StarZero All shows Try the podcast clipper →

Mar 21, 2022 · 55m · startup-acquisition-stories

Startup Acquisition Stories with Kevin McArdle - CEO of SureSwift Capital

Kevin McArdle · 31m spoken Andrew Gazdecki · 17m spoken
0:00 / 0:00

gold bands on the timeline = statements, start to end. Hover to read, click to jump. CC turns on captions

In this episode of SaaS Acquisition Stories, host Andrew Gazdecki interviews SureSwift Capital founder and CEO Kevin McArdle to discuss the software holding company model, acquisition evaluation criteria, and practical guidance for bootstrapped founders planning an exit.

How this conversation actually went

Every chapter scored 0–10 on four independent dynamics. Hover any point for the reasoning behind the score. Andrew holds 35.3% of the talking time here. How this is scored →

Andrew as informed peer 4.3 Guest teaching 2.7 Guest disagreement 1.3 Andrew pushing back 0.8
05100:0015:0030:0045:002:34–8:27 · Andrew as informed peer 3/10 Career Journeys and Entrepreneurial Beginnings The conversation opens on an easygoing, collegial footing as McArdle details his transition from 15 years in enterprise software at Cerner to acquiring cash-flowing businesses. Gazdecki shares his own backstory of graduating Chico State and building his first startup.8:29–11:50 · Andrew as informed peer 5/10 Deal Flow Screening and Acquisition Evaluation Criteria McArdle outlines SureSwift's screening funnel and why they remain stack-agnostic despite industry criticism. Gazdecki actively participates, offering analogies about the nuances of valuing early-stage SaaS businesses based on underlying metrics.11:50–21:06 · Andrew as informed peer 3/10 Memorable Acquisitions: MailParser, DocParser, MeetEdgar, and LeadDyno McArdle shares case studies of acquiring MailParser, DocParser, MeetEdgar, and LeadDyno, emphasizing relational dealmaking after broken previous processes. Gazdecki reinforces SureSwift's reputation in the acquisition community.21:07–30:21 · Andrew as informed peer 6/10 Essential Guidance and Preparation for Selling Founders McArdle advises founders on transparent due diligence and setting realistic expectations across deal stages. Gazdecki builds heavily on this advice, describing his own exit experience and how founders often hurt their leverage by playing coy games with strategic buyers.30:22–48:00 · Andrew as informed peer 7/10 Macroeconomic Trends, Micro-PE Evolution, and De-Risking Deals McArdle poses a direct question warning that lowering barriers might lead inexperienced buyers into disastrous deals during a market shift. Gazdecki pushes back by comparing acquisition risks favorably against the 90% failure rate of greenfield startups, detailing how platform tooling and advisory support de-risk micro-PE.48:00–52:37 · Andrew as informed peer 2/10 Favorite Books, Contrarian Views, and Everyday Entrepreneurs McArdle shares his reading recommendations and takes a contrarian stance against the tech industry's obsession with celebrity entrepreneurs like Elon Musk, championing unheralded local operators instead. Gazdecki agrees with light humor.2:34–8:27 · Guest teaching 2/10 Career Journeys and Entrepreneurial Beginnings The conversation opens on an easygoing, collegial footing as McArdle details his transition from 15 years in enterprise software at Cerner to acquiring cash-flowing businesses. Gazdecki shares his own backstory of graduating Chico State and building his first startup.8:29–11:50 · Guest teaching 3/10 Deal Flow Screening and Acquisition Evaluation Criteria McArdle outlines SureSwift's screening funnel and why they remain stack-agnostic despite industry criticism. Gazdecki actively participates, offering analogies about the nuances of valuing early-stage SaaS businesses based on underlying metrics.11:50–21:06 · Guest teaching 2/10 Memorable Acquisitions: MailParser, DocParser, MeetEdgar, and LeadDyno McArdle shares case studies of acquiring MailParser, DocParser, MeetEdgar, and LeadDyno, emphasizing relational dealmaking after broken previous processes. Gazdecki reinforces SureSwift's reputation in the acquisition community.21:07–30:21 · Guest teaching 3/10 Essential Guidance and Preparation for Selling Founders McArdle advises founders on transparent due diligence and setting realistic expectations across deal stages. Gazdecki builds heavily on this advice, describing his own exit experience and how founders often hurt their leverage by playing coy games with strategic buyers.30:22–48:00 · Guest teaching 4/10 Macroeconomic Trends, Micro-PE Evolution, and De-Risking Deals McArdle poses a direct question warning that lowering barriers might lead inexperienced buyers into disastrous deals during a market shift. Gazdecki pushes back by comparing acquisition risks favorably against the 90% failure rate of greenfield startups, detailing how platform tooling and advisory support de-risk micro-PE.48:00–52:37 · Guest teaching 2/10 Favorite Books, Contrarian Views, and Everyday Entrepreneurs McArdle shares his reading recommendations and takes a contrarian stance against the tech industry's obsession with celebrity entrepreneurs like Elon Musk, championing unheralded local operators instead. Gazdecki agrees with light humor.2:34–8:27 · Guest disagreement 0/10 Career Journeys and Entrepreneurial Beginnings The conversation opens on an easygoing, collegial footing as McArdle details his transition from 15 years in enterprise software at Cerner to acquiring cash-flowing businesses. Gazdecki shares his own backstory of graduating Chico State and building his first startup.8:29–11:50 · Guest disagreement 1/10 Deal Flow Screening and Acquisition Evaluation Criteria McArdle outlines SureSwift's screening funnel and why they remain stack-agnostic despite industry criticism. Gazdecki actively participates, offering analogies about the nuances of valuing early-stage SaaS businesses based on underlying metrics.11:50–21:06 · Guest disagreement 1/10 Memorable Acquisitions: MailParser, DocParser, MeetEdgar, and LeadDyno McArdle shares case studies of acquiring MailParser, DocParser, MeetEdgar, and LeadDyno, emphasizing relational dealmaking after broken previous processes. Gazdecki reinforces SureSwift's reputation in the acquisition community.21:07–30:21 · Guest disagreement 1/10 Essential Guidance and Preparation for Selling Founders McArdle advises founders on transparent due diligence and setting realistic expectations across deal stages. Gazdecki builds heavily on this advice, describing his own exit experience and how founders often hurt their leverage by playing coy games with strategic buyers.30:22–48:00 · Guest disagreement 3/10 Macroeconomic Trends, Micro-PE Evolution, and De-Risking Deals McArdle poses a direct question warning that lowering barriers might lead inexperienced buyers into disastrous deals during a market shift. Gazdecki pushes back by comparing acquisition risks favorably against the 90% failure rate of greenfield startups, detailing how platform tooling and advisory support de-risk micro-PE.48:00–52:37 · Guest disagreement 2/10 Favorite Books, Contrarian Views, and Everyday Entrepreneurs McArdle shares his reading recommendations and takes a contrarian stance against the tech industry's obsession with celebrity entrepreneurs like Elon Musk, championing unheralded local operators instead. Gazdecki agrees with light humor.2:34–8:27 · Andrew pushing back 0/10 Career Journeys and Entrepreneurial Beginnings The conversation opens on an easygoing, collegial footing as McArdle details his transition from 15 years in enterprise software at Cerner to acquiring cash-flowing businesses. Gazdecki shares his own backstory of graduating Chico State and building his first startup.8:29–11:50 · Andrew pushing back 0/10 Deal Flow Screening and Acquisition Evaluation Criteria McArdle outlines SureSwift's screening funnel and why they remain stack-agnostic despite industry criticism. Gazdecki actively participates, offering analogies about the nuances of valuing early-stage SaaS businesses based on underlying metrics.11:50–21:06 · Andrew pushing back 0/10 Memorable Acquisitions: MailParser, DocParser, MeetEdgar, and LeadDyno McArdle shares case studies of acquiring MailParser, DocParser, MeetEdgar, and LeadDyno, emphasizing relational dealmaking after broken previous processes. Gazdecki reinforces SureSwift's reputation in the acquisition community.21:07–30:21 · Andrew pushing back 1/10 Essential Guidance and Preparation for Selling Founders McArdle advises founders on transparent due diligence and setting realistic expectations across deal stages. Gazdecki builds heavily on this advice, describing his own exit experience and how founders often hurt their leverage by playing coy games with strategic buyers.30:22–48:00 · Andrew pushing back 4/10 Macroeconomic Trends, Micro-PE Evolution, and De-Risking Deals McArdle poses a direct question warning that lowering barriers might lead inexperienced buyers into disastrous deals during a market shift. Gazdecki pushes back by comparing acquisition risks favorably against the 90% failure rate of greenfield startups, detailing how platform tooling and advisory support de-risk micro-PE.48:00–52:37 · Andrew pushing back 0/10 Favorite Books, Contrarian Views, and Everyday Entrepreneurs McArdle shares his reading recommendations and takes a contrarian stance against the tech industry's obsession with celebrity entrepreneurs like Elon Musk, championing unheralded local operators instead. Gazdecki agrees with light humor.

speaking balance: gold is Andrew, purple is the guest (3 minute bins)

0:00 · Andrew 25.7% · guest 74.3%0:00 · Andrew 25.7% · guest 74.3%3:00 · Andrew 14.2% · guest 85.8%3:00 · Andrew 14.2% · guest 85.8%6:00 · Andrew 71.7% · guest 28.3%6:00 · Andrew 71.7% · guest 28.3%9:00 · Andrew 29.1% · guest 70.9%9:00 · Andrew 29.1% · guest 70.9%12:00 · Andrew 6.4% · guest 93.6%12:00 · Andrew 6.4% · guest 93.6%15:00 · Andrew 12.1% · guest 87.9%15:00 · Andrew 12.1% · guest 87.9%18:00 · Andrew 15.8% · guest 84.2%18:00 · Andrew 15.8% · guest 84.2%21:00 · Andrew 19% · guest 81%21:00 · Andrew 19% · guest 81%24:00 · Andrew 57% · guest 43%24:00 · Andrew 57% · guest 43%27:00 · Andrew 37.8% · guest 62.2%27:00 · Andrew 37.8% · guest 62.2%30:00 · Andrew 36.7% · guest 63.3%30:00 · Andrew 36.7% · guest 63.3%33:00 · Andrew 46% · guest 54%33:00 · Andrew 46% · guest 54%36:00 · Andrew 79.6% · guest 20.4%36:00 · Andrew 79.6% · guest 20.4%39:00 · Andrew 58.1% · guest 41.9%39:00 · Andrew 58.1% · guest 41.9%42:00 · Andrew 42.4% · guest 57.6%42:00 · Andrew 42.4% · guest 57.6%45:00 · Andrew 47.4% · guest 52.6%45:00 · Andrew 47.4% · guest 52.6%48:00 · Andrew 11.2% · guest 88.8%48:00 · Andrew 11.2% · guest 88.8%51:00 · Andrew 23.2% · guest 76.8%51:00 · Andrew 23.2% · guest 76.8%54:00 · Andrew 33.3% · guest 66.7%54:00 · Andrew 33.3% · guest 66.7%
Sharpest disagreement ▶ 33:30 Warning about naive buyers getting hit by a train

McArdle directly challenges the prevailing optimism in the micro-PE ecosystem, expressing concern that platforms make buying look deceptively easy for inexperienced operators.

 Hardest push from Andrew ▶ 34:37 Countering that acquisitions bypass greenfield startup failure risks

Gazdecki pushes back against McArdle's concern over market failures, arguing that startup failure is already at 90% and buying cash-flowing SaaS is comparatively safer.

 Biggest teaching moment ▶ 23:20 The inevitable inspection of code and operational reality

McArdle educates prospective selling founders on the necessity of radical transparency during diligence, warning that attempting to hide technical debt will inevitably unravel a deal.

 Andrew holds their own ▶ 41:30 Articulating structural tools to professionalize micro-PE deals

Gazdecki demonstrates his deep platform domain knowledge by explaining how unbundled M&A tools and vetted due diligence advisors systematically de-risk dealmaking for retail buyers.
the scores for every segment, with the reasoning behind each
ChapterTopicAndrew as informed peerGuest teachingGuest disagreementAndrew pushing backWhy
Career Journeys and Entrepreneurial Beginnings 3200 The conversation opens on an easygoing, collegial footing as McArdle details his transition from 15 years in enterprise software at Cerner to acquiring cash-flowing businesses. Gazdecki shares his own backstory of graduating Chico State and building his first startup.
Deal Flow Screening and Acquisition Evaluation Criteria 5310 McArdle outlines SureSwift's screening funnel and why they remain stack-agnostic despite industry criticism. Gazdecki actively participates, offering analogies about the nuances of valuing early-stage SaaS businesses based on underlying metrics.
Memorable Acquisitions: MailParser, DocParser, MeetEdgar, and LeadDyno 3210 McArdle shares case studies of acquiring MailParser, DocParser, MeetEdgar, and LeadDyno, emphasizing relational dealmaking after broken previous processes. Gazdecki reinforces SureSwift's reputation in the acquisition community.
Essential Guidance and Preparation for Selling Founders 6311 McArdle advises founders on transparent due diligence and setting realistic expectations across deal stages. Gazdecki builds heavily on this advice, describing his own exit experience and how founders often hurt their leverage by playing coy games with strategic buyers.
Macroeconomic Trends, Micro-PE Evolution, and De-Risking Deals 7434 McArdle poses a direct question warning that lowering barriers might lead inexperienced buyers into disastrous deals during a market shift. Gazdecki pushes back by comparing acquisition risks favorably against the 90% failure rate of greenfield startups, detailing how platform tooling and advisory support de-risk micro-PE.
Favorite Books, Contrarian Views, and Everyday Entrepreneurs 2220 McArdle shares his reading recommendations and takes a contrarian stance against the tech industry's obsession with celebrity entrepreneurs like Elon Musk, championing unheralded local operators instead. Gazdecki agrees with light humor.

Statements from this episode (10)

Disclosure
McArdle: SureSwift does not load debt, flip assets, or plan fund liquidation
“Technically, we're a private equity firm, but most of what people know about PE, which is, Buy load with debt, strip out expenses, and then flip to the next size buyer. We don't do any of that. we don't plan to liquidate our funds. So yeah, I just prefer…”
Kevin McArdle Mar 21, 2022 ▶ 1:05
Assertion Not checkable as stated
McArdle: SureSwift has acquired 46 companies over seven years
“46 over the last seven years.”
Kevin McArdle Mar 21, 2022 ▶ 1:30
Disclosure
McArdle: SureSwift operates 30 businesses and focuses on bootstrapped B2B SaaS
“We're currently operating, I think, 30 businesses, so we've sold some of the smaller ones, we've sold some ones that didn't work out, and most importantly, we started to divest. Right now, we're squarely focused on bootstrapped B to B SaaS.”
Kevin McArdle Mar 21, 2022 ▶ 1:56
Disclosure
McArdle: SureSwift only buys profitable SaaS with $1M-$10M checks
“Top of funnel down, you know, it's gotta be SaaS. It's gotta be profitable. We like writing checks between one and ten million dollars. So those are three pretty quick filters if you're too small or too big.”
Kevin McArdle Mar 21, 2022 ▶ 9:17
Insight
McArdle: Existing teams add SaaS acquisition value, solo founders add risk
“If it's a solo founder with no team and no plan, and if they're gone, you know, the business is hosed. Well, that that's a problem. But if it's somebody, a founder who's built up a team and they're ready to step out, then that, Adds value to the business.”
Kevin McArdle Mar 21, 2022 ▶ 10:29
Disclosure
McArdle: SureSwift Capital acquired MeetEdgar from Laura Roeder
“We just announced that we acquired Meet Edgar a few weeks ago, and I've known Laura for four years, and we were kind of in discussion.”
Kevin McArdle Mar 21, 2022 ▶ 16:20
Insight
McArdle: Founders forced to sell without preparation sell at a discount
“We've seen a lot of situations where people are sort of forced to sell a business for one reason or another. And if you haven't at least thought about these things, haven't had a couple of conversations, haven't like documented the things you're going to docum…”
Kevin McArdle Mar 21, 2022 ▶ 29:34
Opinion
McArdle: SaaS M&A brokers charge hefty fees and fail to deliver
“I don't want to be a broker in five years, because the, especially in, in our space with like SaaS and online businesses, they charge hefty fees. And I'm not sure they deliver.”
Kevin McArdle Mar 21, 2022 ▶ 38:33
Insight
Gazdecki: Acquiring a business has a higher success rate than starting one
“It's literally, you have, you know, a 10% chance of success starting a business. I would argue your success, your chances of success when acquiring a business is probably higher because you're skipping over, you know, some of the hardest parts like finding cus…”
Andrew Gazdecki Mar 21, 2022 ▶ 41:20
Opinion
McArdle: Elon Musk would not make his top 20 admired entrepreneurs list
“You could ask me to list 20, and I wouldn't get to Elon Musk. Not that he's not a super smart and super successful guy. He's just not wouldn't be on my top 20 list.”
Kevin McArdle Mar 21, 2022 ▶ 49:18
Made with StarZero

Turn any episode into a week of clips.

This entire site, over 100 episodes transcribed, diarized, checked and made playable, runs on the StarZero media pipeline. Drop in your own episode and the podcast clipper finds the moments worth sharing, cuts them, captions them, and reframes them for every feed.

Try the podcast clipper Learn more