Cabiyo: Biomass CDR developers ignoring counterfactual baselines are fooling themselves
Dr. Bodhi Cabiyo · Sourcing biomass for carbon removal · Jan 19, 2024 · at 47:17
Carbon Direct forest scientist Dr. Bodhi Cabiyo discusses the necessity of calculating counterfactual scenarios when assessing the true net impact of biomass carbon removal projects.
0:00 / 0:10exact quote · 10.7s
720p mp4 · rendered on demand · StarZero watermark
“I think that if you're working on biomass CDR, and you're not thinking about counterfactuals every day, you're probably fooling yourself, or you have a really easy case that's going to get harder in the next couple decades.”
quote is from the automated transcript, cleaned for reading: filler sounds and stutters are removed, nothing is rephrased. names can be misheard (the analysis reads context, assessments check outside sources). how →
More from Dr. Bodhi Cabiyo
Cabiyo: Enviva turns whole, lumber-grade saw logs into wood pellets for export
“I have a colleague that has toured their facilities in the past and saw that they were pulling whole saw logs, which is, like, stuff you would turn into lumber, like, two-by-fours, pulling saw logs and turning it into pellets to be burned in the UK or elsewher…”
Cabiyo: A Montana cobalt mine is far better than DRC child labor
“On the surface, you know, like, a cobalt mine in Montana seems like a pretty bad deal from that lens, but it's a whole hell of a lot better than the alternative, which is, you know, mining cobalt in open pits in the DRC with child labor.”
Cabiyo: Global biomass demand in 2050 exceeds sustainable supply by 11x
“There's a huge mismatch between the supply and demand there of biomass and biomass uses and that mismatch is, based on the best estimates that, that I've seen, that mismatch is something on the order of, like, 11 to 16 X. In other words, 11 to 16 X more uses i…”
Cabiyo: True "waste wood" does not exist due to competing commercial demands
“Waste wood is not really, especially if we think about that twenty-fifty scenario, waste wood is not really a thing. There's always going to be a use for waste wood.”
Cabiyo: High-quality wood pellets require whole logs, not just waste residues
“You can't make good pellets out of treetops and branches and sawmill residues. You need whole logs to do that well.”
Cabiyo: Assuming harvested biomass power has zero net climate impact is flawed
“All these facilities are predicated on carbon neutrality that if you harvest biomass and burn it, you have no net climate impact which is probably a simplification that we should stop making. Oftentimes you can get close to that, but it's not always going to b…”