why aren't all 8 resolved? a statement only gets an assessment when the public
record can support or contradict it. opinions and what-ifs never can, and 0 checkable
ones are still open, waiting for their date. predictions held up or didn't;
assertions are supported or contradicted. on every card:
▮▮▮▮▮ certainty ·
▮▮▮▮▮ debate potential. speakers are clickable
Assertion Supported
McGavis: 80% of cooling equipment emissions come from energy use, 20% from refrigerants
“80% of the of the CO₂ impact from a piece of equipment is that energy efficiency or the energy that's created to run the equipment. The only, the other 20% comes from the refrigerant.”
Assertion Contradicted
McGavis: Data centers are currently the largest consumer of cooling
“Today, the biggest consumer of cooling is data centers. So as we talk about AI and all the AI applications, all that doesn't exist without a significant amount of cooling to keep those servers warm and keep those data centers operating.”
Assertion Supported
McGavis: Refrigerant reclamation is an economic problem, not a technological one
“The technology exists. Nothing has to be developed to be able to successfully recover, reclaim, and refrigerants. It is more of a, frankly, it's more of an economic problem right now.”
Assertion Supported
McGavis: Europe is shifting to natural refrigerants over PFAS concerns
“In Europe, for example they have they are moving back towards, I shouldn't say back towards, they are moving towards natural refrigerants, so, you know, propane and CO₂, because they are restricting the use of these ultra-low GWP refrigerants because of the PF…”
Assertion Partly supported
McGavis: Commercial refrigeration is the single largest refrigerant emitter
“You know, the single biggest emitter is the refrigeration sector, and that's Primarily the, what I'd call the commercial refrigeration sector. That's supermarkets, convenience stores, and that's the single largest emitter.”
Assertion Supported
McGavis: Reclaimed refrigerant is more expensive than virgin refrigerant
“The market price for reclaimed refrigerant is more expensive than it is to use virgin refrigerant.”
Assertion Partly supported
McGavis: Current residential refrigerants have 2,000 GWP, transitional substitutes reach 600-700
“The refrigerants primarily in use today, the GWP is around 2000. And, you know, I'll use R-Four-Ten-A as an example. It's what's most common in the residential market in the, in, around the world. And so, the GWP there is roughly 2000. So the replacement refri…”
Assertion Supported
McGavis: R-410A cannot be shipped in new equipment starting next year
“The first of the year R-Forten-A, which is kind of the most common refrigerant used in the commercial refrigeration residential the residential markets won't be available to ship in new equipment”