Jun 19, 2025 · 51m · american-optimist
Why California is Collapsing From Within · Joe Lonsdale
0:00 / 0:00
▶ Watch on YouTube →
gold bands on the timeline = statements, start to end. Hover to read, click to jump. CC turns on captions
In this episode of American Optimist, host Joe Lonsdale interviews gubernatorial candidate Steve Hilton on how California's state over-regulation, homelessness, and housing crises can be solved through practical political reform. Hilton outlines his background, details the state's major policy failures, and presents an electoral strategy to unite working-class voters across the state.
How this conversation actually went
Every chapter scored 0–10 on four independent dynamics. Hover any point for the reasoning behind the score. Joe holds 14% of the talking time here. How this is scored →
Joe as informed peer 5.0 Guest teaching 4.6 Guest disagreement 1.8 Joe pushing back 1.8
speaking balance: gold is Joe, purple is the guest (3 minute bins)
Sharpest disagreement ▶ 27:17 Hilton rejects Lonsdale's 'moderate red' characterization
When Lonsdale suggests that California requires a 'very moderate red' approach, Hilton directly disagrees, stating he dislikes the term and argues for aggressive action against state bureaucracy.
Hardest push from Joe ▶ 44:42 Lonsdale pushes Hilton on California's anti-Trump partisan barrierLonsdale challenges Hilton's electoral viability, arguing that regardless of sound policy arguments, California voters will reject any Republican candidate due to visceral hostility toward Donald Trump.
Biggest teaching moment ▶ 32:48 Hilton explains the structural Medicaid barrier to mental health facilitiesHilton educates Lonsdale on the obscure 1965 Medicaid IMD 16-bed cap rule and California's refusal to apply for federal waivers, explaining why psychiatric care capacity remains severely constrained.
Joe holds their own ▶ 41:37 Lonsdale demonstrates local planning graft from firsthand experienceLonsdale showcases his own direct knowledge of regulatory corruption by recounting how Woodside planning officials forced him to pay favored geologists to dig an absurd 80-foot trench before approving his barn conversion permit.
the scores for every segment, with the reasoning behind each
| Chapter | Topic | Joe as informed peer | Guest teaching | Guest disagreement | Joe pushing back | Why |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Steve Hilton on Hungarian Refugee Heritage and Move to Silicon Valley | 3 | 2 | 1 | 0 | Lonsdale warmly introduces Steve Hilton and asks about his Hungarian refugee heritage, Oxford background, and decision to relocate to California. Hilton shares his personal story and naturalization journey in an amicable opening exchange. | |
| Unpacking the Bureaucracy, Administrative State, and Lessons from Brexit | 5 | 6 | 2 | 1 | Hilton gives a granular breakdown of how unelected bureaucracies function via 48-hour deemed-approved write-rounds in the UK/EU. Lonsdale follows attentively and draws an analogy to broken investment committees where departments rubber-stamp each other's agendas. | |
| Media Career at Fox News, COVID Coverage, and Public Free Speech | 5 | 4 | 2 | 3 | Lonsdale probes whether Fox News exerted editorial boundaries, citing Tucker Carlson's shift outside the network, but Hilton insists he experienced total freedom to challenge COVID orthodoxy and lockdown policies. | |
| Transitioning from Media to Politics and Fighting State Over-Regulation | 5 | 3 | 1 | 3 | Lonsdale challenges Hilton on whether the median California voter actually wants bold contrarian leadership. Hilton explains his transition from TV commentary to launching Golden Together to solve housing and regulatory burdens. | |
| Small Business Challenges, PAGA Lawsuit Exploitation, and California's Spirit | 5 | 5 | 1 | 1 | Both interlocutors rail against state labor regulations. Hilton explains how the Private Attorney General's Act (PAGA) creates extortionate legal liabilities for small restaurants, while Lonsdale notes employers feel guilty until proven innocent. | |
| Decades of One-Party Control, Union Power, and Emerging Electoral Changes | 6 | 5 | 4 | 3 | Lonsdale outlines a three-party model of California politics and suggests successful reform must be 'moderate red.' Hilton rejects the 'moderate' framing, asserting that dismantling the state's bloated bureaucracy requires aggressive reform. | |
| Tackling Homelessness, Housing First Failures, and Mental Health Reform | 5 | 7 | 2 | 1 | Hilton provides a thorough policy explanation of homelessness failures in California, pointing out the statutory flaws of 'Housing First' and the federal Medicaid 16-bed IMD restriction that blocks scalable mental health facilities. | |
| Housing Affordability, Environmental Law Abuse, and Construction Innovations | 7 | 6 | 1 | 1 | Hilton breaks down how CEQA private rights of action and Project Labor Agreements inflate home construction costs. Lonsdale reinforces this with a personal anecdote about being required to dig an unnecessary 80-foot trench in Woodside to obtain a building permit. | |
| Overcoming Partisan Obstacles in California | 6 | 5 | 3 | 5 | Lonsdale presses Hilton on how he will overcome visceral anti-Trump sentiment among California general election voters. Hilton counters with historical turnout and midterm vote counts showing a path to victory. | |
| Reaching Latino Voters and the Ladder of Opportunity | 3 | 3 | 1 | 0 | Hilton highlights the working-class Latino demographic as the critical constituency for political change in California, closing with a call to action for his gubernatorial campaign. |
Statements from this episode (19)
Hilton: UK policy write-rounds auto-approved after 48 hours without response
“So there's two, two crucial ways in which the bureaucracy enable this. Number one is that the, that if they don't, they're supposed to write these letters to the relevant cabinet committee, and they're supposed to respond. The time, if there's no response, it'…”
Hilton: 70% of UK policy came from EU directives and internal bureaucracy
“And it turned out that about 70% of it, I said, what proportion of it is necessary for the implementation of what we're supposed to be here to do, the actual program of the coalition government? The answer is 30%. The rest of it was either implementing EU dire…”
Hilton: Fox News Exercised Zero Editorial Control Over My Show
“Incredible freedom. No editorial control at all. Or guidance even.”
Hilton: I was the first TV host to link COVID to Fauci
“I was the first on TV to lay out all the evidence showing that it was Fauci's experiments that were the origin of the pandemic.”
Hilton: Lawyers and government unions are California Democrats' primary funders
“Lawyers, along with government unions, are the main funders of Democrat politicians in California.”
Hilton: Many California restaurants budget $1M annually for PAGA workplace lawsuits
“Many restaurant owners I meet, they say they factor into their cost of doing business a million dollars a year for PAGA lawsuits.”
Hilton: California government unions spend $1 billion annually on political contributions
“The government unions, by the way, it's a billion dollars a year. So one billion dollars a year. To politics. Just from the unions.”
Hilton: Prop 36 passed with 70% statewide and majorities in every county
“So prop 36 last year kind of reversed most of that. That passed with 70% in every county. 70% statewide majorities in every county.”
Hilton: Ten California counties flipped from blue to red in November 2024
“10 counties flipped from blue to red in, in November last year.”
Hilton: Less than half of California students meet basic English standards
“We have, like, barely half a student, less than half a students, Meet basic state standards in English.”
Hilton: San Francisco Homeless Housing Costs Up to $1M Per Unit
“They defined shelter as what they call permanent supportive housing, which is an apartment unit costing because of all the other Corruption and regulation involved in house building in California, 700,000 dollars, 800,000 dollars, a million dollars now in San …”
Hilton: California's 2016 Housing First law bans sobriety requirements for homeless shelters
“They passed a law in 2016, the only state in America to do it implementing in legislation this approach called Housing First. Which says that you've got to, the number one thing is, and it sounds like a sensible thing, of course, give homeless people housing, …”
Hilton: California Failed to Apply for Trump-Era Federal Mental Health Waiver
“The first Trump administration created a waiver from the IMD rule that states could apply for. Guess what? California hasn't applied for the rule.”
Hilton: Developing 1% more California land would house 10 million people
“If we increase the development footprint of California from five percent to six percent, which would still put us really low in, in terms of other states, you could have housing for ten million people in single family homes on quarter acre lots”
Hilton: Over 1 million approved California housing units are blocked by lawsuits
“You've got over a million housing units in California that have been approved by local government, gone through zoning, compliant with CEQA and all the other environmental rules, blocked by lawsuits.”
Hilton: 70% of CEQA Lawsuits Are Filed to Block Housing
“70% of lawsuits under CEQA are used to block housing.”
Hilton: California Republican statewide vote share has averaged 41.7% over 20 years
“The average share of the vote for Republican statewide candidates in the last 20 years, since the last time Republicans won, is 41.7%.”
Hilton: Trump's 6.1M California votes exceed the threshold to win a midterm
“If you look at the data on roughly what you could expect in terms of turnout in 20, 26, it's about 11.7, 11.8 million votes. It's based on the average of the last two midterms. So to win, you need about 5.9 million. Trump just got 6.1 million.”