StarZero All shows Try the podcast clipper →

Mar 1, 2023 · 35m · american-optimist

John Chambers & Pankaj Patel Changed the World with Cisco. Now They're Doing It Again with Nile. · Joe Lonsdale

John Chambers · 14m spoken Pankaj Patel · 13m spoken Joe Lonsdale · 4m spoken
0:00 / 0:00
▶ Watch on YouTube →

gold bands on the timeline = statements, start to end. Hover to read, click to jump. CC turns on captions

Host Joe Lonsdale interviews tech pioneers John Chambers and Pankaj Patel to explore their legendary scaling of Cisco Systems and their new venture, Nile, which aims to revolutionize enterprise networking using artificial intelligence. The conversation covers lessons in disruptive innovation, startup culture, advising global leaders on digital transformation, and fostering economic optimism.

How this conversation actually went

Every chapter scored 0–10 on four independent dynamics. Hover any point for the reasoning behind the score. Joe holds 15.2% of the talking time here. How this is scored →

Joe as informed peer 3.3 Guest teaching 3.3 Guest disagreement 0.1 Joe pushing back 0.3
05100:0010:0020:0030:000:00–7:51 · Joe as informed peer 3/10 Podcast Trailer and Title Sequence Joe introduces John Chambers and Pankaj Patel, setting up their historic Cisco track record and investment background. John and Pankaj detail Cisco's scaling history, acquisitions, and revenue growth in an entirely collaborative exchange.7:51–14:02 · Joe as informed peer 3/10 Reimagining Enterprise Networking with Nile's Autonomous Architecture Pankaj educates the host on enterprise campus networking complexity, highlighting the hundreds of protocol knobs and permutations creating snowflake environments. Joe playfully pushes back that Cisco originally created this complexity, which John concedes.14:02–21:38 · Joe as informed peer 4/10 Stealth Execution, Market Convergence, and Disruption Dynamics Joe asks about stealth development and why large incumbents fail to disrupt themselves. Pankaj and John detail the convergence of cloud, AI/ML, and SaaS business models that enabled Nile's emergence.21:38–25:13 · Joe as informed peer 5/10 Cultivating Culture and Retaining Top Global Engineering Talent Joe demonstrates domain knowledge regarding typical tech salary hopping and high attrition in India. Pankaj explains how hiring seasoned talent with 15-20 years of experience and focusing on transparent engineering culture keeps attrition in single digits.25:13–27:33 · Joe as informed peer 2/10 Leadership Origins and Transforming West Virginia into a Startup Hub Joe inquires into John's West Virginia roots and personal leadership philosophy. John explains his dyslexia, family upbringing, and the initiative to transform West Virginia into an innovation and startup hub.27:33–29:43 · Joe as informed peer 3/10 Advising Heads of State on Global Digital Transformation Joe prompts John on his international advisory work with heads of state. John shares lessons from mentoring leaders in Israel, France, and India on building digital infrastructure and startup economies.29:43–35:36 · Joe as informed peer 3/10 Executive Dynamics: The 25-Year Partnership of Patel and Chambers The conversation closes with reflections on Pankaj and John's 25-year working relationship and their mutual optimism for the future. John shares an anecdote about Shimon Peres testing an electric car despite security constraints.0:00–7:51 · Guest teaching 2/10 Podcast Trailer and Title Sequence Joe introduces John Chambers and Pankaj Patel, setting up their historic Cisco track record and investment background. John and Pankaj detail Cisco's scaling history, acquisitions, and revenue growth in an entirely collaborative exchange.7:51–14:02 · Guest teaching 6/10 Reimagining Enterprise Networking with Nile's Autonomous Architecture Pankaj educates the host on enterprise campus networking complexity, highlighting the hundreds of protocol knobs and permutations creating snowflake environments. Joe playfully pushes back that Cisco originally created this complexity, which John concedes.14:02–21:38 · Guest teaching 4/10 Stealth Execution, Market Convergence, and Disruption Dynamics Joe asks about stealth development and why large incumbents fail to disrupt themselves. Pankaj and John detail the convergence of cloud, AI/ML, and SaaS business models that enabled Nile's emergence.21:38–25:13 · Guest teaching 3/10 Cultivating Culture and Retaining Top Global Engineering Talent Joe demonstrates domain knowledge regarding typical tech salary hopping and high attrition in India. Pankaj explains how hiring seasoned talent with 15-20 years of experience and focusing on transparent engineering culture keeps attrition in single digits.25:13–27:33 · Guest teaching 3/10 Leadership Origins and Transforming West Virginia into a Startup Hub Joe inquires into John's West Virginia roots and personal leadership philosophy. John explains his dyslexia, family upbringing, and the initiative to transform West Virginia into an innovation and startup hub.27:33–29:43 · Guest teaching 3/10 Advising Heads of State on Global Digital Transformation Joe prompts John on his international advisory work with heads of state. John shares lessons from mentoring leaders in Israel, France, and India on building digital infrastructure and startup economies.29:43–35:36 · Guest teaching 2/10 Executive Dynamics: The 25-Year Partnership of Patel and Chambers The conversation closes with reflections on Pankaj and John's 25-year working relationship and their mutual optimism for the future. John shares an anecdote about Shimon Peres testing an electric car despite security constraints.0:00–7:51 · Guest disagreement 0/10 Podcast Trailer and Title Sequence Joe introduces John Chambers and Pankaj Patel, setting up their historic Cisco track record and investment background. John and Pankaj detail Cisco's scaling history, acquisitions, and revenue growth in an entirely collaborative exchange.7:51–14:02 · Guest disagreement 1/10 Reimagining Enterprise Networking with Nile's Autonomous Architecture Pankaj educates the host on enterprise campus networking complexity, highlighting the hundreds of protocol knobs and permutations creating snowflake environments. Joe playfully pushes back that Cisco originally created this complexity, which John concedes.14:02–21:38 · Guest disagreement 0/10 Stealth Execution, Market Convergence, and Disruption Dynamics Joe asks about stealth development and why large incumbents fail to disrupt themselves. Pankaj and John detail the convergence of cloud, AI/ML, and SaaS business models that enabled Nile's emergence.21:38–25:13 · Guest disagreement 0/10 Cultivating Culture and Retaining Top Global Engineering Talent Joe demonstrates domain knowledge regarding typical tech salary hopping and high attrition in India. Pankaj explains how hiring seasoned talent with 15-20 years of experience and focusing on transparent engineering culture keeps attrition in single digits.25:13–27:33 · Guest disagreement 0/10 Leadership Origins and Transforming West Virginia into a Startup Hub Joe inquires into John's West Virginia roots and personal leadership philosophy. John explains his dyslexia, family upbringing, and the initiative to transform West Virginia into an innovation and startup hub.27:33–29:43 · Guest disagreement 0/10 Advising Heads of State on Global Digital Transformation Joe prompts John on his international advisory work with heads of state. John shares lessons from mentoring leaders in Israel, France, and India on building digital infrastructure and startup economies.29:43–35:36 · Guest disagreement 0/10 Executive Dynamics: The 25-Year Partnership of Patel and Chambers The conversation closes with reflections on Pankaj and John's 25-year working relationship and their mutual optimism for the future. John shares an anecdote about Shimon Peres testing an electric car despite security constraints.0:00–7:51 · Joe pushing back 0/10 Podcast Trailer and Title Sequence Joe introduces John Chambers and Pankaj Patel, setting up their historic Cisco track record and investment background. John and Pankaj detail Cisco's scaling history, acquisitions, and revenue growth in an entirely collaborative exchange.7:51–14:02 · Joe pushing back 2/10 Reimagining Enterprise Networking with Nile's Autonomous Architecture Pankaj educates the host on enterprise campus networking complexity, highlighting the hundreds of protocol knobs and permutations creating snowflake environments. Joe playfully pushes back that Cisco originally created this complexity, which John concedes.14:02–21:38 · Joe pushing back 0/10 Stealth Execution, Market Convergence, and Disruption Dynamics Joe asks about stealth development and why large incumbents fail to disrupt themselves. Pankaj and John detail the convergence of cloud, AI/ML, and SaaS business models that enabled Nile's emergence.21:38–25:13 · Joe pushing back 0/10 Cultivating Culture and Retaining Top Global Engineering Talent Joe demonstrates domain knowledge regarding typical tech salary hopping and high attrition in India. Pankaj explains how hiring seasoned talent with 15-20 years of experience and focusing on transparent engineering culture keeps attrition in single digits.25:13–27:33 · Joe pushing back 0/10 Leadership Origins and Transforming West Virginia into a Startup Hub Joe inquires into John's West Virginia roots and personal leadership philosophy. John explains his dyslexia, family upbringing, and the initiative to transform West Virginia into an innovation and startup hub.27:33–29:43 · Joe pushing back 0/10 Advising Heads of State on Global Digital Transformation Joe prompts John on his international advisory work with heads of state. John shares lessons from mentoring leaders in Israel, France, and India on building digital infrastructure and startup economies.29:43–35:36 · Joe pushing back 0/10 Executive Dynamics: The 25-Year Partnership of Patel and Chambers The conversation closes with reflections on Pankaj and John's 25-year working relationship and their mutual optimism for the future. John shares an anecdote about Shimon Peres testing an electric car despite security constraints.

speaking balance: gold is Joe, purple is the guest (3 minute bins)

0:00 · Joe 35.2% · guest 64.8%0:00 · Joe 35.2% · guest 64.8%3:00 · Joe 12.7% · guest 87.3%3:00 · Joe 12.7% · guest 87.3%6:00 · Joe 28.1% · guest 71.9%6:00 · Joe 28.1% · guest 71.9%9:00 · Joe 7.5% · guest 92.5%9:00 · Joe 7.5% · guest 92.5%12:00 · Joe 15.6% · guest 84.4%12:00 · Joe 15.6% · guest 84.4%15:00 · Joe 5.7% · guest 94.3%15:00 · Joe 5.7% · guest 94.3%18:00 · Joe 4.3% · guest 95.7%18:00 · Joe 4.3% · guest 95.7%21:00 · Joe 14.9% · guest 85.1%21:00 · Joe 14.9% · guest 85.1%24:00 · Joe 14.2% · guest 85.8%24:00 · Joe 14.2% · guest 85.8%27:00 · Joe 16.7% · guest 83.3%27:00 · Joe 16.7% · guest 83.3%30:00 · Joe 10.3% · guest 89.7%30:00 · Joe 10.3% · guest 89.7%33:00 · Joe 19.4% · guest 80.6%33:00 · Joe 19.4% · guest 80.6%
Sharpest disagreement ▶ 8:48 Admitting responsibility for industry-wide network complexity

In a very warm and non-combative episode, John and Pankaj address Joe's jab about Cisco creating network complexity by acknowledging the design decisions of earlier computing eras.

 Hardest push from Joe ▶ 8:40 Joe ribbing guests about legacy networking flaws

Joe directly teases the guests that the tens of billions spent fixing network support costs is their fault from their decades building Cisco.

 Biggest teaching moment ▶ 9:51 Pankaj breaking down the mathematical complexity of campus networks

Pankaj methodically explains how combining 10 architectures, 20 protocols, hundreds of knobs, and multiple OS revisions creates hundreds of thousands of snowflake permutations that AI alone could not solve without unified architectural simplification.

 Joe holds their own ▶ 21:41 Joe analyzing compensation hopping in the Indian engineering market

Joe displays deep operational awareness of modern engineering talent dynamics in India, contrasting industry-standard double-digit job-hopping with Nile's low turnover.
the scores for every segment, with the reasoning behind each
ChapterTopicJoe as informed peerGuest teachingGuest disagreementJoe pushing backWhy
Podcast Trailer and Title Sequence 3200 Joe introduces John Chambers and Pankaj Patel, setting up their historic Cisco track record and investment background. John and Pankaj detail Cisco's scaling history, acquisitions, and revenue growth in an entirely collaborative exchange.
Reimagining Enterprise Networking with Nile's Autonomous Architecture 3612 Pankaj educates the host on enterprise campus networking complexity, highlighting the hundreds of protocol knobs and permutations creating snowflake environments. Joe playfully pushes back that Cisco originally created this complexity, which John concedes.
Stealth Execution, Market Convergence, and Disruption Dynamics 4400 Joe asks about stealth development and why large incumbents fail to disrupt themselves. Pankaj and John detail the convergence of cloud, AI/ML, and SaaS business models that enabled Nile's emergence.
Cultivating Culture and Retaining Top Global Engineering Talent 5300 Joe demonstrates domain knowledge regarding typical tech salary hopping and high attrition in India. Pankaj explains how hiring seasoned talent with 15-20 years of experience and focusing on transparent engineering culture keeps attrition in single digits.
Leadership Origins and Transforming West Virginia into a Startup Hub 2300 Joe inquires into John's West Virginia roots and personal leadership philosophy. John explains his dyslexia, family upbringing, and the initiative to transform West Virginia into an innovation and startup hub.
Advising Heads of State on Global Digital Transformation 3300 Joe prompts John on his international advisory work with heads of state. John shares lessons from mentoring leaders in Israel, France, and India on building digital infrastructure and startup economies.
Executive Dynamics: The 25-Year Partnership of Patel and Chambers 3200 The conversation closes with reflections on Pankaj and John's 25-year working relationship and their mutual optimism for the future. John shares an anecdote about Shimon Peres testing an electric car despite security constraints.

Statements from this episode (12)

Assertion Supported
Chambers: Cisco grew from $70M to $48B and created 10,000 employee millionaires
“We went from a company that had seventy million in sales when I joined, and it went to forty-eight billion. Ah, we were number one or number two in 15 of 18 product areas, number three in just three. We created 10,000 millionaires among our employees, so we sh…”
John Chambers Mar 1, 2023 ▶ 1:27
Insight
Chambers: Late market entrants cannot reach number one without partnering or acquiring
“Once the market take off, you can't think I'll be the 10th player in this market three years later and become number one. It doesn't happen. So if we weren't one of the first movers, we partnered with one of them or acquired”
John Chambers Mar 1, 2023 ▶ 5:50
Insight
Chambers: Customers whose problems you solve become more loyal than trouble-free accounts
“And oddly enough, customers who had problems that you helped solve the problem even if it was created by us ended up being more loyal customers and actually grew faster than the ones who didn't.”
John Chambers Mar 1, 2023 ▶ 7:02
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Chambers: Customers recommended almost all of Cisco's 180 acquisitions
“Ah, out of the 180 acquisitions, almost all of them, it was a customer who told us we should buy them.”
John Chambers Mar 1, 2023 ▶ 7:32
Assertion Supported
Chambers: Support costs comprise 75% of enterprise network expenses
“Where 75% of your cost of networks are the support costs, not the product costs.”
John Chambers Mar 1, 2023 ▶ 9:16
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Chambers: Nile will transform networking like AWS transformed cloud
“Think about what Cisco did to all the networking companies. Think about what Amazon did in the cloud. Think what Apple did in terms of ease of use. That really is what now is going to do this industry if we do it right.”
John Chambers Mar 1, 2023 ▶ 21:25
Assertion Supported
Chambers: West Virginia University scaled from zero to 35 startups
“We've got 35 startups at the university from zero.”
John Chambers Mar 1, 2023 ▶ 27:01
Assertion Supported
Chambers: West Virginia has attracted ten billion-dollar projects
“We've attracted now ten billion dollar projects into the state.”
John Chambers Mar 1, 2023 ▶ 27:04
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Chambers: France became Europe's top startup environment in five years
“France went from the worst startup environment in Europe to the best in just five years. State of uniform unicorn growth is the fastest there”
John Chambers Mar 1, 2023 ▶ 28:10
Prediction Open · timeframe Mar 2033
Chambers predicts India will outgrow the world for the next decade
“You watch, ah, one economy that's gonna outgrow the rest of the world for the next decade, It'll be India. Wouldn't surprise me to see him grow in the nine to 11% range for a decade.”
John Chambers Mar 1, 2023 ▶ 28:48
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Chambers: Almost all future jobs will come from startups
“So it's going to be a startup world in the future. That's where almost all jobs will come from.”
John Chambers Mar 1, 2023 ▶ 28:57
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Chambers: Modi Dreams Big and Will Change India in a Big Way
“Modi definitely has it in India. He dreams very big. He'll change that, that country in a big way”
John Chambers Mar 1, 2023 ▶ 35:05
Made with StarZero

Turn any episode into a week of clips.

This entire site, over 150 episodes transcribed, diarized, checked and made playable, runs on the StarZero media pipeline. Drop in your own episode and the podcast clipper finds the moments worth sharing, cuts them, captions them, and reframes them for every feed.

Try the podcast clipper Learn more