why aren't all 25 resolved? a statement only gets an assessment when the public
record can support or contradict it. opinions and what-ifs never can, and 0 checkable
ones are still open, waiting for their date. predictions held up or didn't;
assertions are supported or contradicted. on every card:
▮▮▮▮▮ certainty ·
▮▮▮▮▮ debate potential. speakers are clickable
Assertion Supported
Huberman: 1mg Melatonin Is ~100x Natural Secretion and Suppresses Puberty
“What you take in terms of one milligram melatonin, very small dosage, something like a hundred times what you naturally secrete. I get really concerned about this, especially in kids because melatonin is actually the hormone that suppresses the onset of pubert…”
Assertion Contradicted
Huberman: Mouth breathing causes deviated septums in most non-trauma cases
“The reason you have a deviated septum is because you're a mouth breather. There are rare exceptions where if people boxed or they had broken nose or something like that, but your sinuses can learn to dilate.”
Assertion Contradicted
Huberman: 15 seconds of bright nighttime light drops melatonin to zero
“Light viewed by the eyes inhibits melatonin, so much so that if melatonin levels are at their peak and you walk into the bathroom at night and you flip on the lights and it's really bright, if you spend more than 10 or 15 seconds in that light, your melatonin …”
Assertion Partly supported
Huberman: Cardiovascular exercise increases hippocampal neurons in mice, not humans
“There's some mouse data or studies published on, on mice showing that exercise, cardiovascular exercise can increase the number of neurons in the hippocampus. Turns out that's true for mice, but not for humans.”
Assertion Supported
Huberman: PNAS Study Shows Hyperventilation Prevents E. Coli Symptoms
“There's a beautiful study published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences that shows that when people do this kind of breathing prior to an injection of E. Coli, something I don't recommend people do, they are actually able to remain symptom f…”
Assertion Supported
Huberman: Cold water exposure triggers a 2.5x sustained dopamine increase
“There's a paper published in the European Journal of Physiology. It showed that there's a 2.5 X huge increase in dopamine release, very long lasting. 2.5 X is the amount of dopamine that's triggered by the use of cocaine, but the difference is cocaine has a ve…”
Assertion Supported
Huberman: Sufficient Estrogen in Men Is Essential for Brain Health and Libido
“Having sufficient levels of estrogen for men, provided it's not too high, is important for brain longevity and health. It's actually really important for libido.”
Assertion Partly supported
Huberman: About 10% of people experience a dopamine surge from alcohol
“Now about 10% of people have a genetic predisposition to get a big dopamine increase from alcohol.”
Assertion Partly supported
Huberman: Direct brain benefits of exercise stem from load-bearing skeleton stimulation
“The direct effects bring us to osteocalcin, and the direct effects of exercise on brain function and health actually come from stimulation of the skeleton and load-bearing exercise”
Assertion Contradicted
Huberman: Sunlight through windows fails to set your circadian clock
“Bright light exposure through windows or windshields will not suffice. Those unlike corrective lenses on your eyes, glasses and contacts don't focus the light to your eyes. In fact, they're designed to filter The very light that triggers activation of these ne…”
Assertion Contradicted
Huberman: Late-shifted cortisol peak is a physiological signature of depression
“And actually it's a hallmark physiological signature of depression to have a late shifted cortisol peak.”
Assertion Partly supported
Huberman: Morning Light Triggers Real Cortisol, Adrenaline, and Dopamine Release
“That's not a placebo effect. That's a real effect of the release of cortisol and adrenaline into your body. The release of dopamine is controlled by light, powerful neuromodulator that makes you feel good.”
Assertion Supported
Huberman: Peak alertness occurs 90 minutes before natural bedtime
“The biggest peak in alertness actually occurs about 90 minutes before your natural to sleep time.”
Assertion Supported
Huberman: Theanine, magnesium threonate, and apigenin activate GABA
“Theanine, magnesium threonate, and apigenin all trigger the activation of a neuro hormone, excuse me, a neurotransmitter in the brain called GABA, which tends to shut off our forebrain.”
Assertion Partly supported
Huberman: Short Naps and NSDR Accelerate Neuroplasticity and Learning
“There are several very good papers that were published in the last few years in the journal Cell Report showing that short naps and NSDR, I should say, has some good science to support it, accelerates neuroplasticity and learning. Especially if you take that n…”
Assertion Supported
Huberman: Late caffeine degrades sleep quality even if falling asleep is easy
“Many people find that they can drink caffeine until eight or nine PM and then still fall asleep, but the quality of your sleep will be greatly disrupted.”
Assertion Partly supported
Huberman: Panoramic vision increases motion detection fourfold
“Actually your motion detection goes up fourfold when you're in this panoramic vision mode, because of the, you shift to a different category of neurons that are much better detecting motion.”
Assertion Contradicted
Huberman: Elevating feet 10 to 15 degrees increases brain glymphatic clearance
“One way to enhance it is to have the feet slightly elevated, 10 to 15 degrees. I put a pillow under my ankles when I sleep at night. Usually in the middle of the night, I realize I kicked it away or something like that, but feet elevated naps of about 10 to 15…”
Assertion Contradicted
Huberman: Body temperature is the second most powerful stimulus for wakefulness
“Second to light temperature is the most powerful stimulus for wakefulness. Actually, when you wake up in the morning, it's because your body temperature is rising.”
Assertion Supported
Huberman: Sleep requires body temperature to drop 1 to 3 degrees
“In order to fall asleep and stay asleep, you need your body temperature to be about one to three degrees lower than it was in that in the afternoon.”
Assertion Supported
Huberman: Humans dump heat mainly via palms, upper face, and feet
“We actually dump heat mainly through the palms of our hands, the upper half of our face and the bottoms of our feet.”
Assertion Supported
Huberman: Stanford study shows exercised blood improves brain function
“In fact, there's this really cool study. I'll just mention that it's done at Stanford recently by my colleague, Tony Weiss Corey, where they take the blood from exercised individuals and they infuse it into non-exercise individuals and all sorts of aspects of …”
Assertion Supported
Huberman: Alcohol lowers body temperature while disrupting temperature perception
“Alcohol actually lowers your body temperature, but your perception of that lower body temperature is disrupted. So part of the reason you can fall asleep When you drink alcohol is because it lowers your body temperature.”
Assertion Supported
Huberman: Grip strength indirectly assesses cognitive function in aging
“It's actually well established that cognitive function in aging can be assessed indirectly by grip strength.”
Assertion Partly supported
Huberman: Seasonal Light Changes Dictate Melatonin Release Levels
“Remember, light inhibits melatonin. The longer the day, the shorter the melatonin signal. So in summer months, your body releases very little melatonin. In winter months, because days are shorter and there's less light overall, you release much more melatonin.”