StarZero All shows Try the podcast clipper →

Nov 14, 2024 · 44m · how-i-built-this

Advice Line with Gary Hirshberg of Stonyfield

Gary Hirshberg · 16m spoken Guy Raz · 13m spoken Kate Havstad-Casad · 4m spoken Jamie Poe · 3m spoken Diana Dar · 2m spoken
0:00 / 0:00

gold bands on the timeline = statements, start to end. Hover to read, click to jump. CC turns on captions

Host Guy Raz teams up with Stonyfield Organic co-founder Gary Hirshberg on The Advice Line to coach emerging founders through real-world challenges in brand focus, grassroots marketing, and operational scaling.

How this conversation actually went

Every chapter scored 0–10 on four independent dynamics. Hover any point for the reasoning behind the score. Guy holds 33.7% of the talking time here. How this is scored →

Guy as informed peer 4.6 Guest teaching 3.8 Guest disagreement 1.2 Guy pushing back 1.8
05100:0015:0030:001:30–7:57 · Guy as informed peer 5/10 Gary Hirshberg on Early Stonyfield and Mission-Driven Brands Guy Raz probes Gary on whether modern consumers genuinely care about mission over price and taste, directly challenging Gary's thesis by citing the rapid rise of fast-fashion brands like Shein. Gary clarifies how mission functions as a lever for higher-priced, lower-margin products rather than mass-market leaders.7:58–20:50 · Guy as informed peer 6/10 Caller 1: Scaling Range Revolution's Regenerative Leather Business Kate details how 35% of cattle carcasses are wasted in standard slaughter operations. Guy and Gary offer differing brand advice, with Guy proposing Kate rename the brand after herself like high-end fashion designers, while Gary explicitly disagrees and argues Range Revolution's name embodies its core environmental mission.20:52–32:45 · Guy as informed peer 5/10 Mid-Show Station Break and Reintroduction Jamie seeks advice on positioning dried meals between car campers and hardcore backpackers. Gary pulls up industry data to show camping meals are a multi-billion dollar category growing to nearly five billion, advising grassroots pull strategies while Guy suggests formulating a high-protein SKU.32:46–41:48 · Guy as informed peer 4/10 Mid-Show Intermission and Transition to Caller 3 Diana asks how to find an operations generalist to take over administrative tasks. Gary explains how his early controller hire became his 30-year COO and outlines a three-legged stool compensation structure, with Guy asking about equity incentives.41:49–42:52 · Guy as informed peer 3/10 Gary Hirshberg on Entrepreneurial Focus and Saying No Guy prompts Gary for a closing reflection on early founder mistakes. Gary shares that excessive optimism and saying 'yes' to too many initiatives was Stonyfield's primary bottleneck.1:30–7:57 · Guest teaching 3/10 Gary Hirshberg on Early Stonyfield and Mission-Driven Brands Guy Raz probes Gary on whether modern consumers genuinely care about mission over price and taste, directly challenging Gary's thesis by citing the rapid rise of fast-fashion brands like Shein. Gary clarifies how mission functions as a lever for higher-priced, lower-margin products rather than mass-market leaders.7:58–20:50 · Guest teaching 4/10 Caller 1: Scaling Range Revolution's Regenerative Leather Business Kate details how 35% of cattle carcasses are wasted in standard slaughter operations. Guy and Gary offer differing brand advice, with Guy proposing Kate rename the brand after herself like high-end fashion designers, while Gary explicitly disagrees and argues Range Revolution's name embodies its core environmental mission.20:52–32:45 · Guest teaching 5/10 Mid-Show Station Break and Reintroduction Jamie seeks advice on positioning dried meals between car campers and hardcore backpackers. Gary pulls up industry data to show camping meals are a multi-billion dollar category growing to nearly five billion, advising grassroots pull strategies while Guy suggests formulating a high-protein SKU.32:46–41:48 · Guest teaching 3/10 Mid-Show Intermission and Transition to Caller 3 Diana asks how to find an operations generalist to take over administrative tasks. Gary explains how his early controller hire became his 30-year COO and outlines a three-legged stool compensation structure, with Guy asking about equity incentives.41:49–42:52 · Guest teaching 4/10 Gary Hirshberg on Entrepreneurial Focus and Saying No Guy prompts Gary for a closing reflection on early founder mistakes. Gary shares that excessive optimism and saying 'yes' to too many initiatives was Stonyfield's primary bottleneck.1:30–7:57 · Guest disagreement 2/10 Gary Hirshberg on Early Stonyfield and Mission-Driven Brands Guy Raz probes Gary on whether modern consumers genuinely care about mission over price and taste, directly challenging Gary's thesis by citing the rapid rise of fast-fashion brands like Shein. Gary clarifies how mission functions as a lever for higher-priced, lower-margin products rather than mass-market leaders.7:58–20:50 · Guest disagreement 3/10 Caller 1: Scaling Range Revolution's Regenerative Leather Business Kate details how 35% of cattle carcasses are wasted in standard slaughter operations. Guy and Gary offer differing brand advice, with Guy proposing Kate rename the brand after herself like high-end fashion designers, while Gary explicitly disagrees and argues Range Revolution's name embodies its core environmental mission.20:52–32:45 · Guest disagreement 1/10 Mid-Show Station Break and Reintroduction Jamie seeks advice on positioning dried meals between car campers and hardcore backpackers. Gary pulls up industry data to show camping meals are a multi-billion dollar category growing to nearly five billion, advising grassroots pull strategies while Guy suggests formulating a high-protein SKU.32:46–41:48 · Guest disagreement 0/10 Mid-Show Intermission and Transition to Caller 3 Diana asks how to find an operations generalist to take over administrative tasks. Gary explains how his early controller hire became his 30-year COO and outlines a three-legged stool compensation structure, with Guy asking about equity incentives.41:49–42:52 · Guest disagreement 0/10 Gary Hirshberg on Entrepreneurial Focus and Saying No Guy prompts Gary for a closing reflection on early founder mistakes. Gary shares that excessive optimism and saying 'yes' to too many initiatives was Stonyfield's primary bottleneck.1:30–7:57 · Guy pushing back 4/10 Gary Hirshberg on Early Stonyfield and Mission-Driven Brands Guy Raz probes Gary on whether modern consumers genuinely care about mission over price and taste, directly challenging Gary's thesis by citing the rapid rise of fast-fashion brands like Shein. Gary clarifies how mission functions as a lever for higher-priced, lower-margin products rather than mass-market leaders.7:58–20:50 · Guy pushing back 3/10 Caller 1: Scaling Range Revolution's Regenerative Leather Business Kate details how 35% of cattle carcasses are wasted in standard slaughter operations. Guy and Gary offer differing brand advice, with Guy proposing Kate rename the brand after herself like high-end fashion designers, while Gary explicitly disagrees and argues Range Revolution's name embodies its core environmental mission.20:52–32:45 · Guy pushing back 1/10 Mid-Show Station Break and Reintroduction Jamie seeks advice on positioning dried meals between car campers and hardcore backpackers. Gary pulls up industry data to show camping meals are a multi-billion dollar category growing to nearly five billion, advising grassroots pull strategies while Guy suggests formulating a high-protein SKU.32:46–41:48 · Guy pushing back 1/10 Mid-Show Intermission and Transition to Caller 3 Diana asks how to find an operations generalist to take over administrative tasks. Gary explains how his early controller hire became his 30-year COO and outlines a three-legged stool compensation structure, with Guy asking about equity incentives.41:49–42:52 · Guy pushing back 0/10 Gary Hirshberg on Entrepreneurial Focus and Saying No Guy prompts Gary for a closing reflection on early founder mistakes. Gary shares that excessive optimism and saying 'yes' to too many initiatives was Stonyfield's primary bottleneck.

speaking balance: gold is Guy, purple is the guest (3 minute bins)

0:00 · Guy 92.1% · guest 7.9%0:00 · Guy 92.1% · guest 7.9%3:00 · Guy 48.9% · guest 51.1%3:00 · Guy 48.9% · guest 51.1%6:00 · Guy 27.3% · guest 72.7%6:00 · Guy 27.3% · guest 72.7%9:00 · Guy 16.4% · guest 83.6%9:00 · Guy 16.4% · guest 83.6%12:00 · Guy 8.2% · guest 91.8%12:00 · Guy 8.2% · guest 91.8%15:00 · Guy 32.1% · guest 67.9%15:00 · Guy 32.1% · guest 67.9%18:00 · Guy 38.9% · guest 61.1%18:00 · Guy 38.9% · guest 61.1%21:00 · Guy 42.9% · guest 57.1%21:00 · Guy 42.9% · guest 57.1%24:00 · Guy 17.7% · guest 82.3%24:00 · Guy 17.7% · guest 82.3%27:00 · Guy 26.4% · guest 73.6%27:00 · Guy 26.4% · guest 73.6%30:00 · Guy 24.6% · guest 75.4%30:00 · Guy 24.6% · guest 75.4%33:00 · Guy 33.3% · guest 66.7%33:00 · Guy 33.3% · guest 66.7%36:00 · Guy 3.3% · guest 96.7%36:00 · Guy 3.3% · guest 96.7%39:00 · Guy 31.9% · guest 68.1%39:00 · Guy 31.9% · guest 68.1%42:00 · Guy 62.1% · guest 37.9%42:00 · Guy 62.1% · guest 37.9%
Sharpest disagreement ▶ 18:17 Gary rejects Guy's fashion-brand renaming pitch

Gary directly counters Guy's proposal to rename Range Revolution after the founder, asserting that the existing name conveys the essential environmental mission needed for celebrity and institutional appeal.

 Hardest push from Guy ▶ 7:07 Guy challenges Gary on consumer mission priority with Shein

Guy rejects the premise that modern consumers prioritize eco-conscious values over cost, pointing out that ultra-fast fashion retailer Shein is booming despite having no environmental mission.

 Biggest teaching moment ▶ 27:40 Gary educates caller on global camping food market data

Gary pulls and reads live market intelligence showing the camping food sector is currently valued at $2.5 billion and expanding to $4.8 billion, reframing the caller's niche product as part of a booming market.

 Guy holds their own ▶ 7:07 Guy counters Gary's consumer trend optimism

Guy brings concrete market counter-evidence into the discussion by highlighting Shein's explosive growth to challenge Gary's broad assertion about consumer ethical standards.
the scores for every segment, with the reasoning behind each
ChapterTopicGuy as informed peerGuest teachingGuest disagreementGuy pushing backWhy
Gary Hirshberg on Early Stonyfield and Mission-Driven Brands 5324 Guy Raz probes Gary on whether modern consumers genuinely care about mission over price and taste, directly challenging Gary's thesis by citing the rapid rise of fast-fashion brands like Shein. Gary clarifies how mission functions as a lever for higher-priced, lower-margin products rather than mass-market leaders.
Caller 1: Scaling Range Revolution's Regenerative Leather Business 6433 Kate details how 35% of cattle carcasses are wasted in standard slaughter operations. Guy and Gary offer differing brand advice, with Guy proposing Kate rename the brand after herself like high-end fashion designers, while Gary explicitly disagrees and argues Range Revolution's name embodies its core environmental mission.
Mid-Show Station Break and Reintroduction 5511 Jamie seeks advice on positioning dried meals between car campers and hardcore backpackers. Gary pulls up industry data to show camping meals are a multi-billion dollar category growing to nearly five billion, advising grassroots pull strategies while Guy suggests formulating a high-protein SKU.
Mid-Show Intermission and Transition to Caller 3 4301 Diana asks how to find an operations generalist to take over administrative tasks. Gary explains how his early controller hire became his 30-year COO and outlines a three-legged stool compensation structure, with Guy asking about equity incentives.
Gary Hirshberg on Entrepreneurial Focus and Saying No 3400 Guy prompts Gary for a closing reflection on early founder mistakes. Gary shares that excessive optimism and saying 'yes' to too many initiatives was Stonyfield's primary bottleneck.

Statements from this episode (5)

Insight
Hirshberg: Repeat purchases in food CPG always come down to taste
“It's always comes down to taste if it's food. I always said, used to say you could ship the yogurt 3000 miles, but it was the last 18 inches that made all the difference. It has to, because you're not going to get a second taste. If it doesn't deliver on the f…”
Gary Hirshberg Nov 14, 2024 ▶ 6:05
Insight
Hirshberg: Mission drives trial for high-priced, low-margin products
“If you're trying to build loyalty and with a higher priced, lower gross margin item, then mission is your secret to success. That's your way of getting trial, getting reach, and ultimately getting that holy grail of consumer products, which is word of mouth.”
Gary Hirshberg Nov 14, 2024 ▶ 7:36
Assertion Partly supported
Havstad-Casad: 35% of slaughtered cattle carcass goes to waste
“Most people don't know this, but in current systems today, when we send a steer to slaughter, about 65% of the cattle carcass is being utilized.”
Kate Havstad-Casad Nov 14, 2024 ▶ 8:53
Insight
Hirshberg: Mission-driven founders fail when ignoring the commercial core
“And, you know, again, this is this sort of, ah, theme, I think, that happens as entrepreneurs with a mission, ah, you know, the brand or the company, sometimes, ah, they forget, right, that that's actually what enables them to get to their platform, so, ah, im…”
Gary Hirshberg Nov 14, 2024 ▶ 20:34
Insight
Hirshberg: Saying 'yes' is the most dangerous word for entrepreneurs
“Yeah, I wish I understood that being an entrepreneur is really being a pathological optimist, and the most dangerous word in my vocabulary was yes.”
Gary Hirshberg Nov 14, 2024 ▶ 42:07
Made with StarZero

Turn any episode into a week of clips.

This entire site, over 800 episodes transcribed, diarized, checked and made playable, runs on the StarZero media pipeline. Drop in your own episode and the podcast clipper finds the moments worth sharing, cuts them, captions them, and reframes them for every feed.

Try the podcast clipper Learn more