why aren't all 22 resolved? a statement only gets an assessment when the public
record can support or contradict it. opinions and what-ifs never can, and 0 checkable
ones are still open, waiting for their date. predictions held up or didn't;
assertions are supported or contradicted. on every card:
▮▮▮▮▮ certainty ·
▮▮▮▮▮ debate potential. speakers are clickable
Opinion
Gabbert: Private Equity Firms Ruin More Businesses Than They Grow
“One, if you'd looked at their performance generally They've ruined more businesses that they've grown. They just don't, one, they think they're smarter than the owners of people that created the business in the first place. Second, they think they can over lev…”
Insight
Gabbert: 100% Commission Salespeople Work for Themselves, Not Their Employer
“The truth is if somebody's working for you on a hundred percent commission, they're working for themselves. They're not working for you.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Gabbert: Father Refused to Honor Signed 1980 Buyout Agreement for Family Business
“I went, simply went to him, said, here we have the agreement, and he said, I'm not gonna do it. I said, we have a legal agreement, and he said, oh, I'm not gonna do it.”
Opinion
Gabbert: Treating furniture as a fashion business is a big mistake
“Much of the industry thinks they're in the fashion business, and I think it's a big mistake. We think we're in the business of good design, so you'll be happy with it Five years from now, 20 years from now, but we're definitely not in the fashion business from…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Gabbert: Estranged from family for at least a decade after company split
“I basically didn't see family for at least 10 years.”
Insight
Gabbert: Specialized component manufacturing cuts furniture costs and expands customer choice
“So the unique thing we bring to the process is we bring the design, and then we have these different manufacturers Make the components, which actually reduces the cost of the piece, because we got these specialists doing what they do really well. And it has th…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Domestic Manufacturing Offsets China's 30% Wage Advantage Through Freight and Quality
“And we determined that the only advantage you have making it in China is wages, right? It's about a 30% advantage in cost of product. Well, we felt like between freight and quality and a series of other things, we could make up that difference.”
Insight
Simple Furniture Designs Have Low Labor Ratios, Neutralizing Overseas Cost Advantages
“There's a ratio always in making something between the material and the labor. So if you're making a simple classic something out of solid wood, the labor cost is a fairly small percentage of the cost. If you're making something very elaborate, the labor cost …”
Insight
Avoiding Promotional Discounts Eliminates Costly Operational Peaks in Backend Fulfillment
“It has a side benefit of it evens your business pretty, if you have a sale, you're creating peaks in your business. So you got the back end of the business, which is handling the product and delivering to customers. Now you're dealing with these ups and downs …”
Disclosure
Gabbert: Room & Board does not demand supplier exclusivity
“We, you know, we haven't, but we know that some of those people have gone to some of our manufacturers, like our steel manufacturer is a good example.”
Insight
Gabbert: Room & Board achieves vertical integration entirely through supplier partnerships
“I mean, we are truly a vertically integrated company through partnership. That, that's how I think about it. I mean, we care a lot about that steel manufacturer, about how they grow, about are they profitable? About how we balance our business. It's effective …”
Disclosure
Gabbert: Room & Board committed early to operating with zero bank debt
“Early on, we just said no bank debt. We're going to operate with no debt. And we did for years and years and years.”
Insight
A 2% Macroeconomic Decline Triggers a 20-25% Drop in Furniture Sales
“The economy drops two percent. The furniture business will probably drop 20 or 25%. That's just been the history of, as I think, through the years. Because it's such a discretionary purchase, it gets put off first thing.”
Assertion Partly supported
Gabbert: Mid-Century Modern Was Not Mainstream Trend in Mid-20th Century
“People today think of mid-century as being popular then, but that was not the popular design at all. The popular was more of this American colonial turned legs, fabrics that had prints and flowers and birds on them.”
Assertion Partly supported
Gabbert: IKEA Inverted Furniture Retail by Outsourcing Manufacturing in the 1970s
“What really fascinated me was their process in that they designed everything, and then they went to, at that time, Eastern Europe to have it made. So they kind of turned the process upside down. And they said, we are the creators of the product. You are going …”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Gabbert: Father signed legal agreement to sell controlling shares of Gabbert's
“This must have been in 77, maybe, and I said, can we agree that I'm going to buy you out? I'm running the business. I've been running the business for a while. Things are going pretty well, and we had a legal document signed that I would buy his, enough of his…”
Assertion Not publicly verifiable
John Gabbert traded 30% Gabberts stake for full Room & Board ownership
“I own about 30% of the business, and I would trade that 30% for the full ownership of room and board.”
Insight
Gabbert: Maturing consumers shift from flat-pack to permanent, American-made furniture
“This customer we were trying to appeal to, you know, out of college, not a lot of income they don't mind having the IKEA-like product. Well, now it's 10 years later, and they're established in their job, and they want more, not temporary furniture, they want p…”
Insight
Gabbert: High-ticket furniture buyers seek provenance and manufacturing backstories
“How much people like to know what they just spent a fair amount of money for, what the story is behind it. They like to know that piece of furniture in their home and where it was made and why it was made that way and what the materials are. That's not everybo…”
Disclosure
Gabbert: Room & Board transitioned to ESOP via 100% owner financing
“The way that makes sense for us to do it is have a hundred percent owner finance, so there's no bank loan involved. We just, we gave a loan to the employees, basically, the ESOP, to buy the shares from the owners at an established price”
Assertion Not publicly verifiable
Gabbert: Wasted eight years pursuing multiple side ventures before focusing Room & Board
“I spent those next six or eight, eight years. I did a variety of things. I started a business called bedrooms for kids. I had a wholesale showroom. I bought a design studio. So I spent, as I look at it now, I kind of wasted eight years doing things instead of …”
Assertion Not publicly verifiable
Gabbert's Brother Sold the Family Furniture Business for Almost Nothing in 2008
“He sold it for almost nothing in 2008.”