why aren't all 19 resolved? a statement only gets an assessment when the public
record can support or contradict it. opinions and what-ifs never can, and 0 checkable
ones are still open, waiting for their date. predictions held up or didn't;
assertions are supported or contradicted. on every card:
▮▮▮▮▮ certainty ·
▮▮▮▮▮ debate potential. speakers are clickable
Opinion
Koch: Top-down command-and-control is the world's biggest problem
“This is our, the biggest problem in the world and it always has been this what Nietzsche called and Victor Franklin called the will to power. And that is, ah, this top-down approach that, because I'm smarter than you, or I want power over you, ah, to approach …”
Insight
Koch: Public attacks on our philanthropic network actually attract supporters
“These attacks in many ways help us, because they call attention to what we're doing. So people are interested in finding out, and when they find out they find that what we're doing is the opposite of what we're attacked for. And so it attracts more people to w…”
Opinion
Koch: Philanthropies chasing politically correct trends are often destructive
“And you see, philanthropies doing that. Just, okay, whatever's current in choice, whatever's politically correct, we're, we'll do that. And a lot of that is destructive”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Koch: No society in human history has ever truly had equal rights
“All we've got to do is move toward a society of truly equal rights, which we've never truly had. No society has truly had it. Equal rights and mutual benefit, where people succeed by helping others improve their lives, and everybody has the opportunity to real…”
Insight
Koch: Empowering individual contribution drives progress over coercion
“What we find It makes people's lives better, and improves society, improves well-being, and leads to progress, is empowering everybody to contribute. That is going from, ah, forcing people to do things, motivating them to find their gift, believe in themselves…”
Assertion Partly supported
Koch Industries grew 10,000-fold versus Koch's initial 70-fold projection
“And so I projected, I, you know, being a math, I plotted it all out if we grow this much, and by the time I retire, we will have grown seventy-fold, I predicted. And so that was my goal. And so far it's been more than 10,000 fold.”
Insight
Koch: Organizational leverage comes from empowering employees to challenge practices
“And then the secret in an organization is to get All of your employees to do that, to fully engage them, to get them all to be self, to start self actualizing and looking for these gaps and challenging and finding new ways to do things that are better.”
Insight
Koch: Businesses should maximize value for others, not just profit
“Why people think, oh, I want to maximize my profit. No, you want to focus on maximizing the value you create for others. And then if they don't reward you for it, well, then you need to find better customers.”
Disclosure
Koch: Our philanthropic network strictly opposes corporate welfare
“They may Be into corporate welfare, and we're opposed to corporate welfare, and that undermines equal rights and mutual benefit.”
Disclosure
Koch Industries invested over $30 billion in tech in six years
“So we've been in the last half dozen years or so, we've invested over thirty billion in technology and all these forms.”
Disclosure
Koch: Supervisors' primary job is helping employees self-actualize
“And we apply the Division of Labor by Comparative Advantage, and we, every supervisor's first job is helping their employees self, self-actualize.”
Opinion
Koch: Technology enables personalized education and fast aptitude discovery
“And education, rather than top-down, one-size-fits-all. The technology's there to give everybody the opportunity to discover Their aptitudes, not take 20 years to find them like it did me, but find them quickly, and learn, and be excited about, and want to lea…”
Insight
Koch: Growth requires compounding cycles of mutual benefit and capability expansion
“Our vision and for our business and our, started leading our five dimensions is to start with, ah, what capabilities we have that, ah, would, ah, enable us to do things, create products and services that other people would value. In other words, how do we crea…”
Insight
Koch: Organizational entropy constantly degrades adherence to core principles
“And when we have applied these principles, we've been tremendously successful, but entropy is at work always pulling you down, pulling you away from the principle, so it, it's continual renewal.”
Insight
Charles Koch: True scientific method means finding flaws, not confirming evidence
“This is from Karl Popper's Science is Falsification. A true scientific method Is developing a testable proposition, and not, not, not going around trying to find things supported, but find the flaw in it.”
Disclosure
Koch: Internal challenge process always improves or disproves my proposals
“And any idea I have, I find, ok, what are the key drivers of success in this? Who can really challenge those, how we're applying each of those drivers of success? And then so we brainstorm that, they challenge, show me what's wrong with My idea, or how it can …”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Koch Industries gets many operational innovations from frontline mechanics
“No, we find, we get many of our best ideas, particularly in operations, from operators or mechanics, and they, because they become aware of this, oh, we can use this technology, and we can, here, we'll do it this way.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Koch's father made him do farm chores starting at age six
“His way of preventing that is to have me work in all my spare time, starting at age six, and so I did all the dirty jobs on the farm, and you can imagine that's plenty, whether it's milking cows, shoveling manure digging fenced holes, fenced post holes and fee…”
Opinion
Koch: I was a lousy engineer despite excelling at MIT coursework
“I was a lousy engineer, because although I was good at the subjects I took in math and science, and really interested in them, I wasn't good at applying them to make or operate Things, which is what an engineer does.”