StarZero All shows Try the podcast clipper →

Feb 8, 2024 · 27m · how-i-built-this

Building a decarbonization army with Shashank Samala of Heirloom

Shashank Samala · 16m spoken Guy Raz · 8m spoken
0:00 / 0:00

gold bands on the timeline = statements, start to end. Hover to read, click to jump. CC turns on captions

In this episode of How I Built This Lab, Guy Raz interviews Heirloom co-founder and CEO Shashank Samala about using abundant natural limestone to develop scalable, low-cost direct air capture technology. Samala outlines Heirloom's closed-loop capture process, its commercial business model, and the strategic roadmap to removing one billion tons of atmospheric carbon dioxide annually.

How this conversation actually went

Every chapter scored 0–10 on four independent dynamics. Hover any point for the reasoning behind the score. Guy holds 35.4% of the talking time here. How this is scored →

Guy as informed peer 5.0 Guest teaching 5.5 Guest disagreement 1.2 Guy pushing back 1.5
05100:0010:0020:001:58–6:24 · Guy as informed peer 5/10 Exploring Carbon Removal Pathways at Carbon180 Guy Raz sets a knowledgeable baseline on decarbonization math and why emissions reduction alone is insufficient. Shashank Samala elaborates on his background, building cost models, and transitioning from robotics to process engineering.6:25–8:31 · Guy as informed peer 5/10 Rethinking Direct Air Capture Through Nature Raz cites existing direct air capture approaches like Climeworks. Samala explains the fundamental gas separation physics (1 molecule in 2,500) and why synthetic sorbent supply chains fail to scale economically.8:42–14:07 · Guy as informed peer 5/10 The Billion-Ton Mindset for Carbon Removal Raz challenges whether container-based DAC is just a drop in the ocean, prompting Samala to quiz Raz on what humanity actually manufactures at gigaton scale (cement, steel, fossil fuels). Samala then details how Heirloom supercharges limestone via kilns and vertical tray racks.14:08–18:16 · Guy as informed peer 6/10 Business Model, Corporate Buyers, and Market Potential Raz drills into compliance vs voluntary carbon markets and cites current price tags of $600 to $1,000 per ton. Samala explains the $100-to-$200 per ton target needed to unlock a trillion-dollar carbon removal sector.18:18–22:13 · Guy as informed peer 5/10 Second Mid-Episode Break and Upcoming Expansion Raz inquires about the operational reality of Heirloom's Tracy facility and whether voluntary contracts provide sufficient revenue stability. Samala outlines the concrete sequestration pathway and the massive role of the 45Q tax credit ($180/ton).22:13–26:27 · Guy as informed peer 4/10 Scaling Up: DOE Hub, Land Efficiency, and Global Vision Raz asks about physical land footprints and the number of plants required to make an impact. Samala educates on Heirloom's 5,000x land efficiency relative to afforestation, the DOE Louisiana Hub award, and global deployment in Kenya's Rift Valley.1:58–6:24 · Guest teaching 4/10 Exploring Carbon Removal Pathways at Carbon180 Guy Raz sets a knowledgeable baseline on decarbonization math and why emissions reduction alone is insufficient. Shashank Samala elaborates on his background, building cost models, and transitioning from robotics to process engineering.6:25–8:31 · Guest teaching 6/10 Rethinking Direct Air Capture Through Nature Raz cites existing direct air capture approaches like Climeworks. Samala explains the fundamental gas separation physics (1 molecule in 2,500) and why synthetic sorbent supply chains fail to scale economically.8:42–14:07 · Guest teaching 7/10 The Billion-Ton Mindset for Carbon Removal Raz challenges whether container-based DAC is just a drop in the ocean, prompting Samala to quiz Raz on what humanity actually manufactures at gigaton scale (cement, steel, fossil fuels). Samala then details how Heirloom supercharges limestone via kilns and vertical tray racks.14:08–18:16 · Guest teaching 5/10 Business Model, Corporate Buyers, and Market Potential Raz drills into compliance vs voluntary carbon markets and cites current price tags of $600 to $1,000 per ton. Samala explains the $100-to-$200 per ton target needed to unlock a trillion-dollar carbon removal sector.18:18–22:13 · Guest teaching 5/10 Second Mid-Episode Break and Upcoming Expansion Raz inquires about the operational reality of Heirloom's Tracy facility and whether voluntary contracts provide sufficient revenue stability. Samala outlines the concrete sequestration pathway and the massive role of the 45Q tax credit ($180/ton).22:13–26:27 · Guest teaching 6/10 Scaling Up: DOE Hub, Land Efficiency, and Global Vision Raz asks about physical land footprints and the number of plants required to make an impact. Samala educates on Heirloom's 5,000x land efficiency relative to afforestation, the DOE Louisiana Hub award, and global deployment in Kenya's Rift Valley.1:58–6:24 · Guest disagreement 1/10 Exploring Carbon Removal Pathways at Carbon180 Guy Raz sets a knowledgeable baseline on decarbonization math and why emissions reduction alone is insufficient. Shashank Samala elaborates on his background, building cost models, and transitioning from robotics to process engineering.6:25–8:31 · Guest disagreement 1/10 Rethinking Direct Air Capture Through Nature Raz cites existing direct air capture approaches like Climeworks. Samala explains the fundamental gas separation physics (1 molecule in 2,500) and why synthetic sorbent supply chains fail to scale economically.8:42–14:07 · Guest disagreement 2/10 The Billion-Ton Mindset for Carbon Removal Raz challenges whether container-based DAC is just a drop in the ocean, prompting Samala to quiz Raz on what humanity actually manufactures at gigaton scale (cement, steel, fossil fuels). Samala then details how Heirloom supercharges limestone via kilns and vertical tray racks.14:08–18:16 · Guest disagreement 1/10 Business Model, Corporate Buyers, and Market Potential Raz drills into compliance vs voluntary carbon markets and cites current price tags of $600 to $1,000 per ton. Samala explains the $100-to-$200 per ton target needed to unlock a trillion-dollar carbon removal sector.18:18–22:13 · Guest disagreement 1/10 Second Mid-Episode Break and Upcoming Expansion Raz inquires about the operational reality of Heirloom's Tracy facility and whether voluntary contracts provide sufficient revenue stability. Samala outlines the concrete sequestration pathway and the massive role of the 45Q tax credit ($180/ton).22:13–26:27 · Guest disagreement 1/10 Scaling Up: DOE Hub, Land Efficiency, and Global Vision Raz asks about physical land footprints and the number of plants required to make an impact. Samala educates on Heirloom's 5,000x land efficiency relative to afforestation, the DOE Louisiana Hub award, and global deployment in Kenya's Rift Valley.1:58–6:24 · Guy pushing back 1/10 Exploring Carbon Removal Pathways at Carbon180 Guy Raz sets a knowledgeable baseline on decarbonization math and why emissions reduction alone is insufficient. Shashank Samala elaborates on his background, building cost models, and transitioning from robotics to process engineering.6:25–8:31 · Guy pushing back 2/10 Rethinking Direct Air Capture Through Nature Raz cites existing direct air capture approaches like Climeworks. Samala explains the fundamental gas separation physics (1 molecule in 2,500) and why synthetic sorbent supply chains fail to scale economically.8:42–14:07 · Guy pushing back 2/10 The Billion-Ton Mindset for Carbon Removal Raz challenges whether container-based DAC is just a drop in the ocean, prompting Samala to quiz Raz on what humanity actually manufactures at gigaton scale (cement, steel, fossil fuels). Samala then details how Heirloom supercharges limestone via kilns and vertical tray racks.14:08–18:16 · Guy pushing back 2/10 Business Model, Corporate Buyers, and Market Potential Raz drills into compliance vs voluntary carbon markets and cites current price tags of $600 to $1,000 per ton. Samala explains the $100-to-$200 per ton target needed to unlock a trillion-dollar carbon removal sector.18:18–22:13 · Guy pushing back 1/10 Second Mid-Episode Break and Upcoming Expansion Raz inquires about the operational reality of Heirloom's Tracy facility and whether voluntary contracts provide sufficient revenue stability. Samala outlines the concrete sequestration pathway and the massive role of the 45Q tax credit ($180/ton).22:13–26:27 · Guy pushing back 1/10 Scaling Up: DOE Hub, Land Efficiency, and Global Vision Raz asks about physical land footprints and the number of plants required to make an impact. Samala educates on Heirloom's 5,000x land efficiency relative to afforestation, the DOE Louisiana Hub award, and global deployment in Kenya's Rift Valley.

speaking balance: gold is Guy, purple is the guest (3 minute bins)

0:00 · Guy 59.8% · guest 40.2%0:00 · Guy 59.8% · guest 40.2%3:00 · Guy 40.3% · guest 59.7%3:00 · Guy 40.3% · guest 59.7%6:00 · Guy 45.9% · guest 54.1%6:00 · Guy 45.9% · guest 54.1%9:00 · Guy 33.4% · guest 66.6%9:00 · Guy 33.4% · guest 66.6%12:00 · Guy 37.1% · guest 62.9%12:00 · Guy 37.1% · guest 62.9%15:00 · Guy 18.2% · guest 81.8%15:00 · Guy 18.2% · guest 81.8%18:00 · Guy 41% · guest 59%18:00 · Guy 41% · guest 59%21:00 · Guy 15.3% · guest 84.7%21:00 · Guy 15.3% · guest 84.7%24:00 · Guy 25.4% · guest 74.6%24:00 · Guy 25.4% · guest 74.6%27:00 · Guy 100% · guest 0%27:00 · Guy 100% · guest 0%
Sharpest disagreement ▶ 9:36 Flipping the interview dynamic with a billion-ton scale quiz

Samala rejects the passive framing of carbon removal and directly challenges Raz to name which physical commodities society actually produces at a billion-ton scale.

 Hardest push from Guy ▶ 8:41 Challenging DAC as an inefficient drop in the ocean

Raz questions the viability of direct air capture by arguing that covering the Sahara Desert in massive fans would still only amount to a negligible drop in the ocean.

 Biggest teaching moment ▶ 12:00 Clarifying limestone calcination and lime reactivity

Samala corrects Raz's basic sponge analogy by explaining the specific chemical thermodynamics of driving water/CO2 out via kilns to produce calcium oxide.

 Guy holds their own ▶ 17:30 Citing precise $600 to $1,000/ton cost benchmarks

Raz demonstrates strong industry domain mastery by stepping in to cite current market pricing per ton and highlighting the steep cost reduction curve needed to reach viability.
the scores for every segment, with the reasoning behind each
ChapterTopicGuy as informed peerGuest teachingGuest disagreementGuy pushing backWhy
Exploring Carbon Removal Pathways at Carbon180 5411 Guy Raz sets a knowledgeable baseline on decarbonization math and why emissions reduction alone is insufficient. Shashank Samala elaborates on his background, building cost models, and transitioning from robotics to process engineering.
Rethinking Direct Air Capture Through Nature 5612 Raz cites existing direct air capture approaches like Climeworks. Samala explains the fundamental gas separation physics (1 molecule in 2,500) and why synthetic sorbent supply chains fail to scale economically.
The Billion-Ton Mindset for Carbon Removal 5722 Raz challenges whether container-based DAC is just a drop in the ocean, prompting Samala to quiz Raz on what humanity actually manufactures at gigaton scale (cement, steel, fossil fuels). Samala then details how Heirloom supercharges limestone via kilns and vertical tray racks.
Business Model, Corporate Buyers, and Market Potential 6512 Raz drills into compliance vs voluntary carbon markets and cites current price tags of $600 to $1,000 per ton. Samala explains the $100-to-$200 per ton target needed to unlock a trillion-dollar carbon removal sector.
Second Mid-Episode Break and Upcoming Expansion 5511 Raz inquires about the operational reality of Heirloom's Tracy facility and whether voluntary contracts provide sufficient revenue stability. Samala outlines the concrete sequestration pathway and the massive role of the 45Q tax credit ($180/ton).
Scaling Up: DOE Hub, Land Efficiency, and Global Vision 4611 Raz asks about physical land footprints and the number of plants required to make an impact. Samala educates on Heirloom's 5,000x land efficiency relative to afforestation, the DOE Louisiana Hub award, and global deployment in Kenya's Rift Valley.

Statements from this episode (12)

Insight
Emissions reductions alone cannot prevent climate change without removing billions of tons
“We can't just reduce emissions anymore. It won't be enough to stop climate change if you've emitted too much. And, you know, you can reduce emissions you've already emitted, so we have to start removing some of that carbon from the atmosphere. By some I mean i…”
Shashank Samala Feb 8, 2024 ▶ 3:53
Assertion Supported
Direct air capture must extract one CO2 molecule per 2,500 air molecules
“You're pulling one molecule of CO two out of every 2500 molecules. So fundamentally it's a You know, an expensive gas separation problem.”
Shashank Samala Feb 8, 2024 ▶ 7:28
Opinion
Synthetic direct air capture materials are too expensive to scale globally
“So the traditional way folks have gone about it was basically to build a novel material artificially. But the problem was not whether you could capture the CO two. The problem was the cost of making that material. And because the supply chains don't exist, you…”
Shashank Samala Feb 8, 2024 ▶ 7:37
Assertion Contradicted
Humanity produces only three commodities at the billion-ton scale
“So it's three things. It's cement, steel, and fossil fuels.”
Shashank Samala Feb 8, 2024 ▶ 10:04
Assertion Supported
Limestone costs $30-$40 per ton and constitutes 4% of Earth's crust
“So we found that limestone specifically is, you know, you can get this stuff for like 30, 40 bucks a ton. There's trillions of tons of limestone across the world. There's four percent of the earth's crust.”
Shashank Samala Feb 8, 2024 ▶ 11:35
Assertion Supported
Heirloom's lime trays capture atmospheric CO2 and become limestone within days
“We stack these baking trays vertically To, you know, 2030, 40, 50 feet, and you effectively have a very tall baking rack with trays with thin layers of lime, and as the air passes through, basically gobbles up that CO₂, and in a few days it turns into calcium …”
Shashank Samala Feb 8, 2024 ▶ 13:41
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Carbon removal will become a trillion-dollar industry at $100-$200 per ton
“So, you know, we think that In a medium to long term, the carbon price is likely going to be in the hundred to 200 dollar per ton mark, and at that cost, for five to ten billion tons, we were talking about a trillion dollars worth of carbon removal industry.”
Shashank Samala Feb 8, 2024 ▶ 17:14
Assertion Supported
Heirloom operates North America's first direct air capture and storage plant
“Yeah, so this is the first director capture facility in North America that captures and stores CO₂ from the air.”
Shashank Samala Feb 8, 2024 ▶ 18:56
Disclosure
Heirloom signed a multi-hundred million dollar carbon removal deal with Microsoft
“This year we signed a contract with Microsoft. It's about 315,000 tons. It's a multi-hundred million dollar deal.”
Shashank Samala Feb 8, 2024 ▶ 21:05
Prediction Open · timeframe Dec 2030
Carbon removal credit prices will eventually coalesce around $300 per ton
“And, you know, there's, we think that the price is going to coalesce around 300 dollars per ton, given where the supply and demand, ah, is.”
Shashank Samala Feb 8, 2024 ▶ 21:25
Assertion Supported
Heirloom's direct air capture is 5,000 to 10,000 times more land-efficient than trees
“So compared to trees, these are actually about Five to 10,000 times more land efficient.”
Shashank Samala Feb 8, 2024 ▶ 23:16
Assertion Supported
Heirloom won a $600M DOE grant for a Louisiana carbon capture hub
“The next facility is, you know, recently we won this directory capture hub award from the Department of Energy. So we won about six hundred million dollars to build a facility that can scale up to a million tons a year, and that is Southwest Louisiana.”
Shashank Samala Feb 8, 2024 ▶ 24:09
Made with StarZero

Turn any episode into a week of clips.

This entire site, over 800 episodes transcribed, diarized, checked and made playable, runs on the StarZero media pipeline. Drop in your own episode and the podcast clipper finds the moments worth sharing, cuts them, captions them, and reframes them for every feed.

Try the podcast clipper Learn more