why aren't all 352 resolved? a statement only gets an assessment when the public
record can support or contradict it. opinions and what-ifs never can, and 5 checkable
ones are still open, waiting for their date. predictions held up or didn't;
assertions are supported or contradicted. on every card:
▮▮▮▮▮ certainty ·
▮▮▮▮▮ debate potential. speakers are clickable
Assertion Partly supported
Chan: Google paid up to $70M for a single self-driving engineer
“In fact, Google has been known to pay up to seventy million dollars for a single engineer working on their self-driving car project.”
Assertion Partly supported
Evans: Google and Facebook captured half of print's internet ad revenue
“Internet took about half of the print industry's advertising revenue and growing, but Google and Facebook took half of that.”
Insight
Rampell: Fragmented 1-800 search results signal ripe marketplace opportunities
“If you ever do a Google search and you see 10,000 results and every result ends up with a call this one 800 number and it has really bad clip art on it, that is an opportunity for a new marketplace to emerge.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Mars: AI assistant infrastructures are monopolized by major tech companies
“These kinds of infrastructures are monopolized essentially by companies like Apple, Google, Microsoft, and so forth.”
Prediction Held up
Rampell: Apple and Google will fully open their mobile wallet platforms
“Apple and Google need to open up their respective wallets, but I think they will, because Apple and Google, if they want to build a powerful position and actually truly have the mobile wallet not just be a payment type that has three credit cards in it, But ac…”
Insight
Rampell: Amazon's Fire Phone was a smart move against app store fees
“Amazon, they built the Fire Phone. Which ended up being a flop, but it was a very, very smart move for Amazon to do because they realize if I'm Amazon and I want to go sell a book to somebody, I'm not allowed to do that through Apple or through Google unless I…”
Assertion Supported
Evans: Combined GAFA revenues remain smaller than TV and advertising
“Even Google, Apple, Facebook, and Amazon combined there, or GAFA, as the telecoms industry tends to call them add up to less than TV business or advertising and are much, much smaller than mobile or proper, proper industries like cars or clothes.”
Insight
Rampell: Active searchers for emergency credit represent high credit risk
“But if you go on Google and you say, like, I'm out of money, need money, credit, credit, credit, like you're probably a bad credit risk. So kind of going back to the general store concept, People that aren't looking for credit, that might not have their wallet…”
Disclosure
Litt: AI acts as a Google substitute without doing deep intellectual math work
“What I've found is that the projects that I have that kind of predate AI, like the projects I've been thinking about for three or four or five years it's just not that useful. Like, it's primarily kind of a substitute for Google or something. Like, I might use…”
Insight
Sinofsky: Microsoft worries far more about Amazon and Google than startups
“The only incumbents are only interested in what the other incumbents are doing. Microsoft is worried way more about what Amazon and Google are doing than anyone in a startup space.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Evans: AI integration is driving ad revenue gains at Google and Meta
“Which is, of course, why you see the ad numbers and the, you know, the conversion rates shooting up in the, every quarter from Google and Facebook. Because they're rolling all of this into their ad systems, and their recommendation engines, and their predictio…”
Assertion Supported
Evans: Big Tech produces more profits than the entire telecoms industry
“You have a pretty safe bet that Google, Meta, Amazon Microsoft, Apple produce more profits than the entire telecoms industry.”
Insight
Acharya: Legacy Software Struggles to Innovate Beyond Incremental AI Features
“Conversely, when you look at The existing product services, like Sheets or Docs, there's just so much, one sort of momentum and inertia from the past, but then management overhead around those, it's harder for them to do anything other than the most obvious in…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Moore: Google's NotebookLM Was a Breakthrough in Consumer AI Audio
“I think Notebook LM was actually the first look at this, and that was something truly new in, like, consumer AI audio.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Moore: OpenAI integrated launches into ChatGPT while Google built standalone products
“What we saw was OpenAI tended to keep more things in the ChatGPT interface, so like Pulse, group chats, shopping, research, tasks, all of these features launched inside ChatGPT as the core. The exception there is obviously Sora as a standalone video app, where…”
Opinion
Moore: OpenAI and Google's most viral 2025 models were image and video
“From a model perspective, I would say, I would argue their most viral models this year, at least among consumers, were in image and video.”
Opinion
Moore: Google's Nano Banana image models rivaled OpenAI's Ghibli moment in virality
“Nano banana and Nano banana pro in image models, which went insanely viral, probably comparable to, if not beyond the Ghibli moment for open AI.”
Assertion Supported
Horowitz: Google Reversed Its Position to Work With Defense Department
“Google has definitely since Google slash Alphabet has reversed their position and now do work, ah, with the US government and the Defense Department.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Amjad Masad: Non-technical consumers routinely switch between multiple competing AI models
“Not particularly technical consumers actually do use multiple AIs. Like I didn't expect that, like, you know, people only use Google. They never like looked at Google and then Yahoo or like very few people do it. But now you talk to just average people and the…”
Disclosure
Kuyda bet Replika on dialogue language models in 2015
“When we saw that in August, 2015, we just basically put all of our bet everything we had at the company on building those models. We said, okay, well, this is it. This is right around the corner. We need to really focus on building these language models, getti…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Vahdat: Google estimated Bigtable to Spanner migration required 7,000 staff-years
“The estimate for doing that migration for Google was seven staffed millennia.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Vahdat: The entire computing stack will be unrecognizable by 2030
“And five years from now, whatever the computing stack is from the hardware to the software, right, it's going to be unrecognizable.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Vahdat: Google's seven- and eight-year-old TPUs maintain 100% utilization
“Our seven and eight year old TPUs have a hundred percent utilization.”
Opinion
Acharya: Google is still superior to AI search for navigation queries
“I find for navigation queries, Google is still better.”
Assertion Partly supported
Hoffman: Google achieved 40% data center energy savings using AI
“Google applied its algorithms to its own data centers, which are some of the best tuned grid systems in the world. 40% energy savings.”
Insight
Rampell: Consumer fintech is hard because Google captures all economic rent
“Consumer fintech products are so hard because like all of the, I mean, right now, just all of the economic rent goes to Google or wherever you find it from.”
Assertion Contradicted
Rabois asserts Apple's profits exceed Google's total revenues
“Their profits are greater than like Google's revenues or something.”
Insight
Ghodsi: Ideal hires combine big-tech scale experience with startup grit
“I love to hire people who have seen great at a big company, like, or I don't know if it's great, but they've seen process scale, big company. They've been at a Google, they've been at Amazon, they understand the processes so that I understand how to navigate a…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Moore: LLM hallucinations force shoppers back to Google and Amazon
“All, like, all LLMs, but I'll use ChatGPT as the example, because the most people use it have this really unfortunate and annoying problem of hallucinating around product recommendations that basically everyone experienced if you tried to use it for that.”
Assertion Supported
Acharya: AI consumer software is commanding unprecedented $300 monthly pricing
“Google's top SKU is 250 a month. Grox is 300 a month. I don't think we've ever seen a time where consumers were paying those kinds of prices.”
Assertion Supported
Google NotebookLM sustains flat or growing traffic until late summer
“And then right below the top 10 was Notebook LM. At number 13. And I take your wow as a little bit of a surprise, which was a surprise to me too, and I think a bit of a narrative violation that they went viral almost a year ago. In September of 2024. But they'…”
Disclosure
Yahya: Google refused to pursue crypto beyond basic node hosting
“Google would not touch crypto with a thousand foot pole unless it was like a very, very kind of vanilla, like we will like run and run some like note or whatever.”
Insight
Sinofsky: Tech disruption happens when incumbents fail to shift mindsets
“Can they transform the way they think to something new? Because that's really where the disruption is going to happen.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Justine Moore: Google's next video model will struggle with coherence and cost
“So I would imagine, you know, Google will want to train the next model that's even bigger and is able to generate longer videos, but we'll struggle with things like coherence, and we'll also struggle with, honestly, the pricing of the model.”
Assertion Contradicted
Olivia Moore: NotebookLM pioneered realistic conversational disfluencies in AI voice
“Notebook LM came out, and that was the first real voice experience that put in those ums, ahs, pauses, other things that are so human-like”
Assertion Supported
Anish Acharya: Google's top consumer subscription tier costs $250 per month
“The top Google consumer SKU is 250 dollars a month.”
Insight
Dixon: Google's business model relies on delivering links over direct answers
“The whole business model is predicated on not actually getting the, it's on getting the link and not the actual product, right?”
Opinion
Young software engineers now prefer defense tech startups over Big Tech
“Three years ago for very young talent or software engineers, it was like convincing them that manufacturing or national security was incredibly important. And now I think if you're starting a startup, I think if you're a software engineer, actually most of wha…”
Assertion Supported
Immerman: Google antitrust ruling proves default search deals were anti-competitive
“So earlier this year, Google was declared a monopoly. The court ruled that they're spending billions of dollars to phone manufacturers. In the case of Apple, tens of billions of dollars is monopolistic. It's anti-competitive and it's preventing their competito…”
Opinion
Immerman: Gen AI search offers a much better UX than Google
“If you think about the Google experience as it is today, it's just a long list of links. And the first few are sponsored. They're ads. And I, as a user, when I make a query on Google, I then need to make the decision. I have to sift through the information on …”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Immerman: Standalone vertical AI search apps will thrive in deep domain research
“For the average query on ChatGPT, Perplexity, or Google, they're pretty good. You don't need a vertical specific application, but for deep domain research, I can imagine a world in which standalone apps thrive.”
Disclosure
Casey has held Alphabet stock continuously since its 2004 IPO
“I've held Google since the 2004 IPO.”
Assertion Supported
Andreessen: ChatGPT stemmed from Alec Radford's early LLM work at OpenAI
“The origin story of even, even ChatGPT is this is not what OpenAI actually started to do. They started to do something different, and then there was actually one guy who actually his name is, I think Alec Radford, and he literally was, like, off in the corner …”
Assertion Partly supported
Andreessen: Google formally disregards college degrees in favor of internal testing
“I think Google now formally does not take college degrees into account, or at least they've said they're neutral or ambivalent or don't care. They'll, they'll, they'll equally rank people without degrees. They'll, they do their own testing. And they go on thos…”
Assertion Supported
Ismail: Tech winners like Apple and Google succeeded by becoming platforms
“Yahoo, BlackBerry, Nokia all failed to become platforms, right? Google, Apple, Facebook, Amazon all successfully became platforms, and that business model basically carries you through because now you wire yourself into the infrastructure.”
Assertion Supported
Casado: Google eliminated employee account takeovers by mandating security keys
“There's actually a pretty famous case study where Google rolled them out wall to wall. So every Google employee has a security key. They had account takeover issues, you know, six years ago, over six years of using them, account takeover went to zero.”
Assertion Supported
Bahcall: Google and McKinsey remove promotion decisions from direct managers
“Some companies, actually Google does this, and McKinsey does this, and others, they take the promotion decisions completely away from the manager.”
Opinion
Dixon: GoTo invented the pay-per-click auction, the greatest business model ever
“Company called Overture, GoTo originally, and then Overture, For sort of completely, a little bit orthogonal reasons, invents the greatest business model of all time, which happens to tuck perfectly into Google's model.”