May 1, 2023 · 54m · green-blueprint
America’s green industrial strategy 2.0
Jigar Shah · 14m spoken Stephen Lacey · 12m spoken Katherine Hamilton · 9m spoken Sonia Aggarwal · 8m spoken AI Alexander Hamilton · 50s spoken Brian Dees · 35s spoken John Oliver · 33s spoken Thomas Friedman · 28s spoken Barack Obama · 25s spoken
0:00 / 0:00
gold bands on the timeline = statements, start to end. Hover to read, click to jump. CC turns on captions
Recorded live at the Prelude Ventures Climate Summit, this episode of The Carbon Copy convenes leading energy and policy experts to analyze the mechanics, successes, and challenges of America's revived green industrial strategy.
How this conversation actually went
Every chapter scored 0–10 on four independent dynamics. Hover any point for the reasoning behind the score. How this is scored →
The hosts as informed peer 5.4 Guest teaching 4.0 Guest disagreement 1.7 The hosts pushing back 1.0
speaking balance: gold is the hosts, purple is the guest (3 minute bins)
Sharpest disagreement ▶ 37:15 Shah dismisses government top-down decision making
Shah explicitly pushes back against Lacey's inquiry regarding government picking easy wins, asserting that market entrepreneurs rather than bureaucrats are the smartest people in the room.
Hardest push from the hosts ▶ 53:09 Lacey debunks panelists' guesses in trivia gameLacey rejects the unanimous conclusion of all three panelists by revealing that none of the presented quotes were authentic Biden statements.
Biggest teaching moment ▶ 15:47 Shah educates on intentional industrial strategy vs historical subsidiesShah reframes the discussion by contrasting 2009's broad subsidy approach with today's rigorous sectoral blueprints and intentional public-private coordination.
The host holds their own ▶ 5:49 Lacey demonstrates command of historical clean tech manufacturing dataLacey cites precise statistics contrasting Obama's 40% battery goal with the 5% outcome alongside specific domestic market shares in wind turbine components.
the scores for every segment, with the reasoning behind each
| Chapter | Topic | The hosts as informed peer | Guest teaching | Guest disagreement | The hosts pushing back | Why |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Historical Precedents: From Alexander Hamilton to Obama-Era Clean Energy | 7 | 0 | 0 | 0 | Host Stephen Lacey opens with an extensive historical framing comparing Alexander Hamilton's 1791 report to Obama-era clean energy initiatives. He cites specific data regarding Obama's 40% battery production goal versus the reality of 5%, alongside domestic wind manufacturing figures. | |
| Clean Tech Evolution: Comparing Today's Policy Carrots to the 2009 Era | 5 | 3 | 1 | 1 | Lacey sets up the core question of why today's green industrial push differs from past efforts. The guests collaboratively break down the shift from regulatory sticks to financial carrots, declining clean tech cost curves, and direct production incentives. | |
| The Triple Policy Whammy and Strategic Liftoff Reports | 6 | 6 | 3 | 1 | Lacey introduces RMI's 'triple whammy' policy framework. Jigar Shah pushes back on standard commentary, arguing that critics miss the intentionality of current industrial strategy and the sectoral Liftoff Reports compared to 2009's broad subsidy scattershot. | |
| Political Dynamics and Red State Clean Tech Investment | 5 | 6 | 2 | 1 | Lacey frames political skepticism around the Green New Deal using a Tom Friedman archival clip. Shah counters the premise of bipartisan gridlock by providing specific LPO metrics, noting 134 applications and strong bipartisan backing in conservative districts. | |
| Scaling Industrial Decarbonization and the Sectoral Liftoff Strategy | 6 | 6 | 1 | 1 | Lacey cites concrete federal funding numbers for industrial decarbonization before asking about the Liftoff strategy. Shah details the hundred-billion-dollar private capital threshold required for commercial bankability across hydrogen, carbon management, and storage. | |
| Industrial Heat, Process Electrification, and Coal Plant Replacement | 5 | 5 | 4 | 1 | After Aggarwal and Hamilton explain industrial heat electrification and coal plant conversions, Lacey asks Shah what gives him heartburn and where the easy wins are. Shah rejects the premise, stating it is not the government's place to pick winners or know all the answers. | |
| The Transmission Bottleneck: Planning, Permitting, and Grid Modernization | 6 | 4 | 1 | 1 | Lacey introduces the transmission crisis with DOE study statistics and interconnection queue backlog numbers. The guests walk through practical fixes including reconductoring, FERC planning, and permitting reform. | |
| Virtual Power Plants and Distributed Energy Integration | 6 | 5 | 2 | 1 | Lacey constructs a nuanced two-part question connecting federal transmission funds to distribution-level virtual power plants. Shah details the economics of moving to a supply-following grid and LPO's recent loan commitments. | |
| Live Audience Segment: The "Biden or Bot" Game | 3 | 1 | 1 | 2 | Lacey moderates a lighthearted trivia game featuring AI-generated presidential quotes, successfully misleading the panelists before concluding the live event. |
Statements from this episode (19)
Lacey: US makes just over 5% of global batteries despite Obama-era goals
“In fact, rather than making 40% of batteries, like Obama envisioned, we now make Just over five percent.”
Lacey: Domestic manufacturing accounts for 80% of US nacelles and 70% of wind towers
“But in contrast, 80% of nacelle assembly and 70% of tower manufacturing for domestic wind projects happen right here in America.”
Shah: DOE Loan Programs Office holds over $400B in loan authority
“Obviously, where we have over four hundred billion dollars of loan authority that we're putting to work to get this done.”
Shah: Fracking technology directly powers enhanced geothermal energy
“We have all this extraordinary hydro, you know, hydraulic fracturing technology that has set us apart, right? And that technology is the exact technology that powers enhanced geothermal.”
Shah: A massive part of the private sector ignores the DOE
“Right now, we have a part of the private sector that's coordinating with the government to tell us exactly how they want to allocate capital and how they want us to use our capital, but there's a huge part of the private sector that, for whatever reason, is no…”
Shah: DOE Loan Programs Office has 134 applications seeking $121 billion
“We have a 134 applications in the Loan Programs Office seeking a hundred and twenty-one billion dollars of loan proceeds. It's in about a 165 locations out of those 134 applications, and many of them are in red districts.”
Shah: Tennessee committed $200M to accelerate TVA nuclear deployment at Clinch River
“The governor of Tennessee put up two hundred million dollars of state money to help support you know, TVA accelerating the, you know, deployment of those at Clinch River.”
Shah: Clean tech sectors require $100B in private investment for bankability
“It turns out that you roughly need a hundred billion dollars of private sector investment to get across the bridge to bankability to full market acceptance, right? Which doesn't save you a gigaton Of carbon, but it gets the technology to a cost-effective point…”
Shah: US has $46B in announced clean hydrogen capital allocation
“So on hydrogen We're probably at around forty six billion dollars worth of capital allocation for hydrogen projects that have already been announced, and we're on track to doing about ten million tons of hydrogen production, clean hydrogen production, by the e…”
Shah: US has $40B in announced carbon sequestration investment
“I think the same thing is true out of the carbon liftoff report where we've got about forty billion dollars worth of investment already announced, mostly for easy to abate easy to capture sources, right? So natural gas processing, ethanol, ammonia, right? So w…”
Shah: Long-duration energy storage faces market failures with only $9B invested
“By contrast, you have two other liftoff reports we have in there the advanced nuclear liftoff report, and then the long duration energy storage report, where we're probably only on track to maybe nine billion dollars worth of investment in long duration energy…”
Aggarwal: Burning clean hydrogen should be minimized across industry
“From a kind of overall system efficiency economics, and kind of pollution standpoint, trying to minimize the amount of hydrogen that you're burning, actually, is probably a good direction to go in.”
Aggarwal: 50% to 70% of industrial heat can be electrified today
“About 50 to 70% of all the heat used in the industrial sector right now could be electrified with commercially available technologies.”
Hamilton: Remaining uneconomic coal plants exist solely to supply industrial heat
“The only reason they are still in existence is because they have to provide heat to a paper mill, or to some other industrial facility, and those are things we can tackle right away”
Shah: DOE and John Kerry are organizing advanced market commitments
“And if they need help with an advanced market commitment so that you know, folks who want to pay a premium for clean steel or clean cement or other things, like, you know, we're doing that too at the Department of Energy in coordination with Climate Envoy Kerr…”
DOE Study: Grid Must Accommodate 3-4x Renewable Increase in a Decade
“According to a study released in February by the Department of Energy, the transmission system needs to accommodate a three to four X increase in renewable electricity in about a decade, and boy, oh boy, is that going to be difficult.”
Lacey: Over 1 Terawatt of Renewables Sits in Interconnection Queues
“We have over a terawatt of renewables capacity sitting in interconnection queues, partly because of transmission constraints.”