why aren't all 412 resolved? a statement only gets an assessment when the public
record can support or contradict it. opinions and what-ifs never can, and 0 checkable
ones are still open, waiting for their date. predictions held up or didn't;
assertions are supported or contradicted. on every card:
▮▮▮▮▮ certainty ·
▮▮▮▮▮ debate potential. speakers are clickable
Assertion Supported
Clayton Homes ran a one-person legal department for 30 years
“For 30 years, Clayton Holmes operated with a legal department of one person, Jim himself.”
Assertion Supported
Hetty Green's Inheritance Case Was Among the First Using Statistical Evidence
“The ensuing court case became one of America's first trials to use statistical evidence.”
Assertion Contradicted
Hetty Green Bought the Defaulted Town of Kohlauer for $100,000
“In December of 1890, when the town of Kohlauer defaulted and went up for auction, Hedy and Ned were there before dawn, walking the streets and inspecting every property. When bidding began at 10 o'clock, they had already arranged financing. Before other bidder…”
Assertion Supported
Hetty Green Was America's Wealthiest Woman With an Estimated $50M Fortune
“Her wealth during this period was estimated between 40 and fifty million, making her the richest woman in America and possibly the richest woman in the world.”
Assertion Supported
Hetty Green Multiplied Her Inheritance 20x After Taking Control in Her Thirties
“She basically took her inheritance after she got control of it in her late thirties, and she twenty-x'd it while all the chips in the world basically were stacked against her.”
Assertion Supported
FedEx Employees Worked Without Pay and Used Personal Cards to Fuel Planes
“Years later, when FedEx nearly died, employees would work without pay to save it. They'd use personal credit cards to fuel planes, not because they had to, but because Fred Smith had learned from Sergeant Jack how to earn that kind of loyalty.”
Assertion Supported
Fred Smith Raised a Record $91 Million in Venture Capital
“By late, he'd raised ninety-one million dollars in venture capital. More than any startup had ever raised at that point.”
Assertion Supported
Fred Smith Saved FedEx Payroll by Winning $27,000 at Vegas Blackjack
“Smith Flew to Las Vegas with the company's last 5000 dollars, and by Monday morning, he'd won 27,000 dollars at Blackjack, enough for fuel and payroll for another few weeks.”
Assertion Partly supported
Parrish: FedEx reached $1 billion revenue within 10 years without acquisitions
“By 1979, Federal Express hit one billion dollars in revenue. The first American company to reach that milestone in under 10 years at that point without any acquisitions.”
Assertion Supported
Parrish: FedEx merged express and ground units after Smith resisted for decades
“Under new leadership, FedEx finally merged express and ground operations, something that Smith had resisted for decades.”
Assertion Supported
Parrish: John Bragg openly shares all funded blueberry research with competitors
“40 years ago, Bragg started funding research at the Nova Scotia Agricultural College, and he never stopped. They study everything from pollination to fungal diseases to vegetation management and berry composition. But here's the kicker that'll surprise you. Th…”
Assertion Supported
Parrish: Oxford operates four separate bee divisions due to border bans
“Oxford has to run three completely separate bee operations. One in Nova Scotia, one in New Brunswick, one in Ontario, actually four, one in Maine.”
Assertion Supported
Parrish: Eastlink was first in North America to offer a triple-play bundle
“Eastlink became the first cable company in Canada to offer telephone service over cable. First in North America to bundle internet, phone, and TV into one package. The first to let customers add or drop channels in real time.”
Assertion Supported
Eastlink Won 85% Spectrum Coverage at Fraction of Major Telecoms' Cost
“When the government auctioned wireless spectrum in 2008, the big telecoms brought their consultants and committees. Eastlink brought a simple strategy, run mock auctions, develop fake-out tactics, and know exactly what you need. And they won licenses that cove…”
Assertion Supported
Sol Price Prohibited Below-Cost Sales and Loss Leaders at FedMart
“He makes a rule that nothing in Fedmark Can ever be sold below cost. There's no loss leaders, period.”
Assertion Partly supported
Payroll and benefits account for 80% of typical retail operating costs
“Because payroll and benefits represent approximately 80% of a retailer's cost of operations, pricing advantage follows labor productivity.”
Assertion Contradicted
Costco intentionally loses money on every $1.50 hot dog combo sold
“Price Club sold a hot dog and soda for a dollar 50 in 1976. Today, nearly 50 years later, Costco still charges a dollar 50. They lose money on every single one.”
Assertion Supported
Katharine Graham Became the First Female Fortune 500 CEO
“That she would become the first woman CEO of a Fortune 500 company.”
Assertion Supported
The Washington Post's $40M acquisition of Kaplan eventually became worth billions
“The most per seant move came in 1984 when managers proposed buying Kaplan, a test preparation company, for forty million dollars. Within two decades, Kaplan's revenues would surpass those, the newspapers, and become the company's largest profit center. That ca…”
Assertion Supported
Les Schwab was the first major US tire dealer branded under his own name
“With that simple instruction, Les became the first major tire dealer in America to build his business around his own name instead of a manufacturer's brand.”
Assertion Contradicted
Les Schwab's 1970 profit-sharing formula retained only 38 percent for the company
“By 1970, Les had codified his profit sharing into what he called the 100 story. For every hundred dollars of store profit, 25 went to the manager, 10 to the assistant manager, 27 to the employee bonus and retirement fund. The company kept 38%.”
Assertion Supported
Jimmy Pattison maintains 100 percent ownership of his $16 billion conglomerate
“What is remarkable is that Jim Pattison owns 100% of this.”
Assertion Supported
Wintour's HG redesign caused subscription cancellations needing a dedicated hotline
“Subscription cancellations require a dedicated phone line.”
Assertion Supported
Anna Wintour pioneered fashion affiliate marketing with Neiman Marcus
“Anna negotiated a deal where Condé Nast got a cut of all clothing purchases driven by the Vogue website, essentially inventing fashion e-commerce affiliate marketing.”
Assertion Partly supported
Teen Vogue traffic surged to 12M and print subscribers tripled
“Teen Vogue's traffic exploded from two million to twelve million. Print subscribers tripled.”
Assertion Supported
Anna Wintour cultivated loyalty by aiding unknown creatives
“She helped designer John Galliano get his career back on track. She gave countless people who didn't have a name at the time, photographers and assistants a shot.”
Assertion Supported
Manufacturing complexity blocked competitors from reverse-engineering Intel's 1103 DRAM
“The complexity of manufacturing the 11 oh three made it nearly impossible for competitors to reverse engineer, giving Intel a multi-year advantage in the market. In effect, complicated manufacturing became their core skill.”
Assertion Contradicted
Shane Parrish: El Salvador replaced its K-5 math curriculum with Synthesis Tutor
“And it's crazy, so it teaches the kids math, and my understanding just from reading it a little bit is El Salvador just replaced, like, the K through five math with synthesis tutor, and the results are, like, astounding.”
Assertion Supported
Teledyne Delivered 20.4% Annual Returns From 1963 to 1990
“From 1963 to 1990, Teledyne, the company that Henry Singleton helped build from scratch, delivered annual returns of 20.4%, while the S&P 500 managed a mere eight percent. If you'd invested 10,000 dollars in Teledyne in 1963, by 1990, you'd have over 1.8 Milli…”
Assertion Supported
Teledyne's Decentralized Model Influenced Berkshire Hathaway's Playbook
“Warren Buffett was an admitted singleton admirer, and we can see how Teledyne's decentralized structure with centralized capital allocation became central to Berkshire Hathaway's playbook.”
Assertion Supported
Teledyne's 1960s Stock-Funded Acquisitions Drove 374% Sales Growth
“And they purchased these companies using Teledyne's highly valued shares, often trading at 40 to 70 times earnings. They more than doubled the share count in the late sixties. But the financial results that followed more than made up for the shared dilution, t…”
Assertion Supported
Singleton Moved Teledyne Insurance Assets From Bonds to Depressed Equities
“During the 1968 to 74 period, when most investors considered bonds safe and stocks risky, Singleton took the opposite view. He instructed his insurance companies to move away from fixed income securities and toward equities when the stock market was depressed.”
Assertion Partly supported
Teledyne Repurchased Over 90% of Its Outstanding Shares Over 12 Years
“In an era when virtually no companies bought back shares, Teledyne would conduct eight major share repurchases over the next 12 years, reducing the number of shares outstanding by more than 90%.”
Assertion Supported
Teledyne Investors Achieved Approximately 3,000% Returns Between 1972 and 1983
“Shareholders who stayed with Teledyne from the first buyback in 1972 achieved gains of approximately 3000% by 1983, transforming many patient investors into multi-millionaires.”
Assertion Partly supported
Singleton Repurchased 8.6 Million Teledyne Shares at $200 in Final Buyback
“The same year, Singleton conducted his eighth and final major stock buyback, acquiring 8.6 million shares at 200 dollars per share, approximately 30 dollars above the market price. This reduced Teledyne's outstanding shares to just over twenty million.”
Assertion Supported
Parrish: Teledyne became the highest-priced NYSE stock at $302 in 1984
“After this transaction, Teledyne's stock climbed to 302 dollars per share by September, making it the highest priced stock on the New York Stock Exchange.”
Assertion Supported
Vanderbilt's Famous 'I'll Ruin You' Threat Letter Is Likely Apocryphal
“The letter perfectly capturing Vanderbilt's fierce reputation, Bias toward action and blunt style is likely apocryphal. Historians point out it first appeared decades later in Vanderbilt's obituary without evidence and the language used doesn't match Vanderbil…”
Assertion Partly supported
Vanderbilt's $11M fortune in 1860 likely made him America's richest citizen
“His estimated wealth of around eleven million likely made him America's richest private citizen.”
Assertion Supported
Vacuum incumbents rejected Dyson to protect lucrative replacement bag revenues
“The vacuum giants weren't just blind, they were trapped, because their business model ran on the razor and blades model, cranking out high margin replacement bags. A bagless vacuum didn't just challenge their technology, it threatened their whole way of busine…”
Assertion Supported
Dyson abandoned a £2.5 billion electric car project in 2019
“For example, when Dyson decided to invest 2.5 billion in developing an electric car, a project that was ultimately abandoned in 2019, he did so without having to justify the massive expenditure to shareholders or a board of directors.”
Assertion Supported
Estée Lauder leveraged a $115 price tag as a marketing hook
“When warned that no one would pay a 115 dollars for a cream, she didn't lower her price. She raised their curiosity. Her advertisement simply asked, what makes a cream worth a 115 dollars? Come meet Estee Lauder and find out.”
Assertion Supported
Parrish: Mellon's tax reforms eliminated federal income tax for most Americans by 1927
“By 1927, his reforms meant most Americans paid no federal income tax at all.”
Assertion Partly supported
The Canadian government told Eaton's it was too profitable
“They made so much money that the government told them that they were too profitable.”
Assertion Supported
Wozniak's Open Systems Sustained Apple While Jobs's Closed Models Initially Struggled
“Yeah, so the open one that Wozniak had created where people could put their own components in, take it apart, that was keeping them afloat. And Steve's version of the computer, which was closed and sort of more controlled, which is a theme I think we're gonna …”
Assertion Supported
Rockefeller's Father Ruthlessly Called In Loans to Test His Sons
“He loaned them money at the going rate of interest, showing them that they could do it too. But then, after they absorbed that lesson and tried it out for themselves, he'd go one step further and call in his loans to them suddenly, when they least expected it,…”
Assertion Supported
Parrish: Rockefeller loaned money at interest before age fourteen
“He added with some pride that he had loaned out money and got interest on it before he was 14 years old, and I knew well how to make out a note. My father taught me these things.”
Assertion Partly supported
Rockefeller Relentlessly Audited Eight-Dollar Discrepancies Despite Earning Millions Annually
“Decades later, as an old man with yearly income well past three million dollars, or more than fifty million dollars today, Rockefeller caught an error of 10 dollars and eight cents in a railroad's payment to him. He had his secretary write a letter asking for …”
Assertion Supported
Parrish: 19th-century railroads secretly rebated high-volume shippers below posted rates
“The official bill on a railroad shipment always showed a fixed rate, the same rate the railroad printed on the public schedule for everyone to see and what Rockefeller assumed, at first, everyone would pay. But the right kind of shipper, after he had moved eno…”