Ryan Orbuch

8 statements across 2 episodes · 2 bullish · 5 bearish · 1 people on the record · first statement May 5, 2022 by Ryan Orbuch · across every show →

On the record as a speaker too: Ryan Orbuch's record, appearances and statements → this page counts the times other people say the name.

Everything said about Ryan Orbuch, oldest first

May 5, 2022
Assertion Supported
Orbuch: The Clean Air Act caused net warming by reducing reflective aerosols
“The Clean Air Act was pretty meaningfully net warming for Earth, right? Like, it was an objectively good thing, obviously. Like, it saved probably millions of lives. It protected, you know, millions of people, and especially vulnerable communities from really …”
Ryan Orbuch May 5, 2022 ▶ 45:23 Growing the Carbon Dioxide Removal (CDR) market
May 5, 2022 negative
Assertion Supported
Orbuch: Forest carbon protocols completely ignore albedo effects that negate carbon storage
“No freaking forest carbon protocol accounts for albedo. And in some cases, it's, like, enough to almost undo the carbon storage provided by the forest.”
Ryan Orbuch May 5, 2022 ▶ 46:41 Growing the Carbon Dioxide Removal (CDR) market
Jan 4, 2024 negative
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Orbuch: Buyers cannot purchase real carbon removal for $10 per ton
“Turns out you can't spend 10 dollars a ton and do anything real.”
Ryan Orbuch Jan 4, 2024 ▶ 8:43 Fixing the messy voluntary carbon market
Jan 4, 2024 negative
Opinion
Orbuch: Legacy registry credits only vaguely corresponded to actual carbon cycles
“You need someone whose job it is, is to figure out the effect of a given thing on the carbon cycle. And we have said that the old registries played this role, and people believe they played that role, and that's what it meant for them to issue a ton. And that'…”
Ryan Orbuch Jan 4, 2024 ▶ 31:46 Fixing the messy voluntary carbon market
Jan 4, 2024 positive
Insight
Orbuch: Next-generation carbon registries must be buyer-funded with ex-post credit issuance
“So there's two things that change. One is that the buyer pays the registry to evaluate deliveries and two, the credits are issued after they've been delivered, not preemptively before.”
Ryan Orbuch Jan 4, 2024 ▶ 35:43 Fixing the messy voluntary carbon market
Jan 4, 2024 positive
Insight
Orbuch: Tying supplier margins to narrowing error bars aligns incentives with science
“What you want is you want the supplier to be able to sell more tons and make more money for the same cogs if they can bring in the error bars around the uncertainty. And innovate on measurement, innovate on modeling, innovate on how they deploy, innovate on th…”
Ryan Orbuch Jan 4, 2024 ▶ 47:34 Fixing the messy voluntary carbon market
Jan 4, 2024 negative
Opinion
Orbuch: Legacy carbon registries protected brokers by pretending cheap offsets were real
“The original sin with carbon markets was this bad incentive structure encouraged by registries that weren't aligned around the problem to protect the interests of the sellers and brokers of the credits, to make them look like there are enough credits at low en…”
Ryan Orbuch Jan 4, 2024 ▶ 12:46 Fixing the messy voluntary carbon market
Jan 4, 2024 negative
Insight
Orbuch: Overly conservative scientific governance breaks carbon removal project finance
“Like, loudest, most conservative scientist in the room-based governance doesn't work for this. You actually do need to make something off-takeable and contractable, and the way you do that is for these emerging more uncertain approaches, or the approaches that…”
Ryan Orbuch Jan 4, 2024 ▶ 45:56 Fixing the messy voluntary carbon market
Made with StarZero

Turn any episode into a week of clips.

This entire site, over 200 episodes transcribed, diarized, checked and made playable, runs on the StarZero media pipeline. Drop in your own episode and the podcast clipper finds the moments worth sharing, cuts them, captions them, and reframes them for every feed.