Feb 4, 2021 · 48m · how-i-built-this
How I Built Resilience: M. Night Shyamalan
0:00 / 0:00
gold bands on the timeline = statements, start to end. Hover to read, click to jump. CC turns on captions
In this Sundance Film Festival edition of NPR's How I Built This, filmmaker M. Night Shyamalan joins host Guy Raz to discuss his career journey, creative resilience, immigrant work ethic, and enduring commitment to communal theatrical cinema.
How this conversation actually went
Every chapter scored 0–10 on four independent dynamics. Hover any point for the reasoning behind the score. Guy holds 24.3% of the talking time here. How this is scored →
Guy as informed peer 1.6 Guest teaching 2.3 Guest disagreement 0.8 Guy pushing back 0.2
speaking balance: gold is Guy, purple is the guest (3 minute bins)
Sharpest disagreement ▶ 44:56 Rejecting cinema's decline into a rare spectacle
Shyamalan flatly rejects Raz's suggestion that moviegoing will become an exclusive, rare occurrence, countering that collective human behavior ensures strong cinema commitment.
Hardest push from Guy ▶ 44:31 Probing whether cinema will become rare and spectacle-onlyRaz challenges Shyamalan's optimistic perspective on theatrical viewing by suggesting that streaming has permanently relegated theaters to rare novelty spectacles.
Biggest teaching moment ▶ 8:49 Reframing self-doubt as an enduring creative plightShyamalan corrects Raz's assumption that master artists overcome self-doubt, stating unequivocally that doubt is permanent and present even in that very moment.
Guy holds their own ▶ 3:47 Raz highlights his own decades of trial-and-error masteryRaz bolsters the discussion by citing his own 25-year broadcasting journey, demonstrating personal domain expertise in iterative skill acquisition through early poor performance.
the scores for every segment, with the reasoning behind each
| Chapter | Topic | Guy as informed peer | Guest teaching | Guest disagreement | Guy pushing back | Why |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Childhood Filmmaking and Learning Through Safe Failure | 3 | 2 | 1 | 0 | Raz opens the interview asking about Shyamalan's childhood Super 8 filmmaking. Shyamalan explains how mimicking movies lacked creativity until he learned to embrace safe failure, prompting Raz to share his own early career struggles with interviewing. | |
| Defying Family Expectations to Attend NYU Film | 2 | 1 | 0 | 0 | Raz draws parallels between Shyamalan's immigrant family pressures and the founders featured on How I Built This. Shyamalan humorously describes announcing his film school ambition to his parents as akin to becoming a goth rock star before detailing how he financed Praying with Anger. | |
| Confronting Creative Anxiety and Chronic Self-Doubt | 1 | 5 | 3 | 0 | When Raz asks how Shyamalan overcame self-doubt early in his career, Shyamalan immediately reframes the premise, explaining that self-doubt is never overcome and remains a daily battle even after billions in box office earnings. | |
| The Immigrant Mindset and Permanent Creative Urgency | 2 | 1 | 0 | 0 | Shyamalan describes his persistent anxiety that every film could be his last and links his drive to an ingrained immigrant mentality. Raz warmly affirms the shared cultural experience as a fellow child of immigrants. | |
| Playful Mischief and Cultural Roots of Supernatural Stories | 1 | 2 | 0 | 0 | Raz asks how Shyamalan's joyful personality connects with his dark storytelling themes. Shyamalan attributes this to personal mischievousness, cultural superstition, and protecting a disciplined daily two-hour window for uninterrupted ideation. | |
| Protecting the Artistic Process in Production Management | 1 | 3 | 0 | 0 | Raz inquires about managing the friction between Hollywood business demands and creative integrity. Shyamalan articulates strict production rules, emphasizing 'no dysfunctional geniuses' and guarding the iterative process over monetary gain. | |
| The Jigsaw Puzzle Analogy and Two Columns Philosophy | 2 | 2 | 0 | 0 | Raz cites Shyamalan's Drexel commencement address regarding personal setbacks. Shyamalan explains his two-column mental model of controllable versus uncontrollable factors, using a jigsaw puzzle with his daughter as the turning point for editing The Visit. | |
| Mid-Episode Break and How I Built This Book Promo | 1 | 2 | 0 | 0 | Following the mid-episode book promo, Raz asks about producing during the pandemic. Shyamalan explains how he established strict quarantine bubbles and rapid Zoom casting in the Dominican Republic and Pennsylvania to maintain safe filming schedules. | |
| Theatrical Timing and Navigating Pandemic Release Dates | 2 | 2 | 1 | 0 | Raz shares an audience question regarding advice for creators of color in Hollywood. Shyamalan responds by urging storytellers not to dilute their unique cultural perspectives or demand a seat at the table, but rather to expand the table itself. | |
| Audience Q&A: Plot Twists and Electric Movie Reactions | 1 | 3 | 2 | 0 | Raz relays questions asking if Shyamalan resents his 'plot twist guy' reputation. Shyamalan admits mild frustration with the superficial label, explaining that shifts in perspective serve deeper character realizations, and shares audience reactions from screenings of The Visit and Split. | |
| Audience Q&A: Troubleshooting Narrative and Editing Problems | 1 | 2 | 0 | 0 | Raz presents a question on overcoming scriptwriting blocks. Shyamalan describes externalizing what feels redundant or false in draft revisions and notes the cultural shift where internal drama migrates to television while communal spectacle stays in theaters. | |
| Defending Cinema Commitment and Critiquing Day-and-Date Streaming | 3 | 4 | 4 | 3 | Raz asks about Warner Bros.' unilateral streaming release strategy and pushes Shyamalan on whether cinema is permanently becoming a rare, spectacle-only medium. Shyamalan emphatically rejects this framing, asserting that theatrical moviegoing remains the ultimate undivided commitment to art. | |
| Retrospective Advice: Focus Only on What You Control | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | Raz closes by asking what advice Shyamalan would give his younger self making his debut feature. Shyamalan reiterates focusing exclusively on craft and the internal creative column rather than external outcomes, before Raz wraps the episode. |
Statements from this episode (21)
Shyamalan: Maximize iteration in environments where failure is safe
“One of my rules of life, which is iterate as much as you can, create environments where you can safely iterate. Some people call it failure. I don't, you know, it's so stigmatized that word that just call it iterating.”
Shyamalan took out a mortgage on his house to self-fund The Visit
“When I did the visit, which was many, many, many years later, I put a mortgage on the house and did the whole thing all over again.”
Shyamalan: Artists Must Wrestle with Internal Demons Every Single Day
“My, both my older daughters are artists, and I said, that is your plight. You're going to wrestle with your demons every single day of your life.”
Shyamalan: Box Office, Critics, and External Validation Are Irrelevant
“So all this other stuff, to be honest, I've learned is irrelevant. How many people did come on the weekend, and what did the New York Times think, and what did that fan think, and oh, that other guy made that much, or did that, or oh, the cover, they offered y…”
Shyamalan approaches every film as if studios will never hire him again
“Every single time I go, this is the last movie that they'll ever let me make. This is the one, and is that ok? So, make it so that it's ok. That if this was the last one, you put it all there, wow, I, I'm ready to burn the house down for this value system that…”
Shyamalan wrote Unbreakable during Sixth Sense editing because he feared getting fired
“I remember when I was a kid writing Unbreakable while I was editing Sixth Sense, because I'm like, they're never going to let me direct after this movie comes out, so let me try to, as fast as I can, make this movie about comic books, which no one wants to see…”
Shyamalan: Thriller Storytelling and Twists Stem from Personal Playfulness and Mischief
“If we hung out, we were having beers or whatever, you, I'm a little bit mischievous. So that, that mischievous side of like making you laugh and you know, playing tricks on you, that would be how our relationship would be. And that just kind of transfers into …”
Shyamalan: Indian Cultural Spirituality and Superstition Shaped His Supernatural Storytelling
“I do think the inherent spirituality of the Indian culture Kind of morphed from my grandma saying, you know, this house is haunted, or she puts like a, nails a chicken head outside the house because of some bad thing that was, she thinks a curse has been put o…”
Shyamalan: Early success introduces distractions that lead to poor decision-making
“When you have nothing, you become really clear about what's important and what are your values. You're very clear about them, and then you get up and you start to have success, and there's this accretion of good decision making that gets you here, and then you…”
Shyamalan: Daily writing time without output still drives creative compounding
“Spend those two hours. And even if I sat there for two hours wondering what happens to him after he hits his head, five different iterations of things came and went that were incorrect. Right. It feels like I didn't do anything, but I did. And then the next da…”
Shyamalan maintains a strict policy of never working with dysfunctional geniuses
“There's certain principles that now are absolutely essential, like no dysfunctional geniuses.”
Shyamalan: A filmmaker's blind spots and quirks are their greatest commercial strengths
“Don't copy me or anybody else, or even try to round off the things that are not great about you. Your blind spots are your strengths. That is why you're not doing this, and you're looking at that, that's part of what makes you so beautiful. To concentrate on t…”
Shyamalan: Old was the first movie in the world to cast during COVID-19
“So I was the first, basically the first movie in the world that started casting during the pandemic, so everyone in the world was auditioning for me by Zoom, and at that moment, it was still very odd that you would be in your bedroom or your living room.”
Shyamalan manually draws the storyboards for every single shot of his movies
“I storyboard out everything. I draw every single shot of the movie.”
Shyamalan: Specific personal narrative gives storytellers irreplicable creative power
“The more specific it is,
The more power it is.
Where I go, I could never do that, or Quentin Tarantino could never do that, or Wes Anderson or David Fincher can't do that.
That's what you want.”
Shyamalan: Effective Storytelling Aligns Audience With a Character's Realization
“It's a points of view and how to talk about points of view in the structure of storytelling and not understanding why, why is she acting that way? Why is she acting that way? Oh my gosh, she's acting that way because of that. You know, that kind of thing. I lo…”
Shyamalan: Theatrical Cinema Generates Cross-Demographic Emotional Attunement
“The collective experience is such a wonderful thing. Making movies for me is, and throwing, showing them in a movie theater is a little bit of a sacred thing for me because I think it's, When we're at our best, because the teenage girl is affecting the sixty-y…”
Shyamalan: Creative blocks are a sign you are unconsciously betraying your story
“What happens is when you get stuck, like you're doing, you're essentially, you're betraying the story, but you don't know how you're betraying it. So you can feel the damage. You just don't understand it. This isn't working. So any ways that you can say it out…”
Shyamalan: Dramas are shifting to streaming while movie theaters rely on spectacle
“And you'll see this movement of drama leaving the movie theater and coming to home. Like, you're okay feeling emotional, dramatic things in, at home, but going to a movie theater with a group of people, you want to be scared, and laugh, and thrilled, and spect…”
Shyamalan criticizes Warner Bros for unilaterally moving 2021 film releases to streaming
“It should have been filmmaker by filmmaker's decision of how to handle this here. If they wanted to put it out that way, great, everybody comes to decision, or if they wanted to wait, and if the studio could handle that financial burden of waiting for a beat, …”
Shyamalan: Undivided theatrical attention makes cinema far stickier than at-home viewing
“When you go to the movie theater and you commit to leave your house, park your car, get your babysitter, and come and turn off your phone, you cannot multitask. You are making the biggest commitment that you will ever make to an art form for two hours. And the…”