why aren't all 59 resolved? a statement only gets an assessment when the public
record can support or contradict it. opinions and what-ifs never can, and 0 checkable
ones are still open, waiting for their date. predictions held up or didn't;
assertions are supported or contradicted. on every card:
▮▮▮▮▮ certainty ·
▮▮▮▮▮ debate potential. speakers are clickable
Assertion Partly supported
Rosenthal: Skilling Was the Only Enron Executive Who Did Not Plead the Fifth
“He's the only one who doesn't end up pleading the fifth. Like, he defends himself to the end.”
Assertion Supported
Ben Gilbert: Kinder Morgan is worth $40B and Richard Kinder $8B
“It was an energy pipeline, and today, Kinder Morgan is a forty billion dollar company, and Kinder Is a billionaire. He's worth like eight billion dollars.”
Assertion Supported
Gilbert: John Ray recovered $13B (36¢/$1) for Enron's creditors
“He was able to get thirteen billion out to creditors, which is about 36 cents on the dollar. Much better than the 17 cents that Stephen Cooper, that his plan called for.”
Assertion Supported
Ben Gilbert: GE's wind energy business was acquired from Enron
“GE bought the wind business from Enron, and I believe even today is sort of the cornerstone of their wind energy business.”
Assertion Supported
Rosenthal: Skilling negotiated Enron offer while wife was in labor
“He calls them up to do the final negotiations of the terms of his offer. He calls them up from the hospital where he is with his wife while his wife is in labor with their, I think, second child.”
Assertion Supported
Rosenthal: Dynegy agreed to acquire Enron for $8B and lent $1.5B
“Dyna G's gonna Acquire Enron for eight billion dollars, an all stock deal, no cash, but Enron of course needs more cash to survive until the deal can close and Dynergy can complete its due diligence. So Dynergy lends one and a half billion dollars to Enron in …”
Assertion Supported
Enron won Fortune's Most Innovative Company award six consecutive years
“It was even named Fortune Magazine's most innovative company six years in a row.”
Assertion Partly supported
Enron stock dropped from over $90 to the $40s by spring 2001
“The Enron stock starts falling from the all-time high in the fall of the previous year, just above 90 dollars a share, falls down into the forties. So, like, pretty bad. It's lost, like, over half its value.”
Assertion Contradicted
Enron peaked as the seventh-largest US company by market capitalization
“It was the seventh biggest company in America by market cap.”
Assertion Supported
Rosenthal: Enron's December 2001 Bankruptcy Was the Largest in U.S. History
“On December second, indeed, just a few days later, Enron files for chapter 11 bankruptcy. At the time, the largest bankruptcy in U.S. History.”
Assertion Supported
Gilbert: Lehman Had Hundreds of Billions in Assets vs. Enron's $63B
“Lehman is the largest. It's the only one in the, like, high hundreds of billions, whereas Enron had sixty-three billion in assets before filing.”