May 31, 2024 · 56m · news
Matt Lerner: How to Hire Growth Leaders and Teams and Why in a World of AI | E1159 · 20VC with Harry Stebbings
0:00 / 0:00
▶ Watch on YouTube →
gold bands on the timeline = statements, start to end. Hover to read, click to jump. CC turns on captions
In this episode of 20VC, Harry Stebbings interviews Matt Lerner, founder of SYSTM, on how early-stage startups can systematically identify high-impact growth levers, design value-driven North Star metrics, and hire adaptable, scientifically-minded generalists instead of relying on standard marketing playbooks.
How this conversation actually went
Every chapter scored 0–10 on four independent dynamics. Hover any point for the reasoning behind the score. Harry holds 24.1% of the talking time here. How this is scored →
Harry as informed peer 5.3 Guest teaching 5.5 Guest disagreement 2.4 Harry pushing back 4.0
speaking balance: gold is Harry, purple is the guest (3 minute bins)
Sharpest disagreement ▶ 29:50 Contradicting Host's Guest Consensus
Matt Lerner directly refutes the consensus established by previous high-profile guests on Harry's podcast regarding when early-stage startups should hire growth leads.
Hardest push from Harry ▶ 16:13 Challenging Founder Value Proposition PremiseHarry Stebbings directly refuses Matt's premise that founders need to figure out how they deliver value, arguing that founders start businesses specifically knowing their intended value.
Biggest teaching moment ▶ 8:31 Explaining Frictional Onboarding IntentMatt Lerner re-educates Harry on conversion mechanics, showing how introducing multi-question friction in onboarding flows actually boosts intent and long-term customer conversion.
Harry holds his own ▶ 19:54 VC Founder Execution Speed TaxonomyHarry Stebbings demonstrates sharp venture capital domain expertise by categorizing and contrasting execution velocity across strategy consultants, bankers, and big tech VPs of Product.
the scores for every segment, with the reasoning behind each
| Chapter | Topic | Harry as informed peer | Guest teaching | Guest disagreement | Harry pushing back | Why |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Matt Lerner's Path to Growth | 2 | 3 | 1 | 1 | Harry asks open chronological questions about Matt's career entry into PayPal and VC. Matt elaborates on his key career learnings including PayPal's 90/10 growth distribution rule. | |
| Growth as Information Discovery vs. Playbooks | 3 | 5 | 2 | 2 | Harry asks standard interview questions regarding what Matt knows now versus when entering growth. Matt re-educates the premise by defining growth as information discovery rather than copying playbooks. | |
| Is Growth an Art or a Science? | 6 | 6 | 3 | 6 | Harry forces Matt to pick between Art and Science, and challenges whether user experience conflicts with conversion funnels. Matt corrects Harry by showing how adding user friction (like 30-question onboarding flows) creates higher intent. | |
| Big Swings vs. Micro-Optimizations | 5 | 5 | 3 | 6 | Harry presses Matt with a hypothetical 'gun to my head' choice between Art and Science. Matt maintains his ground choosing Science and details how data and intuition interact. | |
| How to Find the Right North Star Metric | 6 | 5 | 2 | 5 | Harry challenges using revenue as a North Star and adds detailed nuance on user activity intensity versus raw active user counts. Matt breaks down why revenue creates misaligned incentives across team heads. | |
| When and Why to Pivot Your North Star | 6 | 6 | 4 | 7 | Harry pushes back on Matt's premise that startups need to figure out how they deliver value, contending that founders start companies knowing the value prop. Matt defends his view by showing how 10 SMBs give 10 different problem definitions. | |
| The Three Archetypes of Startup Failure | 7 | 5 | 2 | 3 | Harry demonstrates strong VC expertise by categorizing execution speeds among founder archetypes, noting that Andreessen-backed VP of Product founders often execute the slowest. | |
| The Six Growth Channels & The Trap of Diversification | 7 | 6 | 3 | 5 | Harry cites quotes from Kit Bodnar and Adam Gross on channel scaling and PLG paid rules. Matt breaks down the world into six core channels and shows why execution outweighs selection. | |
| The "Locksmith Moment" in Customer Journey | 5 | 6 | 2 | 4 | Harry jokes about everyone starting podcasts and probes whether demand can be synthesized from nothing. Matt shares his locksmith story and customer interview framework. | |
| When to Hire Your First Growth Lead | 6 | 7 | 6 | 5 | Harry sets up the standard advice from previous guests that growth hires belong post-PMF. Matt explicitly refutes and rejects consensus from previous high-profile podcast guests. | |
| Finding and Recruiting Bright Generalists | 4 | 6 | 2 | 3 | Harry asks how to source generalist candidates without a network and jokes about VC overconfidence. Matt explains why scientists and physicists often outperform traditional marketers in growth roles. | |
| Matt Lerner's Interview Framework & Mindset Questions | 4 | 7 | 1 | 2 | Harry acts as a student asking step-by-step interview instructions. Matt delivers a comprehensive framework detailing three specific mindset questions to evaluate growth hires. | |
| Testing Candidates Without Case Study Decks | 5 | 6 | 3 | 5 | Harry presses on pre-prepping candidates with fundraising decks or case study assignments. Matt rejects case study decks and highlights dishonesty as his worst hiring mistake. | |
| In-Person Collaboration and Growth Cadence | 4 | 6 | 2 | 3 | Harry asks whether growth teams need to be in-person. Matt outlines a structured weekly meeting cadence and an onboarding framework to align growth teams. | |
| Quick Wins vs. Fundamental Core Work | 6 | 5 | 2 | 4 | Harry offers his own practical interview tactic of paying candidates to take a week off to trial with the company. Matt discusses the transient nature of quick growth wins. | |
| Emotional Storytelling in Content Building | 6 | 5 | 1 | 2 | Harry shares data on content building performance, contrasting analytical venture tweets with emotional story posts. Matt defines growth loops across channels. | |
| Structural Placement of Growth Teams | 6 | 6 | 2 | 3 | Harry cites specific talent economics, noting that top growth professionals like Elena Verna command compensation beyond early-stage startup reach. Matt breaks down team structural placement. | |
| Quick Fire: Growth in a World of AI | 5 | 5 | 3 | 5 | Harry challenges Matt's view on AI outbound tools, pushing back that infinite supply will cause complete channel decay. Matt acknowledges the risk while explaining current AI capabilities. | |
| Quick Fire: European Tech Regulation and Growth Hubris | 7 | 5 | 2 | 5 | Harry brings concrete deal flow figures comparing zero UK deals against German and French volume to question UK tech competitiveness. Matt validates German startup strength from his own experience. |
Statements from this episode (48)
Lerner: Organizational alignment accounts for 90% of success in big companies
“When you're in a big company where having the right answers like five or 10% of the problem and getting the entire organization and to change people's mindset and align resources ends up becoming like 80 or 90% of the problem.”
Lerner: 90% of PayPal's growth came from 10% of initiatives
“When I look back on my time at PayPal, 90% of our growth came from, like, 10% of the stuff that we did.”
Lerner: PayPal wasted hundreds of millions on unused marketing and products
“They spent hundreds of millions of dollars on marketing campaigns, building products that, frankly, nobody ever used”
Lerner: Startup growth is information discovery, not executing standard playbooks
“How much of growth is actually figuring stuff out? Is actually information discovery rather than running playbooks, doing best practices, copying what other companies did?”
Lerner: Hubris leads startups to overinvest in unproven growth playbooks
“The hardest thing about figuring stuff out Is, honestly, I think it's hubris. I think it's that people come in and they don't realize they need to figure stuff out. They have their best practices, they have what worked in their last job, they have what they he…”
Lerner: Introducing onboarding friction often yields higher quality customers
“So a lot of times you'll get the best customers in situations where you're actually introducing friction into the funnel.”
Lerner: Micro-optimization is premature until startups establish major growth levers
“So in the beginning, you, it's premature to start optimizing. You need to figure out the big stuff first. Once you've got one lever working, two levers working, then you can start devoting resources to optimizing and trying to squeeze more juice out of that le…”
Lerner: Science without art delivers growth results; art without science fails
“I mean, if I were running a company and you had a gun to my head and I had to choose one, I'd say science. Because science without art can deliver business results. And art without science, just, if it does, it's very rare and exceptional down to luck. It just…”
Lerner: Growth models must start with value-delivering North Star metrics
“The way to map your growth model is you start with your North Star, and that's going to be a metric that increments when you deliver value to customers, and something that encompasses the entire funnel, and, you know, you stress test it a bit so it's not creat…”
Lerner: Revenue is the wrong North Star metric for early-stage startups
“The biggest mistake with North Star, and it's a very reasonable one, is they choose their North Star as revenue, or profits.”
Lerner: Asking functional heads for revenue ideas fragments startup strategy
“If you take, you know, your six functional heads in your business, engineering, product sales, whatever, and say, give me your best ideas for making money. They're going to give you six different strategies with six different resource So that's moving in six d…”
Lerner: The Sean Ellis survey strongly tests product-market fit
“I think that's a really good test of the strength of product market fit.”
Lerner: Product-market fit with very few customers does not make a business
“You can have product market fit with six customers, and next year it's seven customers, and you don't have a business.”
Lerner: Startups should pivot North Star metrics when value delivery shifts
“In the beginning, sometimes before product market fit, you're just still figuring out how you deliver value to customers. And when you learn that actually it's something fundamentally different, Then you might want to change your North Star.”
Lerner: Amazon's original 1996 North Star metric was repeat purchases
“Amazon's North Star from 1996 was repeat purchases.”
Lerner: Ask employees how their work impacts the North Star metric
“If you tell people things, they may or may not listen, but if you ask them questions, it forces them to think. So once I have it, explain the North Star to the whole team, I have each manager go around and ask each person, explain to me how your work impacts t…”
Stebbings: Former big-tech product VPs are the slowest executing founders
“Yeah, strategy consultants, and honestly, the slowest executors are the VPs of product from big company. Who've never been a founder before, and they raise five on 25 from Andreessen. Three years of money, and it's just like, ah, the speed is not there.”
Lerner: Early-stage startups only need to excel at 1.5 things
“Like a startup needs to be good at one and a half things tops”
Lerner: Paid acquisition below $100M ARR should only be for testing
“So first of all, I think the exception on paid below a hundred million in ARR is it's a good way to get eyeballs quickly for testing. So it's a good way to validate stuff quickly, but it shouldn't obviously be the crux of your growth early on.”
Lerner: There are only six primary customer acquisition channels available
“So it's kind of a false distinction, but there's really only like six channels in the world. If you think about how are the ways you find out about stuff, You hear from a salesperson, some partner brings you in to enable you to do something, you see some ads, …”
Stebbings: Podcasts require 200 unrewarded episodes before showing any ROI proof
“You will have to do 200 shows, no one will care, you will not make any money, and then you will also have no proof that it works, still.”
Lerner: Startup growth is non-linear, characterized by sudden unexpected breakthroughs
“It's not like, you know, I mean, I see, I know you, you're a runner, like, it's not like you practice every day and you get a little bit better every day and after a year you've cut 30 seconds off your mile or whatever. It's like nothing, nothing, nothing, som…”
Lerner: Successful startups position themselves at the customer's peak moment of need
“Every successful startup finds this kind of exact moment of highest need and figures out a way to insert themselves there.”
Lerner: Effective landing page headlines complete the sentence "now you can"
“A good headline on a landing page completes the sentence, now you can. So I'm trying to do this, and oh, now you can, you know, close out your quarter in minutes, not, Days. Or whatever it is that they're trying to do.”
Lerner: Startups can test 12 value propositions in a week for $500
“In a week for 500 bucks, you can just test a bunch of ads. So you have one ad design and six different now you can headlines and you show it to like a lookalike audience or highly selected target that looks like your customers. And these ads won't be profitabl…”
Lerner: A startup's founder must serve as its first head of growth
“So I really believe very strongly that your first head of growth is your founder, and their first hires, I wouldn't start by hiring somebody senior.”
Lerner: Early growth hires only need 50% of required skills upfront
“Hire people, I say hire people who can do 50% of the hard things you need and figure out the other 90%.”
Lerner: Removing restrictive job filters enables effective inbound startup hiring
“I've actually found, even when I worked for kind of unknown startups, the general broad inbound Tends to work. I find the mistake people make is that they apply too many filters to the search, right? You know, you write the job spec, and the recruiter's like, …”
Lerner: PayPal's best growth hires had zero marketing or product background
“The best, I'll say categorically, the best growth people I hired and managed in my time at PayPal had no marketing experience, had no product experience at all.”
Lerner: Scientists excel in startups due to intellectual humility and curiosity
“Scientists are always aware of what they don't know. Unlike, you know, most people in most jobs, you're just always, you're wrong all the time. You're at these, you see these big gaps in humanity's understanding of whatever your discipline is. And you've got t…”
Stebbings: VCs can be world-class even with a 90% failure rate
“Can you imagine like a chef in a restaurant where 90% of the meals they produce can be terrible, the worst. As long as 10% are great, you are, you can be the best in the world.”
Lerner: Traditional corporate performance skills are useless in early-stage startups
“The way you get promoted in a lot of companies, in product, in marketing, is by doing the stuff you're supposed to do, but doing it faster and doing more of it and making fewer mistakes and managing more people and more budget and making good decks. And none o…”
Lerner: Working at a successful startup doesn't prove you caused its success
“I think the biggest mistake early on in hiring is just being, you know, dazzled by the names on a CV and where you've worked in the past and what you've done. And I think I already said I have very little use for experience. And if you worked for a successful …”
Lerner: Growth teams require at least one to two in-person days weekly
“I think there needs to be a part of it that's in person. A lot of it is really solitary, a lot of it is almost like coding, like spending time with data, Talking to customers, making sense of interviews, refining and designing creative, setting up experiments.…”
Lerner: Weekly growth meeting cadences drive the pace of experimentation
“And on the other hand, because it's a weekly cadence, it pushes the pace. You're like, we have our meeting on Monday. I need to have my experiments done by then. And, you know, the cadence of experimentation and learning is critical.”
Stebbings: Every startup executes employee onboarding terribly across all roles
“I think every startup does onboarding terribly for any role.”
Lerner: Most startups track signups but ignore actual customer value
“Most people track Signups and conversions for their paid stuff, but they don't look at customer value.”
Lerner: Quick growth marketing wins provide one-time jumps, not continuous scale
“If your conversion goes from one percent to 10%, you're not gonna 10 x that number again. So that's where eventually you know, there's just no getting around kind of doing the fundamentals.”
Stebbings: Pay job candidates for a one-week stealth trial before hiring
“I always think, actually in most roles, it's about a week, which is why I try and pay people to take a week off their job beforehand. I say, hey Matt, it's a big decision for you. Let's pay you for a week, join for a week in, in kind of quiet, and we'll see if…”
Lerner: Startups cannot effectively optimize more than two growth loops simultaneously
“It's hard because the doubling down is really down in the trenches of a really tweaking and optimizing”
Lerner: Early-stage startups must turn the entire company into the growth team
“So in an early stage startup, I think there just comes a point where your company becomes the growth team, right? Like you go through fundraising, you go through building your product, and sort of the eye of Sauron turns, and it's like time to do growth, becau…”
Lerner: Growth teams in larger companies must be separate cross-functional units
“When you have a larger company, it needs to stand outside. It needs to be cross-functional and diverse, because growth people have a fundamentally different orientation, different approach to life than other groups, but they need to have really good relationsh…”
Lerner: Screen growth hires for sociability to secure cross-team resources
“Like, you know, when I was hiring these brilliant scientists, the other trait I was screening for was sociability. And people who could just go make friends with the engineers, and the data scientists, and everybody, and just get stuff from people who didn't r…”
Lerner: Every great growth leader started in functional roles like SEO
“Cause every one of these great growth people started as an SEO person or an analyst or a content marketer. And just learned and grew, or an engineer, and just learned and grew very quickly.”
Lerner: AI models perform design and copy better than 90% of people
“AI models can now do design and copy better than 90% of people.”
Lerner: Prospects will become immune to AI outbound outreach within a year
“They will become a nerd to that in a year, but at the moment, the window's kind of still open.”
Lerner: Top European tech talent will leave for founder-friendly environments
“I mean, Europe produces incredible talent, but what you see is a lot of the best talent in Europe is going to move to an environment that's more friendly to startups in terms of regulatory, in terms of funding, in terms of pools of labor, in terms of tax rates…”
Lerner: B2B companies should adopt consumer-style multi-step onboarding funnels
“If you go to some of these sites like Calm or Noom, they have these long convoluted onboarding flows that do a really good job of roping people in Getting them through the whole kind of information journey and building intent. And that's a neat thing because i…”