Apr 6, 2018 · 54m · y-combinator
Cost vs Quality in Edtech – Keith Schacht, Avichal Garg, and Geoff Ralston · Y Combinator
0:00 / 0:00
▶ Watch on YouTube →
gold bands on the timeline = statements, start to end. Hover to read, click to jump. CC turns on captions
Host Geoff Ralston sits down with edtech entrepreneurs Avichal Garg and Keith Schacht to discuss the evolving dynamics of educational technology, examining go-to-market strategies, business models, cost versus quality tradeoffs, and the long-term future of global education.
How this conversation actually went
Every chapter scored 0–10 on four independent dynamics. Hover any point for the reasoning behind the score. How this is scored →
The partners as informed peer 5.6 Guest teaching 4.5 Guest disagreement 3.1 The partners pushing back 3.8
speaking balance: gold is the partners, purple is the guest (3 minute bins)
Sharpest disagreement ▶ 26:30 Avichal rejects Keith's quality thesis
Avichal explicitly tells Keith 'I mostly disagree with what you just said' and challenges his Ikea framing using Tesla and iPhone high-end adoption curves.
Hardest push from the partners ▶ 20:36 Geoff calls out Avichal's reversalGeoff directly corners Avichal on his shift in outlook, summarizing that Avichal is effectively telling founders to ignore his own 2011 blog post.
Biggest teaching moment ▶ 29:58 Keith breaks down false quality metricsKeith educates both participants on how relying on standardized test proxies distorts product design, arguing that child motivation and engagement provide the immediate feedback loop for true learning.
The partners hold their own ▶ 11:45 Geoff demonstrates market data with CheggGeoff counters Avichal's skepticism about edtech scale by citing Chegg's multi-billion dollar market cap and rapid revenue growth from digital services.
the scores for every segment, with the reasoning behind each
| Chapter | Topic | The partners as informed peer | Guest teaching | Guest disagreement | The partners pushing back | Why |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Market Realities and Economic Drivers in Education | 4 | 4 | 1 | 1 | Geoff summarizes Avichal's 2011 blog post accurately and sets the stage for reflection. Avichal lays out a historical economic explanation for why American middle-class consumers prioritize cost over quality in education. | |
| Direct-to-School vs. Direct-to-Parent EdTech Markets | 5 | 4 | 2 | 3 | Geoff prompts Keith on selling to schools versus parents, noting that outside tutoring is mostly for affluent families. Keith breaks down the lifecycle of parental educational spending from early childhood through high school. | |
| EdTech Venture Capital and Market Scaling Dynamics | 7 | 5 | 4 | 6 | Geoff directly challenges Avichal's thesis that VCs wouldn't fund edtech, citing Imagine K-12 investments and Chegg's pivot to digital services. Avichal and Keith debate whether edtech lacks breakout IPO candidates compared to consumer tech. | |
| School Infrastructure Shift and Bottom-Up Adoption Models | 6 | 4 | 1 | 1 | Geoff highlights the infrastructure shift enabling software in schools and articulates the bottom-up pull model. Keith draws an analogy to Salesforce's go-to-market strategy displacing legacy textbook publishers. | |
| Re-evaluating the 2011 Thesis and EdTech's Future Outlook | 7 | 3 | 3 | 6 | Geoff reads through Avichal's 2011 points and presses him on whether founders should disregard them today. Avichal concedes that while the present remains challenging, structural changes will make the next five years very different. | |
| Debate on Cost vs. Quality and Student Engagement | 5 | 6 | 7 | 5 | Avichal bluntly disagrees with Keith's consumer analogy, arguing tech adoption starts high-cost before dropping. Keith reframes the debate by arguing standardized tests are false proxies and student engagement is the true quality metric. | |
| The Broader Purpose of Education in Modern Society | 6 | 5 | 5 | 6 | Keith argues against treating education solely as a workforce pipeline, stating knowledge should serve personal fulfillment. Geoff challenges Keith on whether science knowledge truly fosters happiness and argues for civic critical thinking, while Avichal raises the economic reality of student debt. | |
| Strategic Advice for EdTech Founders | 5 | 5 | 2 | 2 | The panel discusses practical advice for prospective founders. Keith offers a contrarian view comparing modern learning science to pre-Newtonian physics, arguing immense value will be unlocked as cognitive mechanics are understood. |
Statements from this episode (14)
Garg: Edtech founders prioritize quality while mainstream US consumers prioritize cost
“The mainstream market really cared much more about cost rather than quality. And the fundamental sort of disconnect between people who start Education businesses and the consumer themselves is, is fundamentally that. The people who start education businesses t…”
Schacht: Parent educational product spending collapses during elementary and middle school
“Once you send your kid off to school full-time, parents remain involved in some respects. I think reading is one of the main ones. They still think, feel like it's their job to make sure they're reading regularly to their child and helping to reinforce, you kn…”
Garg: US edtech growth ramps pale compared to Chinese counterparts
“I don't know the numbers of most of the American companies, but I think they pale in comparison to like Chinese education companies that go from like zero to a billion, you know, an IPO in seven years.”
Garg: Chegg scaled by discounting textbooks, not reinventing learning
“By and large, if you look at Chegg, the way they got to where they are is they didn't reinvent digital learning, they just made textbooks cheaper.”
Ralston: Almost all US schools now have adequate broadband connectivity
“In 20 11, when you wrote that post, the fact is that most schools were not connected with reasonable internet access. Today, almost all of them in the United States are Connected with, you know, enough bandwidth for more than one person could run YouTube at th…”
Schacht: Edtech technology adoption lags enterprise software by ten years
“In the school space, I think that's one of the most significant things is it's, from my perspective, it seems like it is mirroring the enterprise cycle lagging about 10 years or so.”
Schacht: Legacy publishers sell top-down while new edtech sells bottom-up
“We've got the Pearson, McGraw, Houghton Mifflin, that generation of companies who still assume they're going to sell top down and roll out, and then Mystery Science and other tech companies that, that just do the a la carte and roll it up.”
Garg: High school edtech will take longer to transform than early education
“I think there are gonna be pockets of pretty substantial change in the next five years. And some, I think, will just take a while longer. Like, I actually think high schools will take a bit longer than some of these others just because of the phase shift, righ…”
Garg: Education and healthcare struggle because their ROI horizons span decades
“There are two parts of education, which is kind of like healthcare that I think make it really hard. One is the long ROI cycle, right? It's just like, it pays off in 20 years, and us, like, humans are just bad at that, right? We, we're, that's why healthcare, …”
Schacht: Children cannot be taught anything they do not want to understand
“When you understand that a child's motivation is central to learning, you, I mean, one of our internal principles, you can't teach a child something that they don't care to understand. Like, if they don't want to understand it, no amount of trying to shove it …”
Schacht: Teaching science primarily to fill STEM job shortages is mistaken
“I think it is an absolute mistake to say that we should teach children more science because there's a lot of STEM careers out there that, that, that need to be filled. Like, that's absolutely the mistaken approach.”
Garg: $50M to $100M edtech businesses are worthwhile despite VC scale bias
“And I think, especially in Silicon Valley, there's too much of a, Lens of, well, if it's not a billion dollar outcome or if it's not a ten billion dollar exit, it doesn't matter. And there are lots of motivations that people may have. And so the first step, I …”
Schacht: The science of learning is in its infancy like genetic engineering
“When you think of yourself as a learning company, learning is a field that's in its infancy right now. And it's deceptive because it's an old industry. So it feels like, well, we figured all this out and, you know, that's just like, I don't know, some efficien…”