StarZero All shows Try the podcast clipper →

Semil Shah

Founding General Partner, Haystack · 4 appearances on the record.

computed by AI from the episodes · how this works → · full disclaimer →

investorfounderoperator@semil ↗LinkedIn ↗semilshah.com ↗

He founded early-stage venture capital firm Haystack in 2013, expanding it to hundreds of millions in assets under management across multiple funds. A frequent Forbes Midas Seed List honoree, he is known for early-stage investments in companies such as DoorDash, Figma, Instacart, HashiCorp, and Carta.

82statements → 18claims → 9claims resolved → 44%fully supported → 3.83/5average certainty → 2.21/5average debate potential → 4.1/5argument clarity · the sources → 33said about them ↓

4 supported 2 partly supported 3 contradicted 1 not yet assessed 8 not checkable as stated how the 18 claims stand · each chip opens the sources

6 predictions · 12 assertions · 14 opinions · 29 insights · 21 disclosures · every statement was checked. The predictions and assertions are the 18 claims: statements the public record can support or contradict. 9 are resolved, 1 is not yet assessed, and 8 name no date, number or outcome precise enough to check. Everything else (opinions, insights, what ifs, disclosures) can never be settled by the record, so it carries no assessment.

The record, in short

What the tape says about how Semil argues and how the claims held up. Everything they said, and everything said about them, is in the tabs below.

Their most notable supported claim

Prediction Held up
Shah: Future Haystack funds will remain capped under $100 million
“Our next funds, by the way, will modestly grow, but I still think, you know, for what we do, it's gotta be under a hundred million dollars.”
Semil Shah Nov 21, 2022 ▶ 4:27 Semil Shah: Lessons Learned Scaling from a $1M to a $50M Fund | 20VC #951 · 20VC with Harry Stebbings

Their most notable contradicted claim

Prediction Didn’t hold up
Startups will not see capital-fueled immense growth for three years
“And I think we've exited this period where companies are kind of on steroids with capital and growing at immense rates. That's just not going to happen in the next three years again.”
Semil Shah Oct 23, 2017 ▶ 19:13 20VC: Semil Shah on How To Raise An Institutional Venture Fund, Why LPs Mostly Have Reserve Allocation Theory Wrong & Why IPOs and Acquisitions Are Severely Constrained

Expressed certainty vs assessment result

none yet certainty 1
none yet certainty 2
50% certainty 3
63% certainty 4
none yet certainty 5

weighted support: a fully supported claim counts one, a partly supported claim counts half. Each filled bar is clickable and opens exactly those claims; "none yet" means nothing said at that certainty level has resolved yet

Argument clarity: do they answer the question? how? →

4.1 / 5 directness 4.3 · coherence 4.2 · precision 3.9 · compression 3.6

redirected or did not address 2 of 38 assessed questions (5%). Watch them ▸

This is a score against a rubric. It is not a rank. Every host question → answer exchange is scored with names hidden on directness, coherence, precision and compression, 1–5 each, on meaning alone: disfluencies are ignored, and only raw unedited episodes count. This is the score that measures thought. Every scored exchange, scores shown → · The rubric and its checks →

How they sound: speaking style how? →

261 words/min while actually speaking · 23.3 um and uh per 1k words · 17.3 false starts per 1k · 27.1% of pauses land inside a clause

Measured by listening to the audio itself: 10,654 words across 1 episode of raw-level tape, transcribed verbatim with every um and uh kept, each one attributed only where the alignment onto our timed stream is unambiguous. These are measurements of speaking style. We do not rank them: across this corpus, fluency and argument quality are nearly uncorrelated (ρ≈0.2), and smooth talking does not signal clear thinking. How it's measured →

How the interview went all their pushback → series average →

Across 4 rated episodes:

host pushback ▾ 4/10
pushed back at the host ▾ 3/10
setup questions received 43%

Everything Semil Shah said on 20VC that made the record, most notable first. Filter by type, assessment or year in the ledger →

Opinion
Shah: Seed valuations do not matter to multi-stage mega-funds
“The pricing, when you just have three people and they've got a prototype doesn't really matter right now. So if they want four on 20 or four on 25 or four on 30, it just doesn't matter. We can deal with that later.”
Semil Shah Sep 16, 2019 ▶ 13:40 20VC: Haystack's Semil Shah on Whether Founders Are Bypassing Seed Funds in Favour Of Less Dilutive Multi-Stage Funds, How Fund Strategy Changes With Fund Scaling & Why The Hardest Challenge is Price Discipline
Prediction Held up
Shah: Future Haystack funds will remain capped under $100 million
“Our next funds, by the way, will modestly grow, but I still think, you know, for what we do, it's gotta be under a hundred million dollars.”
Semil Shah Nov 21, 2022 ▶ 4:27 Semil Shah: Lessons Learned Scaling from a $1M to a $50M Fund | 20VC #951 · 20VC with Harry Stebbings
Insight
Shah: Forcing Haystack to lead every deal lowers portfolio quality
“If we tried to lead everything, we would lower the I think the quality of the portfolio that we're in.”
Semil Shah Nov 21, 2022 ▶ 17:24 Semil Shah: Lessons Learned Scaling from a $1M to a $50M Fund | 20VC #951 · 20VC with Harry Stebbings
Insight
Shah: Scaling seed funds to $100M+ breaks collaborative syndicate dynamics
“If I had a hundred, fifty million dollar fund, that whole collaboration layer of how we work would change, which would then set off a chain reaction of how the deal flow would change and how we would have to operate with the companies would change.”
Semil Shah Nov 21, 2022 ▶ 18:56 Semil Shah: Lessons Learned Scaling from a $1M to a $50M Fund | 20VC #951 · 20VC with Harry Stebbings
Insight
Shah: Raising institutional capital requires organic industry chatter and name-checking
“I think that like, if you're not getting name checked by institutional LPs and other people aren't talking about what you're doing, it's almost impossible to raise institutional capital, whether it's a three million dollar check or thirty million dollar check …”
Semil Shah Nov 21, 2022 ▶ 34:37 Semil Shah: Lessons Learned Scaling from a $1M to a $50M Fund | 20VC #951 · 20VC with Harry Stebbings
Opinion
Shah: Union Square Ventures is the best pound-for-pound VC fund
“I just, I follow a lot of honestly what USV does of like try to learn. I think they're the best pound for pound fund in the world both operationally and in every way.”
Semil Shah Nov 21, 2022 ▶ 41:30 Semil Shah: Lessons Learned Scaling from a $1M to a $50M Fund | 20VC #951 · 20VC with Harry Stebbings
Disclosure
Shah: I blocked two LPs from re-investing in future Haystack funds
“I've blocked two LPs from investing in, in future funds.”
Semil Shah Nov 21, 2022 ▶ 46:02 Semil Shah: Lessons Learned Scaling from a $1M to a $50M Fund | 20VC #951 · 20VC with Harry Stebbings
Opinion
Shah: LPs' biggest mistake was permitting fund size escalation and blind pools
“I think on the LP side, the sin was going along with fund size escalation and allowing and enabling those firms to allocate within those funds. So I believe like In having separate vehicles for separate separate activities, because that's the best governor. An…”
Semil Shah Nov 21, 2022 ▶ 59:07 Semil Shah: Lessons Learned Scaling from a $1M to a $50M Fund | 20VC #951 · 20VC with Harry Stebbings
Insight
Shah: Only 50 to 75 VC funds globally can effectively guide IPOs
“I think that there are a set of funds, maybe like 50 to 75 VC funds that in partnership with other funds and entrepreneurs know how to guide a company towards a big outcome or a public offering.”
Semil Shah Nov 21, 2022 ▶ 1:02:18 Semil Shah: Lessons Learned Scaling from a $1M to a $50M Fund | 20VC #951 · 20VC with Harry Stebbings
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Shah: Multiple startups hold $50M+ cash without product-market fit
“There's probably multiple, multiple companies with like over fifty million dollars of cash with no product market fit.”
Semil Shah Nov 21, 2022 ▶ 1:07:28 Semil Shah: Lessons Learned Scaling from a $1M to a $50M Fund | 20VC #951 · 20VC with Harry Stebbings
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Shah: Peak 3x venture funds should realistically be written down to 1.5x
“And we would say, oh, you have a three X fund, Samil, what is it now? I'd probably say it's one and a half X fund. You know, I don't think that that's out of bounds.”
Semil Shah Nov 21, 2022 ▶ 1:15:24 Semil Shah: Lessons Learned Scaling from a $1M to a $50M Fund | 20VC #951 · 20VC with Harry Stebbings
Assertion Not publicly verifiable
Shah: Top tech alumni founders are bypassing seed funds for multi-stage firms
“This group of people right now, they're voting with their feet, and they're bypassing seed.”
Semil Shah Sep 16, 2019 ▶ 8:43 20VC: Haystack's Semil Shah on Whether Founders Are Bypassing Seed Funds in Favour Of Less Dilutive Multi-Stage Funds, How Fund Strategy Changes With Fund Scaling & Why The Hardest Challenge is Price Discipline
Opinion
Shah: Sequoia or Lightspeed seed funding does not guarantee follow-on rounds
“It sort of like a false narrative that like, if you take a seed from a Sequoia or you take a seed from a Lightspeed, they're just going to continue to do your next rounds.”
Semil Shah Sep 16, 2019 ▶ 15:17 20VC: Haystack's Semil Shah on Whether Founders Are Bypassing Seed Funds in Favour Of Less Dilutive Multi-Stage Funds, How Fund Strategy Changes With Fund Scaling & Why The Hardest Challenge is Price Discipline
Insight
Shah: Multi-stage VCs require 10% seed ownership to justify partner time
“What I do think is that it's tough for one of these larger VC firms to warrant a partner's time and brand experience extension to a seed round unless they own about 10% as an option, because what you're saying then is like, I'm going to hold 10% in pro rata, a…”
Semil Shah Sep 16, 2019 ▶ 16:50 20VC: Haystack's Semil Shah on Whether Founders Are Bypassing Seed Funds in Favour Of Less Dilutive Multi-Stage Funds, How Fund Strategy Changes With Fund Scaling & Why The Hardest Challenge is Price Discipline
Insight
Shah: Seed VCs should outsource Series A and B follow-on decisions
“If your competency is seeded, And then you follow on an A or B. You don't really have the competency as a manager to assess whether that's a good A deal, whether that's a good B deal. So part of what you need to do as a manager is outsource that decision to th…”
Semil Shah Sep 16, 2019 ▶ 28:37 20VC: Haystack's Semil Shah on Whether Founders Are Bypassing Seed Funds in Favour Of Less Dilutive Multi-Stage Funds, How Fund Strategy Changes With Fund Scaling & Why The Hardest Challenge is Price Discipline
Insight
Shah: Platform maturity made consumer startups capital inefficient post-2016
“And so my intuition was a platform maturity of the iPhones, of the app store on iOS, of Facebook, of Google, of Snap and Pinterest kind of hit a ceiling where I felt the cost of acquiring these customers in the LTV, according to it, would make the businesses v…”
Semil Shah Sep 16, 2019 ▶ 31:50 20VC: Haystack's Semil Shah on Whether Founders Are Bypassing Seed Funds in Favour Of Less Dilutive Multi-Stage Funds, How Fund Strategy Changes With Fund Scaling & Why The Hardest Challenge is Price Discipline
Insight
Shah: Early venture outcomes are random, making price discipline critical
“When we all invest so early, the outcomes are completely random, they're completely unknown, and so we have to kind of take a cohort basis. And what you have now is especially in the Bay Area, such a free flow of capital and a loosening of norms around how fun…”
Semil Shah Sep 16, 2019 ▶ 37:00 20VC: Haystack's Semil Shah on Whether Founders Are Bypassing Seed Funds in Favour Of Less Dilutive Multi-Stage Funds, How Fund Strategy Changes With Fund Scaling & Why The Hardest Challenge is Price Discipline
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Seed LP proxies may not correlate with actual fund returns
“The problem with all that that we're going to go through probably in the next three or four years is those may not be correlated with results.”
Semil Shah Oct 23, 2017 ▶ 14:17 20VC: Semil Shah on How To Raise An Institutional Venture Fund, Why LPs Mostly Have Reserve Allocation Theory Wrong & Why IPOs and Acquisitions Are Severely Constrained
Opinion
LPs mistakenly apply traditional VC reserve models to seed funds
“I think the majority of LPs have taken the history of how VCs, institutional VCs, A, B, and C reserve and bolted that on to seed, whereas I think seed is a completely different asset class.”
Semil Shah Oct 23, 2017 ▶ 16:35 20VC: Semil Shah on How To Raise An Institutional Venture Fund, Why LPs Mostly Have Reserve Allocation Theory Wrong & Why IPOs and Acquisitions Are Severely Constrained
Insight
Early-stage VCs should maximize upfront ownership instead of heavy reserves
“I think early stage investors have to do the same thing. I think a few can and will be really good at investing in a lot of things and then pouncing on the things that are working, but most people won't have enough bandwidth to manage that.”
Semil Shah Oct 23, 2017 ▶ 17:19 20VC: Semil Shah on How To Raise An Institutional Venture Fund, Why LPs Mostly Have Reserve Allocation Theory Wrong & Why IPOs and Acquisitions Are Severely Constrained
Prediction Didn’t hold up
Startups will not see capital-fueled immense growth for three years
“And I think we've exited this period where companies are kind of on steroids with capital and growing at immense rates. That's just not going to happen in the next three years again.”
Semil Shah Oct 23, 2017 ▶ 19:13 20VC: Semil Shah on How To Raise An Institutional Venture Fund, Why LPs Mostly Have Reserve Allocation Theory Wrong & Why IPOs and Acquisitions Are Severely Constrained
Opinion
Shah dislikes legal AI, but invested in Ironclad for Jason Boehmig
“I actually hate the space that he's in. He's kind of in the legal kind of AI space. I don't like that market, but Jason is so compelling that it's just a pleasure to work with someone like him.”
Semil Shah Oct 23, 2017 ▶ 25:53 20VC: Semil Shah on How To Raise An Institutional Venture Fund, Why LPs Mostly Have Reserve Allocation Theory Wrong & Why IPOs and Acquisitions Are Severely Constrained
Insight
Semil Shah: Attracting Follow-On Capital Is an Investor's Top Priority
“Probably the most important thing any investor can do is attract follow-on capital for their investments.”
Semil Shah Jul 25, 2016 ▶ 15:28 20VC: Semil Shah on Why The Most Important Thing An Investor Can Do Is Attract Follow On & The Fundamentals of VC Branding
Opinion
Shah: Most venture investors cannot build companies like entrepreneurs do
“A lot of us as investors, for the most part, we can't do what entrepreneurs do. We choose not to do what entrepreneurs do.”
Semil Shah Nov 21, 2022 ▶ 2:20 Semil Shah: Lessons Learned Scaling from a $1M to a $50M Fund | 20VC #951 · 20VC with Harry Stebbings

Show 24statements(58 left)

The other half of the tape: Semil Shah's own voice is left out of every number here. Other people bring the name up 33 times in 17 episodes on 20VC. every mention, with the transcript →

Who brings them up most Harry Stebbings 22Barry Eggers 4Katie Stanton 2Jason Lemkin 2Adam Besvinick 2Mike Mignano 1

Every mention by year

tap a year for its mentions
008315520162017201820192020202120222023202420252026episodesmentions
03520162017201820192020202120222023202420252026episodes it came up in
0032.56520162017201820192020202120222023202420252026episodesmentions per episode
2026 1 mention in 1 episode
2023 2 mentions in 1 episode
2022 6 mentions in 1 episode
2020 12 mentions in 5 episodes 2 per episode
2019 4 mentions in 3 episodes 1 per episode
2018 4 mentions in 4 episodes 1 per episode
2017 3 mentions in 1 episode
2016 1 mention in 1 episode

Appearances (4)

EpisodeDateSpeaking time
Semil Shah: Lessons Learned Scaling from a $1M to a $50M Fund | 20VC #951 · 20VC with Harr Nov 21, 2022 54m
20VC: Haystack's Semil Shah on Whether Founders Are Bypassing Seed Funds in Favour Of Less Sep 16, 2019 27m
20VC: Semil Shah on How To Raise An Institutional Venture Fund, Why LPs Mostly Have Reserv Oct 23, 2017 18m
20VC: Semil Shah on Why The Most Important Thing An Investor Can Do Is Attract Follow On & Jul 25, 2016 14m
Made with StarZero

Turn any episode into a week of clips.

This entire site, over 1,200 episodes transcribed, diarized, checked and made playable, runs on the StarZero media pipeline. Drop in your own episode and the podcast clipper finds the moments worth sharing, cuts them, captions them, and reframes them for every feed.

Try the podcast clipper Learn more