StarZero All shows Try the podcast clipper →

May 12, 2022 · 1h 33m · acquired

Arena Show Part I: Idea Dinner + YC Continuity · Acquired

Ben Gilbert · 23m spoken Anu Hariharan · 21m spoken David Rosenthal · 14m spoken Packy McCormick · 6m spoken Mario Gabriele · 4m spoken Shu Nyatta · 3m spoken Travis Hedge · 3m spoken Matt Spitz · 2m spoken
0:00 / 0:00
▶ Watch on YouTube →

gold bands on the timeline = statements, start to end. Hover to read, click to jump. CC turns on captions

Recorded live before an audience at Seattle's Climate Pledge Arena, Ben Gilbert and David Rosenthal host a high-stakes stock-pitch showdown and conduct an in-depth interview with Y Combinator Continuity's Anu Hariharan on scaling growth-stage startups.

How this conversation actually went

Every chapter scored 0–10 on four independent dynamics. Hover any point for the reasoning behind the score. Ben and David hold 47.6% of the talking time here. How this is scored →

Ben and David as informed peer 3.3 Guest teaching 3.0 Guest disagreement 1.0 Ben and David pushing back 1.3
05100:0020:0040:001:00:001:20:000:00–5:36 · Ben and David as informed peer 0/10 Welcome to the Arena Show and Opening Remarks Introductory monologue where Ben and David welcome the audience to Climate Pledge Arena and outline the agenda for the live show. There are no guests on stage during this segment.5:36–41:18 · Ben and David as informed peer 6/10 Act One: The Live Idea Dinner Stock Pitch Contest Ben and David pitch stocks alongside Packy McCormick and Mario Gabriele in front of judge Shu Nyatta. The hosts demonstrate substantial knowledge by detailing valuation multiples, free cash flow figures, and cloud market dynamics, while Shu provides constructive critique on their lack of downside analysis.41:18–46:14 · Ben and David as informed peer 2/10 Sponsor Spotlight: Automated Compliance with Vanta's Matt Spitz A friendly sponsor conversation with Matt Spitz of Vanta. Ben and David prompt Matt to explain automated SOC II compliance and security monitoring in an entirely cooperative tone.46:14–1:23:18 · Ben and David as informed peer 5/10 Act Two: Scaling YC Continuity with Anu Hariharan Anu Hariharan breaks down YC Continuity's fund structure, community programs, and qualitative founder evaluation methods. The hosts display strong venture capital literacy by synthesizing frameworks such as leading versus trailing indicators.0:00–5:36 · Guest teaching 0/10 Welcome to the Arena Show and Opening Remarks Introductory monologue where Ben and David welcome the audience to Climate Pledge Arena and outline the agenda for the live show. There are no guests on stage during this segment.5:36–41:18 · Guest teaching 4/10 Act One: The Live Idea Dinner Stock Pitch Contest Ben and David pitch stocks alongside Packy McCormick and Mario Gabriele in front of judge Shu Nyatta. The hosts demonstrate substantial knowledge by detailing valuation multiples, free cash flow figures, and cloud market dynamics, while Shu provides constructive critique on their lack of downside analysis.41:18–46:14 · Guest teaching 2/10 Sponsor Spotlight: Automated Compliance with Vanta's Matt Spitz A friendly sponsor conversation with Matt Spitz of Vanta. Ben and David prompt Matt to explain automated SOC II compliance and security monitoring in an entirely cooperative tone.46:14–1:23:18 · Guest teaching 6/10 Act Two: Scaling YC Continuity with Anu Hariharan Anu Hariharan breaks down YC Continuity's fund structure, community programs, and qualitative founder evaluation methods. The hosts display strong venture capital literacy by synthesizing frameworks such as leading versus trailing indicators.0:00–5:36 · Guest disagreement 0/10 Welcome to the Arena Show and Opening Remarks Introductory monologue where Ben and David welcome the audience to Climate Pledge Arena and outline the agenda for the live show. There are no guests on stage during this segment.5:36–41:18 · Guest disagreement 3/10 Act One: The Live Idea Dinner Stock Pitch Contest Ben and David pitch stocks alongside Packy McCormick and Mario Gabriele in front of judge Shu Nyatta. The hosts demonstrate substantial knowledge by detailing valuation multiples, free cash flow figures, and cloud market dynamics, while Shu provides constructive critique on their lack of downside analysis.41:18–46:14 · Guest disagreement 0/10 Sponsor Spotlight: Automated Compliance with Vanta's Matt Spitz A friendly sponsor conversation with Matt Spitz of Vanta. Ben and David prompt Matt to explain automated SOC II compliance and security monitoring in an entirely cooperative tone.46:14–1:23:18 · Guest disagreement 1/10 Act Two: Scaling YC Continuity with Anu Hariharan Anu Hariharan breaks down YC Continuity's fund structure, community programs, and qualitative founder evaluation methods. The hosts display strong venture capital literacy by synthesizing frameworks such as leading versus trailing indicators.0:00–5:36 · Ben and David pushing back 0/10 Welcome to the Arena Show and Opening Remarks Introductory monologue where Ben and David welcome the audience to Climate Pledge Arena and outline the agenda for the live show. There are no guests on stage during this segment.5:36–41:18 · Ben and David pushing back 3/10 Act One: The Live Idea Dinner Stock Pitch Contest Ben and David pitch stocks alongside Packy McCormick and Mario Gabriele in front of judge Shu Nyatta. The hosts demonstrate substantial knowledge by detailing valuation multiples, free cash flow figures, and cloud market dynamics, while Shu provides constructive critique on their lack of downside analysis.41:18–46:14 · Ben and David pushing back 0/10 Sponsor Spotlight: Automated Compliance with Vanta's Matt Spitz A friendly sponsor conversation with Matt Spitz of Vanta. Ben and David prompt Matt to explain automated SOC II compliance and security monitoring in an entirely cooperative tone.46:14–1:23:18 · Ben and David pushing back 2/10 Act Two: Scaling YC Continuity with Anu Hariharan Anu Hariharan breaks down YC Continuity's fund structure, community programs, and qualitative founder evaluation methods. The hosts display strong venture capital literacy by synthesizing frameworks such as leading versus trailing indicators.

speaking balance: gold is Ben and David, purple is the guest (3 minute bins)

0:00 · Ben and David 100% · guest 0%0:00 · Ben and David 100% · guest 0%3:00 · Ben and David 89.7% · guest 10.3%3:00 · Ben and David 89.7% · guest 10.3%6:00 · Ben and David 82.7% · guest 17.3%6:00 · Ben and David 82.7% · guest 17.3%9:00 · Ben and David 27.6% · guest 72.4%9:00 · Ben and David 27.6% · guest 72.4%12:00 · Ben and David 26% · guest 74%12:00 · Ben and David 26% · guest 74%15:00 · Ben and David 6.4% · guest 93.6%15:00 · Ben and David 6.4% · guest 93.6%18:00 · Ben and David 6.1% · guest 93.9%18:00 · Ben and David 6.1% · guest 93.9%21:00 · Ben and David 89.6% · guest 10.4%21:00 · Ben and David 89.6% · guest 10.4%24:00 · Ben and David 77.1% · guest 22.9%24:00 · Ben and David 77.1% · guest 22.9%27:00 · Ben and David 73.5% · guest 26.5%27:00 · Ben and David 73.5% · guest 26.5%30:00 · Ben and David 100% · guest 0%30:00 · Ben and David 100% · guest 0%33:00 · Ben and David 65.3% · guest 34.7%33:00 · Ben and David 65.3% · guest 34.7%36:00 · Ben and David 0.3% · guest 99.7%36:00 · Ben and David 0.3% · guest 99.7%39:00 · Ben and David 60.5% · guest 39.5%39:00 · Ben and David 60.5% · guest 39.5%42:00 · Ben and David 25.1% · guest 74.9%42:00 · Ben and David 25.1% · guest 74.9%45:00 · Ben and David 81.1% · guest 18.9%45:00 · Ben and David 81.1% · guest 18.9%48:00 · Ben and David 33.6% · guest 66.4%48:00 · Ben and David 33.6% · guest 66.4%51:00 · Ben and David 21.8% · guest 78.2%51:00 · Ben and David 21.8% · guest 78.2%54:00 · Ben and David 36.9% · guest 63.1%54:00 · Ben and David 36.9% · guest 63.1%57:00 · Ben and David 14.9% · guest 85.1%57:00 · Ben and David 14.9% · guest 85.1%1:00:00 · Ben and David 35.1% · guest 64.9%1:00:00 · Ben and David 35.1% · guest 64.9%1:03:00 · Ben and David 64.9% · guest 35.1%1:03:00 · Ben and David 64.9% · guest 35.1%1:06:00 · Ben and David 14.4% · guest 85.6%1:06:00 · Ben and David 14.4% · guest 85.6%1:09:00 · Ben and David 23.9% · guest 76.1%1:09:00 · Ben and David 23.9% · guest 76.1%1:12:00 · Ben and David 20.3% · guest 79.7%1:12:00 · Ben and David 20.3% · guest 79.7%1:15:00 · Ben and David 26.6% · guest 73.4%1:15:00 · Ben and David 26.6% · guest 73.4%1:18:00 · Ben and David 51.1% · guest 48.9%1:18:00 · Ben and David 51.1% · guest 48.9%1:21:00 · Ben and David 39.2% · guest 60.8%1:21:00 · Ben and David 39.2% · guest 60.8%1:24:00 · Ben and David 61.5% · guest 38.5%1:24:00 · Ben and David 61.5% · guest 38.5%1:27:00 · Ben and David 23.3% · guest 76.7%1:27:00 · Ben and David 23.3% · guest 76.7%1:30:00 · Ben and David 100% · guest 0%1:30:00 · Ben and David 100% · guest 0%1:33:00 · Ben and David 72.2% · guest 27.8%1:33:00 · Ben and David 72.2% · guest 27.8%
Sharpest disagreement ▶ 35:46 Shu calls out missing downside risk

Shu Nyatta delivers a direct critique to the panel, pointing out that everyone is thinking purely like venture investors without considering downside risks or over-earning consumer pricing.

 Hardest push from Ben and David ▶ 31:49 Ben challenges the Goldman research exercise

Ben interrupts David's bull thesis on Amazon to interrogate the premise of a Wall Street firm issuing a research note purely as a speculative thought exercise.

 Biggest teaching moment ▶ 1:15:05 Anu on evaluating internal founder execution

Anu Hariharan explains why growth-stage metrics in pitch decks can be misleading and outlines the specific qualitative traits YC tracks to predict success.

 Ben and David hold their own ▶ 23:35 Ben presents the fundamental case for Coinbase

Ben lays out a data-driven valuation thesis, contrasting Coinbase's ten billion dollars in free cash flow against its thirty-four billion dollar market cap.
the scores for every segment, with the reasoning behind each
ChapterTopicBen and David as informed peerGuest teachingGuest disagreementBen and David pushing backWhy
Welcome to the Arena Show and Opening Remarks 0000 Introductory monologue where Ben and David welcome the audience to Climate Pledge Arena and outline the agenda for the live show. There are no guests on stage during this segment.
Act One: The Live Idea Dinner Stock Pitch Contest 6433 Ben and David pitch stocks alongside Packy McCormick and Mario Gabriele in front of judge Shu Nyatta. The hosts demonstrate substantial knowledge by detailing valuation multiples, free cash flow figures, and cloud market dynamics, while Shu provides constructive critique on their lack of downside analysis.
Sponsor Spotlight: Automated Compliance with Vanta's Matt Spitz 2200 A friendly sponsor conversation with Matt Spitz of Vanta. Ben and David prompt Matt to explain automated SOC II compliance and security monitoring in an entirely cooperative tone.
Act Two: Scaling YC Continuity with Anu Hariharan 5612 Anu Hariharan breaks down YC Continuity's fund structure, community programs, and qualitative founder evaluation methods. The hosts display strong venture capital literacy by synthesizing frameworks such as leading versus trailing indicators.

Statements from this episode (20)

Assertion Supported
Gilbert: PitchBook Built a Multi-Hundred Million Dollar Business on $4M Raised
“PitchBook is PitchBook is Seattle's, like, monster amazing business hiding in plain sight, and it's been really cool to get to know their team more and more and more and understand the business and just learn how on four million dollars they've been able to bu…”
Ben Gilbert May 12, 2022 ▶ 2:15
Assertion Supported
Gabriele: Snowflake grew revenue 105% with 178% net retention
“Revenue's up about a 105% net retention is one 78. It was one 68 the year before.”
Mario Gabriele May 12, 2022 ▶ 11:18
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Gabriele: Snowflake stock will perform extremely well over next three years
“I think over a three plus year time horizon, it can do extremely well. It is a play that summarizes the growth of data in the technology industry, which feels like a safe bet.”
Mario Gabriele May 12, 2022 ▶ 12:02
Assertion Supported
McCormick: Opendoor generated an adjusted EBITDA profit in 2021
“They finally turned, ah, an adjusted EBITDA profit last year so they can make money on this business.”
Packy McCormick May 12, 2022 ▶ 19:48
Opinion
McCormick: Opendoor stock will outperform rivals due to its iBuying lead
“I think that Opendoor is gonna do the best. I think they have the biggest lead in, in iBuying, and I think that's a huge, huge opportunity Particularly because they have the best company value in all of the world, which is bips for breakfast.”
Packy McCormick May 12, 2022 ▶ 20:52
Assertion Contradicted
Gilbert: Coinbase generated $10 billion in free cash flow over 12 months
“In the last 12 months, they've done ten billion dollars in free cash flow.”
Ben Gilbert May 12, 2022 ▶ 23:40
Prediction Held up
Rosenthal: Amazon will soon pass Walmart in total revenue
“The only larger one being Walmart, which Amazon will almost assuredly pass very soon.”
David Rosenthal May 12, 2022 ▶ 29:41
Assertion Partly supported
Rosenthal: AWS market share exceeds Google Cloud and Azure combined
“AWS is growing at 37% annually on a seventy five billion dollar base. Google and Microsoft are growing at 45%, but their market share combined is still significantly less than Amazon.”
David Rosenthal May 12, 2022 ▶ 30:51
Assertion Partly supported
Rosenthal: Amazon holds 56% of US e-commerce market share
“Amazon has a 56% market share of U.S. E-commerce.”
David Rosenthal May 12, 2022 ▶ 32:21
Insight
Nyatta: The future of investing belongs to narrative creators
“The future of investing is people who understand and create narratives, and that's what you all do, and you actually are very good stock pickers, period, because you understand the power of stories And narratives. So this is the future of investing in my view.”
Shu Nyatta May 12, 2022 ▶ 35:17
Assertion Supported
Hariharan: Half of Y Combinator's batch founders are now international
“50% of our batch is international.”
Anu Hariharan May 12, 2022 ▶ 49:42
Assertion Supported
Hariharan: YC Has Around 4,000 Companies and Over 8,500 Alumni
“We have around 4000 companies and more than 8500 alumni.”
Anu Hariharan May 12, 2022 ▶ 52:20
Disclosure
Hariharan: Y Combinator requires only one partner's yes vote for admission
“On the early stage, it's only one group partner needs to say yes. Then the company is accepted into the batch”
Anu Hariharan May 12, 2022 ▶ 1:00:38
Assertion Supported
Hariharan: YC Continuity Made 35 Investments in Seven Years
“So we've done 35 investments in seven years.”
Anu Hariharan May 12, 2022 ▶ 1:01:45
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Hariharan: India's top three recent breakout startups are all Y Combinator alumni
“In fact, the top three breakout companies in India in the last two years are all YC.”
Anu Hariharan May 12, 2022 ▶ 1:02:56
Assertion Partly supported
Hariharan: The median age of a Y Combinator founder is 27
“And remember, the median age of a YC founder is 27, which means they have probably managed a sum total of three people in their life before they founded the company.”
Anu Hariharan May 12, 2022 ▶ 1:07:12
Assertion Supported
Hariharan: YC's acceptance rate remains under 3% and continues to decline
“You know, our acceptance rate is still below three percent, but yeah. Our acceptance rate has only decreased.”
Anu Hariharan May 12, 2022 ▶ 1:11:58
Insight
Hariharan: Iteration speed is the single biggest predictor of founder success
“How fast do they ship? How fast do they iterate? Is the single biggest indicator and correlation to how successful they're going to be, how soon.”
Anu Hariharan May 12, 2022 ▶ 1:16:09
Opinion
Hariharan: Y Combinator is the only venture platform with strong network effects
“Well, I think YC is the only platform that has strong network effects, and as all network effects have shown, if you, if we mess up The YC community, that, that is the, because it's, we are, we have this platform only because of the YC founders.”
Anu Hariharan May 12, 2022 ▶ 1:19:30
Opinion
Hariharan: YC Continuity is highly undercapitalized relative to YC's massive success
“And so, I mean, as I said, we are highly undercapitalized for the success of YC companies.”
Anu Hariharan May 12, 2022 ▶ 1:21:36
Made with StarZero

Turn any episode into a week of clips.

This entire site, nearly 80 episodes transcribed, diarized, checked and made playable, runs on the StarZero media pipeline. Drop in your own episode and the podcast clipper finds the moments worth sharing, cuts them, captions them, and reframes them for every feed.

Try the podcast clipper Learn more