What-if
O'Driscoll: Figma's $98 IPO pop only happened because it priced at $38
“The 98 price only happened because the IPO happened at 38.”
Assertion Supported
Halligan: HubSpot priced its IPO at $25 and opened at $33
“We pressed 25. I think we opened at 33.”
Insight
Halligan: IPO pricing and allocations are decided the night before listing
“So, first of all, you're making the decision on the price and who the investors are the night before the IPO.”
Assertion Not publicly verifiable
Halligan: HubSpot's IPO order book was 40x oversubscribed
“Because we were 27 X over subscribed. You know, I think it was 40 X over subscribed.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Halligan: HubSpot rejected Morgan Stanley's $24 IPO pricing advice
“We wanted to go out at 25. Morgan Stanley said we should go out at 24. And the reason we should go out at 24 is Fidelity has told us That they're in at 24, they're out at 25. Ok, and you really want Fidelity, because Fidelity has trillions of dollars, and they…”
Assertion Supported
Halligan: Morgan Stanley and Fidelity aligned to lower HubSpot's IPO price
“I don't think there was collusion going on, but definitely Morgan Stanley and Fidelity were on the same side of the table trying to get us to sell at a lower price.”
Assertion Open
Halligan: Figma CEO Dylan Field decided IPO pricing, not bankers
“The founders make the decision on what the price is. So Dylan decided at the end of the day.”
Insight
Halligan: Companies engineer IPO pops to retain long-term institutional investors
“Part of it also is you want to pop. You want Fidelity and T. Rowe and these long lonely folks to come in and right out of the gate, feel good about their investment. You want them to hold for decades and decades and decades.”
Assertion Open
O'Driscoll: Figma's 250% IPO pop was largest since 1999
“Instead of getting, let's call it, the designed 15, 20% pop that makes everyone feel good, you ended up with this absurd 250% pop, right, which is clearly off the charts. I mean, I think it's the largest pop since 1999.”
Insight
Jason Lemkin: Startup Employees Care About Stock Value, Not Dilution
“But we forget about the employees don't care about, they don't even know what dilution is. All they care about is what happens with their stock.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Rory O'Driscoll: Figma Did Not Leave $3 Billion on Table in IPO
“The people who said, oh, Figma left three billion dollars on the table because they could have got 95 dollars a share, are talking out of their ass. Because I can guarantee you, the order book, I think it was one of the prices, 35, 38, whatever it was, there w…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
O'Driscoll: Figma IPO Buyers Set Exit Price Targets Under $110
“All those big buyers who came in at Figma at 38, before they buy, they have an internal process with a price target to exit. None of those price targets are going to be more than a 110 bucks a share.”
Insight
Brian Halligan: 'Long-Only' Institutional Funds Actively Trade Public Positions
“People would say long only. They're not long only. They do sell. They come in and out of HubSpot. I see them coming in and out.”
Assertion Supported
Halligan: Big institutional investors own roughly 90% of HubSpot stock
“It's very little of HubSpot is owned by mom and pop, owned by Harry Stebbings, buying Harry Stebbings's mom. It's like, 90% these big institutional investors.”
Opinion
O'Driscoll: Direct listings fail to prevent periodic post-IPO price pops
“It may well be that Megapops are a natural intermittent consequence of the IPO process, and that Direct listing doesn't solve that part of the problem.”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
O'Driscoll: Startups raise unchanged follow-on rounds weeks after big-name leads
“It's like in the venture equivalent that we're seeing now, you know, the way we're seeing it now when someone really big brand name Does a round. Like, six weeks later, many of these companies are doing a follow-on round. Nothing's changed.”
Opinion
Brian Halligan: Direct listings are risky unless you're Google or Facebook
“I think the direct listing is like, you're a little bit scared. You're not going to get those long loneliness. You're not going to properly market it to them. And it's seven percent to the bankers in the grand scheme of things. It's not that much. I think it's…”
Assertion Partly supported
Halligan: Zendesk never secured long-only investors due to shaky IPO timing
“Zendesk at the time went out. And it was just, it was timing, and it was just a shaky week that they went out, and they just didn't get, they didn't get the big long onlys, and they had a good story, and they didn't get them, and they never really got them. Th…”
Opinion
Halligan: NYSE and NASDAQ are identical except for ringing NYSE's bell
“You can do NASDAQ or New York Stock Exchange virtually exactly the same, except with the New York Stock Exchange, you get the ring the bell. That's why we picked New York Stock Exchange.”
Insight
O'Driscoll: Post-IPO dinners exist to placate founders after bankers underprice IPOs
“My mental model on the dinner is the bankers have just screwed you over for a buck a share, and in return, they buy you a very expensive dinner, and they liquor you up so you forget.”
Insight
Halligan: RSUs dampen risk-seeking behavior in tech CEOs compared to ISOs
“It just creates sort of a risk averse behavior in the CEO. Like it's basically cash comp goes up and down a little bit, let's say, but an ISO you're swinging for the fences. Like you've got a strong incentive to swing. And so it's really had a dampening effect…”
Insight
Halligan: Ultra-wealthy CEO compensation must be pegged to net worth
“But you kind of have to peg the comp to the net worth. Same thing with Elon Musk. Like if you paid Elon Musk, like Mary Barra makes twenty nine million dollars a year. You think Elon cares about twenty nine million dollars a year? So you have to kind of comp i…”
Prediction Open · timeframe Aug 2030
O'Driscoll: 2021 executive stock price targets like Airbnb's will never be hit
“All the ones that were put in place in 2021 Are stranded, because all those price targets, like the Airbnb price targets, ain't ever going to happen now.”
Disclosure
Halligan: HubSpot ties executive comp to net new ARR and earnings floors
“The way Hellspot does it is on net new ARR. And an earning, like a floor earnings number.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
O'Driscoll: Founders Will Ask VCs to Waive Missed Stock-Price Targets
“My prediction is, and again, I'm often disagreed with on this on comp committees, because I've done some of these where I've tried to make them on tangible targets. What will happen when you do the stock price ones is if the company is doing really well, but t…”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Lemkin: VCs Will Not Waive Unearned Stock Compensation Triggers
“I'll bet you nickels to dollars that doesn't happen because founders are just signing up. I don't know what Brian you see at Sequoia, but founders are signing up for crazy stuff these days. They're signing up for massive stuff. And I don't think a lot of grouc…”
Disclosure
Halligan regrets early HubSpot secondary stock sale to Sequoia Capital
“When we did our round, it was Sequoia. Sequoia came to us and said, we'd like to buy some of your shares in retrospect. It's a horrible financial decision for me, but it was good at the time. And I saw, I forgot a couple million dollars worth of HubSpot shares…”
Opinion
Halligan: Current Venture Capital Valuations Are 'A Little Bubbly'
“I think the valuation is very high right now across venture. So we'll see how this thing plays out. I think it's a little bubbly right now”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
O'Driscoll: Private rounds were cheaper than public capital for three years
“For the longest time, the private round, the money in the private round was cheaper and less hassle for the last three years than the public's.”
Opinion
O'Driscoll: Cheap capital is now in public markets, making IPOs imperative
“At a highest level, the cheap money is now in the public markets, and Brian's right, you'd be an idiot not to go for it.”
Insight
Rory O'Driscoll: Startups needing capital in next two years should raise now
“Like, if you need to raise money in the next two years, now would be a really good frickin' time.”
Insight
Brian Halligan: Activist investor horror stories are rare and public markets are rational
“Public investors, like there's so much written about what happened with Zendesk or Autodesk, or these really bad things that happen. It's pretty rare. And I have found that public investors be pretty rational.”
Insight
Halligan: Going public will be a top three day in founder's life
“You're exhausted, but the day you go public is going to be one of the top two or three days of your life. It is an amazing day.”
Disclosure
Halligan: Sells fixed number of HubSpot shares monthly to avoid signaling market
“I sell the same number of shares every month since we went public. And the reason I do that is I don't want people to think, I don't want to signal something. If I make a big buy or a big sell, it's going to signal something.”
Assertion Supported
Every major Sand Hill Road VC rejected HubSpot's 2009 Series C
“It was in the throes of the recession back in and we went up and down Sand Hill road, like Darmesh and I get off the plane from Boston, landed in Sand Hill road. We're like, we got this. We're going to go up and down. It's like 20 meetings. And we go all 20 me…”
Disclosure
Scale Venture Partners invested in HubSpot, Box, DocuSign, and RingCentral in 2009
“Yes, I remember that was in O-Nine. We did HubSpot, Box, DocuSign, and I think RingCentral.”
Insight
Rory O'Driscoll: The best time to buy is when nobody else is buying
“The time to buy is when everyone else is not buying, especially when, let's put it out there, you're just little old scale, and you're not Sequoia who came in afterwards.”
Assertion Supported
HubSpot grew from $1B at IPO to $25B in public markets
“Yeah, the smart money on HubSpot was in the public since we went from a billion dollars to 25. In a relatively short period of time.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Brian Halligan: Sequoia's strategy of holding post-IPO stock will succeed long-term
“And I think Skoy is really smart. I suspect HubSpot was one of the reasons why they said, Let's hold these companies after they go public. It's back in some cases, but I think it's going to work over the long haul.”
Opinion
Halligan: Selling software to corporate CIOs is soul-crushing work
“I had spent my entire life Doing the soul crushing exercises of selling to CIOs, and it's just a soul crushing work.”
Insight
Halligan: Silicon Valley has a wrongheaded bias against building for SMBs
“There's a big echo chamber in Silicon Valley and big negative bias towards SMB, but you can make it work in SMB. HubSpot and Shopify have shown it. Block has shown it.”
Insight
Halligan: Prosumer and Enterprise AI Succeeded, but SMB AI Lags
“The stuff I see, Jason, is there's a ton of prosumer stuff that's working. Lovable's working. Reflet's working. Gamma's working. Like, so many prosumer things seem to be working. And then enterprise is working. You're right. I haven't seen much in between.”
Opinion
Lemkin: VCs Should Rush Capital into Uncracked B2B SMB AI Market
“So I just think this AI B to B SMB, It's something that hasn't been cracked to Rory's point, and I think we should all just rush all our capital into that.”
Insight
Rory O'Driscoll: SMBs want enterprise software features, but tightly packaged and priced
“Anything the big companies have, the small and mid-sized companies want too. They're not different. They just need it packaged tightly and priced tightly so they consume, consume of it in bite-sized chunks.”
Prediction Not checkable as stated
Rory O'Driscoll predicts SMBs will adopt pre-packaged AI within two years
“So over the next couple of years, it may well be, as I say, for things like phone answering, simple order dispatch, that there'll be a whole, whole bunch of pre-canned, pre-baked, This is how it works, Mr. SMB. Just turn it on, and you too can sound like a big…”
Opinion
O'Driscoll: Meta's strength stems from core ads, not AI
“This isn't a AI enabled success. This is, I have an awesome existing business, and it kicks off so much money that I'm allowed spend that money on building this great AI vision, and I can probably do that for as long as my existing business kicks off cash.”
Insight
O'Driscoll: Hyperscalers' AI spend is funded by core cash flow
“My big takeaway is not all the AI stuff is working for the hyperscalers. My big takeaway is all their existing businesses are working so well and kicking off so much cash that they can keep doing this for the next year, and they said they're going to keep doin…”
Assertion Partly supported
Rory O'Driscoll: AI App Revenue Maxes Out at $30B Against $600B CapEx
“You still add up all the apps revenue, and it probably comes to 25, thirty billion dollars maximum, and the capex to build that is running between four and six hundred billion dollars.”
Prediction Open · timeframe Aug 2035
Rory O'Driscoll: AI App Revenue Will Reach $300B–$400B in 10 Years
“If you fast forward 10 years, that 25, thirty billion of apps, wherever, and you could easily be three, four hundred billion dollars.”
Assertion Supported
Halligan: Shopify is the only SaaS stock outperforming Oracle and SAP
“If you go from that date and you look at you look at Oracle and you look at SAP, they're both growing, like, 230%. The only SaaS company since August 22 It's growing faster. Shopify. They're growing 300%. So they're outpacing HubSpot, Salesforce, Adobe Box, At…”
Opinion
Brian Halligan names Nvidia's Jensen Huang as CEO of the Year
“I think the CEO of the Year is Jensen. And I like them, but the other thing I like about Jensen is sort of rethinking the role of the CEO. He's rethinking the CEO playbook. I think he's a pretty good inspiration for CEOs out there today.”
Insight
Rory O'Driscoll: GPUs and foundational models dominate the AI tech stack over applications
“I think that the two people who have, the two categories in the stack that didn't meaningfully exist at scale in SAS and cloud land that exists now are the GPUs, which is all Jensen and the models. Neither of those kind of categories even existed. And obviousl…”
Assertion Not checkable as stated
Lemkin: Adobe's shift to the cloud required three years of internal convincing
“Adobe just trying to go to the cloud took three years of convincing everybody, okay?”
Opinion
O'Driscoll: Microsoft's post-OpenAI deal execution under Nadella has been perfect
“If you accept the constraint, That you can't build the core technology internally, which is what Microsoft Had to accept, and he accepted, right? Execution since then has been perfect.”
Insight
Rory O'Driscoll on why private AI valuations escalate rapidly during fundraising
“Demand is high for premium assets, so it's a little like it's the private IPO. You float a price of a hundred, and you end up at one 50. You close the price of ten billion, you end up at 15. I think there's just a lot of demand for premium, perceived premium A…”
Assertion Open · timeframe Aug 2028
Lemkin: Cognition mandated 80-hour weeks and laid off 30% of acquired startup
“Well, I guess today, Cognition laid off 30% of the folks they bought, and they offered to buy out all the other 200 employees. They gave them a nine-month package. They told them they either had to work 80 hours a week, six days a week in the office, or they s…”
Insight
Rory O'Driscoll: Non-standard acquisition deals leave non-key employees vulnerable
“If you're not one of the key players, the minute you move away from the cap table to, you know, making it up as you go along, if you're not one of the key players, you're very vulnerable to, you know, you're basically, Depending on the kindness of strangers, a…”
Assertion Supported
Lemkin: Clay raised $100M at a $3B valuation
“Clay just did around at three billion, which is a stunning growth too, right? But they sold a hundred million, right?”
Insight
O'Driscoll: High valuations only harm startups if they must raise again
“Raising money at too high a price is only, quote, suicide if you have to raise again. If you don't have to raise again, and all you do is have some investors who've overpaid, and they take four or five years to grow into that valuation, well, that's tough shit…”
Assertion Supported
O'Driscoll: Ramp is generating $700M to $800M in revenue
“Like, I've heard they're doing roughly seven, eight hundred million dollars.”
Insight
Lemkin: VCs should size funds smaller to enter carry mode faster
“Normal times you want to optimize your fund size to achieve the maximum carry you can in a given time, right? And then just go raise another, right? In an ideal world, you might even raise the fund a year, right? So you can get into carry mode as quickly as po…”
Disclosure
Lemkin: Opportunity funds were not worth the extra effort for 15% returns
“Wasn't worth it For me to do the opportunity funds. It's not enough. Like I'll make like 15% more money. It's not enough money, right?”
Insight
O'Driscoll: Opportunity funds fail without $20B portfolio mega-winners
“Unless you end up with one of the very few companies that are not just amazing, but are super amazing, where they can be a twenty billion dollar outcome, your ability to deploy lots of capital relative to your early stage fund is actually much smaller than you…”
Assertion Supported
Jason Lemkin: Benchmark is no longer in top VC conversations on X
“If you look on social media, benchmark isn't listed the way Andreessen and Sequoia was like it was a generation ago. It's just not, does it matter? Harry, Harry's built a big brand. He's concerned. It matters. You could argue both sides, but when the industry …”
Insight
Rory O'Driscoll: Specialist VCs face deal-loss risk; mega-funds risk subpar returns
“The risk you face as a specialist is you get crowded out by the noise, and people don't know you're amazing enough, and therefore you lose some of the at-bats to the people who have more brand. The risk you face as a brand is in your wild urge to put all the m…”