active management

23 statements across 20 episodes · 9 bullish · 9 bearish · 19 people on the record · first statement May 17, 2017 by Jenny Heller · across every show →

Everything said about active management, oldest first

May 17, 2017 bearish
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Heller: Active alpha will never reliably return to 2000-era levels
“I think alpha's never going to be as high on a repeatable basis as it probably was in 2000 or one, but we still believe in active management very much.”
Jenny Heller May 17, 2017 ▶ 37:55 Jennifer Heller – Thinking it Through (Capital Allocators, EP.07)
May 22, 2017 bearish
Insight
Ellis: Overcoming fees and transaction costs requires 33% outperformance
“With certain carefully identified exceptions, you, not only is it very difficult, you won't, and you almost can't, outperform the market after two big things. And it doesn't look big when you say it, only one percent. But if you say, wait a minute, seven perce…”
Charlie Ellis May 22, 2017 ▶ 32:40 Charley Ellis – Multiple Ways to Win (Capital Allocators, EP.08)
May 30, 2017 neutral
Assertion Supported
Solomon: Total active management assets are at an all-time high
“Active management today, there's more assets in active management today than there ever has been. So it's not that active management has gotten smaller. It's just gotten smaller as a percentage of the overall market.”
Jeffrey Solomon May 30, 2017 ▶ 20:51 Jeffrey Solomon – Vision, Tenacity, and Empathy (Capital Allocators, EP.09)
May 30, 2017 bullish
Prediction Open · timeframe May 2027
Solomon: Active Management Will Not Disappear
“One, active management isn't going away. So I think there will always be a portion of the market that wants to outperform and is willing to pay for the option around outperformance. So I think that's going to still be here.”
Jeffrey Solomon May 30, 2017 ▶ 48:15 Jeffrey Solomon – Vision, Tenacity, and Empathy (Capital Allocators, EP.09)
Jan 8, 2018 bearish
Assertion Supported
Mauboussin: Standard Deviation Of Active Manager Alpha Has Narrowed Over Time
“So one of the ways to quantify that as we measure the standard deviation of excess returns, the standard deviation of alpha, right? So you imagine alpha plotted as a bell shaped distribution, which is roughly not a horrible way to look at it. And that bell has…”
Michael Mauboussin Jan 8, 2018 ▶ 14:58 Michael Mauboussin – Active Challenges, Rational Decisions and Team Dynamics (Capital Allocators, EP.36)
Jan 8, 2018 positive
Insight
Mauboussin: Forced Sellers And Buyers Create Active Investing Opportunities
“There are people who are for sellers. There are people who are forced buyers and they're doing things that are non-economic or for non-economic reasons. And those can present opportunities for the other side.”
Michael Mauboussin Jan 8, 2018 ▶ 1:05:25 Michael Mauboussin – Active Challenges, Rational Decisions and Team Dynamics (Capital Allocators, EP.36)
Mar 19, 2018 bullish
Opinion
Active management holds an advantage over passive indexing in emerging markets
“I think recently we introduced a emerging markets fund. It took us a little while to get the structure put into place because of some of the things that are unique in emerging markets and clearing. But that is an area that certainly we believe that active has …”
Wayne Wicker Mar 19, 2018 ▶ 31:49 Wayne Wicker - Managing for Millions who Matter (Capital Allocators, EP.44)
Apr 23, 2018 bearish
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Active managers have three years to prove outperformance over passive ETFs
“So the industry basically has three years starting now to prove it can do it. If three years from now, we still have meeting an active manager below the ETF, the story will ride itself.”
Michael Cembalest Apr 23, 2018 ▶ 59:49 Michael Cembalest – Eye on the Market (Capital Allocators, EP.49)
Jun 11, 2018 positive
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Lydon: Active managers will prove value by protecting against market declines
“So we're not really yet in a period where active management can really show its worth, but I think we're going to be getting there, and that's really going to get us more back to full circle, where active managers are going to come in. They can show that maybe…”
Tom Lydon Jun 11, 2018 ▶ 34:05 Tom Lydon – ETF Trends (Capital Allocators, EP.56)
Jan 14, 2019 neutral
Insight
Hynes: Rising data and IT costs threaten mid-sized active asset managers
“Differentiated investment insights about the world will still matter, but you're going to need to invest in IT, and you're going to need to invest in science to augment that art, and so how do mid-sized companies continue to make those investments? I know they…”
Jean Hynes Jan 14, 2019 ▶ 50:40 Jean Hynes – Inside Wellington Management (Capital Allocators, EP.82)
Jul 8, 2019 bullish
Insight
Active Management Outperforms Passive Indexing in Emerging and Frontier Markets
“As you move out of the U.S. Into non-U.S. Equities, and the further afield you go into emerging markets and eventually into frontier markets, then the attractiveness of active versus passive becomes compellingly active.”
Ash Williams Jul 8, 2019 ▶ 49:08 Ash Williams – Florida SBA's Reigning Chief (Capital Allocator, EP.104)
Aug 19, 2019 neutral
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Druley: Less active management could make markets less efficient
“In some ways, it may provide us even additional opportunity if you have less people actually pursuing active management. It could make the markets a little less efficient, if you will.”
David Druley Aug 19, 2019 ▶ 44:32 David Druley – Structure into Action at Cambridge Associates (Capital Allocators, EP. 106)
Aug 19, 2019 negative
Insight
Druley: Active management in aggregate delivers net negative returns after fees
“In aggregate of all the people going through the effort, is it worth it? No. Because we know that after fees, in aggregate, it's gonna be a negative return relative to the index, if you will.”
David Druley Aug 19, 2019 ▶ 43:40 David Druley – Structure into Action at Cambridge Associates (Capital Allocators, EP. 106)
Sep 9, 2019 neutral
Disclosure
Whineray: NZ Super Fund holds zero active managers in developed listed markets
“We've got two managers in New Zealand that run active equities. We've got one global emerging markets active manager, and that's it. Right. So we don't have any developed markets, active managers. We don't have any fixed income market active managers in those …”
Matt Whineray Sep 9, 2019 ▶ 47:46 Matt Whineray – Leading New Zealand Super Fund (Capital Allocators, EP.108)
Apr 2, 2020 bullish
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Baumgartner: Active Management Will See a Golden Resurgence in Coming Years
“I'd specifically point out that I think active management is going to have a golden resurgence here in the coming years.”
Mark Baumgartner Apr 2, 2020 ▶ 26:20 Mark Baumgartner – Allocating in a Crisis at IAS (Capital Allocators, EP.128)
Jul 9, 2020 positive
Insight
Mizuno: Passive Investing Becomes Inefficient Without Active Investors Setting Prices
“Passive investment is effective or efficient because it take all the active managers or the active investors opinion into their pricing. So the basically they are free riding all the other active investors. I'm not only talking about active portfolio manager, …”
Hiro Mizuno Jul 9, 2020 ▶ 20:59 Sustainable Investing 10: Hiro Mizuno – Changing the Game (Capital Allocators, EP.148)
Nov 2, 2020 negative
Insight
Trigg: Active management struggles because career risk drives groupthink and benchmark-hugging
“I think these really counterproductive behaviors that largely explain why active management struggles, and it's a lot of group think. People are worried about standing out from the crowd. They're worried about careers. So they play it safe. They hug the benchm…”
Mike Trigg Nov 2, 2020 ▶ 49:08 Mike Trigg – Defying the Fade at WCM (Capital Allocators, EP.162)
Nov 9, 2020 negative
Insight
Williams: Uncontrolled Macro Factors Frequently Swamp Active Managers' Bottom-Up Stock Selection
“And what we found generally was that a lot of times the factors would swamp the good work that they were doing on the individual positions in the portfolio. So all this great analysis and research Being put into individual decisions, but macroeconomic effects …”
Karyn Williams Nov 9, 2020 ▶ 33:46 Karyn Williams – Measuring Risk Practically at Hightree Advisors (Capital Allocators, EP.163)
Dec 21, 2020 bullish
Prediction Not checkable as stated
André Perold: Concentrated active management will always have a place
“So there is absolutely a sense of time arbitrage in the markets. I think you see it in all markets. And as long as that's the case, I think longer dated, concentrated active management will always have a place. I don't see it going, even in the largest cap sto…”
André Perold Dec 21, 2020 ▶ 38:28 André Perold – Pockets of Inefficiency at HighVista Strategies (Capital Allocators, EP.169)
Sep 9, 2023 bearish
Insight
Seides: Active management faces steep obstacles in market efficiency and fees
“Investors hoping to beat the odds by playing the game of active management face daunting obstacles ranging from the efficiency and pricing of most marketable securities to the burden of extraordinary fees in most alternative asset investment vehicles. Success …”
Ted Seides Sep 9, 2023 ▶ 4:18 WTT: The Real Yale Model
Dec 23, 2024 bullish
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Hynes: Market concentration will broaden, favoring active managers over index funds
“I think what will benefit active management is that Concentration broadens. I'm a big believer that those seven companies will be successful only if the benefits broaden to the economy around the world, and so I would suspect that you're in an environment in t…”
Jean Hynes Dec 23, 2024 ▶ 42:25 Training Grounds: Wellington Management – Jean Hynes (EP.423)
Sep 15, 2025 negative
Opinion
Meli: Mega-Cap Tech Outperformance Impaired Active Fund Performance
“I basically think mega cap technology killed a lot of the active management world.”
Adrian Meli Sep 15, 2025 ▶ 38:56 Adrian Meli – Active Equity Excellence at Eagle (EP.459)
Jan 26, 2026
Insight
MacDonald: Go passive in low dispersion and active in high dispersion
“Where there's dispersion, you go active. Where there's low dispersion, like public equity, you go passive.”
Lane MacDonald Jan 26, 2026 ▶ 34:44 Lane MacDonald – Teamwork, Alignment, and Investing at the Highest Levels at SCS (EP.483)
Made with StarZero

Turn any episode into a week of clips.

This entire site, over 700 episodes transcribed, diarized, checked and made playable, runs on the StarZero media pipeline. Drop in your own episode and the podcast clipper finds the moments worth sharing, cuts them, captions them, and reframes them for every feed.