why aren't all 41 resolved? a statement only gets an assessment when the public
record can support or contradict it. opinions and what-ifs never can, and 1 checkable
ones are still open, waiting for their date. predictions held up or didn't;
assertions are supported or contradicted. on every card:
▮▮▮▮▮ certainty ·
▮▮▮▮▮ debate potential. speakers are clickable
Assertion Supported
Eliahu-Ontiveros: Google deployed $50B in balance sheet backstops for Anthropic
“If you look at how much capital they have sort of indirectly deployed, it's already fifty billion dollars of sort of applications that they have on their balance sheets that are solely in sort of the goal of supporting Anthropix data center build out.”
Assertion Open · timeframe Dec 2027
Eliahu-Ontiveros: Anthropic aims to add over 8 GW of power by 2027
“Anthropic, you know, one and a half gigs of capacity end of 20, 25. By 27, they won over 10 gigs, right? So they're going to build basically more than eight gigawatts in two years. That's the size of Google today.”
Opinion
Eliahu-Ontiveros: Microsoft has dropped to fourth in hyperscaler energy sophistication
“I don't think I wouldn't call Microsoft now the second. I probably would rank them fourth now. I think you've seen Amazon step up pretty dramatically, and you've seen them at the frontier of a bunch of, you know, unique type of deals.”
Opinion
Eliahu-Ontiveros: Nvidia risks losing silicon share unless it backstops neocloud power
“It's actually becoming a pretty existential risk for NVIDIA because if they don't support the NeoClouds, they're at risk of basically seeing Google Amazon and others take tremendous market share on the silicon side, right? So you would see Tranium take, take m…”
Disclosure
Vahdat: Google trades uptime for capacity in customer co-design
“Without saying too much, it's happening. I would say there's actually the co-design there with our customers at Google has been one of our sources of significant efficiency.”
Insight
Vahdat: The AI industry should accept lower-reliability power delivery
“No, it is not intrinsic and we should be thinking about lower reliability power delivery overall.”
Insight
Vahdat: AI inference does not require gigawatt-scale data center capacity
“You don't strictly need a gigawatt of capacity to be able to do useful work. You probably don't even need a hundred megawatts of capacity. It gets a little bit more interesting than that because of, let's say, co-located compute and storage and networking and …”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Vahdat: AI footprint will favor many medium data centers over gigawatt hubs
“It'll really come down to geographic locality and probably a medium number of medium-sized data centers. Sorry for the whatever lack of precision there, but medium number of medium-sized data centers augmented with a small number of large data centers.”
Insight
Vahdat: AI scaling bottlenecks constantly rotate between labor, power, and chips
“When delivering the end-to-end, we unfortunately don't have the luxury of focusing on a single limiter. I would say very sincerely and honestly at 10 a.m. It's labor, at noon it's power, and at two p.m. It's chips every single day.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Janus: Hyperscaler climate targets are probably not achievable on time
“And so there is, I think at this point, a point of coming to grips with the fact that those targets are probably not achievable in the time horizons that they had all set.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
States use tech hyperscalers' ratepayer pledge to fight transmission tariffs
“In their complaints to FERC, for example, a bunch of states have cited that pledge, and I think that creates it's an opening for any time anyone wants to argue against however a tariff is getting structured, or a new transmission line, or whatever it might be …”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Vahdat: Interactive AI models will require geographically distributed inference infrastructure
“So as these services become more interactive, as they become more efficient, and that, that is still going to be a journey. We're not there today. You're going to want to have geographic locality. That's also going to impact reliability, because again, you can…”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Major tech companies will achieve true zero-carbon power without using offsets
“So there is a future In my opinion, for those companies to get to not just net zero on a on a basis of using offsets or other things, but actually truly having zero carbon power”
Opinion
Kann: Google has the best community playbook among data center developers
“Google maybe is the best at this, have a playbook where you address all of those things as close to upfront as you can, and you offer a lot in exchange to the community.”
Assertion Partly supported
Eliahu-Ontiveros: Google and Amazon drove bulk of 150 GW utility load pipeline
“The bulk of these contracted loads, I think at the end of 25, we had like a 150 gigawatts the PPL, you know, in, in, in Pennsylvania. That's mostly Google and Amazon. They're the ones sort of scouting all of the utility markets and you know, putting deposits a…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Kann: Google's energy team is multiples larger than other hyperscalers
“I think Google's energy team is probably a multiple of the size of the next hyperscaler. Just the number, the sheer number of people they have dedicated to it.”
Opinion
Eliahu-Ontiveros: Google is the most sophisticated hyperscaler in energy strategy
“Generally speaking, I think it's fair to say that Google is the most sophisticated company. And on the energy side, they have sort of the biggest, you know, trading desks. They've choked some pretty big deals with utilities, as you probably know, for low flexi…”
Assertion Supported
Google reached 1 GW in utility demand response agreements by March 2026
“In March, we actually hit a significant milestone in agreements with utilities for a gigawatt of demand response across our fleet.”
Disclosure
Vahdat: Google co-designs TPUs directly with power sources, buildings, and Gemini
“In other words, for us, for let's say our TPUs, we co-design them with a building. We co-design them with the power generation source. We co-design them with the DeepMind team that builds Gemini models. So it's the software above, the models above that, the ch…”
Disclosure
Vahdat: Google does not use blank workloads to smooth training power draw
“We don't do this, but yes, others.”
Disclosure
Google uses behind-the-meter power while waiting years for grid transmission
“We like behind the meter if it means that we get the capacity up most quickly, but we're always going to look to invest with the utilities to bring the transmission. Maybe it's a year after. Maybe it's two years after, right?”
Insight
Vahdat: Dominant compute costs force data centers to sacrifice fungibility
“If compute is not the dominant portion of your cost, you actually want to have flexibility and fungibility. When compute becomes a more dominant portion of your cost, you now actually are thinking, okay, what am I going to do for this year, next year, and the …”
Assertion Supported
Google reached 1 GW of flexible data center capacity across five utilities
“Google now, ah, has reached a gigawatt of contracted flexible capacity across, I think, five different utility territories, at least some of whom, ah, are willing to provide some of these benefits.”
Disclosure
Google deal directly funds Elemental Power's upfront nuclear project development costs
“They made investment, you know, mostly in the technology, but increasingly as this deal we're doing now with Google is in the upfront development, which is really the key part that needs to be re-risked.”
Assertion Supported
Google and Elemental Power announce 1.8 GW US nuclear portfolio
“Elemental came out of stealth this week and announced a big partnership with Google to develop a three-site portfolio of at least 1.8 gigawatts of new nuclear in the U.S.”
Assertion Supported
Google and TPG inject $800M into Intersect Power for co-located generation
“Intersect partnered with TPG, which is a big investment firm, and Google on a partnership that initially will inject about eight hundred million dollars into Intersect to develop solar and storage and wind and some gas co-located with data centers in the Unite…”
Assertion Supported
Bullard: Google data center power usage effectiveness has plateaued since 2021
“PUE is now pretty much flat when you adjusted for seasons since the 21. This is data from Google's data centers, and they're about as transparent as you can get with this figure.”
Opinion
Rayford Smith: 24/7 carbon-free energy is vastly harder than 100% renewables
“This is a fundamental sea change in how we do it, and it's considerably harder than what we had been accomplished up to that date.”
Disclosure
Smith: Google dynamically shifted computing loads based on grid constraints and carbon
“When I was at Google, one of the things we did was we created the ability to basically forecast forward power prices grid constraints, carbon content and then dynamically move our load around to take advantage of that. So if there was a storm and there was goi…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Rayford Smith: Google sometimes waited seven years for data center transmission access
“I can tell you when we were building data centers at Google, you know, in some places it took us seven years to get transmission access. In other places it took us, you know, 18 months to two years.”
Assertion Supported
Vahdat: AI accelerator power density is 100x higher than storage
“And the difference between storage and compute was at most 10 X. The difference between storage and accelerators are approaching a hundred X.”
Disclosure
Vahdat: Many Google data centers target four nines of availability
“Many of our data centers aim for four nines of, I mean, minutes of downtime a year maximum, which as you said has a large amount of costs associated with it.”
Assertion Supported
Google achieves a data center power usage effectiveness near 1.1
“Google's PUE is close to 1.1, which is to say for every watt going to compute, there's an additional .1 watts going to the overheads of power delivery or cooling or whatever.”
Insight
Energy startup buyouts bring pay cuts, not tech-style windfalls
“You know, about five startups later and three buyouts later, I realized the startup world in energy was much different than Google. It was more of a pay decline. Type of buyout rather than a, you know, million dollar buyout you see in the tech world.”
Assertion Supported
Kann: Google partnered with TVA and Michigan Power for demand response
“Google actually made a big announcement about doing this at their data centers just a few weeks ago. They've announced that they've partnered with two utilities, Michigan Power and TVA, to introduce demand response via workload flexibility in their data center…”
Assertion Supported
Sivaram: Google shifted video indexing to nighttime to lower carbon load
“Google also, by the way, has exploited temporal flexibility. There was a Paper, a post they put out a couple years ago, a friend of mine, Varun Mehra, wrote it about moving video indexing operations to nighttime in order to reduce load during periods, as you m…”
Assertion Supported
Sivaram: Modern AI data centers convert 90% of power into compute
“Historically, a data center might lose 33% of the power or use it, 33% of that power for non-IT or information technology uses, and the remaining 66 or 67% goes into actual computations. Nowadays, with the increasingly customized design of these AI factories a…”
Assertion Supported
Kann: Fervo Energy holds PPAs with utilities and Google for hundreds of MW
“Fervo Energy, notably, has PPAs, both with utilities and with Google, for hundreds of megawatts of new development.”
Assertion Supported
Small modular reactors for tech companies fit on 100 acres or less
“The smaller plant sizes, the small modular reactors you're looking at for Google, can probably fit about a hundred acres or so or less.”
Assertion Supported
Kann: Google signed the first US enhanced geothermal PPA with Fervo
“The first PPA that ever got signed for enhanced geothermal in the United States from Fervo was with Google.”
Assertion Supported
Palmer: Google matched 100% of its electricity with renewables in 2017
“And we did meet that goal of a hundred percent renewable What I think is even. In 2017, exactly.”