why aren't all 12 resolved? a statement only gets an assessment when the public
record can support or contradict it. opinions and what-ifs never can, and 2 checkable
ones are still open, waiting for their date. predictions held up or didn't;
assertions are supported or contradicted. on every card:
▮▮▮▮▮ certainty ·
▮▮▮▮▮ debate potential. speakers are clickable
Insight
Schroepfer: Customers buy savings, making 'climate tech' a confusing category label
“I would actually say it even slightly stronger, which is we use this word climate tech like it's an actual good definition of a market segment. When we just talked about like, I sell products to consumers that save the money. I'll sell products to consumers th…”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Schroepfer: Well-funded tech companies will build massive power capacity globally
“Underhyped in the sense that I like Respectfully disagree with Nick, which is just look at NVIDIA's earning calls. Like people are buying those chips and powering them up. So, and I think companies are, I spent a lot of time being incredibly creative about fin…”
Prediction Open · timeframe May 2030
Schroepfer: Economically viable fusion will produce history's largest companies
“And so I think this is a very binary thing, that if we can actually hit unit economics that are competitive in fusion, It'll create the largest companies we've ever seen.”
Prediction Open · timeframe May 2030
Schroepfer: Nature-based carbon removal will hit sub-$100/ton surprisingly fast
“I think we will be shocked at how fast, low cost, particularly nature-based carbon removal systems, and when I say nature-based, I don't mean planting trees. I mean, enhanced rock weathering. I mean, ocean alkalinity enhancement. I mean, biochar. These are sys…”
Opinion
Schroepfer: Consumer demand response is overhyped due to fragmentation and friction
“I'm gonna say consumer sort of demand response is overhyped. It's just, like, so damn hard to get consumers to sign up for these things, and it's such a fragmented Market that getting to reasonable scales is hard.”
Insight
Schroepfer: AI does not solve climate tech's manufacturing scale-up bottleneck
“AI for material science, great for discovering new materials. The manufacturing scale-up is usually the hard part. So great, I've got this new MOF. I've got to make a lot of it very cheaply. The AI doesn't really help me very much with that. Like, in theory, m…”
Disclosure
Schroepfer: Meta's Portal Failed Because Dedicated Video Chat Market Was Too Small
“We built this thing at medical or Facebook at the time called the portal. And it was a video chat device and it was amazing. It was basically center stage before you had it. You could stick it in the corner and video chat with your kids and it would follow you…”
Assertion Supported
Schroepfer: Geoengineering to lock current temperatures costs ~$10B annually
“About ten billion a year to, like, lock in current, current temperatures.”
Opinion
Schroepfer: Wave Power Is Probably the Largest Untapped Energy Source
“Wave power is basically concentrated wind energy. And there's a tremendous amount of it out there, and we're harnessing very little of it. So it is probably the largest single untapped energy source on the planet.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Schroepfer: EVs and manufacturing drive US power demand alongside data centers
“Overhyped in the sense that people over attribute data center load growth with electricity demand inside the United States. You know, manufacturing and EVs are a huge portion of that. So people think it's all data centers. It's not.”
Opinion
Schroepfer: Commercial and enterprise demand response is underhyped due to scale
“And I think enterprise and commercial demand responses is sort of underhyped. There's just so much, there's big money there to be saved when you're, when I'm operating many hundred megawatt plant, like I can save a lot of money.”
Assertion Partly supported
Schroepfer: US Produces None of Six Critical Minerals Banned by China
“China just, you know, banned the export of six major critical minerals. We make none of these in the United States so that seems like a real big problem.”