why aren't all 26 resolved? a statement only gets an assessment when the public
record can support or contradict it. opinions and what-ifs never can, and 0 checkable
ones are still open, waiting for their date. predictions held up or didn't;
assertions are supported or contradicted. on every card:
▮▮▮▮▮ certainty ·
▮▮▮▮▮ debate potential. speakers are clickable
Assertion Supported
Wurwand: Dermalogica launched on $14,000 with zero outside funding or debt
“We had 14,000 dollars of self-funding, and we've never take, we never took outside funding, all the way through to the acquisition. We'd never had, we had no debt,”
Insight
Wurwand: Outside experts do not know your business better than founders
“There are people that have more experience, and they may have had more success, and they may have made more money, but it doesn't mean that they're experts about your business. You know your business the best.”
Insight
Wurwand: Outside CEOs struggle when founders insist on having the last word
“The problem probably wasn't the CEOs, the problem was probably us, because we are the founders, you know, we have this sort of, ah, passion about the ownership, and it's very hard to run a company when the founders are in place and kind of want to have the las…”
Insight
Wurwand: Skincare brands need a full product suite to win professional therapists
“Well, because we needed to go in with a full footprint. If we went in with one or two products, we couldn't Capture a skin therapist's attention and say, you need to use this exclusively in your room, and you need to sell this to your clients. It wouldn't have…”
Disclosure
Dermalogica committed exclusively to professional skin therapist distribution
“No, no. Because I'm a skin therapist. We knew that this was an educated sale. It had to be people that understood the skin. And also, these were the people that brought us to the party. And my mum, another piece of advice she gave me was, you leave the party w…”
Insight
Wurwand: Dermalogica Needed a Full Product Line to Win Therapists
“Well, because we needed to go in with a full footprint. If we went in with one or two products, we couldn't Capture a skin therapist's attention and say, you need to use this exclusively in your room, and you need to sell this to your clients. It wouldn't have…”
Disclosure
Wurwand: Dermalogica's wholesale revenue surpassed $250 million prior to Unilever acquisition
“And last year, our wholesale turnover was a little north of two hundred and fifty million dollars.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Wurwand: Dermalogica paid its founding chemist based on manufacturing volume, not sales
“So we figured out, Raymond figured out this amazing kind of way of paying him based on the first two years of manufactured products. So a percentage of The product that we manufactured, not a percentage of sales, because we wanted to make sure he was tied into…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Dermalogica's wholesale revenue exceeded $250 million prior to its acquisition
“And last year, ah, our wholesale turnover was a little north of two hundred and fifty million dollars.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Wurwand negotiated a $14,000 buyout to acquire Dermalogica's original formulas
“Well, I mean, he wanted something extraordinary, and we whittled him down, and it came down to, you know, sort of, 14,000 dollars.”
Disclosure
Wurwand: Dermalogica refused all buyout calls to avoid distraction
“We'd never taken a phone call from anyone that was interested in buying, never even taken a call, because we said we don't even want to have the conversation. It's a distraction.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Wurwand: Dermalogica generated $1 million in first-year revenue
“Did a million dollars in our first year.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Dermalogica's chemist reneged on deferred payments right before their 1986 launch
“So we launched in January of 1986, and the crazy thing was the chemist who developed these formulas, who we were going to pay off over a two-year period, came to us in December of 85, so a month before we were due to launch, and said that he did not believe in…”
Assertion Contradicted
Wurwand: No American-made skincare products existed in the salon industry in 1980s
“And I realized there were no American-made products in the salon industry. There were tons in the department store and in the drug store. There was nothing in the salon industry.”
Disclosure
Wurwand: Dermalogica paid first chemist in manufactured product royalties
“Raymond figured out this amazing kind of way of paying him based on the first two years of manufactured products. So a percentage of The product that we manufactured, not a percentage of sales, because we wanted to make sure he was tied into the fact that if w…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Wurwand: Dermalogica Developed 27 Formulas in Nine Months
“I mean, and in nine months, we had developed 27 formulas, and we'd named them in one afternoon.”
Assertion Contradicted
Jane Wurwand: No American-Made Skincare Products Existed in 1980s Salons
“And I realized there were no American-made products in In the salon industry. There were tons in the department store and in the drug store. There was nothing in the salon industry.”
Assertion Supported
Wurwand: Dermalogica reached $1 million in revenue in its first year
“Did a million dollars in our first year.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Wurwand: Dermalogica bought out its chemist's formulas for $14,000 before launch
“Well, I mean, he wanted something extraordinary, and we whittled him down, and it came down to, you know, sort of, 14,000 dollars.”
Disclosure
Wurwand: Dermalogica launched without mineral oil, fragrance, alcohol, or artificial color
“I wanted no mineral oil, no fragrance, no drying alcohol, no artificial color.”
Assertion Supported
Wurwand: Dermalogica used utilitarian grey-and-white bottles and tubes over ornate jars
“Yeah, we stepped forward with no jars, only bottles and tubes, and we didn't have sort of pink jars with gold tops and pink boxes. We had grey and white packaging.”
Opinion
Wurwand: Sun avoidance is the single best skincare practice
“The single best thing you can do for your skin is keep it out of the sun.”
Disclosure
Wurwand: US market size justified launching Dermalogica on 1% penetration
“And we did the classic immigrant thing where, look at the population, it only takes one percent of the population to buy one product, and it's already enormous, bigger than it could ever be in the UK.”
Insight
Wurwand: Practical skill training guarantees universal employability and independence
“The five words that changed my life were my mom saying to my sisters and myself, learn how to do something. Learn how to do something. She was absolutely adamant that we, each of us, had to get a skill set training, that no matter what happened, if we were som…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Wurwand: Dermalogica formulated 27 products within nine months
“I mean, and in nine months, we had developed 27 formulas, and we'd named them in one afternoon.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Wurwand: Only five of 70 prospective chemists took Dermalogica's calls
“Out of the 70 names we had, five would take our call, and of the five, there was one that Number one, was willing to work with us, and number two, we felt could do it.”