G, I have no idea. So I only, I base everything I ever do based on, do I like it?”
quote is from the automated transcript, cleaned for reading: filler sounds and stutters are removed, nothing is rephrased. names can be misheard (the analysis reads context, assessments check outside sources). how →
More from Simon Cowell
Simon Cowell claims many music industry A&R executives are genuinely tone-deaf.
“You know, I don't think anyone even today is really trained to be an A&R person. I don't even know how people today, you know, get that job, because a lot of the A&R people I knew were genuinely tone deaf. Seriously.”
Simon Cowell prioritizes commercial entertainment over critical prestige in music.
“It's the music business. I'm just trying to make money. You know, it doesn't really matter. Does it? If someone's enjoying it, let them enjoy it. Who cares?”
Simon Cowell: 1980s UK gay clubs predicted pop trends six months early.
“There was this kind of crossover period between what was happening in a lot of the gay clubs in the UK. They were kind of ahead of the curve. It was like, you want to know what's going to happen in six months time? You went to this club.”
Simon Cowell reveals a 1990s hit saw 930,000 first-morning retail reorders.
“And I saw this number, and I went, no, what is the real repeat order this morning? That number was 930,000.”
Simon Cowell offered to blindly double the Spice Girls' record deal.
“I get in my car, floor it back to my office, call the manager and said, look, I'll literally double whatever deal you've been offered if you haven't already signed. And he said, too late to sign.”
Simon Cowell took zero salary for American Idol to secure backend rights.
“And by the way, I didn't ask for any money for myself on both the British show and the American show on the first year. I said, I don't want a contract. I don't want to be paid. If it works, then we're going to have another conversation if it works.”