Top-three carbon credit broker applied a massive 23x markup
Alistair Frew (Alistair Fury) · The carbon market’s quality problem · Jun 8, 2023 · at 45:39
Alistair Fury, CEO of carbon credit ratings firm Sylvera, discusses opacity and broker margins in voluntary carbon markets with Shayle Kann.
0:00 / 0:14exact quote · 14.0s
720p mp4 · rendered on demand · StarZero watermark
“The biggest markup we've seen from a top three broker. This is, I won't name names cause it's probably just a bit much, but it's 23 times. So, so like, so somebody's buying a credit for 85 cents and selling it for like 20 bucks.”
quote is from the automated transcript, cleaned for reading: filler sounds and stutters are removed, nothing is rephrased. names can be misheard (the analysis reads context, assessments check outside sources). how →
More from Alistair Frew (Alistair Fury)
Fury: Forestry projects frequently claim credits for pre-funded government plantings
“Maybe your, maybe the field report was in China, and the Chinese government paid us fully to do that project as part of its, like, regional reforestation initiatives five years before the project even started, right? So, and this is, like, not a theoretical ex…”
Carbon auditor approved dead mangrove project because specific sample plots survived
“And we've seen that, for example, in a mangrove project where we were asking the auditor who's doing the verification, the MRV, hey, you know, what was going on in the project? We knew that most of the mangroves were dead, right? So, and they were like saying,…”
Sylvera rates under a quarter of carbon credits in top three grades
“We would say of the credits on the market the minority have like a strong environmental integrity. So you'd maybe say around, well actually less than a quarter, we would rate in our top three grades. And now you would have very, very high degree of confidence …”
Fury: Carbon credit prices were initially inversely correlated with project quality
“In fact, at the beginning, when we first did our first kind of plot of the market price versus the rating, they were inversely correlated. So it's basically like the better the credit, the cheaper it was.”
Fury: None of 40+ biochar developers shared data with Sylvera
“In the biochar sector we reached out to over 40 developers And typically, you can issue credits with, for biochar without having to go through a very process where you'd have public documentation and a level of transparency. Not a single one would share us any…”
Fury: Lack of legal liability incentivizes carbon developers to inflate impact figures
“Where there's an incentive for the number to be high and there's no legal no legal consequence for you putting an extra zero on the end. People tend to put an extra zero on the end which is just like human nature and like, you know, people want their, they bel…”