Jun 23, 2022 · 50m · catalyst
Which tech is overhyped, underhyped and just right?
0:00 / 0:00
gold bands on the timeline = statements, start to end. Hover to read, click to jump. CC turns on captions
In this episode of Catalyst, host Shayle Kann and energy experts Dr. Lara Pierpoint and Stephen Lacey play a game of 'Buy, Sell, Hold' to separate genuine market potential from speculative hype across clean technologies, storage, electrification, and carbon management.
How this conversation actually went
Every chapter scored 0–10 on four independent dynamics. Hover any point for the reasoning behind the score. Shayle holds 44.5% of the talking time here. How this is scored →
Shayle as informed peer 6.3 Guest teaching 2.3 Guest disagreement 2.3 Shayle pushing back 4.0
speaking balance: gold is Shayle, purple is the guest (3 minute bins)
Sharpest disagreement ▶ 32:16 Lara pushes back on hydrogen leakage optimism
Lara directly challenges Shayle's dismissal of hydrogen leakage concerns, arguing that uncertainties around real-world leakage rates could prove even worse than natural gas.
Hardest push from Shayle ▶ 34:22 Shayle rejects V2G viabilityShayle firmly rejects Lara's hold rating on vehicle-to-grid, outlining why battery degradation and poor economics ensure grid discharge will not scale.
Biggest teaching moment ▶ 9:35 Lara contextualizes NRC regulatory posture on OkloLara reframes Shayle's skeptical question about Oklo's license rejection, explaining insider industry dynamics and constructive regulatory engagement behind the scenes.
Shayle holds their own ▶ 30:46 Shayle critiques GWP methodology in hydrogen leakage reportsShayle demonstrates deep domain knowledge by critiquing the 5-year vs. 100-year global warming potential metrics used in recent high-profile hydrogen leakage studies.
the scores for every segment, with the reasoning behind each
| Chapter | Topic | Shayle as informed peer | Guest teaching | Guest disagreement | Shayle pushing back | Why |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Contestants and Rules for Buy, Sell, Hold | 4 | 0 | 1 | 2 | Shayle lays out the rules and framing of the game, setting the scope around hype cycles rather than absolute technology viability. The guests engage playfully in banter regarding Reddit meme stocks and EV SPACs. | |
| Lara Pierpoint's Buy: Advanced Nuclear Energy | 6 | 5 | 2 | 5 | Lara presents her buy on advanced nuclear, citing Diablo Canyon and shifting public opinion. Shayle challenges her by asking about the Nuclear Regulatory Commission's recent rejection of Oklo's application, which Lara contextualizes as regulatory growing pains rather than a fatal setback. | |
| Stephen Lacey's Buy: Heat Pumps and Building Decarbonization | 6 | 4 | 2 | 3 | Stephen pitches heat pumps based on user experience and hybrid conversion economics. Shayle and Lara broadly agree while nuancing the hype level by distinguishing residential vs. industrial heat pump applications. | |
| Shayle Kann's Buy: Non-Lithium Battery Chemistries | 8 | 1 | 3 | 3 | Shayle delivers a detailed thesis on non-lithium stationary storage, explaining how EV priority over grid storage and commodity crunches create market openings. Stephen and Lara offer mild pushback regarding persistent alternative chemistry scaling bottlenecks. | |
| Stephen Lacey's Hold: Lithium-Ion Battery Recycling | 5 | 4 | 1 | 2 | Stephen explains his hold rating on battery recycling, contrasting pyro- and hydro-metallurgy and emphasizing national security supply chain drivers. Lara and Shayle largely concur with the assessment. | |
| Midroll Sponsor: Bloom Energy and ENGIE | 8 | 2 | 4 | 7 | Following the midroll ads, Shayle pitches hydrogen and directly challenges recent studies from EDF and the UK on hydrogen leakage, arguing that 5-year GWP timeframes distort hydrogen's true 100-year climate impact. Lara defends the study's warning regarding infrastructure leakage risks. | |
| Lara Pierpoint's Hold: Vehicle-to-Grid (V2G) Systems | 6 | 1 | 3 | 6 | Lara rates vehicle-to-grid as a hold tied to fleet electrification, but Shayle pushes back firmly with a sell, arguing that battery degradation, warranty issues, and thin economics make V2G net unviable compared to smart managed charging. | |
| Shayle Kann's Sell: Web3 and Voluntary Carbon Markets | 7 | 1 | 1 | 3 | Shayle presents a sell on Web3 carbon markets, arguing crypto addresses liquidity and discovery when the true problem is high-quality supply. Both guests quickly agree. | |
| Lara Pierpoint's Sell: Carbon to Value and Utilization | 6 | 3 | 2 | 4 | Lara sells carbon-to-value due to mismatched commodity pricing and lack of true permanence. Shayle counters by noting selective emerging demand for high-end carbon-negative materials and products. | |
| Climate Tech Lightning Round: Audience Picks from Twitter | 7 | 2 | 4 | 5 | The panel rapidly scores Twitter-suggested categories including fusion, geothermal, transmission, and e-micromobility, offering quick analytical rationales with frequent amicable splits. |
Statements from this episode (25)
Lacey: Reddit and Retail Investors Drove Tesla's Pandemic Surge
“I mean, the Tesla's rise during the pandemic had a lot to do with the Reddit community and a lot of those new armchair investors.”
Pierpoint: California majority now favors keeping Diablo Canyon nuclear plant open
“And so for the first time in decades, you actually see more people Wanting to keep the Diablo Canyon plant open than wanting to close it.”
Lacey: Meaningful decarbonization from advanced nuclear is still far away
“It feels to me, though, that the technology cycles are still quite long, and as a real meaningful decarbonization solution, it's still a ways out.”
Kann: The NRC rejected Oklo's petition out of hand in 2022
“They rejected their petition, like out straight up out of hand earlier this year.”
Lacey: The US sells 4M heat pumps and 6M AC units annually
“We sell four million heat pumps a year in this country, and we sell six million residential air conditioning units.”
Lacey: Biden administration invoked Defense Production Act for heat pump manufacturing
“Actually, the Biden administration just announced that they're going to use the Defense Production Act to encourage production of heat pumps for residential and commercial applications, and there was a bill introduced in the Senate that would encourage manufac…”
Kann: Europe will see even stronger heat pump tailwinds than US
“I mean, there's definitely going to be tailwinds for heat pumps in the U S for sure, but in Europe, even more so, I think for the next few years.”
Kann: Battery OEMs will always prioritize EVs over stationary grid storage
“Battery OEMs, all things equal, will pick EVs over stationary storage, because they're going to sell way more batteries into electric vehicles than they are into the grid. So if they have to pick and choose and they're limited in supply stationary storage is g…”
Kann: Supply crunch creates opening for alternative grid battery chemistries
“And I think this is creating an opening For a bunch of alternative chemistries, flow batteries, sodium batteries, zinc-based batteries, metal air batteries, a bunch of other technologies that, that do look really interesting on paper and have specs that lithiu…”
Lacey: Alternative battery chemistries must stand without lithium price spikes
“So these technologies may get a second look, but I think that, you know, they need to stand on their own absent these commodity price spikes.”
Lacey: Market forces and national security now strongly favor battery recycling
“I think now you have a really clear economic, national security, and environmental case for battery recycling. So there's a lot of activity right now, and it's pretty compelling, and the market forces Are definitely in favor of this push for more battery recyc…”
Kann: Clean hydrogen will significantly decarbonize ammonia, chemicals, and heavy industry
“In the sectors where, first of all, we already use hydrogen, things like ammonia and chemicals production and then potentially in a few other really difficult to abate industrial sectors including to some extent in the power sector, I think hydrogen is going t…”
Kann: Zero-carbon hydrogen will get cheaper sooner than expected
“I also think that it is going to be cheaper, clean hydrogen, zero C hydrogen is going to be cheaper sooner than people generally appreciate.”
Pierpoint: Hydrogen is probably not going to power passenger vehicles
“I think we're all sort of in agreement that passenger vehicle transportation is
Probably not in the offing for hydrogen.”
Kann: Even with 10% leakage, hydrogen yields an 80% GHG reduction
“Even in a worst-case scenario, like worst-case leakage, 10% hydrogen leakage is crazy.
Nobody expects that to happen.
Even then, over the course of a hundred years, hydrogen is like an 80% reduction in
In greenhouse gases.”
Pierpoint: Commercial fleet electrification is the sweet spot for vehicle-to-grid
“And I think if you electrify fleets, that's really the sweet spot for vehicle to grid applications.”
Kann: Electric vehicles will never discharge to the grid at scale
“I do not think we'll ever see vehicles discharging into the grid at scale.”
Kann: Web3 cannot solve the shortage of high-quality carbon credits
“The actual challenge is A very limited supply of high quality carbon credits or carbon removals and a huge supply of really low quality, really bad carbon credits or offsets. That is the actual problem, and Web three is not really a solution to that.”
Pierpoint: Clean crypto mining can function as a flexible grid resource
“If you're going to be making crypto, do it cleanly. And if you do it cleanly, that actually starts to become sort of interesting as a grid resource because there's a way to shift load into making crypto and you can make money when there's really high amounts o…”
Pierpoint: Carbon-to-value faces structural volume and pricing trade-offs
“And this has just always been a really tough space because the places where you have a lot of volume, like, you know, making cement you have really low commodity prices. So it's hard to get a good price for the carbon that you're capturing. And in places where…”
Pierpoint: Carbon credit buyers will increasingly demand permanence and clarity
“I think what's really gonna drive some of the carbon markets in the near term are a lot of the companies that are actually interested in buying credits, and when they do that, they want to see, I think they're increasingly going to want to see some level of pe…”
Lacey: Renewable natural gas can only meet 20% of gas demand
“Pretty much every state study and government study shows that it can only be, you know, that, that you were looking at between five and 20% Of the total gas supply. That's the amount of renewable gas that we could supply.”
Kann: Every big company will be forced to use carbon accounting software
“I mean, you know, I would be a sell on some of the valuations of some of the companies in that space, but it's going to happen. Every big company is going to have to do it one way or another.”
Lacey: Transmission hype outpaces the reality of difficult US construction
“Relative, the hype relative to the reality of building out transmission lines that they don't match up. And I have to, I unfortunately have to be a sell. Even though, you know, I generally support lots more transmission build out in this country. I think it's …”
Kann: E-micromobility is returning via personal ownership rather than shared fleets
“I think the model of shared scooters that was the thing that was really hyped a few years ago, I mean, I wouldn't necessarily be a buy on that today. You see a lot less of that, but I think ownership of e-bikes, e-scooters, stuff like that is starting to pick …”